OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. Introduction · §1

The trace cone T(C), its canonical topology (1.2), and cone isomorphisms: The cone T(C)T(C) of norm lower semicontinuous traces C+→[0,∞]C_+ \to [0,\infty] with canonical convergence along filters, and the bijections preserving both structures

Extended traces, canonical convergence and isomorphisms of trace cones.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let CC be a C*^*-algebra, not necessarily unital.

The trace cone T(C)T(C) of CC is the set of its extended traces, the lower semicontinuous traces C+→[0,∞]C_+ \to [0,\infty] defined below. Two questions come with the cone: when a family of traces converges to a trace that may take the value ∞\infty, and when the trace cones of two C*^*-algebras AA and BB are isomorphic.

Positive Elements and Their Cuts

The positive cone C+C_+ of CC is the set of positive elements of CC for its star order, with the norm topology: C+={a∈C:a≥0}.C_+ = \{\, a \in C : a \ge 0 \,\}.(1)✦

For a∈C+a \in C_+ and a real ε≥0\varepsilon \ge 0, the cut of aa at level ε\varepsilon is the element of CC obtained from aa by the nonunital continuous functional calculus applied to the function fεf_\varepsilon on ℝ\mathbb{R}: (a−ε)+=fε(a),fε(t)=max⁡(t−ε,0).(a-\varepsilon)_+ = f_\varepsilon(a), \qquad f_\varepsilon(t) = \max(t-\varepsilon,\, 0).(2)✦

The Definition

Definition 1. Let CC be a C*^*-algebra. An extended trace on CC is a map τ:C+→[0,∞]\tau \colon C_+ \to [0,\infty], lower semicontinuous for the norm topology on C+C_+, such that for all a,b∈C+a, b \in C_+, every real r>0r > 0 and every x∈Cx \in C τ(0)=0,τ(a+b)=τ(a)+τ(b),τ(ra)=rτ(a),τ(x*x)=τ(xx*).\tau(0) = 0, \qquad \tau(a+b) = \tau(a) + \tau(b), \qquad \tau(ra) = r\,\tau(a), \qquad \tau(x^*x) = \tau(xx^*).(3)✦ The trace cone T(C)T(C) is the set of extended traces on CC. For τ,σ∈T(C)\tau, \sigma \in T(C) and a real r≥0r \ge 0, the sum τ+σ\tau + \sigma, the zero trace 00 and the multiple rτr\tau are defined at a∈C+a \in C_+ by (τ+σ)(a)=τ(a)+σ(a),(\tau + \sigma)(a) = \tau(a) + \sigma(a),(4)✦ 0(a)=0,0(a) = 0,(5)✦ (rτ)(a)=rτ(a),(r\tau)(a) = r\,\tau(a),(6)✦ with the convention 0⋅∞=00 \cdot \infty = 0.

Let (τi)i∈I(\tau_i)_{i \in I} be a family in T(C)T(C), ℱ\mathcal{F} a filter on II and τ∈T(C)\tau \in T(C). The family converges canonically to τ\tau along ℱ\mathcal{F}, written τi→ℱτ\tau_i \xrightarrow{\mathcal{F}} \tau, if for every a∈C+a \in C_+ and every real ε>0\varepsilon > 0 limsupi→ℱτi((a−ε)+)≤τ(a)≤liminfi→ℱτi(a).\limsup_{i \to \mathcal{F}} \tau_i\big((a-\varepsilon)_+\big) \;\le\; \tau(a) \;\le\; \liminf_{i \to \mathcal{F}} \tau_i(a).(7)✦ A net (τi)i∈I(\tau_i)_{i \in I} in T(C)T(C) converges canonically to τ∈T(C)\tau \in T(C) when it converges canonically to τ\tau along the filter of its tails.

Let AA and BB be C*^*-algebras. A map f:T(A)→T(B)f \colon T(A) \to T(B) preserves canonical convergence if, for every filter ℱ\mathcal{F} on T(A)T(A) and every σ∈T(A)\sigma \in T(A) such that the family (τ)τ∈T(A)(\tau)_{\tau \in T(A)} converges canonically to σ\sigma along ℱ\mathcal{F}, the family (f(τ))τ∈T(A)(f(\tau))_{\tau \in T(A)} converges canonically to f(σ)f(\sigma) along ℱ\mathcal{F}: τ→ℱσ⇒f(τ)→ℱf(σ).\tau \xrightarrow{\mathcal{F}} \sigma \quad\Longrightarrow\quad f(\tau) \xrightarrow{\mathcal{F}} f(\sigma).(8)✦

A cone isomorphism from T(A)T(A) to T(B)T(B) is a bijection Φ:T(A)→T(B)\Phi \colon T(A) \to T(B) such that Φ\Phi and Φ−1\Phi^{-1} preserve canonical convergence and, for all τ,σ∈T(A)\tau, \sigma \in T(A) and every real r>0r > 0, Φ(τ+σ)=Φ(τ)+Φ(σ),Φ(0)=0,Φ(rτ)=rΦ(τ).\Phi(\tau + \sigma) = \Phi(\tau) + \Phi(\sigma), \qquad \Phi(0) = 0, \qquad \Phi(r\tau) = r\,\Phi(\tau).(9)✦

In the paper, the result reads: T(C)T(C) consists of all τ:C+→[0,∞]\tau \colon C_+ \to [0,\infty] with τ(0)=0\tau(0) = 0, τ(a+b)=τ(a)+τ(b)\tau(a+b) = \tau(a) + \tau(b), τ(ra)=rτ(a)\tau(ra) = r\tau(a) for r>0r > 0, τ(x*x)=τ(xx*)\tau(x^*x) = \tau(xx^*) and lower semicontinuity for norm-convergent nets in C+C_+, with no density condition on the finite domain; τi→τ\tau_i \to \tau if and only if limsup⁡iτi((a−ε)+)≤τ(a)≤liminf⁡iτi(a)\limsup_i \tau_i((a-\varepsilon)_+) \le \tau(a) \le \liminf_i \tau_i(a) for all a∈C+a \in C_+ and ε>0\varepsilon > 0; and an isomorphism of topological cones is a homeomorphism preserving addition, the zero weight and multiplication by every positive real scalar.

What Is Checked

The definitions are stated over an arbitrary C*^*-algebra, unital or not, with its star order, its positive cone C+C_+ in the norm topology (1) and the cut (a−ε)+(a-\varepsilon)_+ of the nonunital continuous functional calculus (2).

The library proves that C+C_+ contains 00, the sum a+ba+b, the multiple rara for real r≥0r \ge 0, and x*xx^*x and xx*xx^* for every x∈Cx \in C, and that every cut (a−ε)+(a-\varepsilon)_+ lies in C+C_+. The sum (4) of two extended traces, the zero map (5) and a nonnegative multiple (6) of an extended trace are again extended traces, so T(C)T(C) is a cone.

A map that preserves canonical convergence along every filter on T(A)T(A) also sends every canonically convergent net of extended traces on AA, indexed by any set, to a canonically convergent net.