OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Closed subiterations and countable determination · §5

Lemma 5.1 [Unique extensions along a chain]: Unique extension holds along a continuous chain of injective bridge steps over a simple B0B_0, and unique lifts of equivalent pure states are equivalent

Unique extension of pure states passes along continuous chains.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Fix an ordinal λ\lambda and build a family of C*^*-algebras by transfinite recursion: a C*^*-algebra BαB_\alpha for each ordinal α≤λ\alpha\le\lambda, with unital **-homomorphisms Bα→BβB_\alpha\to B_\beta for α≤β\alpha\le\beta, where each successor stage Bα+1B_{\alpha+1} is made from BαB_\alpha, for instance as a reduced Higman-Neumann-Neumann (HNN) extension, and each limit stage is the closure of the stages before it.

The question is whether pure states keep a unique extension through the recursion. If every pure state of BαB_\alpha has at most one extension to a state of Bα+1B_{\alpha+1}, for every α<λ\alpha<\lambda, does every pure state of BαB_\alpha have at most one extension to a state of BβB_\beta, across the limit stages as well? And when two pure states of BαB_\alpha have unitarily equivalent Gelfand-Naimark-Segal (GNS) representations, are their extensions to BβB_\beta equivalent too?

The library answers both questions, and gives a second answer to the first for chains whose successor steps are isomorphisms or embeddings into reduced HNN extensions, over a simple first stage.

States and Unique Extension

A state of a C*^*-algebra BB is a continuous linear functional ff on BB of norm one such that f(a*a)f(a^*a) is real and nonnegative for every aa in BB.✦ A pure state of BB is an extreme point of the set of states of BB.✦

Two representations π\pi and ρ\rho of BB on Hilbert spaces ℋ\mathcal H and 𝒦\mathcal K are unitarily equivalent when some unitary UU of ℋ\mathcal H onto 𝒦\mathcal K satisfies Uπ(a)=ρ(a)UU\pi(a)=\rho(a)U for every aa in BB.✦ Two pure states hh and kk of BB are equivalent, h∼kh\sim k, when their GNS representations πh\pi_h and πk\pi_k are unitarily equivalent.

The restriction of a bounded functional FF on CC along a unital **-homomorphism φ:B→C\varphi\colon B\to C is the functional F|B=F∘φF|_B=F\circ\varphi on BB.✦ A bounded functional hh on BB has at most one state extension to CC when any two states of CC whose restrictions to BB equal hh coincide.✦ A unital **-homomorphism φ:B→C\varphi\colon B\to C has the unique extension property (U) when every pure state of BB has at most one state extension to CC.✦

Ordinal Chains

An ordinal chain (Bα,φαβ)(B_\alpha,\varphi_{\alpha\beta}) of C*^*-algebras is a family of C*^*-algebras BαB_\alpha, one for every ordinal α\alpha, with a unital **-homomorphism φαβ:Bα→Bβ\varphi_{\alpha\beta}\colon B_\alpha\to B_\beta for every α≤β\alpha\le\beta, such that φαα=idBα,φβγ∘φαβ=φαγ(α≤β≤γ).\varphi_{\alpha\alpha}=\mathrm{id}_{B_\alpha},\qquad \varphi_{\beta\gamma}\circ\varphi_{\alpha\beta}=\varphi_{\alpha\gamma} \quad(\alpha\le\beta\le\gamma).(1) The successor steps of an ordinal chain (Bα,φαβ)(B_\alpha,\varphi_{\alpha\beta}) are the maps φα,α+1\varphi_{\alpha,\alpha+1}. The chain is continuous up to an ordinal λ\lambda when, at every limit ordinal β≤λ\beta\le\lambda, the images of the earlier stages have dense union in BβB_\beta: Bβ=⋃α<βφαβ(Bα)¯.B_\beta=\overline{\bigcup_{\alpha<\beta}\varphi_{\alpha\beta}(B_\alpha)}.(2)

Bridge Steps

A C*^*-algebra BB is simple when it is nonzero and its only closed two-sided ideals are 00 and BB.✦ A positive functional τ\tau on BB is tracial when τ(ab)=τ(ba)\tau(ab)=\tau(ba) for all aa, bb in BB.✦ A decreasing sequence of projections (pn)(p_n) in BB peaks to a state ff of BB when f(pn)=1f(p_n)=1 for every nn and ff is the only state of BB with this property✦; its differences are dn=pn−pn+1d_n=p_n-p_{n+1}✦.

