OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. The invariant, its ideals, and matrix conventions · §2

The finite ideal Fin(τ), the zero ideal Ker(τ), and (2.6): Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) is the least closed ideal holding every positive element of finite trace, and Ker(τ)\mathrm{Ker}(\tau) holds those of trace zero

The two closed ideals cut out by an extended trace.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let CC be a C*^*-algebra, not necessarily unital, and let τ\tau be an extended trace on CC, that is, a lower semicontinuous trace on its positive cone with values in [0,∞][0,\infty]. These traces form the trace cone T(C)T(C), and each τ\tau in it carries two closed ideals of CC: the finite ideal Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau), which records where τ\tau is finite, and the zero ideal Ker(τ)\mathrm{Ker}(\tau), which records where it vanishes.

The questions are which closed ideal the elements of finite trace generate, and how the values of τ\tau tell whether a given positive element lies in either ideal.

Extended Traces and Closed Ideals

The positive cone C+C_+ of CC is the set of elements a≥0a \ge 0 for the star order of CC, with the norm topology.✦ A closed ideal of CC is a norm-closed star subalgebra JJ of CC such that xyxy and yxyx lie in JJ for every x∈Cx \in C and y∈Jy \in J; closed ideals are ordered by inclusion.✦

An extended trace on CC is a lower semicontinuous map τ:C+→[0,∞]\tau : C_+ \to [0,\infty], with ∞\infty an actual value, such that τ(0)=0,τ(a+b)=τ(a)+τ(b),τ(ra)=rτ(a),τ(x*x)=τ(xx*)\tau(0) = 0, \qquad \tau(a+b) = \tau(a) + \tau(b), \qquad \tau(ra) = r\,\tau(a), \qquad \tau(x^*x) = \tau(xx^*)(1)✦ for all a,b∈C+a, b \in C_+, every real r>0r > 0 and every x∈Cx \in C.

For a∈C+a \in C_+ and real ε≥0\varepsilon \ge 0, the positive cut (a−ε)+(a-\varepsilon)_+ is the positive element of CC given by the nonunital continuous functional calculus as (a−ε)+=fε(a),fε(t)=max⁡(t−ε,0).(a-\varepsilon)_+ = f_\varepsilon(a), \qquad f_\varepsilon(t) = \max(t-\varepsilon,\,0).(2)✦

The Claim

Definition 1. Let τ\tau be an extended trace on a C*^*-algebra CC. The square-integrable set NτN_\tau of τ\tau is the subset of CC Nτ={x∈C:τ(x*x)<∞}.N_\tau = \{\, x \in C : \tau(x^*x) < \infty \,\}.(3)✦ The finite ideal Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) of τ\tau is the norm closure of NτN_\tau, a closed ideal of CC: Fin(τ)=Nτ¯.\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) = \overline{N_\tau}.(4)✦ The support weight στ\sigma_\tau of τ\tau is the extended trace on CC given for a∈C+a \in C_+ by στ(a)={0if τ(a)=0,∞otherwise.\sigma_\tau(a) = \begin{cases} 0 & \text{if } \tau(a) = 0,\\ \infty & \text{otherwise.} \end{cases}(5)✦ The zero ideal Ker(τ)\mathrm{Ker}(\tau) of τ\tau is the finite ideal of its support weight, Ker(τ)=Fin(στ)\mathrm{Ker}(\tau) = \mathrm{Fin}(\sigma_\tau).✦

Theorem 1. Let τ\tau be an extended trace on a C*^*-algebra CC. For every closed ideal JJ of CC, Fin(τ)⊆J⇔a∈J for every a∈C+ with τ(a)<∞.\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) \subseteq J \iff a \in J \text{ for every } a \in C_+ \text{ with } \tau(a) < \infty.(6)✦ If a∈C+a \in C_+ lies in Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau), there is a sequence (bn)(b_n) in C+C_+ with τ(bn)<∞ for every nand∥bn−a∥→0.\tau(b_n) < \infty \text{ for every } n \quad\text{and}\quad \|b_n - a\| \to 0.(7)✦ For every positive element aa of CC, a∈Fin(τ)⇔τ((a−ε)+)<∞ for every ε>0,a \in \mathrm{Fin}(\tau) \iff \tau\bigl((a-\varepsilon)_+\bigr) < \infty \text{ for every } \varepsilon > 0,(8)✦ and a∈Ker(τ)⇔τ(a)=0.a \in \mathrm{Ker}(\tau) \iff \tau(a) = 0.(9)✦

In the paper, the result reads: Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) is the closed ideal generated by the positive elements on which τ\tau is finite and Ker(τ)\mathrm{Ker}(\tau) is the zero ideal of τ\tau, τ(a)=∞\tau(a) = \infty for every a∈C+\Fin(τ)a \in C_+ \setminus \mathrm{Fin}(\tau), and its (2.6) states that a∈C+a \in C_+ lies in Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) if and only if dτ((a−ε)+)<∞d_\tau((a-\varepsilon)_+) < \infty for every ε>0\varepsilon > 0, where dτd_\tau is the dimension function of τ\tau.

Here (6) makes Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) the closed ideal generated by the positive elements of finite trace, and (8) is (2.6) with τ\tau in place of dτd_\tau.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over an arbitrary C*^*-algebra CC, not necessarily unital, with its star order; an extended trace τ\tau on CC satisfying (1); the closed ideals of CC; and the positive cuts of (2).

The library proves that the set NτN_\tau of (3) is a star subalgebra✦ and a left ideal of CC✦, and that the support weight στ\sigma_\tau is lower semicontinuous on C+C_+✦.