OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §3. Reduced HNN adjunctions · §3

Proposition 3.1 [The reduced adjunction]: The algebra H(A)H(A) with vpn1v*=pn2vp^1_nv^* = p^2_n, a faithful trace and an expectation onto AA, determined by a faithful state vanishing on reduced words

Adjoining a unitary that carries one peaking sequence to another.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let AA be a C*C^*-algebra with a faithful tracial state, and let two decreasing sequences of projections in AA have the same traces term by term and peak to states f1f_1 and f2f_2. The question is whether a unitary carrying the first sequence to the second can be adjoined to AA as freely as possible, keeping a faithful trace that extends the given one and an expectation back onto AA, and how far these data determine the algebra so obtained. The library answers with the reduced Higman-Neumann-Neumann (HNN) extension H(A)H(A) of AA along the two sequences.

Bridge Data and Reduced Words

A decreasing sequence (pn)n≥0(p_n)_{n \ge 0} of projections in AA peaks to a state hh of AA when h(pn)=1h(p_n) = 1 for every nn and hh is the only state of AA with this property.✦ The atoms of a sequence (pn)(p_n) of projections are the differences dn=pn−pn+1d_n = p_n - p_{n+1}.✦

Bridge data (τ,p1,p2)(\tau, p^1, p^2) on a C*C^*-algebra AA consist of a faithful tracial state τ\tau of AA and two sequences p1p^1 and p2p^2 of projections in AA, with atoms dn1d^1_n and dn2d^2_n, that peak to states f1f_1 and f2f_2 and satisfy, for i=1,2i = 1, 2 and every nn, p0i=1,τ(dni)>0,τ(pni)→0,τ(pn1)=τ(pn2).p^i_0 = 1, \qquad \tau(d^i_n) > 0, \qquad \tau(p^i_n) \to 0, \qquad \tau(p^1_n) = \tau(p^2_n).(1)✦

Let c=C(ℕ∪{∞})c = C(\mathbb{N} \cup \{\infty\}) be the C*C^*-algebra of convergent complex sequences, with g(∞)=lim⁡ngng(\infty) = \lim_n g_n for g∈cg \in c.✦ Each sequence pip^i gives a unital **-homomorphism δi:c→A\delta_i : c \to A and a bounded linear map εi:A→c\varepsilon_i : A \to c, δi(g)=g(∞)1+∑n(gn−g(∞))dni,εi(a)n=τ(dniadni)τ(dni),εi(a)(∞)=fi(a).\delta_i(g) = g(\infty)\,1 + \sum_n \bigl(g_n - g(\infty)\bigr)\,d^i_n, \qquad \varepsilon_i(a)_n = \frac{\tau(d^i_n a d^i_n)}{\tau(d^i_n)}, \qquad \varepsilon_i(a)(\infty) = f_i(a).(2) The diagonal of pip^i is the range Di=δi(c)D_i = \delta_i(c), and δi\delta_i is injective.✦ The expectation EiE_i of AA onto DiD_i is δi∘εi\delta_i \circ \varepsilon_i, and θ=δ2∘δ1−1\theta = \delta_2 \circ \delta_1^{-1} is the **-isomorphism of D1D_1 onto D2D_2 that sends each dn1d^1_n to dn2d^2_n. The algebra cc carries the faithful tracial state g↦τ(δ1(g))g \mapsto \tau(\delta_1(g)), the pullback of τ\tau along the injective map δ1\delta_1. Write en=ε1(dn1)e_n = \varepsilon_1(d^1_n) for n≥0n \ge 0; these sequences play the role of the atoms in cc, and they satisfy eng=gnene_n g = g_n e_n for g∈cg \in c. The 2×22 \times 2 matrix algebras M2(A)M_2(A) and M2(c)M_2(c) carry the normalized traces of these states, with atoms the diagonal matrix units multiplied by the atoms of AA and of cc.

