OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §3. Reduced HNN adjunctions · §3

Proposition 3.4 [Interchanging adjunctions]: Separated bridge data BB, QQ with one trace on a simple AA give HQ(HB(A))≅HB(HQ(A))H_Q(H_B(A))\cong H_B(H_Q(A)), preserving traces and fixing AA, vBv_B, vQv_Q

Two separated reduced Higman-Neumann-Neumann extensions can be taken in either order.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let AA be a simple C*-algebra with a faithful tracial state τ\tau, and let p1=(pn1)p^1=(p^1_n) and p2=(pn2)p^2=(p^2_n) be decreasing sequences of projections in AA, each peaking to a state of AA, with p0i=1p^i_0=1, τ(pni−pn+1i)>0\tau(p^i_n-p^i_{n+1})>0 and τ(pni)→0\tau(p^i_n)\to 0 for i=1,2i=1,2, and with τ(pn1)=τ(pn2)\tau(p^1_n)=\tau(p^2_n) for every nn. The reduced Higman-Neumann-Neumann (HNN) extension of AA along them adjoins a stable unitary vv with vpn1v*=pn2vp^1_nv^*=p^2_n, and carries a trace extending τ\tau and an expectation onto AA.

Take two such pairs for the same AA and τ\tau: BB, with sequences p1,p2p^1,p^2, and QQ, with sequences q1,q2q^1,q^2, giving the extensions HB(A)H_B(A) and HQ(A)H_Q(A) with stable unitaries vBv_B and vQv_Q. Both unitaries can be adjoined, in either order: adjoining vQv_Q to HB(A)H_B(A) along the images of q1q^1 and q2q^2 gives HQ(HB(A))H_Q(H_B(A)), and adjoining vBv_B to HQ(A)H_Q(A) along the images of p1p^1 and p2p^2 gives HB(HQ(A))H_B(H_Q(A)). The question is whether the order matters: is there an isomorphism of HQ(HB(A))H_Q(H_B(A)) onto HB(HQ(A))H_B(H_Q(A)) that fixes AA, vBv_B and vQv_Q and carries one trace to the other?

Bridge Data and Their HNN Extensions

A decreasing sequence of projections (pn)(p_n) in a C*-algebra AA peaks to a state ff of AA when f(pn)=1f(p_n)=1 for every nn and ff is the only state of AA with this property✦; its differences are dn=pn−pn+1d_n=p_n-p_{n+1}✦.

Bridge data BB on a C*-algebra AA consist of a faithful tracial state τ\tau of AA and two sequences p1p^1, p2p^2 in AA peaking to states f1f_1, f2f_2, such that for i=1,2i=1,2 and every nn p0i=1,τ(dni)>0,limn→∞τ(pni)=0,τ(pn1)=τ(pn2).p^i_0=1,\qquad \tau(d^i_n)>0,\qquad \lim_{n\to\infty}\tau(p^i_n)=0,\qquad \tau(p^1_n)=\tau(p^2_n).(1)✦ Bridge data BB on a C*-algebra AA are separated when the Gelfand-Naimark-Segal (GNS) representations of the pure states M↦f1(M11)M\mapsto f_1(M_{11}) and M↦f2(M22)M\mapsto f_2(M_{22}) of M2(A)M_2(A) are not unitarily equivalent.

