OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Pure states, excision, and peaking projections · §2

Lemma 2.4 [Decreasing excision]: For a unit vector ξ\xi of a representation π\pi, the positive contractions 1−e1-e, where e≥0e\ge 0, ∥e∥<1\|e\|<1 and π(e)ξ=0\pi(e)\xi=0, decrease and excise its vector functional

A decreasing net excises vector functionals of irreducible representations.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let BB be a C*-algebra and hh a pure state of BB. Excision of hh, in the sense of Akemann, Anderson and Pedersen, asks for positive contractions x∈Bx \in B with h(x)=1h(x) = 1 that cut every a∈Ba \in B down to nearly the scalar h(a)h(a), with ∥x(a−h(a)1)x∥\|x(a - h(a)1)x\| small. In its Gelfand-Naimark-Segal representation π\pi, which is irreducible, hh is given by a unit vector ξ\xi through h(a)=⟨π(a)ξ,ξ⟩h(a)=\langle \pi(a)\xi,\xi\rangle, and the lemma builds such contractions out of π\pi and ξ\xi.

Representations, States and the Excision Net

A state of BB is a continuous linear functional ff on BB of norm one such that f(a*a)f(a^*a) is real and nonnegative for every a∈Ba \in B.✦ A pure state of BB is a state of BB that is an extreme point of the convex set of states of BB.✦

A representation π\pi of BB on a Hilbert space HH is a *-homomorphism from BB into the algebra ℬ(H)\mathcal{B}(H) of bounded operators on HH, not necessarily unital. A representation π\pi of BB on HH is irreducible when it is nonzero and the only closed subspaces MM of HH with π(a)M⊆M\pi(a)M \subseteq M for every a∈Ba \in B are 00 and HH.✦

Fix a representation π\pi of BB on HH and a vector ξ∈H\xi \in H. The vector functional of ξ\xi is the linear functional hh on BB given by h(a)=⟨π(a)ξ,ξ⟩(a∈B).h(a) = \langle \pi(a)\xi, \xi \rangle \qquad (a \in B).(1) The null algebra NξN_\xi of ξ\xi is the subset of BB of the elements aa such that π(a)\pi(a) and π(a*)\pi(a^*) both vanish at ξ\xi: Nξ={a∈B:π(a)ξ=0 and π(a*)ξ=0}.N_\xi = \{\, a \in B : \pi(a)\xi = 0 \text{ and } \pi(a^*)\xi = 0 \,\}.(2)✦ The index set Λξ\Lambda_\xi of ξ\xi is the set of positive elements of NξN_\xi of norm less than one, ordered by e≤e′e \le e' when e′−ee' - e is positive: Λξ={e∈Nξ:e≥0,∥e∥<1}.\Lambda_\xi = \{\, e \in N_\xi : e \ge 0,\ \|e\| < 1 \,\}.(3)✦ The excision net of ξ\xi is the net (xe)e∈Λξ(x_e)_{e \in \Lambda_\xi} of elements of BB indexed by Λξ\Lambda_\xi and given by xe=1−e(e∈Λξ).x_e = 1 - e \qquad (e \in \Lambda_\xi).(4)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1 (Decreasing excision). Let π\pi be a representation of BB on a Hilbert space HH, let ξ∈H\xi \in H, and let (xe)e∈Λξ(x_e)_{e \in \Lambda_\xi} be the excision net of ξ\xi. For all ee and e′e' in Λξ\Lambda_\xi with e≤e′e \le e', xe≥0,x_e \ge 0,(5)✦ ∥xe∥≤1,\|x_e\| \le 1,(6)✦ xe′≤xe.x_{e'} \le x_e.(7)✦ If π(1)=1\pi(1) = 1, then for every e∈Λξe \in \Lambda_\xi π(xe)ξ=ξ,\pi(x_e)\xi = \xi,(8)✦ and if moreover ∥ξ∥=1\|\xi\| = 1, the vector functional hh of ξ\xi satisfies h(xe)=1.h(x_e) = 1.(9)✦ If π\pi is irreducible and ∥ξ∥=1\|\xi\| = 1, then for every a∈Ba \in B lime∈Λξ∥xe(a−h(a)1)xe∥=0,\lim_{e \in \Lambda_\xi} \bigl\| x_e \, (a - h(a)1) \, x_e \bigr\| = 0,(10)✦ Finally, if ff is a pure state of BB, a∈Ba \in B and ε>0\varepsilon > 0, there is an element x∈Bx \in B with x≥0,∥x∥≤1,f(x)=1,∥x(a−f(a)1)x∥<ε.x \ge 0, \qquad \|x\| \le 1, \qquad f(x) = 1, \qquad \bigl\| x \, (a - f(a)1) \, x \bigr\| < \varepsilon.(11)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a pure state hh of BB there is a decreasing net of positive contractions xλ∈Bx_\lambda \in B with h(xλ)=1h(x_\lambda) = 1, decreasing strongly to the minimal projection rhr_h in the bidual B**B^{**}, such that ∥xλ(a−h(a)1)xλ∥→0\|x_\lambda(a - h(a)1)x_\lambda\| \to 0 for every a∈Ba \in B, and moreover rharh=h(a)rhr_h a r_h = h(a) r_h for every a∈Ba \in B.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over a representation π\pi of BB on a Hilbert space HH, a vector ξ∈H\xi \in H, its null algebra NξN_\xi, the index set Λξ\Lambda_\xi and the excision net (4), with irreducibility of π\pi in (10), and over the states and pure states of BB in (11). The library proves that NξN_\xi is a *-subalgebra of BB.