The Setting
Naimark’s problem asks whether a -algebra with only one irreducible representation up to unitary equivalence must be isomorphic to the compact operators on some Hilbert space. In a counterexample all pure states are equivalent, and a construction that merges the classes of two pure states, the bridge, is a step toward one. Given two inequivalent pure states and of a simple -algebra , the question is whether their classes can be merged in a larger algebra without merging any other two, while each pure state of keeps exactly one state extension.
The larger algebra is the reduced HNN (Higman-Neumann-Neumann) extension . It takes a faithful tracial state of and two decreasing sequences of projections and that single out and , with , and adjoins to a unitary with for every . The library states the bridge for such data under the condition that the matrix states and of , defined below, be inequivalent, together with the successor step of a transfinite recursion built from such extensions, the bridge successor defined below.
Pure States and Unique Extensions
A state of a -algebra is a continuous linear functional on of norm one that is real and nonnegative on every ✦, and a pure state of is an extreme point of the set of states.✦ Two pure states and of are equivalent, , when their GNS (Gelfand-Naimark-Segal) representations on and on are unitarily equivalent: for some unitary of onto , (1)✦
Let be a unital -homomorphism of -algebras. The restriction of a functional on is ✦, and a state extension of a functional on is a state of with . A functional on extends uniquely along when it has at most one state extension to .✦ A unital -homomorphism has property (U) when every pure state of extends uniquely along .✦
A -algebra is simple when and its only closed two-sided ideals are and .✦
Bridge Data and the HNN Extension
A decreasing sequence of projections in peaks to a state of when for every and is the only state of with this property.✦ The atoms of a decreasing sequence of projections are the differences .✦
Bridge data on a -algebra consist of a faithful tracial state of and two decreasing sequences of projections and in , peaking to states and , such that for and every (2)✦ For bridge data on and , the matrix state is the pure state of given by (3)✦ Bridge data on are separated when their matrix states are inequivalent, .✦
The reduced HNN extension of bridge data on is built with the -algebra of convergent complex sequences, the continuous functions on . Each sequence gives a unital -homomorphism and an expectation , with equal to at and (4)
Let be the reduced free product of and amalgamated over , which sits in as the matrices and in as the diagonal matrices, with the expectations and . It acts on a Fock space of reduced words, its vacuum state is a trace, and is its expectation onto . With the matrix unit of in the first diagonal place, the extension , the unital -homomorphism , the trace of and the expectation are (5)
A unital -homomorphism is a bridge successor when either is a -isomorphism of onto , or there are separated bridge data on and a -isomorphism of onto with .✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be a -algebra with bridge data peaking to and , and let , , and be as in (5). For every in and every in , (6)✦ (7)✦ (8)✦ If , then (9)✦ Suppose now that is simple and the bridge data are separated. Then (10)✦ and every pure state of has at most one state extension to : for all states and of , (11)✦ For all pure states and of , (12)✦ Let and be inequivalent pure states of such that is neither nor up to equivalence. For all pure states and of , (13)✦ Let be a unital -homomorphism of -algebras, and let and be pure states of with such that extends uniquely along . For all pure states and of , (14)✦ If is injective and a pure state of extends uniquely along , then for some pure state of , (15)✦ If is simple and is a bridge successor, then (16)✦
In the paper, the result reads: let be a unital -algebra with a faithful tracial state and no finite-dimensional irreducible representations, for let be a decreasing sequence of projections with peaking to a pure state , with and , where and , and form the reduced HNN extension with and ; then every pure state of has a unique state extension to , these extensions are pure, and if and only if or , with the class of ; has a faithful tracial state extending and a faithful trace-preserving conditional expectation onto ; and if is simple, then is simple.
What Is Checked
The claim, (9) to (16), is stated over bridge data on a -algebra , a faithful tracial state and two decreasing sequences of projections peaking to and under (2); over the matrix states (3) and their separation, simplicity, and the extension with , and of (5), built from the maps (4); and over unital -homomorphisms, states and pure states, their equivalence (1), unique extension, property (U) and bridge successors.
About these constructions the library proves that a state to which a decreasing sequence of projections peaks is pure✦, and that the atoms of such a sequence are pairwise orthogonal projections. For a state positive on every atom, the ratios converge to for every .✦ When , the matrices over of a fixed finite size with at the diagonal place and zeros elsewhere form a sequence that peaks to the state .✦ For bridge data each is injective✦, and the normalized trace on is tracial when is tracial✦ and faithful when is faithful.✦ The normalized trace takes the value at the identity matrix when .