OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. Introduction · §1

§1 (setting): simple algebras, faithful tracial states, irreducible representations, compacts: Simple C*C^*-algebras, states and faithful tracial states, irreducible representations up to unitary equivalence, and isomorphism with the compact operators K(H)K(H)

The notions behind the counterexample to Naimark’s problem.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Naimark’s problem asks whether a C*C^*-algebra with only one irreducible representation up to unitary equivalence is isomorphic to the algebra K(H)K(H) of compact operators on some Hilbert space HH. The library states its main theorem in the notions this question uses, together with simplicity and faithful tracial states. Every C*C^*-algebra here is complex and unital.

The Definition

Definition 1. A C*C^*-algebra AA is simple when it is nonzero and its only closed two-sided ideals are 00 and AA: A≠0,I⊆A a closed two-sided ideal⟹I=0 or I=A.A \neq 0, \qquad I \subseteq A \text{ a closed two-sided ideal} \implies I = 0 \text{ or } I = A.(1)✦

A state of a C*C^*-algebra AA is a continuous linear functional f:A→ℂf \colon A \to \mathbb{C} of norm one that is real and nonnegative on every a*aa^*a: ∥f∥=1,f(a*a)≥0(a∈A).\|f\| = 1, \qquad f(a^*a) \geq 0 \quad (a \in A).(2)✦

A faithful tracial state of a C*C^*-algebra AA is a state τ\tau of AA such that τ(ab)=τ(ba)(a,b∈A),τ(a*a)>0(a∈A,a≠0).\tau(ab) = \tau(ba) \quad (a, b \in A), \qquad \tau(a^*a) > 0 \quad (a \in A,\ a \neq 0).(3)✦

A representation of a C*C^*-algebra AA on a complex Hilbert space HH is a **-homomorphism π:A→B(H)\pi \colon A \to B(H) into the algebra B(H)B(H) of bounded operators on HH, not necessarily unital. A representation π\pi of a C*C^*-algebra AA on a complex Hilbert space HH is irreducible when it is nonzero and its only closed invariant subspaces are 00 and HH: π≠0,M⊆H a closed subspace with π(A)M⊆M⟹M=0 or M=H.\pi \neq 0, \qquad M \subseteq H \text{ a closed subspace with } \pi(A)M \subseteq M \implies M = 0 \text{ or } M = H.(4)✦

Two representations π\pi of AA on HH and ρ\rho of AA on H′H' are unitarily equivalent, written π≃ρ\pi \simeq \rho, when there is a unitary U:H→H′U \colon H \to H' such that Uπ(a)=ρ(a)U(a∈A).U \pi(a) = \rho(a) U \quad (a \in A).(5)✦

A C*C^*-algebra AA has a unique irreducible representation when any two irreducible representations π\pi and ρ\rho of AA, on any two complex Hilbert spaces, are unitarily equivalent: π,ρ irreducible⟹π≃ρ.\pi, \rho \text{ irreducible} \implies \pi \simeq \rho.(6)✦

A C*C^*-algebra AA is isomorphic to the algebra K(H)K(H) of compact operators on a complex Hilbert space HH when there is an injective **-homomorphism φ:A→B(H)\varphi \colon A \to B(H) with φ(A)=K(H).\varphi(A) = K(H).(7)✦

In the paper, the definitions read: AA is simple when it is nonzero with no closed two-sided ideals but 00 and AA; a tracial state τ\tau is faithful when τ(a*a)>0\tau(a^*a) > 0 for a≠0a \neq 0; a representation is irreducible when it is nonzero and has no nontrivial closed invariant subspace; and AA is isomorphic to K(H)K(H) when some injective **-homomorphism A→B(H)A \to B(H) has range exactly the compact operators.

What Is Checked

The definitions (1) to (7) are stated over a C*C^*-algebra AA, continuous linear functionals on AA, complex Hilbert spaces HH and H′H', and **-homomorphisms of AA into B(H)B(H) and B(H′)B(H').