OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. Tracial approximation on a cone · §6

The trace representation and its normal trace: On the von Neumann algebra NτN_\tau of its trace representation, agreeing with τ\tau on its finite ideal; strong-star density in weak operator closures

An extended trace yields a faithful normal semifinite trace.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let AA be a C*^*-algebra, not necessarily unital. The positive cone A+A_+ of AA is the set of elements a≥0a\ge 0 of AA in the star order, with the norm topology.✦ An extended trace on AA is a map τ:A+→[0,∞]\tau\colon A_+\to[0,\infty], the value ∞\infty allowed, that vanishes at 00, is lower semicontinuous for the norm topology and satisfies τ(a+b)=τ(a)+τ(b),τ(ra)=rτ(a),τ(x*x)=τ(xx*)\tau(a+b)=\tau(a)+\tau(b),\qquad \tau(ra)=r\,\tau(a),\qquad \tau(x^*x)=\tau(xx^*)(1)✦ for all a,b∈A+a,b\in A_+, every real r>0r>0 and every x∈Ax\in A.

Such a trace may be infinite on much of A+A_+: the usual trace on the compact operators of an infinite-dimensional Hilbert space is finite at x*xx^*x exactly when xx is a Hilbert-Schmidt operator. The question is whether the Gelfand-Naimark-Segal (GNS) construction for an extended trace τ\tau still gives a von Neumann algebra on which τ\tau becomes a faithful normal semifinite trace, on a Hilbert space that is separable when AA is.

The second question is how an operator yy in the weak operator closure of a star algebra BB of operators is approximated by elements of BB in the strong-star sense, yy and y*y^* at once on finitely many vectors: within the norm bound of Kaplansky’s density theorem, and, when BB is the image of a representation of a C*^*-algebra whose identity is approximated on finite sets by completely positive maps through matrix algebras, through completely positive maps that factor through matrix algebras.

The Trace Representation

Fix an extended trace τ\tau on AA. The finite square set of τ\tau is the subset of AA 𝔫τ={x∈A:τ(x*x)<∞}.\mathfrak n_\tau=\{x\in A:\tau(x^*x)<\infty\}.(2)✦ The finite ideal Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) of τ\tau is the star subalgebra of AA given by the norm closure of 𝔫τ\mathfrak n_\tau, and Fin(τ)+=Fin(τ)∩A+\mathrm{Fin}(\tau)_+=\mathrm{Fin}(\tau)\cap A_+ is its positive part.✦

The GNS space HτH_\tau of τ\tau is the Hilbert space completion of 𝔫τ\mathfrak n_\tau for the seminorm ∥x∥τ=τ(x*x)1/2(x∈𝔫τ),\|x\|_\tau=\tau(x^*x)^{1/2}\qquad(x\in\mathfrak n_\tau),(3)✦ and [x]∈Hτ[x]\in H_\tau denotes the image of x∈𝔫τx\in\mathfrak n_\tau.

A representation of AA on a Hilbert space HH is a star homomorphism π:A→B(H)\pi\colon A\to B(H) into the bounded operators on HH. The trace representation πτ\pi_\tau of AA is the representation on HτH_\tau in which πτ(a)\pi_\tau(a) is the bounded operator extending left multiplication by aa on 𝔫τ\mathfrak n_\tau: πτ(a)[x]=[ax](a∈A,x∈𝔫τ).\pi_\tau(a)[x]=[ax]\qquad(a\in A,\ x\in\mathfrak n_\tau).(4)✦

A star subalgebra BB of B(H)B(H) is a linear subspace closed under products and adjoints, not necessarily containing the identity. The weak operator closure B¯wo\overline{B}^{\,\mathrm{wo}} of a star subalgebra BB of B(H)B(H) is its closure in the weak operator topology, again a star subalgebra of B(H)B(H).✦ The weak closure NτN_\tau of the trace representation is the weak operator closure of its image: Nτ=πτ(A)¯wo.N_\tau=\overline{\pi_\tau(A)}^{\,\mathrm{wo}}.(5)✦

Normal and Semifinite Traces

An extended trace TT on NτN_\tau is normal if, for every nonempty upward directed set SS of positive elements of NτN_\tau with a least upper bound aa in (Nτ)+(N_\tau)_+ for the star order, T(a)=supb∈ST(b).T(a)=\sup_{b\in S}T(b).(6)✦ An extended trace TT on NτN_\tau is semifinite if every a∈(Nτ)+a\in(N_\tau)_+ satisfies T(a)=sup⁡{T(b):b∈(Nτ)+,b≤a,T(b)<∞}.T(a)=\sup\,\{T(b): b\in(N_\tau)_+,\ b\le a,\ T(b)<\infty\}.(7)✦

