OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Closed subiterations and countable determination · §5

Lemma 5.3 [The initial algebra]: Separable and infinite-dimensional; its projections pnp_n, of trace 2−n2^{-n}, peak to a state, and algebras receiving it unitally have no finite-dimensional irreducible representations

The canonical anticommutation relations algebra is simple with a faithful trace.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Lemma 5.3 concerns the initial algebra A0A_0, the CAR (canonical anticommutation relations) algebra: the infinite tensor product of copies of the algebra M2M_2 of 2×22 \times 2 complex matrices. The algebra A0A_0 carries a normalized trace τ\tau and a sequence of projections pnp_n, where pnp_n is the matrix unit e11e_{11} of M2M_2 in each of the first nn tensor factors and 11 in all the others.

Is A0A_0 separable and simple, and how large is it? Is τ\tau faithful, and what is τ(pn)\tau(p_n)? Is there exactly one state of A0A_0 that takes the value 11 on every pnp_n? And when A0A_0 maps by a unital *^*-homomorphism into a C*^*-algebra BB, can an irreducible representation of BB act on a finite-dimensional space?

States, Ideals and Representations

A state of a C*^*-algebra BB is a continuous linear functional on BB of norm one that is real and nonnegative on every a*aa^*a with a∈Ba \in B.✦ A sequence (pn)n≥0(p_n)_{n \ge 0} in BB peaks to a state hh of BB when the pnp_n are projections with pn+1≤pnp_{n+1} \le p_n, h(pn)=1h(p_n) = 1 for every nn, and every state gg of BB with g(pn)=1g(p_n) = 1 for every nn equals hh.✦

A C*^*-algebra BB is simple when it is nonzero and its only closed two-sided ideals are 00 and BB.✦

An irreducible representation π:B→ℬ(H)\pi \colon B \to \mathcal{B}(H) of a C*^*-algebra BB on a Hilbert space HH is a nonzero *^*-homomorphism whose only closed subspaces M⊆HM \subseteq H with π(B)M⊆M\pi(B)M \subseteq M are 00 and HH.✦

The CAR Algebra

The stage algebra M2nM_{2^n} of level nn is the C*^*-algebra defined by recursion as ℂ\mathbb{C} at level 00 and as the 2×22 \times 2 matrices over the stage algebra of level nn at level n+1n+1✦, and the stage step σn\sigma_n is the unital *^*-homomorphism a↦diag(a,a)a \mapsto \mathrm{diag}(a, a) from one stage to the next: M20=ℂ,M2n+1=M2(M2n),σn:M2n→M2n+1,σn(a)=(a00a).M_{2^0} = \mathbb{C}, \qquad M_{2^{n+1}} = M_2\bigl(M_{2^n}\bigr), \qquad \sigma_n \colon M_{2^n} \to M_{2^{n+1}}, \quad \sigma_n(a) = \begin{pmatrix} a & 0 \\ 0 & a \end{pmatrix}.(1)✦ For n≤mn \le m the bonding map βnm:M2n→M2m\beta_{nm} \colon M_{2^n} \to M_{2^m} is the identity when m=nm = n and the composite σm−1∘⋯∘σn\sigma_{m-1} \circ \cdots \circ \sigma_n when m>nm > n.✦

The C*^*-direct limit of a directed system of C*^*-algebras DiD_i with connecting *^*-homomorphisms fijf_{ij} is the completion of their algebraic direct limit in the limit norm✦, and DiD_i maps into it by the unital *^*-homomorphism that sends an element to its class.✦ States ψi\psi_i of the DiD_i that are compatible, with ψj∘fij=ψi\psi_j \circ f_{ij} = \psi_i for i≤ji \le j, induce a state of the C*^*-direct limit: the continuous extension of the functional on the algebraic direct limit that agrees with ψi\psi_i on the image of DiD_i.✦

A directed system (Di,fij)i≤j(D_i, f_{ij})_{i \le j} of *^*-homomorphisms is isometric when every connecting map fijf_{ij} is isometric.✦

The CAR algebra A0A_0 is the C*^*-direct limit of the stage algebras along the bonding maps✦, and ιn\iota_n is the inclusion of the stage of level nn: A0=lim→(M2n,βnm),ιn:M2n→A0.A_0 = \underset{\longrightarrow}{\lim}\,\bigl(M_{2^n}, \beta_{nm}\bigr), \qquad \iota_n \colon M_{2^n} \to A_0.(2)✦

