OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. Recovery of the coefficients

Proposition 6.3: Equality of conic connections and restricted transport rows for smooth positive coefficients

Normalized holomorphic transport comparisons are the identity.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Coefficient recovery for isotropic elasticity involves transport matrices indexed by complex null directions. The comparison here concerns these matrices in the two affine charts of the null conic. The spatial domain is X=ℝ3X=\mathbb R^3, with coordinate basis e1,e2,e3e_1,e_2,e_3, and the direction space is ℂ3\mathbb C^3. The dot product is complex bilinear, without conjugation. A nonzero null direction θ\theta is a nonzero vector in the direction space satisfying θ⋅θ=0\theta\cdot\theta=0.✦ For a nonzero null direction θ\theta, the transverse space HθH_\theta and constrained transport fiber EθE_\theta are the subspace and direct sum defined in (1): Hθ={p∈ℂ3:θ⋅p=0},Eθ=Hθ⊕ℂ.H_\theta=\{p\in\mathbb C^3:\theta\cdot p=0\}, \qquad E_\theta=H_\theta\oplus\mathbb C.(1) The smooth coefficient algebra A=C∞(X;ℂ)A=C^\infty(X;\mathbb C) consists of infinitely differentiable complex functions.✦ A smooth real function is viewed in AA by the inclusion ℝ⊂ℂ\mathbb R\subset\mathbb C✦; for a nowhere zero f∈Af\in A, its smooth reciprocal is the function x↦f(x)−1x\mapsto f(x)^{-1}.✦ For real Lamé coefficients λ,μ\lambda,\mu with μ>0\mu>0 and 3λ+2μ>03\lambda+2\mu>0, write m=μm=\mu, k=λ+μk=\lambda+\mu and ℓ=λ+2μ\ell=\lambda+2\mu. The positive square root of a smooth positive mm is the function r(x)=m(x)r(x)=\sqrt{m(x)}, viewed in AA.✦

For a function ff between real normed spaces, a point xx in its domain and a vector vv in its domain space, the constant directional derivative Dvf(x)D_vf(x) is the vector in the codomain of ff given by Dvf(x)=dfx(v)D_vf(x)=\mathrm df_x(v), where dfx\mathrm df_x is the real differential of ff at xx.✦ On XX, the coordinate derivative ∂i\partial_i, gradient, Hessian and complex directional derivative have the formulas ∂if=Deif,(∇f)i=∂if,(∇2f)ij=∂j∂if,Dθf=∑i=13θi∂if.\partial_i f=D_{e_i}f,\qquad (\nabla f)_i=\partial_i f,\qquad (\nabla^2 f)_{ij}=\partial_j\partial_i f,\qquad D_\theta f=\sum_{i=1}^3\theta_i\partial_i f.(2) For a complex algebra with three coordinate derivations, the last formula in (2) also defines directional differentiation.✦ For a matrix with entries in AA, DθD_\theta acts entry by entry.✦