The algebra of convergent sequences is the C*^*-algebra C(ℕ∪{∞})C(\mathbb N\cup\{\infty\}) of continuous complex functions on the one-point compactification of ℕ\mathbb N, that is, of convergent complex sequences.✦

For a projection ee in a C*^*-algebra AA, the corner eAe={a∈A:ea=a=ae}eAe=\{a\in A:\ ea=a=ae\} is a C*^*-algebra with unit ee.

Atomic trace data on a C*^*-algebra AA consist of a faithful normalized tracial positive functional τ\tau and pairwise orthogonal projections ere_r in AA, indexed by a set VV, each of positive trace, whose traces sum to τ(1)\tau(1).✦

Given C*^*-algebras AiA_i with atomic trace data did_i, the atomic C*^*-algebra is the norm closure of the algebra generated by the AiA_i in their atomic representations on the Fock space over the atomic letters, the Hilbert space ℓ2\ell^2 of the reduced words in those letters.✦

The two factors of the construction are M2(B)M_2(B) and M2(C(ℕ∪{∞}))M_2(C(\mathbb N\cup\{\infty\})), with ejke_{jk} the matrix units of M2M_2. On each the trace is the normalized matrix trace M↦12∑iτ(Mii)M\mapsto\frac12\sum_i\tau(M_{ii}), with atoms indexed by pairs (i,n)(i,n); the atoms of M2(B)M_2(B) are the matrix units dnieiid^i_n e_{ii}, and the algebra of convergent sequences carries the trace induced from τ\tau by its embedding g↦g(∞)1+∑n(gn−g(∞))dng\mapsto g(\infty)1+\sum_n(g_n-g(\infty))d_n into BB.

Bridge data on BB consist of a tracial positive functional τ\tau on BB with τ(1)=1\tau(1)=1 that is faithful, τ(a*a)=0\tau(a^*a)=0 only for a=0a=0, and two decreasing sequences of projections p1p^1 and p2p^2 in BB peaking to states f1f_1 and f2f_2, such that for i=1,2i=1,2 and every nn p0i=1,τ(dni)>0,τ(pn1)=τ(pn2),limn→∞τ(pni)=0.p^i_0=1,\qquad \tau(d^i_n)>0,\qquad \tau(p^1_n)=\tau(p^2_n),\qquad \lim_{n\to\infty}\tau(p^i_n)=0.(3)✦ The reduced HNN extension H(B)H(B) of bridge data on BB is the corner φ(e11)Dφ(e11)\varphi(e_{11})\,D\,\varphi(e_{11}) of the atomic C*^*-algebra DD of the two factors M2(B)M_2(B) and M2(C(ℕ∪{∞}))M_2(C(\mathbb N\cup\{\infty\})), where φ:M2(B)→D\varphi\colon M_2(B)\to D is the embedding of the first factor; its unit is φ(e11)\varphi(e_{11}), and ι:B→H(B)\iota\colon B\to H(B) is the unital **-homomorphism b↦φ(be11)b\mapsto\varphi(b\,e_{11}). The matrix state ωi\omega_i of bridge data on BB, for i=1,2i=1,2, is the state of M2(B)M_2(B) that applies fif_i to the iith diagonal entry: ωi(x)=fi(xii)(x=(xjk)∈M2(B)).\omega_i(x)=f_i(x_{ii})\qquad\bigl(x=(x_{jk})\in M_2(B)\bigr).(4)✦ Bridge data on BB are separated when their matrix states, both pure, satisfy ω1≁ω2\omega_1\not\sim\omega_2.✦

A unital **-homomorphism φ:B→C\varphi\colon B\to C is a bridge step when either φ\varphi is a **-isomorphism of BB onto CC, or there are separated bridge data on BB and a **-isomorphism ee of H(B)H(B) onto CC with e∘ι=φe\circ\iota=\varphi.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. In (a) and (b), (Bα,φαβ)(B_\alpha,\varphi_{\alpha\beta}) is an ordinal chain of C*^*-algebras that is continuous up to an ordinal λ\lambda, as in (2).

