OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Closed subiterations and countable determination · §5

Lemma 5.2 [Inequivalence passes to limits]: Pure states with inequivalent restrictions to algebras of dense union are inequivalent; inequivalence kept at successors persists along continuous chains of compatible states

Inequivalence of pure states passes to limits.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let AA be a C*C^*-algebra that is the closure of an increasing union of C*C^*-subalgebras, and let hh and kk be pure states of AA whose restrictions to every subalgebra are pure and have inequivalent Gelfand-Naimark-Segal (GNS) representations. Can the GNS representations of hh and kk be unitarily equivalent? This is the situation at a limit stage of a chain of C*C^*-algebras indexed by ordinals, where the algebra is the closure of the union of the earlier ones.

The library states the answer in two forms: for one algebra AA and a family of algebras mapped into it with a dense union of images, and for two pure states followed along a chain of algebras from an initial stage up to a final stage.

Pure States and Restrictions

A state of a C*C^*-algebra AA is a bounded linear functional hh on AA of norm one such that h(a*a)h(a^*a) is real and nonnegative for every aa in AA.✦ A pure state of AA is a state that is an extreme point of the set of states of AA.✦ The GNS representation πh\pi_h of a pure state hh of AA is the representation that the GNS construction attaches to hh as a positive linear functional on AA.✦

Two representations π\pi and ρ\rho of AA by bounded operators on Hilbert spaces ℋ\mathcal H and 𝒦\mathcal K are unitarily equivalent when there is a unitary UU from ℋ\mathcal H onto 𝒦\mathcal K with Uπ(a)x=ρ(a)Ux(a∈A,x∈ℋ).U\pi(a)x = \rho(a)Ux \qquad (a \in A,\ x \in \mathcal H).(1)✦ Two pure states hh and kk of AA are equivalent, h∼kh \sim k, when πh\pi_h and πk\pi_k are unitarily equivalent, and inequivalent, h≁kh \not\sim k, otherwise.✦

For a unital **-homomorphism φ:B→A\varphi\colon B \to A, the restriction of a bounded linear functional hh on AA to BB is the bounded linear functional on BB given by h|B=h∘φ.h|_B = h \circ \varphi.(2)✦

Chains Indexed by Ordinals

A chain of C*C^*-algebras indexed by the ordinals is a family (Bα)(B_\alpha) of C*C^*-algebras, one for each ordinal α\alpha, with unital **-homomorphisms ιαβ:Bα→Bβ\iota_{\alpha\beta}\colon B_\alpha \to B_\beta for α≤β\alpha \le \beta such that ιβγ∘ιαβ=ιαγ(α≤β≤γ);\iota_{\beta\gamma} \circ \iota_{\alpha\beta} = \iota_{\alpha\gamma} \qquad (\alpha \le \beta \le \gamma);(3) restrictions from BβB_\beta to BαB_\alpha are taken along ιαβ\iota_{\alpha\beta}. The chain is continuous at a limit ordinal γ\gamma when the union of the images ιαγ(Bα)\iota_{\alpha\gamma}(B_\alpha) over all α<γ\alpha < \gamma is dense in BγB_\gamma. A compatible family of pure states on the chain is a family (hα)(h_\alpha) with hαh_\alpha a pure state of BαB_\alpha for every ordinal α\alpha and hβ|Bα=hαh_\beta|_{B_\alpha} = h_\alpha whenever α≤β\alpha \le \beta.

The Claim

Theorem 1.

  1. Let AA be a C*C^*-algebra, (Bi)i∈I(B_i)_{i \in I} a family of C*C^*-algebras and φi:Bi→A\varphi_i\colon B_i \to A unital **-homomorphisms such that the union of the images φi(Bi)\varphi_i(B_i) is dense in AA. Let hh and kk be pure states of AA such that, for every ii in II, the restrictions h|Bih|_{B_i} and k|Bik|_{B_i} are pure and inequivalent. Then h≁k.h \not\sim k.(4)✦

  2. Let (Bα)(B_\alpha) be a chain of C*C^*-algebras indexed by the ordinals, let (hα)(h_\alpha) and (kα)(k_\alpha) be compatible families of pure states on it, and let α0\alpha_0 and LL be ordinals. Suppose that the chain is continuous at every limit ordinal γ≤L\gamma \le L, that hα0≁kα0h_{\alpha_0} \not\sim k_{\alpha_0}, and that hα+1≁kα+1h_{\alpha+1} \not\sim k_{\alpha+1} for every ordinal α\alpha with α0≤α<L\alpha_0 \le \alpha < L and hα≁kαh_\alpha \not\sim k_\alpha. Then hβ≁kβfor every ordinal β with α0≤β≤L.h_\beta \not\sim k_\beta \qquad \text{for every ordinal } \beta \text{ with } \alpha_0 \le \beta \le L.(5)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if (Bα)α≤λ(B_\alpha)_{\alpha \le \lambda} is a continuous chain with λ\lambda a nonzero limit ordinal, and pure states hh and kk of BλB_\lambda restrict to inequivalent pure states of BαB_\alpha for every α\alpha in some tail below λ\lambda, then h≁kh \not\sim k.

What Is Checked

Both claims are stated over pure states of C*C^*-algebras, their restrictions along unital **-homomorphisms and their equivalence through the unitary equivalence of their GNS representations; the second is stated also over chains of C*C^*-algebras indexed by the ordinals, continuous at the limit ordinals up to LL, with compatible families of pure states on them.

The library also proves that a bounded linear functional hh on AA with h(a*a)h(a^*a) real and nonnegative for every aa in AA is a positive linear functional✦, and that a unital **-homomorphism φ\varphi is a linear map of norm at most one, ∥φ(a)∥≤∥a∥\|\varphi(a)\| \le \|a\| for every aa.✦