Transport Matrices and Comparison

Take k,r∈Ak,r\in A with rr, kk and k+r2k+r^2 nowhere zero; the logarithmic gradient Γ\Gamma is a smooth vector field, its directional contraction gθg_\theta is a smooth scalar field, and the transport coefficients 𝖳[k,r]\mathsf T[k,r] and 𝖰[k,r]\mathsf Q[k,r] are respectively a smooth scalar field and a smooth vector field for each direction θ\theta, given by (3): Γi=2∂irr,gθ=θ⋅Γ,𝖳[k,r](θ)=Dθkk−Dθ(k+r2)k+r2,𝖰[k,r](θ)i=12[(r2Dθk(k+r2)k−12gθ)Γi−r2k+r2DθΓi].\begin{aligned} \Gamma_i&=\frac{2\partial_i r}{r},& g_\theta&=\theta\cdot\Gamma,\\ \mathsf T[k,r](\theta) &=\frac{D_\theta k}{k}-\frac{D_\theta(k+r^2)}{k+r^2},\\ \mathsf Q[k,r](\theta)_i &=\frac12\left[ \left(\frac{r^2D_\theta k}{(k+r^2)k}-\frac12g_\theta\right)\Gamma_i -\frac{r^2}{k+r^2}D_\theta\Gamma_i\right]. \end{aligned}(3) For complex homogeneous coordinates z0,z1z_0,z_1, the homogeneous conic parametrization Θ\Theta and its frame vectors h1,h2h_1,h_2 are Θ(z0,z1)=(z02−z12,i(z02+z12),2z0z1),h1(z0,z1)=(z0,iz0,z1),h2(z0,z1)=(−z1,iz1,z0).\begin{aligned} \Theta(z_0,z_1)&=(z_0^2-z_1^2,\,i(z_0^2+z_1^2),\,2z_0z_1),\\ h_1(z_0,z_1)&=(z_0,iz_0,z_1),& h_2(z_0,z_1)&=(-z_1,iz_1,z_0). \end{aligned}(4) The two charts use the homogeneous coordinates in (5), with chart index b∈{0,∞}b\in\{0,\infty\} and coordinate z∈ℂz\in\mathbb C; their directions are obtained from (4): (z0,0(z),z0,1(z))=(1,z),(z∞,0(z),z∞,1(z))=(z,1),θb(z)=Θ(zb,0(z),zb,1(z)).(z_{0,0}(z),z_{0,1}(z))=(1,z),\qquad (z_{\infty,0}(z),z_{\infty,1}(z))=(z,1),\qquad \theta_b(z)=\Theta(z_{b,0}(z),z_{b,1}(z)).(5) For t∈At\in A and V∈A3V\in A^3, the conic transport matrix CbC_b and the physical conic transport matrix 𝖬b[k,r]\mathsf M_b[k,r] are defined by (6), where hjh_j is evaluated at the chart’s homogeneous coordinates: Cb(z;t,V)=(00zb,0(z)00zb,1(z)h1⋅Vh2⋅Vt),𝖬b[k,r](z)=Cb(z;𝖳[k,r](θb(z)),𝖰[k,r](θb(z))).\begin{aligned} C_b(z;t,V)&= \begin{pmatrix} 0&0&z_{b,0}(z)\\ 0&0&z_{b,1}(z)\\ h_1\cdot V&h_2\cdot V&t \end{pmatrix},\\ \mathsf M_b[k,r](z) &=C_b\bigl(z;\mathsf T[k,r](\theta_b(z)), \mathsf Q[k,r](\theta_b(z))\bigr). \end{aligned}(6)

The normal form connection M(q,t)M(q,t) associated with row functions q:X×ℂ→ℂ2q:X\times\mathbb C\to\mathbb C^2 and t:X×ℂ→ℂt:X\times\mathbb C\to\mathbb C is the complex 3×33\times3 matrix valued function on X×ℂX\times\mathbb C given in (7): M(q,t)(x,z)=(00100zq1(x,z)q2(x,z)t(x,z)).M(q,t)(x,z)= \begin{pmatrix}0&0&1\\0&0&z\\q_1(x,z)&q_2(x,z)&t(x,z)\end{pmatrix}.(7) A holomorphic comparison is a pair G0,G∞:X×ℂ→ℂ3×3G_0,G_\infty:X\times\mathbb C\to\mathbb C^{3\times3} whose entries are entire in the chart coordinate at every xx and satisfy the transition law (8): G0(x,z)=S(z)−1G∞(x,z−1)S(z),S(z)=diag⁡(z,z,1),z≠0.G_0(x,z)=S(z)^{-1}G_\infty(x,z^{-1})S(z),\qquad S(z)=\operatorname{diag}(z,z,1),\qquad z\ne0.(8)✦ For two normal form connections Mj=M(qj,tj)M_j=M(q_j,t_j), the gauge transport equation is (9), with θ0(z)\theta_0(z) as in (5): Dθ0(z)G0(x,z)=M2(x,z)G0(x,z)−G0(x,z)M1(x,z).D_{\theta_0(z)}G_0(x,z) =M_2(x,z)G_0(x,z)-G_0(x,z)M_1(x,z).(9)✦

