OctoInformBeta

Trace cones and Razak–Jacelon stabilization

For a C*C^*-algebra CC, an extended trace is a map τ:C+→[0,∞]\tau\colon C_+\to[0,\infty] with τ(0)=0\tau(0)=0 that is additive, positively homogeneous, tracial in the sense that τ(x*x)=τ(xx*)\tau(x^*x)=\tau(xx^*), and lower semicontinuous in norm, with no density condition on the set where it is finite. The trace cone T(C)T(C) is the set of all extended traces on CC, with pointwise addition and multiplication by positive reals. Its canonical topology is the one in which a net (τi)(\tau_i) converges to τ\tau exactly when limsup⁡iτi((a−ε)+)≤τ(a)≤liminf⁡iτi(a)\limsup_i\tau_i((a-\varepsilon)_+)\le\tau(a)\le\liminf_i\tau_i(a) for every a∈C+a\in C_+ and every ε>0\varepsilon>0. For a closed two-sided ideal II of CC, the ideal weight τI\tau_I is 00 on I+I_+ and ∞\infty on C+\I+C_+\setminus I_+. An isomorphism of trace cones is a homeomorphism for the canonical topologies that preserves addition, the zero weight and multiplication by every positive real. The simple, monotracial, stably projectionless nuclear C*C^*-algebra 𝒲\mathcal W of Jacelon is the Razak-Jacelon algebra. Tensoring with 𝒲\mathcal W removes the KK-theoretic part of classifying separable nuclear C*C^*-algebras. Write 𝒦\mathcal K for the compact operators on ℓ2(ℕ)\ell^2(\mathbb N). The question is whether, for a separable nuclear C*C^*-algebra AA, the topological cone T(A)T(A) determines A⊗𝒲⊗𝒦A\otimes\mathcal W\otimes\mathcal K up to isomorphism, whatever the ideal structure of AA.

Razak’s classification of simple inductive limits of stably projectionless building blocks made the cone of traces, together with its scale, an effective classification invariant. Elliott, Robert and Santiago developed the compact topological cone of extended lower semicontinuous traces. The question is due to Leonel Robert. It was recorded in Santiago’s 2012 conference abstract. The question appears as Problem LXVIII in the survey of Schafhauser, Tikuisis and White, in a formulation that keeps every extended trace, the ideal weights included. A C*C^*-algebra is traceless when every extended trace on it takes only the values 00 and ∞\infty. The trace cone of a traceless C*C^*-algebra records only its ideals.

The preprint answers the question positively: if AA and BB are separable nuclear C*C^*-algebras whose trace cones are isomorphic, then A⊗𝒲⊗𝒦≅B⊗𝒲⊗𝒦A\otimes\mathcal W\otimes\mathcal K\cong B\otimes\mathcal W\otimes\mathcal K. It also shows that this isomorphism can be chosen to induce the given isomorphism of trace cones, once the trace cones of AA and BB are identified with the trace cones of A⊗𝒲⊗𝒦A\otimes\mathcal W\otimes\mathcal K and B⊗𝒲⊗𝒦B\otimes\mathcal W\otimes\mathcal K.

The Lean library TraceCone does not prove this theorem. It proves that closed ideals satisfy I⊆JI\subseteq J exactly when τI+τJ=τI\tau_I+\tau_J=\tau_I. For an extended trace τ\tau, the finite ideal Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) is the smallest closed ideal containing every positive aa with τ(a)<∞\tau(a)<\infty. The zero ideal Ker(τ)\mathrm{Ker}(\tau) is the closed ideal whose positive elements are those on which τ\tau vanishes. For any two C*C^*-algebras AA and BB, the Lean library proves the half of the preprint’s Proposition 2.2 that concerns trace cones: an isomorphism F:T(A)→T(B)F\colon T(A)\to T(B) of trace cones induces an order isomorphism I↦F(I)I\mapsto F(I) between their lattices of closed ideals, with F(τI)=τF(I)F(\tau_I)=\tau_{F(I)}, that carries Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) to Fin(Fτ)\mathrm{Fin}(F\tau) and Ker(τ)\mathrm{Ker}(\tau) to Ker(Fτ)\mathrm{Ker}(F\tau) for every extended trace τ\tau. It also proves that rτr\tau converges in the canonical topology to τFin(τ)\tau_{\mathrm{Fin}(\tau)} as r→0+r\to0^+ and to τKer(τ)\tau_{\mathrm{Ker}(\tau)} as r→∞r\to\infty. From the proofs of the preprint’s Lemmas 6.3 and 6.5, whose statements it does not contain, the Lean library proves that the weak closure of the GNS representation of an extended trace τ\tau carries a normal, semifinite, faithful trace taking the value τ(a)\tau(a) at the image of each positive a∈Fin(τ)a\in\mathrm{Fin}(\tau). For a C*C^*-algebra with the completely positive approximation property, it proves that finitely many operators in the weak closure of a representation are approximated in the strong-star topology, on finitely many vectors, by images of the approximating maps. The Lean library does not prove that nuclear C*C^*-algebras have this property, a known result of Choi and Effros; it takes the property as a hypothesis of that approximation. Lean has checked every result of the Lean library, so the Lean library is the reference: each result on these pages is stated as the Lean library states it and linked to the Lean declaration behind it, with the preprint’s statement beside it where the two differ. The preprint is a guide only, giving the results their order and their names.