OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. Introduction · §1

The ideal weights τ_I (1.1) and I ⊆ J iff τ_I + τ_J = τ_I: The weight τI\tau_I of a closed ideal II vanishes on I+I_+ and is infinite elsewhere, and I⊆JI \subseteq J exactly when τI+τJ=τI\tau_I + \tau_J = \tau_I

Closed ideals give extended traces that record inclusion.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let CC be a C*^*-algebra, not necessarily unital, with its star order. Traces on CC are defined on positive elements and take values in [0,∞][0,\infty], ∞\infty being an actual value, so a trace can vanish on part of the positive cone and be infinite on the rest. The question is how the closed two-sided ideals of CC appear among such traces: whether each closed ideal II has a trace that takes only the values 00 and ∞\infty and vanishes exactly on the positive elements of II, and whether inclusion of closed ideals can be read off from addition of traces.

Extended Traces and Closed Ideals

The positive cone C+C_+ of CC is the set of elements a≥0a \ge 0 of CC, with the norm topology.✦ An extended trace on CC is a lower semicontinuous map τ:C+→[0,∞]\tau\colon C_+ \to [0,\infty] such that τ(0)=0,τ(a+b)=τ(a)+τ(b),τ(ra)=rτ(a),τ(x*x)=τ(xx*)\tau(0) = 0, \qquad \tau(a + b) = \tau(a) + \tau(b), \qquad \tau(ra) = r\,\tau(a), \qquad \tau(x^*x) = \tau(xx^*)(1)✦ for all a,b∈C+a, b \in C_+, all real r>0r > 0 and all x∈Cx \in C. The sum τ+σ\tau + \sigma of extended traces τ\tau and σ\sigma on CC is defined pointwise: (τ+σ)(a)=τ(a)+σ(a),a∈C+.(\tau + \sigma)(a) = \tau(a) + \sigma(a), \qquad a \in C_+.(2)✦

A closed ideal II of CC is a norm-closed star subalgebra of CC that absorbs multiplication by CC on both sides: xy∈Iandyx∈Ifor all x∈C,y∈I.xy \in I \quad\text{and}\quad yx \in I \qquad \text{for all } x \in C,\ y \in I.(3)✦ Closed ideals of CC are ordered by inclusion, and I+=I∩C+I_+ = I \cap C_+ is the set of positive elements of II.

The Claim

Definition 1. Let CC be a C*^*-algebra and II a closed ideal of CC. There is an extended trace τ\tau on CC with τ(a)={0,a∈I+,∞,a∈C+\I+.\tau(a) = \begin{cases} 0, & a \in I_+,\\ \infty, & a \in C_+ \setminus I_+. \end{cases}(4)✦ The weight τI\tau_I of II is this extended trace τ\tau. For every a∈C+a \in C_+, the weight of II takes the value 00 or ∞\infty at aa: τI(a)={0,a∈I,∞,a∉I.\tau_I(a) = \begin{cases} 0, & a \in I,\\ \infty, & a \notin I. \end{cases}(5)✦ For closed ideals II and JJ of CC, I⊆J⇔τI+τJ=τI.I \subseteq J \iff \tau_I + \tau_J = \tau_I.(6)✦

In the paper, the result reads: every closed two-sided ideal II of CC contributes the weight τI\tau_I with τI(a)=0\tau_I(a) = 0 for a∈I+a \in I_+ and τI(a)=∞\tau_I(a) = \infty for a∈C+\I+a \in C_+ \setminus I_+, and for closed ideals, I⊆JI \subseteq J if and only if τI+τJ=τI\tau_I + \tau_J = \tau_I.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over a C*^*-algebra CC, not necessarily unital, with its star order and its positive cone C+C_+ in the norm topology, over the extended traces (1) on CC with their sum (2), and over the closed ideals (3) of CC ordered by inclusion.

The library proves that the sum of two extended traces on CC is again an extended trace.