The Setting
Naimark asked whether a -algebra whose irreducible representations are all unitarily equivalent, as those of the algebra of compact operators on a Hilbert space are, must be isomorphic to for some . The library states its main theorem on this question together with three results: a property of a transfinite tower of -algebras built from the canonical anticommutation relations (CAR) algebra by reduced Higman-Neumann-Neumann (HNN) extensions, and two facts about arbitrary -algebras.
Representations and States
A representation of a -algebra on a complex Hilbert space is a -homomorphism from to the algebra of bounded operators on , and it is irreducible when and the only closed subspaces of invariant under are and .✦ Representations on and on are unitarily equivalent, , when there is a unitary with (1)✦ A -algebra has a unique irreducible representation when for any two irreducible representations and of , on any Hilbert spaces✦, and it is isomorphic to , written , when for some injective -homomorphism .✦
A state of a -algebra is a continuous linear functional on of norm one such that is real and nonnegative for every ✦, and a pure state is an extreme point of the set of states.✦ Pure states and are equivalent, , when their Gelfand-Naimark-Segal (GNS) representations are unitarily equivalent.✦ A faithful tracial state of is a state with for all and for every nonzero .✦ The algebra is simple when and its only closed two-sided ideals are and .✦
The Tower
The CAR algebra is the -direct limit of the matrix algebras , with and connecting maps .✦ The CAR peak is the image in of the projection onto the first basis vector of .✦ The state of is the state whose restriction to each is the vector state of the first basis vector✦, and the tracial state of is the state whose restriction to each is the normalized trace, with .✦
An inclusion of -algebras is a unital -homomorphism , and a state of extends a state of when its composition with is . An inclusion has (U) when every pure state of has at most one state extension to .✦ A tracial stage is a simple -algebra with a tracial state and an injective -homomorphism such that has (U).✦ A morphism of tracial stages is an injective -homomorphism such that has (U), and .✦ The reference state of a tracial stage is the unique state of whose restriction to is .✦
A decreasing sequence of projections in a -algebra peaks to a state when for every and is the only state with this property✦; its differences are .✦ Bridge data on a -algebra are a faithful tracial state of and two decreasing sequences and of projections in peaking to states and of , with differences for , such that (2)✦ The reduced HNN extension of for bridge data on is a -algebra containing , with a trace extending and a stable unitary with .
Let . The algebra of convergent sequences embeds in along by ✦, with the conditional expectation given by and . With and the matrix units of and of , let be the reduced free product of and amalgamated over their diagonals , the -th diagonal entry of receiving along , taken with respect to the conditional expectation of onto , , and the conditional expectation of onto its diagonal entries; the extension is the corner of .✦ The algebra acts on a Fock space of reduced words, and twice the vacuum vector state, restricted to , is the trace of . The stable unitary is .✦ The algebra embeds in by , the image in of the matrix unit of . Each of the algebras and carries a faithful normalized trace and a family of pairwise orthogonal projections of positive trace, its atoms, whose traces sum to .✦ On the trace is ✦ and the atoms are the .✦ On the trace is built in the same way from the trace composed with the embedding of along , and the atoms are built from atoms , , of with . The traces of the atoms are the same in the two algebras.✦
For elements of a tracial stage and a set of ordinals, is the closed -algebra generated by and the with , and .✦ A chronological stage of height , an ordinal, is a tracial stage with elements , a set of active indices below , and for each a countable set of ordinals below and bridge data on with trace and , such that and for every inactive , and such that for every active the projections of lie in .✦ For an active index , since the projections of lie in , the bridge data restrict to bridge data on , with the same projections, the trace restricted to and the restrictions of the two states, and denotes the reduced HNN extension for the restricted data.✦ The restrictions of the two states of to are inequivalent✦, and (3)✦ by an isomorphism that is the identity on and carries to and the trace of to .
A morphism of chronological stages is a morphism of tracial stages that does not lower the height and, below the height of , keeps the active indices and the sets and sends each and the projections of each to those of .✦ A joining successor of a chronological stage at a pure state of is a chronological stage whose height is one more than that of , with a morphism and a pure state of that extends and is equivalent to .
Let be a morphism of tracial stages and bridge data on with trace . The bridge data pushed forward along are the bridge data on with trace and sequences , peaking to the pure state extensions to of the states of , each unique by (U). The bridge data of a limit are those of the earlier stages pushed forward into it.✦
Let be the continuum and , and fix a map with . The full tower is the system of chronological stages , , with morphisms for , defined by transfinite recursion. Its first stage is with , the identity inclusion, height and no active index.✦ At a limit ordinal , is the -direct limit of the with , with the trace restricting to on each and the inclusion of given by that of any followed by the inclusion into the limit. Its height is the supremum of the heights of the with , its elements , active indices and sets are those of the with below the height of , and its bridge data are those of such an pushed forward into . The stage is a chosen joining successor of at a pure state . If , then is the unique state of extending , where lists the pure states of when there are at most of them and is constantly otherwise; if is not a value of , then .✦ The limit of the tower is the tracial stage formed by the -direct limit of all the .✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. (i) There is a simple infinite-dimensional -algebra with a faithful tracial state and a unique irreducible representation such that, for every complex Hilbert space , (4)✦
(ii) Let be injective with , and let be the limit of its full tower. Every pure state of satisfies (5)✦
(iii) Let be a -algebra any two of whose pure states are equivalent. Any two irreducible representations and of , on any Hilbert spaces, satisfy (6)✦
(iv) Let be an infinite-dimensional -algebra. For every complex Hilbert space , (7)✦
Statement (4) answers Naimark’s question in the negative.
What Is Checked
Statements (4), (6) and (7) are stated over -algebras and complex Hilbert spaces, with the states, pure states and their equivalence, representations and unitary equivalence, simplicity, faithful tracial states and isomorphism with defined above; statement (5) is stated over the full tower of chronological stages for an injective , its limit and the reference state .
About these constructions the library proves that the CAR algebra is simple✦ with a tracial state, and that in every tracial stage the trace is faithful✦ and the reference state is pure✦, with the projections peaking to it.✦ The -direct limit of a directed system of tracial stages is a tracial stage✦, each stage included in it injectively✦ with (U) and its trace restricting to the trace of each stage✦, and the direct limit of chronological stages is again a chronological stage.✦ Every pure state of a chronological stage has a joining successor.✦ For projections in a -algebra peaking to a state of , the differences are pairwise orthogonal projections, and for every and every state of with all .✦ Each stage of a directed system of chronological stages maps into the direct limit by a morphism of chronological stages✦, and its height is at most the height of the limit.✦ The state of the recursion is a pure state of .✦ The map is an injective unital -homomorphism of into .✦ The map is bounded of norm at most one, fixes , is linear over it from the left, and satisfies whenever . The normalized trace of is tracial, normalized and faithful when is, is a projection of ✦, and lies in the corner .✦