The stage peak qnq_n of level nn is the element of M2nM_{2^n} given by the recursion below✦, and the peak pnp_n of A0A_0 is its image under ιn\iota_n: q0=1,qn+1=(qn000),pn=ιn(qn).q_0 = 1, \qquad q_{n+1} = \begin{pmatrix} q_n & 0 \\ 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix}, \qquad p_n = \iota_n(q_n).(3)✦

The stage trace trn\mathrm{tr}_n is the normalized trace of M2nM_{2^n}✦, and the stage vector state ωn\omega_n is the vector state of e1⊗⋯⊗e1e_1 \otimes \cdots \otimes e_1, with e1e_1 the first basis vector of ℂ2\mathbb{C}^2.✦ Both are defined by recursion, each being the identity of ℂ\mathbb{C} at level 00; for M=(Mij)M = (M_{ij}) in M2(M2n)M_2(M_{2^n}), trn+1(M)=12(trn(M11)+trn(M22)),ωn+1(M)=ωn(M11).\mathrm{tr}_{n+1}(M) = \tfrac{1}{2}\bigl(\mathrm{tr}_n(M_{11}) + \mathrm{tr}_n(M_{22})\bigr), \qquad \omega_{n+1}(M) = \omega_n(M_{11}).(4)

The trace τ\tau of A0A_0 and its vector state f0f_0 are the states induced by the stage traces and by the stage vector states: for every nn and every a∈M2na \in M_{2^n}, τ(ιn(a))=trn(a),f0(ιn(a))=ωn(a).\tau\bigl(\iota_n(a)\bigr) = \mathrm{tr}_n(a), \qquad f_0\bigl(\iota_n(a)\bigr) = \omega_n(a).(5)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let A0A_0 be the CAR algebra (2), with peaks pnp_n (3), trace τ\tau and vector state f0f_0 (5). Then A0 is separable,A_0 \text{ is separable,}(6)✦ A0 is simple,A_0 \text{ is simple,}(7)✦ dim⁡ℂA0=∞,\dim_{\mathbb{C}} A_0 = \infty,(8)✦ τ(a*a)>0for every nonzero a∈A0,\tau(a^*a) > 0 \quad \text{for every nonzero } a \in A_0,(9)✦ p0=1,p_0 = 1,(10)✦ (pn)n≥0 peaks to f0,(p_n)_{n \ge 0} \text{ peaks to } f_0,(11)✦ τ(pn)=2−nfor every n≥0.\tau(p_n) = 2^{-n} \quad \text{for every } n \ge 0.(12)✦ If moreover BB is a C*^*-algebra, φ:A0→B\varphi \colon A_0 \to B a unital *^*-homomorphism and π\pi an irreducible representation of BB on a Hilbert space HH, then dim⁡ℂH=∞.\dim_{\mathbb{C}} H = \infty.(13)✦

In the paper, the result reads: the algebra A0=⨂M2A_0 = \bigotimes M_2 is separable, simple and infinite-dimensional, its trace is faithful, and pn=e11⊗n⊗1p_n = e_{11}^{\otimes n} \otimes 1 peaks to a pure state f0f_0, with τ(pn)=2−n\tau(p_n) = 2^{-n}; every unital C*^*-algebra containing A0A_0 has no finite-dimensional irreducible representations.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over the CAR algebra A0A_0 of (2), built from the stage algebras and steps (1); over its peaks (3), and over its trace τ\tau and vector state f0f_0, induced as in (5) by the stage states (4); and over the notions of a state, a peaking sequence, a simple C*^*-algebra and an irreducible representation.

About these constructions the library proves that the stage traces and the stage vector states are compatible with the bonding maps: for n≤mn \le m and a∈M2na \in M_{2^n}, trm(βnm(a))=trn(a),ωm(βnm(a))=ωn(a).\mathrm{tr}_m\bigl(\beta_{nm}(a)\bigr) = \mathrm{tr}_n(a), \qquad \omega_m\bigl(\beta_{nm}(a)\bigr) = \omega_n(a).(14) It also proves that a bounded linear functional ff on a C*^*-algebra that is real and nonnegative on every a*aa^*a is positive✦, and that a positive linear functional ff satisfies |f(a)|≤f(1)∥a∥|f(a)| \le f(1)\,\|a\| for every aa.✦