OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. Introduction · §1

Theorem 1.1 [Main theorem]: A simple infinite-dimensional C*C^*-algebra with a faithful tracial state and pairwise unitarily equivalent irreducible representations, isomorphic to no K(H)K(H)

A counterexample to Naimark’s problem.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Naimark asked whether a C*C^*-algebra whose irreducible representations are all unitarily equivalent, as those of the algebra K(H)K(H) of compact operators on a Hilbert space HH are, must be isomorphic to K(H)K(H) for some HH. The library states its main theorem on this question together with three results: a property of a transfinite tower of C*C^*-algebras built from the canonical anticommutation relations (CAR) algebra by reduced Higman-Neumann-Neumann (HNN) extensions, and two facts about arbitrary C*C^*-algebras.

Representations and States

A representation of a C*C^*-algebra AA on a complex Hilbert space HH is a **-homomorphism π\pi from AA to the algebra B(H)B(H) of bounded operators on HH, and it is irreducible when π≠0\pi\neq0 and the only closed subspaces of HH invariant under π(A)\pi(A) are 00 and HH.✦ Representations π\pi on HH and ρ\rho on KK are unitarily equivalent, π≃ρ\pi\simeq\rho, when there is a unitary U:H→KU\colon H\to K with Uπ(a)=ρ(a)U(a∈A).U\pi(a)=\rho(a)U\qquad(a\in A).(1)✦ A C*C^*-algebra AA has a unique irreducible representation when π≃ρ\pi\simeq\rho for any two irreducible representations π\pi and ρ\rho of AA, on any Hilbert spaces✦, and it is isomorphic to K(H)K(H), written A≅K(H)A\cong K(H), when φ(A)=K(H)\varphi(A)=K(H) for some injective **-homomorphism φ:A→B(H)\varphi\colon A\to B(H).✦

A state of a C*C^*-algebra AA is a continuous linear functional ff on AA of norm one such that f(a*a)f(a^*a) is real and nonnegative for every a∈Aa\in A✦, and a pure state is an extreme point of the set of states.✦ Pure states hh and kk are equivalent, h∼kh\sim k, when their Gelfand-Naimark-Segal (GNS) representations are unitarily equivalent.✦ A faithful tracial state of AA is a state τ\tau with τ(ab)=τ(ba)\tau(ab)=\tau(ba) for all a,b∈Aa,b\in A and τ(a*a)>0\tau(a^*a)>0 for every nonzero aa.✦ The algebra AA is simple when A≠0A\neq0 and its only closed two-sided ideals are 00 and AA.✦

The Tower

The CAR algebra M2∞M_{2^\infty} is the C*C^*-direct limit of the matrix algebras M2n(ℂ)M_{2^n}(\mathbb C), with M2n+1(ℂ)=M2(M2n(ℂ))M_{2^{n+1}}(\mathbb C)=M_2(M_{2^n}(\mathbb C)) and connecting maps a↦diag⁡(a,a)a\mapsto\operatorname{diag}(a,a).✦ The CAR peak pnp_n is the image in M2∞M_{2^\infty} of the projection onto the first basis vector of M2n(ℂ)M_{2^n}(\mathbb C).✦ The state ω\omega of M2∞M_{2^\infty} is the state whose restriction to each M2n(ℂ)M_{2^n}(\mathbb C) is the vector state of the first basis vector✦, and the tracial state τ0\tau_0 of M2∞M_{2^\infty} is the state whose restriction to each M2n(ℂ)M_{2^n}(\mathbb C) is the normalized trace, with τ0(pn)=2−n\tau_0(p_n)=2^{-n}.✦

An inclusion B⊂CB\subset C of C*C^*-algebras is a unital **-homomorphism φ:B→C\varphi\colon B\to C, and a state of CC extends a state hh of BB when its composition with φ\varphi is hh. An inclusion B⊂CB\subset C has (U) when every pure state of BB has at most one state extension to CC.✦ A tracial stage is a simple C*C^*-algebra XX with a tracial state τX\tau_X and an injective **-homomorphism ιX:M2∞→X\iota_X\colon M_{2^\infty}\to X such that M2∞⊂XM_{2^\infty}\subset X has (U).✦ A morphism of tracial stages X→YX\to Y is an injective **-homomorphism φ:X→Y\varphi\colon X\to Y such that X⊂YX\subset Y has (U), τY∘φ=τX\tau_Y\circ\varphi=\tau_X and φ∘ιX=ιY\varphi\circ\iota_X=\iota_Y.✦ The reference state ωX\omega_X of a tracial stage XX is the unique state of XX whose restriction to M2∞M_{2^\infty} is ω\omega.✦