The Completely Positive Approximation Property

The matrix algebra MnM_n is the C*^*-algebra of complex n×nn\times n matrices. A completely positive contraction φ\varphi between C*^*-algebras is a completely positive map with ∥φ(x)∥≤∥x∥\|\varphi(x)\|\le\|x\| for every xx in its domain. A C*^*-algebra AA has the completely positive approximation property if, for every finite set F⊆AF\subseteq A and every ε>0\varepsilon>0, there are nn and completely positive contractions α:A→Mn\alpha\colon A\to M_n and β:Mn→A\beta\colon M_n\to A with ∥β(α(a))−a∥<ε(a∈F).\|\beta(\alpha(a))-a\|<\varepsilon\qquad(a\in F).(8)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let AA be a C*^*-algebra, τ\tau an extended trace on AA, and HH a Hilbert space. Then:

  1. there are a Hilbert space KK, a representation ρ\rho of AA on KK and a linear map Λ:𝔫τ→K\Lambda\colon\mathfrak n_\tau\to K with dense range such that, for all a∈Aa\in A and x∈𝔫τx\in\mathfrak n_\tau, ∥Λx∥2=τ(x*x),ρ(a)Λx=Λ(ax);\|\Lambda x\|^2=\tau(x^*x),\qquad \rho(a)\Lambda x=\Lambda(ax);(9)✦

  2. the weak closure of the trace representation satisfies Nτis a von Neumann algebra onHτ;N_\tau\ \text{is a von Neumann algebra on}\ H_\tau;(10)✦

  3. there is a normal semifinite extended trace TτT_\tau on NτN_\tau, faithful in that Tτ(a)=0T_\tau(a)=0 only for a=0a=0, such that Tτ(πτ(a))=τ(a)(a∈Fin(τ)+);T_\tau(\pi_\tau(a))=\tau(a)\qquad(a\in\mathrm{Fin}(\tau)_+);(11)✦

  4. if AA is separable, then Hτis separable;H_\tau\ \text{is separable};(12)✦

  5. if AA has the completely positive approximation property, π\pi is a representation of AA on HH, y1,…,ym∈π(A)¯woy_1,\dots,y_m\in\overline{\pi(A)}^{\,\mathrm{wo}}, ξ1,…,ξk∈H\xi_1,\dots,\xi_k\in H and ε>0\varepsilon>0, then there are nn, completely positive contractions α:A→Mn\alpha\colon A\to M_n and β:Mn→A\beta\colon M_n\to A, and a1,…,am∈Aa_1,\dots,a_m\in A such that, for all ii and jj, ∥(π(β(α(aj)))−yj)ξi∥<ε,∥(π(β(α(aj)))*−yj*)ξi∥<ε;\bigl\|\bigl(\pi(\beta(\alpha(a_j)))-y_j\bigr)\xi_i\bigr\|<\varepsilon,\qquad \bigl\|\bigl(\pi(\beta(\alpha(a_j)))^*-y_j^*\bigr)\xi_i\bigr\|<\varepsilon;(13)✦

  6. if BB is a star subalgebra of B(H)B(H), y∈B¯woy\in\overline{B}^{\,\mathrm{wo}}, ξ1,…,ξn∈H\xi_1,\dots,\xi_n\in H and ε>0\varepsilon>0, then there is b∈Bb\in B such that, for all ii, ∥(b−y)ξi∥<ε,∥(b*−y*)ξi∥<ε;\|(b-y)\xi_i\|<\varepsilon,\qquad \|(b^*-y^*)\xi_i\|<\varepsilon;(14)✦

  7. if moreover BB is norm closed and ∥y∥≤1\|y\|\le 1, then there is b∈Bb\in B such that, for all ii, ∥b∥≤1,∥(b−y)ξi∥<ε,∥(b*−y*)ξi∥<ε.\|b\|\le 1,\qquad \|(b-y)\xi_i\|<\varepsilon,\qquad \|(b^*-y^*)\xi_i\|<\varepsilon.(15)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for an extended trace τ\tau with I=Fin(τ)I=\mathrm{Fin}(\tau), the trace representation πτ\pi_\tau on I/Ker(τ)I/\mathrm{Ker}(\tau), Ker(τ)\mathrm{Ker}(\tau) being the zero ideal of τ\tau, has weak closure NτN_\tau with a faithful normal semifinite trace TτT_\tau which agrees with τ\tau on πτ(I)+\pi_\tau(I)_+; NτN_\tau has separable predual, and nuclearity makes it hyperfinite.

What Is Checked

The claims are stated over extended traces on a C*^*-algebra and its positive cone, the finite square set 𝔫τ\mathfrak n_\tau and the finite ideal Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau), the GNS space HτH_\tau with the trace representation πτ\pi_\tau, weak operator closures of star subalgebras of B(H)B(H) with the weak closure NτN_\tau, normal and semifinite extended traces on NτN_\tau, and the completely positive approximation property.

About these constructions, the library proves that 𝔫τ\mathfrak n_\tau is a left ideal of AA✦ closed under the adjoint✦, and that left multiplication by a∈Aa\in A satisfies ∥ax∥τ≤∥a∥∥x∥τ\|ax\|_\tau\le\|a\|\,\|x\|_\tau for x∈𝔫τx\in\mathfrak n_\tau✦. It also proves that πτ(a)\pi_\tau(a) is a positive element of NτN_\tau for every a∈A+a\in A_+.✦