The reduced HNN extension HB(A)H_B(A) is a corner of an amalgamated free product. Let cc be the C*-algebra of convergent complex sequences, the continuous functions on ℕ∪{∞}\mathbb N\cup\{\infty\}.✦ For i=1,2i=1,2, the map δi(g)=g(∞)1+∑n(gn−g(∞))dni\delta_i(g)=g(\infty)1+\sum_n(g_n-g(\infty))\,d^i_n is a unital *-homomorphism of cc into AA✦, and Ei:A→cE_i\colon A\to c sends aa to the sequence of the τ(dniadni)/τ(dni)\tau(d^i_nad^i_n)/\tau(d^i_n), whose limit is fi(a)f_i(a)✦. Let MBM_B be the reduced amalgamated free product of M2(A)M_2(A) and M2(c)M_2(c) over c⊕cc\oplus c, which sits in M2(A)M_2(A) as the matrices diag⁡(δ1(x1),δ2(x2))\operatorname{diag}(\delta_1(x_1),\delta_2(x_2)) with expectation M↦(E1(M11),E2(M22))M\mapsto(E_1(M_{11}),E_2(M_{22})) and in M2(c)M_2(c) as the diagonal matrices, formed on a Fock space with the normalized traces of τ\tau on M2(A)M_2(A) and of τ∘δ1\tau\circ\delta_1 on M2(c)M_2(c). The reduced amalgamated free product MBM_B comes with embeddings φ\varphi of M2(A)M_2(A) and ψ\psi of M2(c)M_2(c), a vacuum trace τM\tau_M and an expectation FF of MBM_B onto M2(A)M_2(A). The reduced HNN extension HB(A)H_B(A) of AA along BB is the corner φ(e11)MBφ(e11)\varphi(e_{11})M_B\varphi(e_{11}), where eije_{ij} are the matrix units of M2M_2; it comes with the embedding ιB\iota_B of AA, the stable unitary vBv_B, the trace τ̃B\tilde\tau_B and the expectation EBE_B onto AA given by ιB(a)=φ(ae11),vB=φ(e12)ψ(e21),τ̃B(x)=2τM(x),EB(x)=F(x)11.\iota_B(a)=\varphi(a\,e_{11}),\qquad v_B=\varphi(e_{12})\,\psi(e_{21}),\qquad \tilde\tau_B(x)=2\,\tau_M(x),\qquad E_B(x)=F(x)_{11}.(2)

The same construction gives, for bridge data DD on any C*-algebra CC, the extension HD(C)H_D(C) with ιD\iota_D, vDv_D, τ̃D\tilde\tau_D and EDE_D. Let DD have sequences r1,r2r^1,r^2 peaking to h1,h2h_1,h_2 and trace τD\tau_D, let α:C→C′\alpha\colon C\to C' be an injective unital *-homomorphism along which each hih_i has at most one state extension, and let σ\sigma be a faithful tracial state of C′C' with σ∘α=τD\sigma\circ\alpha=\tau_D. The push of DD along α\alpha is the bridge data on C′C' with trace σ\sigma, sequences α(rni)\alpha(r^i_n) and states the unique pure state extensions of h1h_1 and h2h_2.✦

For bridge data BB and QQ on a simple C*-algebra AA with the same trace, BB separated, QBQ^B is the push of QQ along ιB\iota_B with trace τ̃B\tilde\tau_B.✦ When QQ is separated, BQB^Q denotes the push of BB along ιQ\iota_Q with trace τ̃Q\tilde\tau_Q, which is bridge data on HQ(A)H_Q(A). Then HQ(HB(A))H_Q(H_B(A)) and HB(HQ(A))H_B(H_Q(A)) stand for HQB(HB(A))H_{Q^B}(H_B(A)) and HBQ(HQ(A))H_{B^Q}(H_Q(A)).

The Claim

Theorem 1. (a) Let AA be a simple C*-algebra and BB, QQ separated bridge data on AA with the same trace. Then there is a *-isomorphism e:HQ(HB(A))→HB(HQ(A))e\colon H_Q(H_B(A))\to H_B(H_Q(A)) with e(ιQB(ιB(a)))=ιBQ(ιQ(a))(a∈A),e(ιQB(vB))=vBQ,e(vQB)=ιBQ(vQ),τ̃BQ∘e=τ̃QB.\begin{gathered} e\bigl(\iota_{Q^B}(\iota_B(a))\bigr)=\iota_{B^Q}(\iota_Q(a))\quad(a\in A),\qquad e\bigl(\iota_{Q^B}(v_B)\bigr)=v_{B^Q},\\ e\bigl(v_{Q^B}\bigr)=\iota_{B^Q}(v_Q),\qquad \tilde\tau_{B^Q}\circ e=\tilde\tau_{Q^B}. \end{gathered}(3)✦

