OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Closed subiterations and countable determination · §5

Corollary 5.7 [Counting pure states]: For a tracial stage with chronological data of height δ\delta, whose pure states any set of size at least 𝔠\mathfrak{c} then lists

Height at most 𝔠\mathfrak{c} forces at most 𝔠\mathfrak{c} pure states.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let XX be a simple C*C^*-algebra with a tracial state, generated by a copy of the canonical anticommutation relations (CAR) algebra and elements vkv_k indexed by the ordinals kk below an ordinal δ\delta, each vkv_k either 11 or the stable unitary of a reduced Higman-Neumann-Neumann (HNN) extension. At such a step, the C*C^*-algebra generated by the CAR algebra and the vjv_j with j≤kj \le k is the reduced HNN extension of the one generated by the vjv_j with j<kj < k, along two decreasing sequences of projections, each determining a state as the only state that takes the value 11 on all its terms, and these two states are inequivalent. These projections lie in the C*C^*-algebra generated by the CAR algebra and countably many earlier vjv_j. The question is how many pure states XX can have when δ\delta has at most the cardinality 𝔠\mathfrak{c} of the continuum, and whether a set of that size then lists them all. The same count is asked of a C*C^*-algebra generated by a separable subset and elements zkz_k, k<δk < \delta, which, together with countable sets IkI_k and bridge data QkQ_k, satisfy the hypotheses listed in (a) below.

Pure States and Tracial Stages

A state of a C*C^*-algebra AA is a continuous linear functional on AA of norm one that is real and nonnegative on every a*aa^*a✦, and a pure state of AA is an extreme point of the set of states of AA.✦ We write 𝒫(A)\mathcal{P}(A) for the set of pure states of AA. Two pure states ff and gg of AA are equivalent, f∼gf \sim g, when their Gelfand-Naimark-Segal (GNS) representations are unitarily equivalent.✦

The CAR algebra M2∞M_{2^\infty} is the C*C^*-direct limit of the matrix algebras M2n(ℂ)M_{2^n}(\mathbb{C}) along the embeddings a↦diag(a,a)a \mapsto \mathrm{diag}(a, a).✦ Let e11e_{11} be the matrix unit of M2(ℂ)M_2(\mathbb{C}) with entry 11 in the upper left corner and e1e_1 the first standard basis vector of ℂ2\mathbb{C}^2. The peaks of the CAR algebra M2∞M_{2^\infty} are the elements pnp_n, where pnp_n is the image of e11⊗⋯⊗e11∈M2n(ℂ)e_{11} \otimes \cdots \otimes e_{11} \in M_{2^n}(\mathbb{C})✦, and the vector state ω\omega of M2∞M_{2^\infty} is the state that restricts on each M2n(ℂ)M_{2^n}(\mathbb{C}) to the vector state of e1⊗⋯⊗e1e_1 \otimes \cdots \otimes e_1.✦

A unital **-homomorphism ι:B→C\iota \colon B \to C has (U) when for every pure state ff of BB at most one state gg of CC satisfies g∘ι=fg \circ \iota = f.✦ A tracial stage is a simple C*C^*-algebra XX together with a tracial state τ\tau of XX and an injective unital **-homomorphism ι:M2∞→X\iota \colon M_{2^\infty} \to X that has (U).✦ The reference state ωX\omega_X of a tracial stage XX is the unique pure state of XX with ωX∘ι=ω\omega_X \circ \iota = \omega.✦

Chronological Data

A sequence (pn)(p_n) in a C*C^*-algebra AA peaks to a state hh of AA when the pnp_n are decreasing projections, h(pn)=1h(p_n) = 1 for every nn, and hh is the only state of AA with this property.✦ We write dn=pn−pn+1d_n = p_n - p_{n+1}.✦ Bridge data on AA consist of a faithful tracial state τ\tau of AA and two sequences p1,p2p^1, p^2 in AA peaking to states f1,f2f_1, f_2 such that, for i=1,2i = 1, 2 and every nn, p0i=1,τ(dni)>0,τ(pni)→0,τ(pn1)=τ(pn2).p^i_0 = 1, \qquad \tau(d^i_n) > 0, \qquad \tau(p^i_n) \to 0, \qquad \tau(p^1_n) = \tau(p^2_n).(1)✦ The reduced HNN extension H(A)H(A) of AA along bridge data is a C*C^*-algebra equipped with a unital **-homomorphism of AA into it, a stable unitary vv with vpn1v*=pn2v p^1_n v^* = p^2_n, and a trace extending τ\tau.

For a subset SS of AA, elements zkz_k of AA and a set TT of indices, C*(S,zT)C^*(S, z_T) is the closure of the **-subalgebra of AA generated by SS and the zkz_k with k∈Tk \in T.✦ In a tracial stage XX with elements vkv_k indexed by the ordinals, A[T]=C*(ι(M2∞),vT),A[k]=A[{j:j<k}].A[T] = C^*\bigl(\iota(M_{2^\infty}), v_T\bigr), \qquad A[k] = A[\{j : j < k\}].(2)

Let (τ,p1,p2)(\tau, p^1, p^2) be bridge data on AA peaking to states f1,f2f_1, f_2, and let SS be a closed **-subalgebra of AA that contains all the pnip^i_n. The restriction of the bridge data to SS consists of the restriction of τ\tau to SS and the same sequences p1,p2p^1, p^2, now viewed in SS, peaking to the restrictions of f1f_1 and f2f_2 to SS.✦

