OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. Recovery of the coefficients

Lemma 6.4: Global vanishing from a nonempty open set for smooth real potentials in dimension at least two

A finite-type Hessian system closes.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

In coefficient recovery, a scalar potential can satisfy a Hessian constraint with an unknown scalar remainder on the diagonal. The prescribed coefficients multiply the first derivatives of the potential.

Let EE and FF be real normed spaces. The constant directional derivative Dvf:E→FD_vf:E\to F of a function f:E→Ff:E\to F in a fixed direction v∈Ev\in E is the real Fréchet derivative applied to vv: Dvf(x)=dfx(v).D_vf(x)=df_x(v).(1)✦ For a finite index set II and a family of directions (ei)i∈I(e_i)_{i\in I} in EE, write ∂if=Deif\partial_i f=D_{e_i}f for the derivative in (1).

A finite-type Hessian system for scalar functions η,q:E→ℝ\eta,q:E\to\mathbb R with coefficients Bija:E→ℝB_{ij}^{a}:E\to\mathbb R is the system ∂j∂iη(x)=∑a∈IBija(x)∂aη(x)+δijq(x),i,j∈I,x∈E,\partial_j\partial_i\eta(x) =\sum_{a\in I}B_{ij}^{a}(x)\,\partial_a\eta(x)+\delta_{ij}q(x), \qquad i,j\in I,\quad x\in E,(2) where δij\delta_{ij} is the Kronecker delta. The function η\eta is the scalar potential and qq is the scalar Hessian remainder.

For s,i,b∈Is,i,b\in I, the gradient closure coefficients Csib:E→ℝC_{si}^{b}:E\to\mathbb R are the functions in (3): Csib(x)=∂iBsib(x)−∂sBiib(x)+∑a∈I(Bsia(x)Baib(x)−Biia(x)Basb(x)).\begin{split} C_{si}^{b}(x) ={}&\partial_iB_{si}^{b}(x)-\partial_sB_{ii}^{b}(x)\\ &+\sum_{a\in I}\bigl( B_{si}^{a}(x)B_{ai}^{b}(x) -B_{ii}^{a}(x)B_{as}^{b}(x)\bigr). \end{split}(3) The scalar closure coefficients dsi:E→ℝd_{si}:E\to\mathbb R are the functions in (4): dsi(x)=Bsii(x)−Biis(x).d_{si}(x)=B_{si}^{i}(x)-B_{ii}^{s}(x).(4)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let EE be a real normed space, II a finite index set, and (ei)i∈I(e_i)_{i\in I} a family of constant directions in EE. Let η\eta, qq, and every BijaB_{ij}^{a} be smooth real-valued functions on EE satisfying (2). For each pair i,s∈Ii,s\in I with i≠si\ne s, the scalar remainder satisfies ∂sq(x)=∑b∈ICsib(x)∂bη(x)+dsi(x)q(x),x∈E.\partial_s q(x) =\sum_{b\in I}C_{si}^{b}(x)\,\partial_b\eta(x)+d_{si}(x)q(x), \qquad x\in E.(5)✦ If, in addition, EE is finite-dimensional, (ei)i∈I(e_i)_{i\in I} is a basis with at least two vectors, and η\eta vanishes on a nonempty open set W⊂EW\subset E, then η(x)=q(x)=0,x∈E.\eta(x)=q(x)=0,\qquad x\in E.(6)✦

In the paper, the result reads: on a connected open set U⊂ℝnU\subset\mathbb R^n, n≥2n\ge2, let η\eta, qq, and BijaB_{ij}^{a} be smooth real- or complex-valued functions satisfying ∂i∂jη=∑aBija∂aη+δijq\partial_i\partial_j\eta=\sum_a B_{ij}^{a}\partial_a\eta+\delta_{ij}q; then (∇η,q)(\nabla\eta,q) satisfies a homogeneous first-order system with smooth coefficients, and if η\eta vanishes on a nonempty open subset of UU, then η=q=0\eta=q=0 throughout UU.

What Is Checked

The closure (5) is stated over smooth real scalar fields and finite families of constant directions in a real normed space, while the vanishing claim (6) is stated over a finite-dimensional real space with a basis of at least two vectors and a nonempty open set of vanishing.