Let ψ:A→C\psi : A \to C be a unital **-homomorphism into a C*C^*-algebra CC, and let x∈Cx \in C. A word in ψ(A)\psi(A) and xx is a product x1ψ(a1)x2ψ(a2)⋯xkψ(ak),k≥1,xj∈{x,x*},aj∈A,x_1\psi(a_1)\,x_2\psi(a_2)\cdots x_k\psi(a_k), \qquad k \ge 1, \quad x_j \in \{x, x^*\}, \quad a_j \in A,(3) with coefficients a1,…,aka_1, \dots, a_k. A word (3) is reduced when E1(aj)=0E_1(a_j) = 0 wherever xj=xx_j = x and xj+1=x*x_{j+1} = x^*, and E2(aj)=0E_2(a_j) = 0 wherever xj=x*x_j = x^* and xj+1=xx_{j+1} = x.✦ For x∈Cx \in C, the C*C^*-algebra C*(ψ(A),x)C^*(\psi(A), x) is the closed **-subalgebra of CC generated by ψ(A)\psi(A) and xx.✦

The Reduced HNN Extension

The reduced HNN extension H(A)H(A) of AA along bridge data is built as a corner. Write ejke_{jk} for the matrix units. The algebras M2(A)M_2(A) and M2(c)M_2(c) act on a common Fock space, built from τ\tau and the atoms dnid^i_n, through unital **-homomorphisms φA\varphi_A and φc\varphi_c, amalgamated over c⊕cc \oplus c, whose element (g,h)(g, h) sits in M2(A)M_2(A) as the matrix diag(δ1(g),δ2(h))\mathrm{diag}(\delta_1(g), \delta_2(h)) and in M2(c)M_2(c) as diag(g,h)\mathrm{diag}(g, h). Let ℳ\mathcal{M} be the C*C^*-algebra generated by the two images✦, τℳ\tau_{\mathcal{M}} its vector functional at the vacuum vector✦ and Eℳ:ℳ→M2(A)E_{\mathcal{M}} : \mathcal{M} \to M_2(A) its expectation onto M2(A)M_2(A).✦ Then H(A)H(A) is the corner eℳee\mathcal{M}e cut by the projection e=φA(e11)e = \varphi_A(e_{11}), a C*C^*-algebra with unit ee.✦ The canonical map ι:A→H(A)\iota : A \to H(A), a unital **-homomorphism, the stable unitary vv, the trace τH\tau_H and the expectation EA:H(A)→AE_A : H(A) \to A, a bounded linear map, are given for a∈Aa \in A and x∈H(A)x \in H(A) by ι(a)=φA(ae11),v=φA(e12)φc(e21),τH(x)=2τℳ(x),EA(x)=Eℳ(x)11.\iota(a) = \varphi_A(a\,e_{11}), \qquad v = \varphi_A(e_{12})\,\varphi_c(e_{21}), \qquad \tau_H(x) = 2\,\tau_{\mathcal{M}}(x), \qquad E_A(x) = E_{\mathcal{M}}(x)_{11}.(4) The letters of H(A)H(A) are vv and v*v^*.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let AA be a C*C^*-algebra with bridge data (τ,p1,p2)(\tau, p^1, p^2), and let H(A)H(A), ι\iota, vv, τH\tau_H and EAE_A be as in (4). Then the following hold, where aa ranges over AA, xx and yy over H(A)H(A), nn over the integers n≥0n \ge 0, and uu over the reduced words in ι(A)\iota(A) and vv. ker⁡ι=0,\ker \iota = 0,(5)✦ vι(pn1)v*=ι(pn2),v\,\iota(p^1_n)\,v^* = \iota(p^2_n),(6)✦ the letters satisfy the turn relations vι(a)v*=vι(a−E1(a))v*+ι(θ(E1(a))),v*ι(a)v=v*ι(a−E2(a))v+ι(θ−1(E2(a))),\begin{aligned} v\,\iota(a)\,v^* &= v\,\iota\bigl(a - E_1(a)\bigr)\,v^* + \iota\bigl(\theta(E_1(a))\bigr),\\ v^*\iota(a)\,v &= v^*\iota\bigl(a - E_2(a)\bigr)\,v + \iota\bigl(\theta^{-1}(E_2(a))\bigr), \end{aligned}(7)✦ and C*(ι(A),v)=H(A).C^*(\iota(A), v) = H(A).(8)✦ The trace τH\tau_H satisfies ∥τH∥=1,τH(x*x)≥0,\|\tau_H\| = 1, \qquad \tau_H(x^*x) \ge 0,(9)✦ τH(ι(a))=τ(a),\tau_H(\iota(a)) = \tau(a),(10)✦ τH(x*x)=0⟹x=0,\tau_H(x^*x) = 0 \implies x = 0,(11)✦ τH(xy)=τH(yx),\tau_H(xy) = \tau_H(yx),(12)✦ and the expectation EAE_A satisfies EA(ι(a))=a,E_A(\iota(a)) = a,(13)✦ EA(ι(a)u)=0,E_A(\iota(a)\,u) = 0,(14)✦ τ(EA(x))=τH(x),\tau(E_A(x)) = \tau_H(x),(15)✦ EA(x*x)=0⟹x=0.E_A(x^*x) = 0 \implies x = 0.