OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §3. Reduced HNN adjunctions · §3

Lemma 3.2 [Reduced amalgamated free product]: The algebras AiA_i act faithfully on a Fock space; the C*C^*-algebra they generate has a faithful trace extending theirs and trace-preserving expectations onto each

Free products over atomic amalgamation data carry a faithful trace.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let AiA_i, i∈Ii \in I, be C*C^*-algebras with faithful tracial states τi\tau_i, all containing a common subalgebra Δ\Delta onto which they have expectations EiE_i. Their reduced free product amalgamated over Δ\Delta is to be built as a concrete algebra of operators, with its trace and its expectations onto the AiA_i. The library does this when Δ\Delta acts by scalars on a family of orthogonal projections in each AiA_i, taking the norm closure of the AiA_i acting on a Fock space of reduced paths, with the vector functional of a vacuum vector as the trace.

Atomic Data

Atomic trace data on a C*C^*-algebra AA, with atoms indexed by a set VV, consist of a faithful tracial state τ\tau on AA and projections er∈Ae_r \in A, r∈Vr \in V, called atoms, such that elek=0(l≠k),τ(er)>0,∑r∈Vτ(er)=1.e_l e_k = 0 \quad (l \neq k), \qquad \tau(e_r) > 0, \qquad \sum_{r \in V} \tau(e_r) = 1.(1)✦

From here on each AiA_i, i∈Ii \in I, carries atomic trace data (τi,ei)(\tau_i, e^i), its atoms erie^i_r indexed by one set VV for all ii.

Atomic amalgamation data for this family consist of a C*C^*-algebra Δ\Delta, unital *-homomorphisms δi:Δ→Ai\delta_i \colon \Delta \to A_i, scalars χx(r)\chi_x(r) for x∈Δx \in \Delta and r∈Vr \in V, bounded linear maps Ei:Ai→ΔE_i \colon A_i \to \Delta and a base index i0∈Ii_0 \in I, such that for all i∈Ii \in I, x∈Δx \in \Delta, a∈Aia \in A_i and r∈Vr \in V eriδi(x)=χx(r)eri,Ei(δi(x))=x,Ei(δi(x)a)=xEi(a),Ei(a)=0⟹τi(eriaeri)=0,τi(eri)=τi0(eri0).\begin{gathered} e^i_r \, \delta_i(x) = \chi_x(r) \, e^i_r, \qquad E_i(\delta_i(x)) = x, \qquad E_i(\delta_i(x) \, a) = x \, E_i(a), \\ E_i(a) = 0 \implies \tau_i(e^i_r \, a \, e^i_r) = 0, \qquad \tau_i(e^i_r) = \tau_{i_0}(e^{i_0}_r). \end{gathered}(2)✦

An element aa of AiA_i is centered when Ei(a)=0E_i(a) = 0.

The Fock Space

Let τ\tau be a tracial positive functional on a C*C^*-algebra AA and q∈Aq \in A a projection. The trace column of qq is the closed subspace Aq¯\overline{Aq} of the Gelfand-Naimark-Segal (GNS) space L2(A,τ)L^2(A, \tau), the range of right multiplication bˆ↦bqˆ\hat b \mapsto \widehat{bq}, where bˆ\hat b is the class of bb.✦ The column representation of AA on Aq¯\overline{Aq} is the restriction of the GNS representation to it.✦

For atomic trace data (τ,e)(\tau, e) on AA and l,r∈Vl, r \in V, the centered column from ll to rr is the subspace of Aer¯\overline{A e_r} Cl,r={ξ∈elAer¯:⟨eˆr,ξ⟩=0}.C_{l,r} = \bigl\{ \xi \in e_l \, \overline{A e_r} : \langle \hat e_r, \xi \rangle = 0 \bigr\}.(3)✦ For i∈Ii \in I and l,r∈Vl, r \in V, fix a Hilbert basis of the centered column Cl,rC_{l,r} of (τi,ei)(\tau_i, e^i) and let Li(l,r)L_i(l, r) be its index set; the elements of Li(l,r)L_i(l, r) are the letters of AiA_i from ll to rr. The column index set Ji(r)J_i(r) consists of one vacuum point *\ast and the letters in Li(l,r)L_i(l, r) for all l∈Vl \in V.✦ The unit vector eˆri/τi(eri)\hat e^i_r / \sqrt{\tau_i(e^i_r)} and the chosen bases of the centered columns Cl,rC_{l,r}, l∈Vl \in V, form the tracial column basis of Aieri¯\overline{A_i e^i_r}, indexed by Ji(r)J_i(r)✦; carried by it to ℓ2(Ji(r))\ell^2(J_i(r)), the column representation becomes a representation πri\pi^i_r of AiA_i on ℓ2(Ji(r))\ell^2(J_i(r)).✦

