OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Pure states, excision, and peaking projections · §2

Lemma 2.3 [Peaking under restriction]: Projections pnp_n of BB whose images peak to a state HH of CC peak to H|BH|_B, and HH is its only state extension

Projections peaking in a larger algebra peak in the smaller one.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Take an inclusion B⊂CB \subset C of C*^*-algebras, given by an injective unital **-homomorphism φ:B→C\varphi\colon B \to C, and a decreasing sequence of projections p0≥p1≥⋯p_0 \ge p_1 \ge \cdots in BB whose images φ(pn)\varphi(p_n) determine a state HH of CC through its values on them. The question is whether the pnp_n determine a state of BB in the same way, and whether HH is then the only state of CC that agrees with it on BB.

This is Lemma 2.3 of OpenAI’s preprint A counterexample to Naimark’s problem in ZFC (September 2026), in its section on pure states, excision and peaking projections.

Peaking Sequences and State Extensions

A state of a C*^*-algebra AA is a continuous linear functional ff on AA of norm one such that f(a*a)f(a^*a) is real and nonnegative for every aa in AA.✦

The restriction of a continuous linear functional HH on CC along a unital **-homomorphism φ:B→C\varphi\colon B \to C is the continuous linear functional H|B=H∘φH|_B = H \circ \varphi on BB.✦

A sequence (pn)(p_n) in a C*^*-algebra AA peaks to a continuous linear functional ff on AA when the pnp_n are projections with p0≥p1≥p2≥⋯p_0 \ge p_1 \ge p_2 \ge \cdots and ff is the only state of AA equal to 11 at every pnp_n: {g a state of A:g(pn)=1 for every n}={f}.\{\, g \text{ a state of } A : g(p_n) = 1 \text{ for every } n \,\} = \{ f \}.(1)✦

A continuous linear functional hh on BB has at most one state extension along a unital **-homomorphism φ:B→C\varphi\colon B \to C when any two states G1G_1 and G2G_2 of CC with G1|B=G2|B=hG_1|_B = G_2|_B = h are equal.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let φ:B→C\varphi\colon B \to C be an injective unital **-homomorphism of C*^*-algebras, let (pn)(p_n) be a sequence in BB, and let HH be a state of CC such that the sequence (φ(pn))(\varphi(p_n)) peaks to HH. Then (pn) peaks to H|B in B,{G a state of C:G|B=H|B}={H}.(p_n) \text{ peaks to } H|_B \text{ in } B, \qquad \{\, G \text{ a state of } C : G|_B = H|_B \,\} = \{ H \}.(2)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a unital inclusion B⊂CB \subset C and a decreasing sequence (pn)(p_n) of projections in BB that peaks to a state HH of CC, the sequence (pn)(p_n) peaks to h=H|Bh = H|_B in BB, and HH is the unique state extension of hh to CC, where pnp_n stands for the paper’s PnP_n.

What Is Checked

The claim (2) is stated for an injective unital **-homomorphism φ:B→C\varphi\colon B \to C, a sequence (pn)(p_n) in BB and a state HH of CC to which (φ(pn))(\varphi(p_n)) peaks, over the states of a C*^*-algebra, the restriction H|B=H∘φH|_B = H \circ \varphi, peaking sequences (1) and functionals with at most one state extension.

The library also proves that every **-homomorphism φ:B→C\varphi\colon B \to C of C*^*-algebras is a bounded linear map of norm at most one: ∥φ(b)∥≤∥b∥\|\varphi(b)\| \le \|b\| for every bb in BB.✦