The Setting
Take an inclusion of C-algebras, given by an injective unital -homomorphism , and a decreasing sequence of projections in whose images determine a state of through its values on them. The question is whether the determine a state of in the same way, and whether is then the only state of that agrees with it on .
This is Lemma 2.3 of OpenAI’s preprint A counterexample to Naimark’s problem in ZFC (September 2026), in its section on pure states, excision and peaking projections.
Peaking Sequences and State Extensions
A state of a C-algebra is a continuous linear functional on of norm one such that is real and nonnegative for every in .✦
The restriction of a continuous linear functional on along a unital -homomorphism is the continuous linear functional on .✦
A sequence in a C-algebra peaks to a continuous linear functional on when the are projections with and is the only state of equal to at every : (1)✦
A continuous linear functional on has at most one state extension along a unital -homomorphism when any two states and of with are equal.✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be an injective unital -homomorphism of C-algebras, let be a sequence in , and let be a state of such that the sequence peaks to . Then (2)✦
In the paper, the result reads: for a unital inclusion and a decreasing sequence of projections in that peaks to a state of , the sequence peaks to in , and is the unique state extension of to , where stands for the paper’s .
What Is Checked
The claim (2) is stated for an injective unital -homomorphism , a sequence in and a state of to which peaks, over the states of a C-algebra, the restriction , peaking sequences (1) and functionals with at most one state extension.
The library also proves that every -homomorphism of C-algebras is a bounded linear map of norm at most one: for every in .✦