The recovery transport coefficient TT and vector QQ for real coefficient fields m,km,k on XX are defined through the real matrix 𝒬[m,k](x)∈ℝ3×3\mathcal Q[m,k](x)\in\mathbb R^{3\times3} in (10), where the coefficients and derivatives are evaluated at xx: T[m,k](x,θ)=Dθlog⁡kk+m(x),𝒬[m,k]ij=12[(mk+m∂jlogk−12∂jlogm)∂ilogm−mk+m∂j∂ilogm],Q[m,k](x,θ)=𝒬[m,k](x)θ.\begin{aligned} T[m,k](x,\theta)&=D_\theta\log\frac{k}{k+m}(x),\\ \mathcal Q[m,k]_{ij} &=\frac12\left[ \left(\frac{m}{k+m}\partial_j\log k-\frac12\partial_j\log m\right) \partial_i\log m -\frac{m}{k+m}\partial_j\partial_i\log m\right],\\ Q[m,k](x,\theta)&=\mathcal Q[m,k](x)\theta. \end{aligned}(10) The restricted transport row consists of T[m,k](x,θ)T[m,k](x,\theta) and the linear functional p↦Q[m,k](x,θ)⋅pp\mapsto Q[m,k](x,\theta)\cdot p on HθH_\theta.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let G0,G∞G_0,G_\infty be a holomorphic comparison satisfying (9). Suppose every entry of G0(⋅,z)G_0(\,\cdot\,,z) is real differentiable for each zz, and suppose G0(x0,0)=IG_0(x_0,0)=I at some x0∈Xx_0\in X. Then (11) and (12) hold for all x∈Xx\in X and z,w∈ℂz,w\in\mathbb C: G0(x,z)=I,G∞(x,w)=I.G_0(x,z)=I,\qquad G_\infty(x,w)=I.(11)✦ M1(x,z)=M2(x,z).M_1(x,z)=M_2(x,z).(12)✦

Let kj,rj∈Ak_j,r_j\in A, j=1,2j=1,2, with rjr_j, kjk_j and kj+rj2k_j+r_j^2 nowhere zero. Let K⊂XK\subset X be compact, let χ∈A\chi\in A have compact support and equal 11 on KK, and choose x0∈X\Kx_0\in X\setminus K. Suppose k1=k2k_1=k_2 and r1=r2r_1=r_2 on X\KX\setminus K. For each chart and coordinate, let 𝖦b(z)∈A3×3\mathsf G_b(z)\in A^{3\times3} have every entry of 𝖦b(z)−I\mathsf G_b(z)-I supported in KK, and satisfy (13): Dθb(z)𝖦b(z)=𝖬b[k2,r2](z)𝖦b(z)−𝖦b(z)𝖬b[k1,r1](z).D_{\theta_b(z)}\mathsf G_b(z) =\mathsf M_b[k_2,r_2](z)\mathsf G_b(z) -\mathsf G_b(z)\mathsf M_b[k_1,r_1](z).(13) Then (14) holds for both charts and every z∈ℂz\in\mathbb C: 𝖬b[k1,r1](z)=𝖬b[k2,r2](z).\mathsf M_b[k_1,r_1](z)=\mathsf M_b[k_2,r_2](z).(14)✦

Let m1,k1,m2,k2m_1,k_1,m_2,k_2 be smooth strictly positive real functions on XX. Suppose the physical conic matrices 𝖬b[k1,m1](z)\mathsf M_b[k_1,\sqrt{m_1}](z) and 𝖬b[k2,m2](z)\mathsf M_b[k_2,\sqrt{m_2}](z) agree for both charts and all zz. The coefficient pairs then have equal restricted transports as in (15), for every x∈Xx\in X, every nonzero null θ\theta and every p∈Hθp\in H_\theta: T[m1,k1](x,θ)=T[m2,k2](x,θ),Q[m1,k1](x,θ)⋅p=Q[m2,k2](x,θ)⋅p.\begin{aligned} T[m_1,k_1](x,\theta)&=T[m_2,k_2](x,\theta),\\ Q[m_1,k_1](x,\theta)\cdot p&=Q[m_2,k_2](x,\theta)\cdot p. \end{aligned}(15)✦

In the paper, the result reads: the comparison endomorphism from Proposition 5.3 is G=IG=I, and consequently the transport endomorphisms satisfy M1,θ=M2,θM_{1,\theta}=M_{2,\theta} on EθE_\theta for every x∈ℝ3x\in\mathbb R^3 and every nonzero null θ\theta.

What Is Checked

The claims are stated over holomorphic comparisons with the transition law (8) and the normalization at one spatial point, over smooth physical comparisons with compactly supported deviation from the identity, and over smooth positive real coefficient pairs for the restricted transport rows. Coordinate differentiation on AA is complex linear and satisfies the Leibniz rule. For smooth positive m,km,k, the positive square root r=mr=\sqrt m is nowhere zero✦, and k+r2k+r^2 is nowhere zero.✦