OctoInform Beta

A ZFC counterexample to Naimark's problem

For a complex Hilbert space HH, K(H)K(H) denotes the C*C^*-algebra of compact operators on HH. Every irreducible representation of K(H)K(H) is unitarily equivalent to its defining representation. Naimark’s problem asks whether every C*C^*-algebra any two of whose irreducible representations are unitarily equivalent is isomorphic to K(H)K(H) for some Hilbert space HH. A counterexample to Naimark’s problem is a C*C^*-algebra, any two of whose irreducible representations are unitarily equivalent, that is isomorphic to K(H)K(H) for no Hilbert space HH. A tracial state τ\tau is faithful when τ(a*a)>0\tau(a^*a)>0 for every a≠0a\neq0.

Naimark’s problem dates to 1951, as the historical account of Akemann and Weaver records. A C*C^*-algebra whose irreducible representations are all unitarily equivalent to one acting on a separable Hilbert space is isomorphic to the compact operators (Calderón and Farah, Proposition 7.2). Akemann and Weaver constructed a counterexample assuming Jensen’s diamond principle ♢\diamondsuit. The same work shows that the existence of a counterexample generated by ℵ1\aleph_1 elements is independent of ZFC. Calderón and Farah obtained a counterexample from the continuum hypothesis together with the Cohen diamond principle ♢Cohen\diamondsuit_{\mathrm{Cohen}}. Under ♢\diamondsuit, Vaccaro constructed counterexamples whose tracial state spaces are affinely homeomorphic to any prescribed metrizable Choquet simplex (with the corrigendum). Tanaka constructed, in ZFC, a counterexample with a faithful tracial state. Tanaka’s counterexample has a faithful representation on a separable Hilbert space. That representation is not irreducible.

The preprint proves, in ZFC, that there is a unital, infinite-dimensional, simple C*C^*-algebra AA with a faithful tracial state, any two of whose irreducible representations are unitarily equivalent. In particular, AA is isomorphic to K(H)K(H) for no complex Hilbert space HH.

The Lean library Naimark proves both statements as its main theorem, which has no hypothesis. Lean has checked every result of the Lean library, so the Lean library is the reference. Each result on these pages is stated as the Lean library states it and linked to the Lean declaration behind it, with the preprint’s statement beside it where the two differ. The preprint is a guide only: it gives the results their order and their names. The Lean library proves, rather than assumes, the homogeneity theorem of Kishimoto, Ozawa and Sakai: any two pure states ff and gg of a separable, simple, infinite-dimensional unital C*C^*-algebra BB satisfy g=f∘γg=f\circ\gamma for some **-automorphism γ\gamma of BB.

The Lean library: Naimark

Naimark is a Lean library: 29 items, in six groups. Each has a page written by OctoInform, listed below.

§1. Introduction 2 items
  1. §1 (setting): simple algebras, faithful tracial states, irreducible representations, compacts The notions behind the counterexample to Naimark’s problem. §1
  2. Theorem 1.1 [Main theorem] A counterexample to Naimark’s problem. §1
§2. Pure states, excision, and peaking projections 10 items
  1. §2 (setting): pure states, equivalence, property (U), peaking sequences A state peaked by decreasing projections is pure. §2
  2. Lemma 2.1 [Unique lifts are pure] A unique state extension of a pure state is pure. §2
  3. Lemma 2.2 [Equivalent pure states are unitarily conjugate] Equivalent pure states are unitarily conjugate. §2
  4. Lemma 2.3 [Peaking under restriction] Projections peaking in a larger algebra peak in the smaller one. §2
  5. Lemma 2.4 [Decreasing excision] A decreasing net excises vector functionals of irreducible representations. §2
  6. Lemma 2.5 [Projection excision] Peaking projections excise the state they peak to. §2
  7. Lemma 2.6 [Cross-excision] Cross terms of inequivalent pure-state excisions tend to zero. §2
  8. Lemma 2.7 [Trace-null supports] Small projections send traces of excising nets to zero. §2
  9. Lemma 2.9 [Expectation onto a peaking algebra] A conditional expectation onto the algebra of peaking projections. §2
  10. Lemma 2.10 [Simple extensions] Simplicity passes upward under unique state extension and faithful expectation. §2
§3. Reduced HNN adjunctions 6 items
  1. §3 (setting): words and reduced words Reduced words: centered coefficients at each change of letter. §3
  2. Proposition 3.1 [The reduced adjunction] Adjoining a unitary that carries one peaking sequence to another. §3
  3. Lemma 3.2 [Reduced amalgamated free product] Free products over atomic amalgamation data carry a faithful trace. §3
  4. Corollary 3.3 [Restriction of the adjunction] Restricted bridge data give a subalgebra of the Higman-Neumann-Neumann (HNN) extension. §3
  5. Proposition 3.4 [Interchanging adjunctions] Two separated reduced Higman-Neumann-Neumann extensions can be taken in either order. §3
  6. Lemma 3.5 [Limits of adjunctions] Limits of reduced Higman-Neumann-Neumann extensions are again reduced extensions. §3
§4. Joining two classes while preserving unique extensions 1 item
  1. Theorem 4.1 [The bridge] Merging two classes of pure states and no others. §4
§5. Closed subiterations and countable determination 8 items
  1. §5 (setting): bridge iterations, the algebras A[T], dependency closure Transfinite bridge iterations and the subalgebras they generate. §5
  2. Lemma 5.1 [Unique extensions along a chain] Unique extension of pure states passes along continuous chains. §5
  3. Lemma 5.2 [Inequivalence passes to limits] Inequivalence of pure states passes to limits. §5
  4. Lemma 5.3 [The initial algebra] The canonical anticommutation relations algebra is simple with a faithful trace. §5
  5. Lemma 5.4 [Inherited iterations] Inherited algebras of a bridge iteration grow by bridge steps. §5
  6. Theorem 5.5 [Closed subiterations] Pure states of a dependency-closed subalgebra extend uniquely. §5
  7. Lemma 5.6 [Countable determination] Pure states of the iteration are countably determined. §5
  8. Corollary 5.7 [Counting pure states] Height at most 𝔠\mathfrak{c} forces at most 𝔠\mathfrak{c} pure states. §5
§6. The construction in ZFC 2 items
  1. Theorem 6.1 [Kishimoto, Ozawa and Sakai] Pure states of a separable simple infinite-dimensional C*C^*-algebra are homogeneous. §6
  2. §6 (proof of Theorem 1.1): the schedule and the recursion A transfinite recursion that leaves one class of pure states. §6

No item matches.