A reduced path starting at a vertex l∈Vl \in V is either the empty path ⌀l\varnothing_l at ll or a letter a∈Li(l,r)a \in L_i(l, r), for some i∈Ii \in I and r∈Vr \in V, followed by a reduced path starting at rr whose first letter, if it has one, is not a letter of AiA_i.✦ The Fock space ℱ\mathcal F is the Hilbert space ℓ2\ell^2 of the reduced paths over all starting vertices, with standard basis vectors δt\delta_t, one for each reduced path tt.✦ For k∈Ik \in I, the vacuum vector of kk is Ωk=∑r∈Vτk(erk)δ⌀r.\Omega_k = \sum_{r \in V} \sqrt{\tau_k(e^k_r)} \; \delta_{\varnothing_r}.(4)✦

Fix i∈Ii \in I, and let s(t)s(t) be the starting vertex of a reduced path tt. Joining sends a pair (t,c)(t, c) of a reduced path tt that does not begin with a letter of AiA_i and a point c∈Ji(s(t))c \in J_i(s(t)) to the path tt when c=*c = \ast, and to the path ctct when cc is a letter.✦ The Fock block unitary UiU_i is the unitary of ⨁tℓ2(Ji(s(t)))\bigoplus_t \ell^2(J_i(s(t))) onto ℱ\mathcal F, where tt runs over the reduced paths not beginning with a letter of AiA_i, that sends the basis vector indexed by a pair (t,c)(t, c) to the basis vector of the joined path. The left representation of AiA_i on ℱ\mathcal F is λi(a)=Ui(⨁tπs(t)i(a))Ui*(a∈Ai).\lambda_i(a) = U_i \Bigl( \bigoplus_t \pi^i_{s(t)}(a) \Bigr) U_i^* \qquad (a \in A_i).(5)✦

The atomic C*C^*-algebra 𝒜\mathcal A is the norm closure of the *-algebra of bounded operators on ℱ\mathcal F generated by the λi(Ai)\lambda_i(A_i), i∈Ii \in I. The atomic embedding of AiA_i is λi\lambda_i, taken as a unital *-homomorphism Ai→𝒜A_i \to \mathcal A.✦ The atomic trace on 𝒜\mathcal A is the vector functional of the vacuum vector of the base index, φ(b)=⟨Ωi0,bΩi0⟩(b∈𝒜).\varphi(b) = \langle \Omega_{i_0}, b \, \Omega_{i_0} \rangle \qquad (b \in \mathcal A).(6)✦

Centered Words and Expectations

Given linear subspaces KiK_i, i∈Ii \in I, of an algebra BB, a centered word in the KiK_i is a finite sequence (i1,b1),…,(in,bn)(i_1, b_1), \dots, (i_n, b_n) with bj∈Kijb_j \in K_{i_j} for every jj and ij≠ij+1i_j \neq i_{j+1} for j<nj < n.✦ The value of such a word is the product b1b2⋯bnb_1 b_2 \cdots b_n in BB, and 11 for the empty word.✦ The normal span of a subalgebra DD and the KiK_i is the linear span of DD and the values of all centered words in the KiK_i.✦ A family of subalgebras FiF_i of BB has a centered decomposition over DD with the KiK_i when D⊂FiD \subset F_i, Ki⊂FiK_i \subset F_i, Fi=D+KiF_i = D + K_i and DKi⊂KiD K_i \subset K_i for every ii.✦

The atomic expectation kernel KiK_i at i∈Ii \in I is the subspace λi(ker⁡Ei)\lambda_i(\ker E_i) of 𝒜\mathcal A, the image of the centered elements of AiA_i.✦ The atomic diagonal DkD_k at k∈Ik \in I is the subalgebra λk(δk(Δ))\lambda_k(\delta_k(\Delta)) of 𝒜\mathcal A.✦

Let BB be a *-algebra of bounded operators on a Hilbert space, ιi:Ai→B\iota_i \colon A_i \to B *-homomorphisms, DD a subalgebra and KiK_i subspaces of BB, and ξ\xi a vector. Suppose the ιi(Ai)\iota_i(A_i) have a centered decomposition over DD with the KiK_i, the vector functional of ξ\xi is tracial on BB and vanishes on the values of nonempty centered words, the normal span of DD and the KiK_i is dense in BB, and ξ\xi is separating for each ιi(Ai)\iota_i(A_i). Let MiM_i be the cyclic subspace ιi(Ai)ξ¯\overline{\iota_i(A_i) \xi} and PiP_i the orthogonal projection onto it. The factor expectation onto AiA_i is the bounded linear map B→AiB \to A_i that sends bb to the unique a∈Aia \in A_i with Pibη=ιi(a)η(η∈Mi).P_i \, b \, \eta = \iota_i(a) \, \eta \qquad (\eta \in M_i).(7)✦