(a) If every successor step φα,α+1\varphi_{\alpha,\alpha+1} with α<λ\alpha<\lambda has (U), then φαβ:Bα→Bβhas (U) for allα≤β≤λ.\varphi_{\alpha\beta}\colon B_\alpha\to B_\beta\ \text{has (U) for all}\ \alpha\le\beta\le\lambda.(5)✦

(b) If B0B_0 is simple, every map φαβ\varphi_{\alpha\beta} with α≤β\alpha\le\beta is injective, and every successor step φα,α+1\varphi_{\alpha,\alpha+1} with α<λ\alpha<\lambda is a bridge step, then φαβ:Bα→Bβhas (U) for allα≤β≤λ.\varphi_{\alpha\beta}\colon B_\alpha\to B_\beta\ \text{has (U) for all}\ \alpha\le\beta\le\lambda.(6)✦

(c) Let φ:B→C\varphi\colon B\to C be a unital **-homomorphism, and let hh and kk be pure states of BB with h∼kh\sim k, where kk has at most one state extension to CC. If h̃\tilde h and k̃\tilde k are pure states of CC with h̃|B=h\tilde h|_B=h and k̃|B=k\tilde k|_B=k, then h̃∼k̃.\tilde h\sim\tilde k.(7)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if (Bα)α≤λ(B_\alpha)_{\alpha\le\lambda} is a continuous chain whose successor inclusions have (U), then every inclusion Bα⊂BβB_\alpha\subset B_\beta with α≤β≤λ\alpha\le\beta\le\lambda has (U), and the unique lifts of equivalent pure states are equivalent, the inclusions being the maps φαβ\varphi_{\alpha\beta} and the lift of a pure state its unique state extension.

What Is Checked

The claims (5) and (6) are stated over ordinal chains (1) of C*^*-algebras continuous up to λ\lambda and over the property (U) of unital **-homomorphisms, with its states, pure states and restrictions of states; the claim (6) is stated over simple C*^*-algebras and bridge steps as well, built from bridge data (3), their reduced HNN extensions H(B)H(B) and their matrix states (4). The claim (7) is stated over pure states, their GNS representations and unitary equivalence, and at most one state extension along a unital **-homomorphism.

The library proves that a state to which a decreasing sequence of projections peaks is pure✦, and that peaking passes to matrices: if (pn)(p_n) peaks to ff in BB and p0=1p_0=1, then for every positive integer mm and each i≤mi\le m the matrices pneiip_ne_{ii} of Mm(B)M_m(B), where ejke_{jk} are the matrix units, with pnp_n at the iith diagonal place and zeros elsewhere, peak to the state x↦f(xii)x\mapsto f(x_{ii}). For a sequence peaking to ff, the differences dnd_n are mutually orthogonal projections, and for every state τ\tau of BB with τ(dn)>0\tau(d_n)>0 for all nn the states a↦τ(dnadn)/τ(dn)a\mapsto\tau(d_nad_n)/\tau(d_n) converge to f(a)f(a) for every aa in BB✦. The library also proves that a positive functional τ\tau on a C*^*-algebra with τ(1)=1\tau(1)=1 is a state, that the normalized trace M↦1n∑iτ(Mii)M\mapsto\frac1n\sum_i\tau(M_{ii}) on n×nn\times n matrices over BB is tracial, normalized and faithful when τ\tau is, that φ(e11)\varphi(e_{11}) is a projection for a **-homomorphism φ\varphi defined on 2×22\times 2 matrices, and that for the peak projections of bridge data the map sending a convergent sequence gg to g(∞)1+∑n(gn−g(∞))dng(\infty)1+\sum_n(g_n-g(\infty))d_n is an injective unital **-homomorphism into BB.