A chronological history of height δ\delta on a tracial stage XX, for an ordinal δ\delta, consists of a set of active ordinals below δ\delta and, for every ordinal kk, an element vkv_k of XX, a set DkD_k of ordinals, and bridge data on XX with the trace τ\tau of XX and sequences pk,1,pk,2p^{k,1}, p^{k,2} peaking to f1k,f2kf^k_1, f^k_2.✦ It is required that pnk,1=ι(pn)p^{k,1}_n = \iota(p_n) for all kk and nn, that vk=1v_k = 1 for inactive kk, that DkD_k is a countable set of ordinals below kk for every k<δk < \delta, and that every active kk satisfies, with the algebras of (2):

  1. pnk,i∈A[Dk]∩A[k]p^{k,i}_n \in A[D_k] \cap A[k] for i=1,2i = 1, 2 and every nn;

  2. A[k+1]A[k+1] is the reduced HNN extension of A[k]A[k] with stable unitary vkv_k: there is a **-isomorphism θ\theta of H(A[k])H(A[k]), formed with the data restricted to A[k]A[k], onto A[k+1]A[k+1] that is the identity on A[k]A[k], sends the stable unitary of H(A[k])H(A[k]) and its adjoint to vk*v_k^* and vkv_k, and has τ∘θ\tau \circ \theta equal to the trace of H(A[k])H(A[k]);✦

  3. f1k|A[k]≁f2k|A[k]f^k_1|_{A[k]} \not\sim f^k_2|_{A[k]}, these being the states to which pk,1p^{k,1} and pk,2p^{k,2} peak in A[k]A[k].✦

Chronological data of height δ\delta on XX are a chronological history of height δ\delta on XX with A[δ]=XA[\delta] = X.✦ A chronological stage is a tracial stage XX with an ordinal height δ\delta and chronological data of height δ\delta on XX.✦

For a set KK of cardinality at least 𝔠\mathfrak{c}, the list of pure states (ht)t∈K(h_t)_{t \in K} of a chronological stage XX is a chosen map of KK onto 𝒫(X)\mathcal{P}(X) when |𝒫(X)|≤𝔠|\mathcal{P}(X)| \le \mathfrak{c}, and the constant family ht=ωXh_t = \omega_X otherwise.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let δ\delta be an ordinal of cardinality |δ|≤𝔠|\delta| \le \mathfrak{c}.

  1. Let AA be a C*C^*-algebra and SS a subset of AA; for every ordinal kk let zkz_k be an element of AA, IkI_k a set of ordinals and QkQ_k bridge data on AA with trace τk\tau_k; and let some ordinals be singled out as active. Suppose that SS is separable, that IkI_k is a countable set of ordinals below kk for every k<δk < \delta, and that SS and the zkz_k, k<δk < \delta, generate AA as a C*C^*-algebra. Suppose also that the peaks of QkQ_k lie in C*(S,z{j:j<k})C^*(S, z_{\{j : j < k\}}) for every active kk, and that for every active k<δk < \delta they lie in C*(S,zIk)C^*(S, z_{I_k}), the restrictions to C*(S,z{j:j<k})C^*(S, z_{\{j : j < k\}}) of the two states peaked by QkQ_k are inequivalent, and there is a **-isomorphism θ\theta of H(C*(S,z{j:j<k}))H(C^*(S, z_{\{j : j < k\}})), formed with QkQ_k restricted to C*(S,z{j:j<k})C^*(S, z_{\{j : j < k\}}), onto C*(S,z{j:j≤k})C^*(S, z_{\{j : j \le k\}}) that is the identity on C*(S,z{j:j<k})C^*(S, z_{\{j : j < k\}}), sends the stable unitary and its adjoint to zk*z_k^* and zkz_k, and has τk∘θ\tau_k \circ \theta equal to the trace of the extension. Suppose finally that zk=1z_k = 1 for every k<δk < \delta that is not active, that C*(S,z∅)C^*(S, z_\emptyset) is simple, and that the traces τk\tau_k, k<δk < \delta, all coincide. Then |𝒫(A)|≤𝔠.|\mathcal{P}(A)| \le \mathfrak{c}.(3)✦

  2. If XX is a tracial stage with chronological data of height δ\delta, then |𝒫(X)|≤𝔠.|\mathcal{P}(X)| \le \mathfrak{c}.(4)✦

  3. If XX is a chronological stage of height δ\delta and KK is a set of cardinality at least 𝔠\mathfrak{c}, then the list of pure states (ht)t∈K(h_t)_{t \in K} of XX satisfies 𝒫(X)⊆{ht:t∈K}.\mathcal{P}(X) \subseteq \{h_t : t \in K\}.(5)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if |δ|≤𝔠|\delta| \le \mathfrak{c}, then XδX_\delta has at most 𝔠\mathfrak{c} pure states, XδX_\delta being the paper’s name for XX.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over the states and pure states of a C*C^*-algebra, over tracial stages with their copy of the CAR algebra, over chronological data and chronological stages, built from bridge data, the algebras A[T]A[T] and reduced HNN extensions, over the list of pure states of a stage and, in (a), over a C*C^*-algebra generated by a separable subset and elements zkz_k.

About these constructions the library proves that the vector states of e1⊗⋯⊗e1e_1 \otimes \cdots \otimes e_1 on the algebras M2n(ℂ)M_{2^n}(\mathbb{C}) are compatible with the embeddings a↦diag(a,a)a \mapsto \mathrm{diag}(a, a).✦ For a sequence (pn)(p_n) peaking to a state ff, it proves that the dnd_n are pairwise orthogonal projections and that, for every state τ\tau with τ(dn)>0\tau(d_n) > 0 for all nn, the states a↦τ(dnadn)/τ(dn)a \mapsto \tau(d_n a d_n)/\tau(d_n) converge to f(a)f(a) for every aa.✦