OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Closed subiterations and countable determination · §5

Lemma 5.6 [Countable determination]: Each pure state ff restricts to a pure state of a separable simple A[S]A[S] with SS countable, and is its only state extension

Pure states of the iteration are countably determined.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Fix an ordinal δ\delta and a simple C*C^*-algebra XX with a tracial state, built by an iteration of length δ\delta from a copy of the algebra of the canonical anticommutation relations, the CAR algebra. Some of the steps k<δk < \delta are singled out as active. At an active step kk the algebra built so far is replaced by its reduced Higman-Neumann-Neumann (HNN) extension along a pair of decreasing sequences of projections, with a new stable unitary vkv_k; each step kk also records a countable set DkD_k of earlier steps on which it depends. For uncountable δ\delta the question is how much of XX a single pure state ff sees: is ff determined by its restriction to the C*C^*-subalgebra generated by the CAR algebra and countably many of the vkv_k?

The library states the answer in four forms, from increasing families of separable closed subalgebras up to the construction itself.

States, Generated Subalgebras and Dependencies

For a C*C^*-algebra BB, 𝒮(B)\mathcal{S}(B) is the set of states of BB and 𝒫(B)\mathcal{P}(B) the set of its pure states, the extreme points of 𝒮(B)\mathcal{S}(B). Two pure states gg and hh of BB are equivalent, g∼hg \sim h, when their Gelfand-Naimark-Segal (GNS) representations are unitarily equivalent.✦ For an inclusion B⊂CB \subset C, a state hh of BB extends uniquely to CC when any two states of CC whose restrictions to BB equal hh coincide✦, and the inclusion has (U) when every pure state of BB extends uniquely to CC.✦

For a subset Σ\Sigma of a C*C^*-algebra XX, a family z=(zj)j∈Jz = (z_j)_{j \in J} in XX and a subset SS of JJ, the C*C^*-subalgebra C*(Σ,zS)C^*(\Sigma, z_S) is the closure of the **-subalgebra of XX generated by Σ\Sigma and the zjz_j with j∈Sj \in S.✦

Let every index jj of a set JJ be given a set Dj⊂JD_j \subset J of indices on which it depends. A dependency-closed set is a subset SS of JJ that contains the dependencies of each of its members: Dj⊂Sfor every j∈S.D_j \subset S \qquad \text{for every } j \in S.(1)✦

Tracial Stages and Chronological Data

The CAR algebra CAR\mathrm{CAR} is the C*C^*-direct limit of the matrix algebras M2n(ℂ)M_{2^n}(\mathbb{C}) along the embeddings a↦diag(a,a)a \mapsto \mathrm{diag}(a, a)✦; its projection pnp_n is the image of e11⊗⋯⊗e11e_{11} \otimes \cdots \otimes e_{11} in M2n(ℂ)M_{2^n}(\mathbb{C}), where e11e_{11} is the matrix unit of M2(ℂ)M_2(\mathbb{C}). A tracial stage is a simple C*C^*-algebra XX together with a tracial state τ\tau and an injective unital **-homomorphism ι\iota of CAR\mathrm{CAR} into XX with (U).✦

A decreasing sequence of projections (pn)(p_n) in a C*C^*-algebra BB peaks to a state hh of BB when h(pn)=1h(p_n) = 1 for every nn and hh is the only state with this property✦; its atoms are dn=pn−pn+1d_n = p_n - p_{n+1}.✦ Bridge data on BB consist of a faithful normalized tracial functional τ\tau on BB and two decreasing sequences of projections p1,p2p^1, p^2 in BB, peaking to states f1,f2f_1, f_2, such that for i=1,2i = 1, 2 and every nn p0i=1,τ(dni)>0,τ(pni)→0,τ(pn1)=τ(pn2).p^i_0 = 1, \qquad \tau(d^i_n) > 0, \qquad \tau(p^i_n) \to 0, \qquad \tau(p^1_n) = \tau(p^2_n).(2)✦ For bridge data (τ,p1,p2)(\tau, p^1, p^2) on BB, the reduced HNN extension H(B)H(B) of BB is a C*C^*-algebra containing BB, with a stable unitary vv such that vpn1v*=pn2v p^1_n v^* = p^2_n and with a trace extending τ\tau.

Let bridge data on XX with trace τ\tau have their peaks in a closed **-subalgebra SS of XX, let TT be another closed **-subalgebra and zz an element of XX. The algebra TT is the reduced HNN extension of SS along the pair with stable unitary zz when there are bridge data on SS with the same peaks and with trace τ|S\tau|_S, and a **-isomorphism of their HNN extension H(S)H(S) onto TT that is the identity on SS, sends v*v^* to zz and vv to z*z^*, and turns τ\tau into the trace of H(S)H(S).✦

A chronological history of height δ\delta on a tracial stage XX assigns to every ordinal kk an element vkv_k of XX, a set DkD_k of ordinals and bridge data (p1,k,p2,k)(p^{1,k}, p^{2,k}) on XX with the trace τ\tau of XX and with first sequence pn1,k=ι(pn)p^{1,k}_n = \iota(p_n), and it singles out a set of active ordinals below δ\delta. For a set SS of ordinals, A[S]=C*(ι(CAR),vS)A[S] = C^*(\iota(\mathrm{CAR}), v_S); in particular A[k]A[k] is the case S=kS = k.✦ The history requires that DkD_k be a countable subset of kk for every k<δk < \delta and that vk=1v_k = 1 whenever kk is not active. For every active kk it requires that the peaks pni,kp^{i,k}_n lie in A[Dk]A[D_k] and in A[k]A[k], that A[k+1]A[k+1] be the reduced HNN extension of A[k]A[k] along the pair with stable unitary vkv_k, and that the states of A[k]A[k] peaked by p1,kp^{1,k} and p2,kp^{2,k} be inequivalent.