A decreasing sequence of projections (qn)(q_n) in a C*C^*-algebra AA peaks to a state hh when h(qn)=1h(q_n)=1 for every nn and hh is the only state with this property✦; its differences are dn=qn−qn+1d_n=q_n-q_{n+1}.✦ Bridge data on a C*C^*-algebra AA are a faithful tracial state τ\tau of AA and two decreasing sequences p1p^1 and p2p^2 of projections in AA peaking to states f1f_1 and f2f_2 of AA, with differences dni=pni−pn+1id^i_n=p^i_n-p^i_{n+1} for i=1,2i=1,2, such that p0i=1,τ(dni)>0,τ(pni)→0,τ(pn1)=τ(pn2).p^i_0=1,\qquad\tau(d^i_n)>0,\qquad\tau(p^i_n)\to0,\qquad\tau(p^1_n)=\tau(p^2_n).(2)✦ The reduced HNN extension H(A)H(A) of AA for bridge data on AA is a C*C^*-algebra containing AA, with a trace extending τ\tau and a stable unitary vv with vpn1v*=pn2vp^1_nv^*=p^2_n.

Let ℕ¯=ℕ∪{∞}\overline{\mathbb N}=\mathbb N\cup\{\infty\}. The algebra C(ℕ¯)C(\overline{\mathbb N}) of convergent sequences embeds in AA along pip^i by g↦g(∞)1+∑n(g(n)−g(∞))dnig\mapsto g(\infty)1+\sum_n(g(n)-g(\infty))d^i_n✦, with the conditional expectation Ei:A→C(ℕ¯)E_i\colon A\to C(\overline{\mathbb N}) given by Ei(a)(n)=τ(dniadni)/τ(dni)E_i(a)(n)=\tau(d^i_nad^i_n)/\tau(d^i_n) and Ei(a)(∞)=fi(a)E_i(a)(\infty)=f_i(a). With eije_{ij} and eij′e'_{ij} the matrix units of M2(A)M_2(A) and of M2(C(ℕ¯))M_2(C(\overline{\mathbb N})), let PP be the reduced free product of M2(A)M_2(A) and M2(C(ℕ¯))M_2(C(\overline{\mathbb N})) amalgamated over their diagonals C(ℕ¯)2C(\overline{\mathbb N})^2, the ii-th diagonal entry of M2(A)M_2(A) receiving C(ℕ¯)C(\overline{\mathbb N}) along pip^i, taken with respect to the conditional expectation of M2(A)M_2(A) onto C(ℕ¯)2C(\overline{\mathbb N})^2, a↦(E1(a11),E2(a22))a\mapsto(E_1(a_{11}),E_2(a_{22})), and the conditional expectation of M2(C(ℕ¯))M_2(C(\overline{\mathbb N})) onto its diagonal entries; the extension H(A)H(A) is the corner e11Pe11e_{11}Pe_{11} of PP.✦ The algebra PP acts on a Fock space of reduced words, and twice the vacuum vector state, restricted to H(A)H(A), is the trace of H(A)H(A). The stable unitary is v=e12e21′v=e_{12}e'_{21}.✦ The algebra AA embeds in H(A)H(A) by a↦ae11a\mapsto a\,e_{11}, the image in PP of the matrix unit ae11a\,e_{11} of M2(A)M_2(A). Each of the algebras M2(A)M_2(A) and M2(C(ℕ¯))M_2(C(\overline{\mathbb N})) carries a faithful normalized trace and a family of pairwise orthogonal projections of positive trace, its atoms, whose traces sum to 11.✦ On M2(A)M_2(A) the trace is 12∑iτ(Mii)\tfrac12\sum_i\tau(M_{ii})✦ and the atoms are the dnieiid^i_ne_{ii}.✦ On M2(C(ℕ¯))M_2(C(\overline{\mathbb N})) the trace is built in the same way from the trace τ\tau composed with the embedding of C(ℕ¯)C(\overline{\mathbb N}) along p1p^1, and the atoms are built from atoms ene_n, n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N, of C(ℕ¯)C(\overline{\mathbb N}) with enx=x(n)ene_nx=x(n)e_n. The traces of the atoms are the same in the two algebras.✦

