OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. The invariant, its ideals, and matrix conventions · §2

Additive idempotents and the scalar limits (2.7): Closed ideals match additive idempotents by I↦τII \mapsto \tau_I; rτr\tau tends canonically to τFin(τ)\tau_{\mathrm{Fin}(\tau)} as r→0+r \to 0^+, to τKer(τ)\tau_{\mathrm{Ker}(\tau)} as r→∞r \to \infty

Idempotent traces are ideal weights, and so are scalar limits.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let CC be a C*-algebra, not necessarily unital. Its extended traces, the lower semicontinuous traces on the positive cone C+C_+ that may take the value ∞\infty, form a cone T(C)T(C), and each closed ideal II of CC has a weight τI\tau_I in this cone. Two questions about T(C)T(C) arise: which of its points are additive idempotents, and where the multiples rτr\tau of a trace τ\tau go as rr tends to 00 and to ∞\infty.

Extended Traces, Closed Ideals and Canonical Limits

The positive cone C+C_+ of CC is the set of elements a≥0a \ge 0 of CC in its star order, with the norm topology.✦ For a∈C+a \in C_+ and a real ε≥0\varepsilon \ge 0, the positive cut (a−ε)+(a-\varepsilon)_+ is the element of C+C_+ given by the nonunital continuous functional calculus, (a−ε)+=fε(a),fε(t)=max⁡(t−ε,0).(a-\varepsilon)_+ = f_\varepsilon(a), \qquad f_\varepsilon(t) = \max(t-\varepsilon,\, 0).(1)✦

An extended trace on CC is a map τ:C+→[0,∞]\tau \colon C_+ \to [0,\infty], lower semicontinuous for the norm topology, such that τ(0)=0,τ(a+b)=τ(a)+τ(b),τ(ra)=rτ(a),τ(x*x)=τ(xx*)\tau(0) = 0, \qquad \tau(a+b) = \tau(a) + \tau(b), \qquad \tau(ra) = r\,\tau(a), \qquad \tau(x^*x) = \tau(xx^*)(2)✦ for all a,b∈C+a, b \in C_+, every real r>0r > 0 and every x∈Cx \in C. The extended traces on CC form the set T(C)T(C). The sum of two extended traces τ\tau and σ\sigma on CC and the multiple of τ\tau by a real r≥0r \ge 0 are the extended traces (τ+σ)(a)=τ(a)+σ(a),(rτ)(a)=rτ(a)(a∈C+),(\tau+\sigma)(a) = \tau(a) + \sigma(a), \qquad (r\tau)(a) = r\,\tau(a) \qquad (a \in C_+),(3) computed in [0,∞][0,\infty] with 0⋅∞=00 \cdot \infty = 0.

The set Idem⁡(C)\operatorname{Idem}(C) of additive idempotents of T(C)T(C) is the subset of extended traces fixed by doubling, Idem⁡(C)={τ∈T(C):τ+τ=τ}.\operatorname{Idem}(C) = \{\tau \in T(C) : \tau + \tau = \tau\}.(4)✦

A closed ideal II of CC is a norm-closed star subalgebra of CC that absorbs multiplication on both sides: xy∈Ixy \in I for all x,y∈Cx, y \in C with x∈Ix \in I or y∈Iy \in I.✦ Closed ideals are ordered by inclusion. The weight τI\tau_I of a closed ideal II is the extended trace on CC given by τI(a)=0(a∈I∩C+),τI(a)=∞(a∈C+\I).\tau_I(a) = 0 \quad (a \in I \cap C_+), \qquad \tau_I(a) = \infty \quad (a \in C_+ \setminus I).(5)✦

The finite ideal Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) of an extended trace τ\tau on CC is the subset of CC Fin(τ)=𝔫τ¯,𝔫τ={x∈C:τ(x*x)<∞},\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) = \overline{\mathfrak n_\tau}, \qquad \mathfrak n_\tau = \{x \in C : \tau(x^*x) < \infty\},(6) Here 𝔫τ\mathfrak n_\tau is the set of elements xx of CC at which τ\tau is finite on x*xx^*x. The support weight sτs_\tau of an extended trace τ\tau on CC is the extended trace that is 00 at the elements of C+C_+ where τ\tau vanishes and ∞\infty at the others✦, and the zero ideal of τ\tau is the finite ideal of its support weight, Ker(τ)=Fin(sτ).\mathrm{Ker}(\tau) = \mathrm{Fin}(s_\tau).(7)✦

A family (τi)i∈ι(\tau_i)_{i \in \iota} in T(C)T(C) converges canonically along a filter ℱ\mathcal F on ι\iota to σ∈T(C)\sigma \in T(C), written τi→σ\tau_i \to \sigma along ℱ\mathcal F, if, with the positive cut (1), limsupℱτi((a−ε)+)≤σ(a)≤liminfℱτi(a)(a∈C+,ε>0).\limsup_{\mathcal F}\, \tau_i\big((a-\varepsilon)_+\big) \;\le\; \sigma(a) \;\le\; \liminf_{\mathcal F}\, \tau_i(a) \qquad (a \in C_+,\ \varepsilon > 0).(8)✦ A net (τi)i∈ι(\tau_i)_{i \in \iota} in T(C)T(C) converges canonically to σ∈T(C)\sigma \in T(C) when it converges canonically to σ\sigma along its filter of tails. The limits of rτr\tau are taken along two filters on [0,∞)[0,\infty): as r→0+r \to 0^+, along the filter generated by the intervals (0,δ)(0,\delta) with δ>0\delta > 0, and as r→∞r \to \infty, along the filter generated by the intervals [R,∞)[R,\infty) with R≥0R \ge 0.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let CC be a C*-algebra.