(16)✦ Let further CC be a C*C^*-algebra, ψ:A→C\psi : A \to C a unital **-homomorphism and w∈Cw \in C an element such that ψ\psi and ww satisfy the turn relations (7) in place of ι\iota and vv. If gg is a faithful positive functional on CC with g∘ψ=τg \circ \psi = \tau and g(ψ(a)u)=0g(\psi(a)\,u) = 0 for every a∈Aa \in A and every reduced word uu in ψ(A)\psi(A) and ww, there is an injective unital **-homomorphism F:H(A)→CF : H(A) \to C with F∘ι=ψ,F(v)=w,g∘F=τH,F(H(A))=C*(ψ(A),w).F \circ \iota = \psi, \qquad F(v) = w, \qquad g \circ F = \tau_H, \qquad F(H(A)) = C^*(\psi(A), w).(17)✦ If instead C=C*(ψ(A),w)C = C^*(\psi(A), w), SS is a dense subset of AA that contains a−E1(a)a - E_1(a) and a−E2(a)a - E_2(a) for every a∈Sa \in S, and gg is a faithful state on CC with g∘ψ=τg \circ \psi = \tau and g(ψ(a)u)=0g(\psi(a)\,u) = 0 for every a∈Sa \in S and every reduced word uu in ψ(A)\psi(A) and ww with coefficients in SS, there is a **-isomorphism Φ:H(A)→C\Phi : H(A) \to C with Φ∘ι=ψ,Φ(v)=w,g∘Φ=τH.\Phi \circ \iota = \psi, \qquad \Phi(v) = w, \qquad g \circ \Phi = \tau_H.(18)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a unital C*C^*-algebra AA with a faithful tracial state τ\tau, unital subalgebras D1,D2⊂AD_1, D_2 \subset A with trace-preserving conditional expectations Ei:A→DiE_i : A \to D_i and a trace-preserving isomorphism θ:D1→D2\theta : D_1 \to D_2, there is a unital extension H(A)=C*(A,v)H(A) = C^*(A, v) with a faithful tracial state extending τ\tau, with vdv*=θ(d)vdv^* = \theta(d) for d∈D1d \in D_1 and with a trace-preserving conditional expectation EA:H(A)→AE_A : H(A) \to A annihilating every nonempty reduced word, and among faithfully tracial extensions generated by AA and such a unitary, the relation and the vanishing of the trace on nonempty reduced words determine H(A)H(A) uniquely, by an isomorphism fixing AA and vv.

The statement takes for DiD_i the diagonals of p1p^1 and p2p^2, and gives uniqueness as the embedding (17) and the isomorphism (18).

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over bridge data (1) on a C*C^*-algebra AA, the maps δi\delta_i and εi\varepsilon_i of (2) with the expectations EiE_i and the isomorphism θ\theta, the reduced words (3), and the reduced HNN extension H(A)H(A) with the maps and the unitary of (4).

Beyond the claim, the library proves that the atoms dnid^i_n are pairwise orthogonal projections and that the corner states τ(dniadni)/τ(dni)\tau(d^i_n a d^i_n)/\tau(d^i_n) converge to fi(a)f_i(a) as n→∞n \to \infty.✦ The map εi\varepsilon_i has norm at most one, with εi(δi(g))=g\varepsilon_i(\delta_i(g)) = g and εi(δi(g)a)=gεi(a)\varepsilon_i(\delta_i(g)\,a) = g\,\varepsilon_i(a) for g∈cg \in c and a∈Aa \in A, and on Mk(A)M_k(A) the normalized trace m↦1k∑jτ(mjj)m \mapsto \frac{1}{k}\sum_j \tau(m_{jj}) is a faithful tracial state.