OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. The invariant, its ideals, and matrix conventions

Proposition 2.2: The induced order isomorphism of closed ideals matches ideal weights, finite ideals and zero ideals, and exists for any additive bijection of trace cones

A trace cone equivalence transports closed ideals.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let AA be a C*-algebra. Its closed ideals and its extended traces are tied together in two directions: each closed ideal II has a weight τI\tau_I, and each extended trace τ\tau has a finite ideal Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) and a zero ideal Ker(τ)\mathrm{Ker}(\tau).

The question is what an isomorphism FF from the cone T(A)T(A) of extended traces on AA onto the cone T(B)T(B) of a second C*-algebra BB does to closed ideals. Does it induce an isomorphism of the lattices of closed ideals of AA and BB under which the weight of each ideal goes to the weight of the corresponding ideal, and the finite and zero ideals of each τ\tau go to those of FτF\tau?

Extended Traces

Throughout, a C*-algebra may be nonunital and carries its star order, and A+A_+ is the positive cone of AA, the elements a≥0a\ge 0, with the norm topology.

An extended trace on AA is a lower semicontinuous map τ:A+→[0,∞]\tau\colon A_+\to[0,\infty], the value ∞\infty allowed, with τ(0)=0\tau(0)=0 and τ(a+b)=τ(a)+τ(b),τ(ra)=rτ(a),τ(x*x)=τ(xx*)\tau(a+b)=\tau(a)+\tau(b),\qquad \tau(ra)=r\,\tau(a),\qquad \tau(x^*x)=\tau(xx^*)(1)✦ for all a,b∈A+a,b\in A_+, every real r>0r>0 and every x∈Ax\in A. The extended traces on AA form the cone T(A)T(A): the sum τ+σ\tau+\sigma and the multiple rτr\tau by a real r≥0r\ge 0 are taken pointwise in [0,∞][0,\infty], with 0⋅∞=00\cdot\infty=0, and the zero trace vanishes on all of A+A_+✦.

A family (τi)i∈ι(\tau_i)_{i\in\iota} in T(A)T(A) converges canonically to σ∈T(A)\sigma\in T(A) along a filter ll on ι\iota if limsuplτi((a−ε)+)≤σ(a)≤liminflτi(a)\limsup_{l}\,\tau_i\bigl((a-\varepsilon)_+\bigr)\le\sigma(a)\le\liminf_{l}\,\tau_i(a)(2)✦ for every a∈A+a\in A_+ and every ε>0\varepsilon>0, where the positive cut (a−ε)+(a-\varepsilon)_+ is the image of aa under t↦max⁡(t−ε,0)t\mapsto\max(t-\varepsilon,0) in the nonunital continuous functional calculus; a net converges canonically when it does so along its filter of tails. A map f:T(A)→T(B)f\colon T(A)\to T(B) preserves canonical convergence if, whenever a filter on T(A)T(A) converges canonically to σ\sigma, its image under ff converges canonically to f(σ)f(\sigma).✦

A trace cone equivalence F:T(A)→T(B)F\colon T(A)\to T(B) is a bijection that preserves sums, sends the zero trace to the zero trace and commutes with multiplication by every real r>0r>0, such that FF and F−1F^{-1} both preserve canonical convergence.✦

Ideals and Traces

A closed ideal of AA is a norm-closed complex star subalgebra II of AA that absorbs multiplication on both sides: xy∈Ixy\in I whenever x∈Ix\in I or y∈Iy\in I, for x,y∈Ax,y\in A.✦ The closed ideals of AA are ordered by inclusion.

The weight of a closed ideal II of AA is the extended trace τI\tau_I on AA given by τI(a)={0,a∈I+,∞,a∈A+\I.\tau_I(a)=\begin{cases}0, & a\in I_+,\\ \infty, & a\in A_+\setminus I.\end{cases}(3)✦

The finite ideal of an extended trace τ\tau on AA is the closed ideal of AA given by the norm closure of the star subalgebra of the elements xx with τ(x*x)\tau(x^*x) finite: Fin(τ)={x∈A:τ(x*x)<∞}¯.\mathrm{Fin}(\tau)=\overline{\{x\in A:\tau(x^*x)<\infty\}}.(4)✦

The support weight of an extended trace τ\tau on AA is the extended trace ∞τ\infty\tau on AA with (∞τ)(a)={0,τ(a)=0,∞,τ(a)>0,(\infty\tau)(a)=\begin{cases}0, & \tau(a)=0,\\ \infty, & \tau(a)>0,\end{cases}(5)✦ and the zero ideal of τ\tau is the closed ideal of AA given by Ker(τ)=Fin(∞τ).\mathrm{Ker}(\tau)=\mathrm{Fin}(\infty\tau).(6)✦

For a bijection e:T(A)→T(B)e\colon T(A)\to T(B) that preserves sums, e(τ+σ)=e(τ)+e(σ)e(\tau+\sigma)=e(\tau)+e(\sigma) for all τ,σ∈T(A)\tau,\sigma\in T(A), the induced map Φe\Phi_e from the closed ideals of AA to the closed ideals of BB is Φe(I)=Fin(e(τI)).\Phi_e(I)=\mathrm{Fin}\bigl(e(\tau_I)\bigr).(7)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let AA and BB be C*-algebras.