The atomic expectation ℰi:𝒜→Ai\mathcal E_i \colon \mathcal A \to A_i is the factor expectation (7) for B=𝒜B = \mathcal A, ιi=λi\iota_i = \lambda_i, D=Di0D = D_{i_0}, the kernels KiK_i and ξ=Ωi0\xi = \Omega_{i_0}.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let AiA_i, i∈Ii \in I, be C*C^*-algebras carrying atomic trace data (τi,ei)(\tau_i, e^i) with atoms indexed by a common set VV, and let (Δ,δi,χ,Ei,i0)(\Delta, \delta_i, \chi, E_i, i_0) be atomic amalgamation data for them, as in (2). Let 𝒜\mathcal A be the atomic C*C^*-algebra, with atomic embeddings λi\lambda_i, atomic trace φ\varphi, atomic expectations ℰi\mathcal E_i, vacuum vectors Ωk\Omega_k and atomic diagonals DkD_k, and let WW be the set of values of centered words in the kernels KiK_i. Then for every i∈Ii \in I ker⁡λi={0}.\ker \lambda_i = \{0\}.(8)✦ For i∈Ii \in I, a∈Aia \in A_i and b,c∈𝒜b, c \in \mathcal A, the atomic trace satisfies φ(λi(a))=τi(a),\varphi(\lambda_i(a)) = \tau_i(a),(9)✦ φ(bc)=φ(cb),\varphi(bc) = \varphi(cb),(10)✦ φ(b*b)=0⟹b=0,\varphi(b^* b) = 0 \implies b = 0,(11)✦ and the atomic expectation onto AiA_i satisfies ℰi(λi(a))=a,\mathcal E_i(\lambda_i(a)) = a,(12)✦ τi(ℰi(b))=φ(b),\tau_i(\mathcal E_i(b)) = \varphi(b),(13)✦ ℰi(b*b)=0⟹b=0.\mathcal E_i(b^* b) = 0 \implies b = 0.(14)✦ For every k∈Ik \in I and every centered word (i1,b1),…,(in,bn)(i_1, b_1), \dots, (i_n, b_n) in the KiK_i with n≥1n \geq 1, ⟨Ωk,b1b2⋯bnΩk⟩=0,\langle \Omega_k, b_1 b_2 \cdots b_n \, \Omega_k \rangle = 0,(15)✦ and for every k∈Ik \in I span⁡(Dk∪W)¯=𝒜.\overline{\operatorname{span}(D_k \cup W)} = \mathcal A.(16)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if A1A_1 and A2A_2 are C*C^*-algebras with faithful tracial states, containing a common subalgebra Δ\Delta on which the traces agree, with trace-preserving conditional expectations E1E_1, E2E_2 onto Δ\Delta, then there is a C*C^*-algebra ZZ generated by faithful copies of A1A_1 and A2A_2 agreeing on Δ\Delta, with a faithful tracial state extending both traces and faithful trace-preserving conditional expectations EΔ:Z→ΔE_\Delta \colon Z \to \Delta and EA1:Z→A1E_{A_1} \colon Z \to A_1 with EΔ=E1∘EA1E_\Delta = E_1 \circ E_{A_1}, such that EΔE_\Delta vanishes on every nonempty alternating product of centered elements, EA1E_{A_1} vanishes on the products (3.3) of the paper, and A1A_1 and these products span a dense subspace of ZZ, the paper writing FF, GG, DD and EDFE^F_D for A1A_1, A2A_2, Δ\Delta and E1E_1.

The box answers it for any family (Ai)i∈I(A_i)_{i \in I} whose common algebra Δ\Delta acts on the atoms by scalars, with 𝒜\mathcal A, φ\varphi and ℰi\mathcal E_i in the roles of ZZ, its tracial state and EA1E_{A_1}.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over atomic trace data on the AiA_i and atomic amalgamation data for them, and over what is built from them: the Fock space ℱ\mathcal F of reduced paths in the letters, the left representations λi\lambda_i, the atomic C*C^*-algebra 𝒜\mathcal A with its vacuum vectors Ωk\Omega_k and atomic trace φ\varphi, the centered words in the kernels KiK_i, and the atomic expectations ℰi\mathcal E_i.

About these constructions the library proves that the trace column Aq¯\overline{Aq} is invariant under the GNS representation✦, and that for a representation π\pi of AA and a vector ξ\xi the cyclic subspace π(A)ξ¯\overline{\pi(A)\xi} is invariant under π(A)\pi(A).✦ A unit vector ξ\xi together with orthonormal bases of the subspaces Ml∩{ξ}⟂M_l \cap \{\xi\}^\perp, for mutually orthogonal subspaces MlM_l, is shown to be an orthonormal family✦, and joining a pair (t,c)(t, c) into a path to be a bijection whose inverse splits off a first letter of AiA_i.✦ Under the hypotheses of the factor expectation, the compression η↦Pibη\eta \mapsto P_i b \eta of every b∈Bb \in B to MiM_i is proved to be the action of an element of AiA_i; in 𝒜\mathcal A, every λi(Ai)\lambda_i(A_i) has a centered decomposition over Di0D_{i_0} with the kernels KiK_i, and Ωi0\Omega_{i_0} is separating for each λi(Ai)\lambda_i(A_i). For Hilbert bases of Hilbert spaces HiH_i, the basis vectors of each HiH_i, placed in the iith summand of the Hilbert direct sum of the HiH_i, form an orthonormal family.