For elements vkv_k of a tracial stage XX and a set TT of ordinals, X[T]X[T] is the closed **-algebra generated by ιX(M2∞)\iota_X(M_{2^\infty}) and the vkv_k with k∈Tk\in T, and X[<k]=X[{j:j<k}]X[<k]=X[\{j:j<k\}].✦ A chronological stage of height δ\delta, an ordinal, is a tracial stage XX with elements (vk)k<δ(v_k)_{k<\delta}, a set of active indices below δ\delta, and for each k<δk<\delta a countable set DkD_k of ordinals below kk and bridge data 𝒫k\mathcal P_k on XX with trace τX\tau_X and pn1=ιX(pn)p^1_n=\iota_X(p_n), such that X=X[<δ]X=X[<\delta] and vk=1v_k=1 for every inactive kk, and such that for every active kk the projections of 𝒫k\mathcal P_k lie in X[Dk]X[D_k].✦ For an active index kk, since the projections of 𝒫k\mathcal P_k lie in X[<k]X[<k], the bridge data 𝒫k\mathcal P_k restrict to bridge data on X[<k]X[<k], with the same projections, the trace τX\tau_X restricted to X[<k]X[<k] and the restrictions of the two states, and H(X[<k])H(X[<k]) denotes the reduced HNN extension for the restricted data.✦ The restrictions of the two states of 𝒫k\mathcal P_k to X[<k]X[<k] are inequivalent✦, and X[<k+1]≅H(X[<k]),X[<k+1]\cong H(X[<k]),(3)✦ by an isomorphism that is the identity on X[<k]X[<k] and carries v*v^* to vkv_k and the trace of H(X[<k])H(X[<k]) to τX\tau_X.

A morphism of chronological stages X→YX\to Y is a morphism of tracial stages that does not lower the height and, below the height of XX, keeps the active indices and the sets DkD_k and sends each vkv_k and the projections of each 𝒫k\mathcal P_k to those of YY.✦ A joining successor of a chronological stage XX at a pure state gg of XX is a chronological stage YY whose height is one more than that of XX, with a morphism X→YX\to Y and a pure state of YY that extends gg and is equivalent to ωY\omega_Y.

Let φ:X→Y\varphi\colon X\to Y be a morphism of tracial stages and 𝒫\mathcal P bridge data on XX with trace τX\tau_X. The bridge data 𝒫\mathcal P pushed forward along φ\varphi are the bridge data on YY with trace τY\tau_Y and sequences φ(pni)\varphi(p^i_n), peaking to the pure state extensions to YY of the states fif_i of 𝒫\mathcal P, each unique by (U). The bridge data of a limit are those of the earlier stages pushed forward into it.✦

Let 𝔠\mathfrak c be the continuum and κ=𝔠+\kappa=\mathfrak c^+, and fix a map σ:κ×κ→κ\sigma\colon\kappa\times\kappa\to\kappa with σ(γ,β)≥γ\sigma(\gamma,\beta)\ge\gamma. The full tower is the system of chronological stages XαX_\alpha, α<κ\alpha<\kappa, with morphisms Xα→XβX_\alpha\to X_\beta for α≤β\alpha\le\beta, defined by transfinite recursion. Its first stage X0X_0 is M2∞M_{2^\infty} with τ0\tau_0, the identity inclusion, height 00 and no active index.✦ At a limit ordinal α\alpha, XαX_\alpha is the C*C^*-direct limit of the XβX_\beta with β<α\beta<\alpha, with the trace restricting to τXβ\tau_{X_\beta} on each XβX_\beta and the inclusion of M2∞M_{2^\infty} given by that of any XβX_\beta followed by the inclusion into the limit. Its height is the supremum of the heights of the XβX_\beta with β<α\beta<\alpha, its elements vkv_k, active indices and sets DkD_k are those of the XβX_\beta with kk below the height of XβX_\beta, and its bridge data 𝒫k\mathcal P_k are those of such an XβX_\beta pushed forward into XαX_\alpha. The stage Xα+1X_{\alpha+1} is a chosen joining successor of XαX_\alpha at a pure state gαg_\alpha. If α=σ(γ,β)\alpha=\sigma(\gamma,\beta), then gαg_\alpha is the unique state of XαX_\alpha extending fβγf^\gamma_\beta, where (fβγ)β<κ(f^\gamma_\beta)_{\beta<\kappa} lists the pure states of XγX_\gamma when there are at most 𝔠\mathfrak c of them and is constantly ωXγ\omega_{X_\gamma} otherwise; if α\alpha is not a value of σ\sigma, then gα=ωXαg_\alpha=\omega_{X_\alpha}.✦ The limit XκX_\kappa of the tower is the tracial stage formed by the C*C^*-direct limit of all the XαX_\alpha.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. (i) There is a simple infinite-dimensional C*C^*-algebra AA with a faithful tracial state and a unique irreducible representation such that, for every complex Hilbert space HH, A≆K(H).A\not\cong K(H).(4)✦