  1. Let τ\tau be an additive idempotent of T(C)T(C). Then τ(a)∈{0,∞}(a∈C+),\tau(a) \in \{0, \infty\} \qquad (a \in C_+),(9)✦ τ(a)=0(a∈Fin(τ)∩C+),\tau(a) = 0 \qquad (a \in \mathrm{Fin}(\tau) \cap C_+),(10)✦ and τFin(τ)=τ.\tau_{\mathrm{Fin}(\tau)} = \tau.(11)✦

  2. Let II be a closed ideal of CC. Then τI+τI=τI\tau_I + \tau_I = \tau_I(12)✦ and Fin(τI)=I.\mathrm{Fin}(\tau_I) = I.(13)✦

  3. The map {closed ideals of C}→Idem⁡(C),I↦τI,\{\text{closed ideals of } C\} \longrightarrow \operatorname{Idem}(C), \qquad I \longmapsto \tau_I,(14)✦ is a bijection, with inverse τ↦Fin(τ)\tau \mapsto \mathrm{Fin}(\tau).

  4. Let τ\tau be an extended trace on CC. Its multiples converge canonically, rτ→τFin(τ)as r→0+,r\tau \to \tau_{\mathrm{Fin}(\tau)} \quad \text{as } r \to 0^+,(15)✦ and rτ→τKer(τ)as r→∞.r\tau \to \tau_{\mathrm{Ker}(\tau)} \quad \text{as } r \to \infty.(16)✦

  5. Let τ\tau be an extended trace on CC. There are a closed ideal II of CC and an extended trace ω\omega on CC such that, for every closed ideal JJ of CC and every a∈C+a \in C_+, I⊆J⇔{b∈C+:τ(b)<∞}⊆J,a∈I⇔τ((a−ε)+)<∞for every ε>0,ω(a)=0if a∈I,ω(a)=∞if a∉I,rτ→ωas r→0+.\begin{gathered} I \subseteq J \iff \{b \in C_+ : \tau(b) < \infty\} \subseteq J, \\ a \in I \iff \tau\big((a-\varepsilon)_+\big) < \infty \ \text{for every } \varepsilon > 0, \\ \omega(a) = 0 \ \text{if } a \in I, \quad \omega(a) = \infty \ \text{if } a \notin I, \quad r\tau \to \omega \ \text{as } r \to 0^+. \end{gathered}(17)✦

  6. Let (τi)i∈ι(\tau_i)_{i \in \iota} be a family in T(C)T(C), ℱ\mathcal F a filter on ι\iota that does not contain the empty set, and σ,σ′∈T(C)\sigma, \sigma' \in T(C). If τi→σ\tau_i \to \sigma and τi→σ′\tau_i \to \sigma' along ℱ\mathcal F, then σ=σ′.\sigma = \sigma'.(18)✦

In the paper, the result reads: the additive idempotents of the trace cone T(C)T(C) are exactly the ideal weights τI\tau_I, τ+τ=τ\tau + \tau = \tau forcing every value to be 00 or ∞\infty and the zero set being a closed ideal, and in (2.7), lim⁡r↓0rτ=τFin(τ)\lim_{r \downarrow 0} r\tau = \tau_{\mathrm{Fin}(\tau)} and lim⁡r↑∞rτ=τKer(τ)\lim_{r \uparrow \infty} r\tau = \tau_{\mathrm{Ker}(\tau)}, both limits preserved by the continuity and positive homogeneity of a map FF.

The box takes the paper’s limits as canonical limits of the family (rτ)r≥0(r\tau)_{r \ge 0} along the filters r→0+r \to 0^+ and r→∞r \to \infty.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over the extended traces on a C*-algebra CC with their sums and scalar multiples, over the closed ideals of CC and their weights τI\tau_I, over the finite ideal Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) and the zero ideal Ker(τ)\mathrm{Ker}(\tau) built from the support weight sτs_\tau, and over canonical convergence along a filter, defined through the positive cut (a−ε)+(a-\varepsilon)_+.

The library proves that, for every extended trace τ\tau, the set 𝔫τ\mathfrak n_\tau contains 00✦, is closed under sums✦, complex scalar multiples and the adjoint, and absorbs multiplication on the left✦, so that it is a star subalgebra of CC✦ whose closure Fin(τ)\mathrm{Fin}(\tau) is a closed ideal✦. It proves as well that the support weight sτs_\tau of an extended trace is lower semicontinuous.✦