(b) Let BB and QQ be bridge data on a C*-algebra AA with the same trace τ\tau, let DD be bridge data on HB(A)H_B(A) with sequences ιB(qni)\iota_B(q^i_n) and trace τ∘EB\tau\circ E_B, and let D′D' be bridge data on HQ(A)H_Q(A) with sequences ιQ(pni)\iota_Q(p^i_n) and trace τ∘EQ\tau\circ E_Q. Then there is a *-isomorphism e:HD(HB(A))→HD′(HQ(A))e\colon H_D(H_B(A))\to H_{D'}(H_Q(A)) with e(ιD(ιB(a)))=ιD′(ιQ(a))(a∈A),e(ιD(vB))=vD′,e(vD)=ιD′(vQ),τ̃D′∘e=τ̃D.\begin{gathered} e\bigl(\iota_D(\iota_B(a))\bigr)=\iota_{D'}(\iota_Q(a))\quad(a\in A),\qquad e\bigl(\iota_D(v_B)\bigr)=v_{D'},\\ e(v_D)=\iota_{D'}(v_Q),\qquad \tilde\tau_{D'}\circ e=\tilde\tau_D. \end{gathered}(4)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a unital faithfully tracial C*-algebra OO and, for t∈{j,k}t\in\{j,k\}, data D1t,D2t,Eit,θtD^t_1,D^t_2,E^t_i,\theta_t satisfying the hypotheses of its Proposition 3.1, with the other data’s expectations extended by composition with the expectation onto OO, there is a trace-preserving isomorphism Hk(Hj(O))≅Hj(Hk(O))H_k(H_j(O))\cong H_j(H_k(O)) fixing OO and the stable unitaries vjv_j and vkv_k, where OO, jj and kk play the parts of AA, BB and QQ.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over bridge data on a C*-algebra and their separation, over simple C*-algebras, over the reduced HNN extension HB(A)H_B(A) with its embedding ιB\iota_B, stable unitary vBv_B, trace τ̃B\tilde\tau_B and expectation EBE_B, and over the push of bridge data along an embedding.

For bridge data BB on AA, the library proves that ιB\iota_B and the maps δi\delta_i are injective✦ and that τ̃B\tilde\tau_B is tracial✦ and faithful. For a sequence (pn)(p_n) peaking to a state ff, it proves that ff is pure✦, that the dnd_n are pairwise orthogonal✦ projections✦, and, when p0=1p_0=1, that for every kk and every i≤ki\le k the sequence (pneii)n(p_n\,e_{ii})_n in Mk(A)M_k(A) peaks to the state M↦f(Mii)M\mapsto f(M_{ii})✦. It also proves that φ(e11)\varphi(e_{11}) is a projection✦, that vB=φ(e12)ψ(e21)v_B=\varphi(e_{12})\psi(e_{21}) lies in the corner φ(e11)MBφ(e11)\varphi(e_{11})M_B\varphi(e_{11})✦, and that the normalized trace of τ\tau on M2(A)M_2(A) is tracial✦, faithful and takes the value one at the identity✦. For a sequence (pn)(p_n) peaking to a state ff and a state τ\tau with τ(dn)>0\tau(d_n)>0 for every nn, it also proves that τ(dnadn)/τ(dn)→f(a)\tau(d_nad_n)/\tau(d_n)\to f(a) for every a∈Aa\in A.✦ For separated bridge data BB on a simple C*-algebra AA and bridge data QQ on AA with the same trace, it also proves that each peaked state of QQ has exactly one state extension to HB(A)H_B(A), and that this extension is pure, so that the push of QQ along ιB\iota_B with trace τ̃B\tilde\tau_B is defined.