(ii) Let σ:κ×κ→κ\sigma\colon\kappa\times\kappa\to\kappa be injective with σ(γ,β)≥γ\sigma(\gamma,\beta)\ge\gamma, and let XκX_\kappa be the limit of its full tower. Every pure state ff of XκX_\kappa satisfies f∼ωXκ.f\sim\omega_{X_\kappa}.(5)✦

(iii) Let AA be a C*C^*-algebra any two of whose pure states are equivalent. Any two irreducible representations π\pi and ρ\rho of AA, on any Hilbert spaces, satisfy π≃ρ.\pi\simeq\rho.(6)✦

(iv) Let AA be an infinite-dimensional C*C^*-algebra. For every complex Hilbert space HH, A≆K(H).A\not\cong K(H).(7)✦

Statement (4) answers Naimark’s question in the negative.

What Is Checked

Statements (4), (6) and (7) are stated over C*C^*-algebras and complex Hilbert spaces, with the states, pure states and their equivalence, representations and unitary equivalence, simplicity, faithful tracial states and isomorphism with K(H)K(H) defined above; statement (5) is stated over the full tower of chronological stages for an injective σ\sigma, its limit XκX_\kappa and the reference state ωXκ\omega_{X_\kappa}.

About these constructions the library proves that the CAR algebra is simple✦ with τ0\tau_0 a tracial state, and that in every tracial stage XX the trace is faithful✦ and the reference state ωX\omega_X is pure✦, with the projections ιX(pn)\iota_X(p_n) peaking to it.✦ The C*C^*-direct limit of a directed system of tracial stages is a tracial stage✦, each stage included in it injectively✦ with (U) and its trace restricting to the trace of each stage✦, and the direct limit of chronological stages is again a chronological stage.✦ Every pure state of a chronological stage has a joining successor.✦ For projections (qn)(q_n) in a C*C^*-algebra AA peaking to a state ff of AA, the differences dnd_n are pairwise orthogonal projections, and τ(dnadn)/τ(dn)→f(a)\tau(d_nad_n)/\tau(d_n)\to f(a) for every a∈Aa\in A and every state τ\tau of AA with all τ(dn)>0\tau(d_n)>0.✦ Each stage of a directed system of chronological stages maps into the direct limit by a morphism of chronological stages✦, and its height is at most the height of the limit.✦ The state gαg_\alpha of the recursion is a pure state of XαX_\alpha.✦ The map g↦g(∞)1+∑n(g(n)−g(∞))dnig\mapsto g(\infty)1+\sum_n(g(n)-g(\infty))d^i_n is an injective unital **-homomorphism of C(ℕ¯)C(\overline{\mathbb N}) into AA.✦ The map EiE_i is bounded of norm at most one, fixes C(ℕ¯)C(\overline{\mathbb N}), is linear over it from the left, and satisfies τ(dniadni)=0\tau(d^i_nad^i_n)=0 whenever Ei(a)=0E_i(a)=0. The normalized trace of M2(A)M_2(A) is tracial, normalized and faithful when τ\tau is, e11e_{11} is a projection of PP✦, and v=e12e21′v=e_{12}e'_{21} lies in the corner e11Pe11e_{11}Pe_{11}.✦