Chronological data of height δ\delta on XX are a chronological history of height δ\delta whose generators, with the CAR algebra, generate XX: A[δ]=X.A[\delta] = X.(3)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let ff be a pure state of a C*C^*-algebra XX.

  1. Let JJ be a set with countable sets Dj⊂JD_j \subset J of dependencies, j∈Jj \in J, and let every subset SS of JJ be assigned a closed **-subalgebra B(S)B(S) of XX, increasing in SS and separable when SS is countable. Suppose that every element of XX lies in some B(S)B(S) with SS countable, and that B(⋃nNn)⊂⋃nB(Nn)¯B(\bigcup_n N_n) \subset \overline{\bigcup_n B(N_n)} for every increasing sequence N0⊂N1⊂⋯N_0 \subset N_1 \subset \cdots of subsets of JJ. Then there is a countable dependency-closed set S⊂JS \subset J with f|B(S)∈𝒫(B(S)).f|_{B(S)} \in \mathcal{P}\bigl(B(S)\bigr).(4)✦

  2. Let Σ\Sigma be a separable subset of XX and z=(zj)j∈Jz = (z_j)_{j \in J} a family in XX with C*(Σ,zJ)=XC^*(\Sigma, z_J) = X, and let Dj⊂JD_j \subset J be countable for every j∈Jj \in J. Then there is a countable dependency-closed set S⊂JS \subset J with f|C*(Σ,zS)∈𝒫(C*(Σ,zS)).f|_{C^*(\Sigma, z_S)} \in \mathcal{P}\bigl(C^*(\Sigma, z_S)\bigr).(5)✦

  3. Let Σ\Sigma be a subset of XX, let z=(zk)z = (z_k) be a family in XX indexed by the ordinals, for every ordinal kk let DkD_k be a set of ordinals and QkQ_k bridge data on XX, and let some ordinals be singled out as active. Suppose that Σ\Sigma is separable, that DkD_k is a countable subset of kk for every k<δk < \delta, and that C*(Σ,zδ)=XC^*(\Sigma, z_\delta) = X. Suppose also that the peaks of QkQ_k lie in C*(Σ,zk)C^*(\Sigma, z_k) for every active kk; that for every active k<δk < \delta the peaks of QkQ_k lie in C*(Σ,zDk)C^*(\Sigma, z_{D_k}), C*(Σ,zk+1)C^*(\Sigma, z_{k+1}) is the reduced HNN extension of C*(Σ,zk)C^*(\Sigma, z_k) along QkQ_k with stable unitary zkz_k, and the states of C*(Σ,zk)C^*(\Sigma, z_k) peaked by the two sequences of QkQ_k are inequivalent; that zk=1z_k = 1 for every k<δk < \delta that is not active; that C*(Σ,z∅)C^*(\Sigma, z_\emptyset) is simple; and that the QkQ_k with k<δk < \delta all have the same trace. Then there is a countable dependency-closed set S⊂δS \subset \delta such that Y=C*(Σ,zS)Y = C^*(\Sigma, z_S) is separable and simple and f|Y∈𝒫(Y),{g∈𝒮(X):g|Y=f|Y}={f}.f|_Y \in \mathcal{P}(Y), \qquad \{ g \in \mathcal{S}(X) : g|_Y = f|_Y \} = \{f\}.(6)✦

  4. Let XX be a tracial stage with chronological data of height δ\delta. Then there is a countable dependency-closed set S⊂δS \subset \delta such that A[S]A[S] is separable and simple and f|A[S]∈𝒫(A[S]),{g∈𝒮(X):g|A[S]=f|A[S]}={f}.f|_{A[S]} \in \mathcal{P}\bigl(A[S]\bigr), \qquad \{ g \in \mathcal{S}(X) : g|_{A[S]} = f|_{A[S]} \} = \{f\}.(7)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for every pure state hh of XδX_\delta there is a countable dependency-closed set S⊂δS \subset \delta such that h|A[S]h|_{A[S]} is pure and hh is its unique state extension to XδX_\delta, where hh stands for ff and XδX_\delta for XX.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over pure states with their restrictions and unique state extensions, separable and simple C*C^*-algebras, dependency-closed sets, the generated subalgebras C*(Σ,zS)C^*(\Sigma, z_S) and A[S]A[S], bridge data and their reduced HNN extensions, the CAR algebra and its peaks, tracial stages, and chronological histories and data of height δ\delta.

About these constructions the library proves that every C*(Σ,zS)C^*(\Sigma, z_S) is closed✦ and that the atoms dnd_n of a sequence peaking to a state hh are pairwise orthogonal projections. It also proves that for a state σ\sigma with σ(dn)>0\sigma(d_n) > 0 for every nn, the states a↦σ(dnadn)/σ(dn)a \mapsto \sigma(d_n a d_n)/\sigma(d_n) converge to h(a)h(a) for every aa.✦