(a) Let e:T(A)→T(B)e\colon T(A)\to T(B) be a bijection that preserves sums. Then Φe\Phi_e is a bijection from the closed ideals of AA onto the closed ideals of BB, and for all closed ideals II and JJ of AA I⊆J⇔Φe(I)⊆Φe(J).I\subseteq J\iff\Phi_e(I)\subseteq\Phi_e(J).(8)✦

(b) Let F:T(A)→T(B)F\colon T(A)\to T(B) be a trace cone equivalence, and let ΦF\Phi_F be the order isomorphism of (a) for e=Fe=F. Then for every closed ideal II of AA τΦF(I)=F(τI),\tau_{\Phi_F(I)}=F(\tau_I),(9)✦ and for every extended trace τ\tau on AA ΦF(Fin(τ))=Fin(Fτ),\Phi_F\bigl(\mathrm{Fin}(\tau)\bigr)=\mathrm{Fin}(F\tau),(10)✦ ΦF(Ker(τ))=Ker(Fτ).\Phi_F\bigl(\mathrm{Ker}(\tau)\bigr)=\mathrm{Ker}(F\tau).(11)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for two separable nuclear C*-algebras with isomorphic trace cones, their stabilizations PP and QQ by 𝒲⊗𝒦\mathcal W\otimes\mathcal K, with 𝒲\mathcal W the Razak-Jacelon algebra and 𝒦\mathcal K the compact operators, and the isomorphisms F:T(Q)→T(P)F\colon T(Q)\to T(P) and G:Cu(P)→Cu(Q)G\colon\mathrm{Cu}(P)\to\mathrm{Cu}(Q) of the paper’s Theorem 2.1, with Cu\mathrm{Cu} the Cuntz semigroup, the maps FF and GG identify the complete ideal lattices of PP and QQ, these identifications agree, and they identify the finite and zero ideals of corresponding weights, so that, with Prim(P)=Prim(Q)=X\mathrm{Prim}(P)=\mathrm{Prim}(Q)=X through the resulting homeomorphism of primitive ideal spaces and P(U)P(U), Q(U)Q(U) the ideals of an open set U⊆XU\subseteq X, one has G(Cu(P(U)))=Cu(Q(U))G(\mathrm{Cu}(P(U)))=\mathrm{Cu}(Q(U)) and, for τ∈T(Q)\tau\in T(Q), Fin(τ)=Q(U)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau)=Q(U) if and only if Fin(Fτ)=P(U)\mathrm{Fin}(F\tau)=P(U), and Ker(τ)=Q(U)\mathrm{Ker}(\tau)=Q(U) if and only if Ker(Fτ)=P(U)\mathrm{Ker}(F\tau)=P(U).

The theorem states the trace cone half of this for any two C*-algebras AA and BB and any trace cone equivalence F:T(A)→T(B)F\colon T(A)\to T(B), with ΦF\Phi_F identifying their closed ideals.

What Is Checked

The theorem is stated over two C*-algebras AA and BB with their star orders, their cones T(A)T(A) and T(B)T(B) of extended traces, their closed ideals ordered by inclusion, the weights τI\tau_I, the finite and zero ideals Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) and Ker(τ)\mathrm{Ker}(\tau), a bijection ee preserving sums in (8), and a trace cone equivalence FF, with canonical convergence on both cones, in (9), (10) and (11).

The library proves that, for an extended trace τ\tau on AA, the set of x∈Ax\in A with τ(x*x)<∞\tau(x^*x)<\infty contains 00✦, is closed under sums✦, complex multiples✦ and adjoints✦, and absorbs multiplication on the left by AA✦, and that the support weight ∞τ\infty\tau is lower semicontinuous✦. It proves that the idempotent extended traces on AA, those τ\tau with τ+τ=τ\tau+\tau=\tau, include every weight τI\tau_I✦, and that I↦τII\mapsto\tau_I is a bijection from the closed ideals of AA onto them, with inverse τ↦Fin(τ)\tau\mapsto\mathrm{Fin}(\tau)✦. A bijection e:T(A)→T(B)e\colon T(A)\to T(B) that preserves sums carries the idempotent extended traces on AA bijectively onto those on BB.✦