OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. Recovery of the coefficients

§6 (completion of Theorem 1.1): coefficient recovery from equal restricted transports: From restricted transports with local agreement, or from variational boundary data for Lamé pairs with a common exterior

Global recovery of the elasticity coefficients.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The inverse elasticity problem asks whether two coefficient pairs with the same boundary displacement and traction data can differ in the interior. The physical and recovery space is X=ℝ3X=\mathbb R^3, and the displacement space is V=XV=X.✦ The derived coefficients m,k,ℓm,k,\ell of a real Lamé pair (λ,μ)(\lambda,\mu) are defined by (1). m=μ,k=λ+μ,ℓ=λ+2μ=k+m.m=\mu,\qquad k=\lambda+\mu,\qquad \ell=\lambda+2\mu=k+m.(1)

The smooth coefficient space C∞(X;ℂ)C^\infty(X;\mathbb C) consists of infinitely differentiable complex-valued functions.✦ The complexification of a real smooth coefficient ff on XX is the function x↦f(x)+0ix\mapsto f(x)+0i in C∞(X;ℂ)C^\infty(X;\mathbb C).✦ A smooth coefficient ff is constant outside a compact set if f−cf-c has compact support for some c∈ℂc\in\mathbb C.✦

The vectors e1,e2,e3e_1,e_2,e_3 are the standard coordinate unit vectors of XX. The constant directional derivative DvfD_vf of a map between real normed spaces is its real Fréchet derivative applied to the fixed direction vv.✦ Coordinate derivatives, and the gradient and Hessian of a real scalar function, are given in (2). Dvf(x)=dfx(v),∂if=Deif,(∇f)i=Deif,(∇2f)ij=Dej(Deif).\begin{aligned} D_vf(x)&=df_x(v),& \partial_i f&=D_{e_i}f,\\ (\nabla f)_i&=D_{e_i}f,& (\nabla^2f)_{ij}&=D_{e_j}(D_{e_i}f). \end{aligned}(2)

Variational Boundary Data

For a set Ω⊂X\Omega\subset X, the square-integrable jet space 𝒥(Ω)\mathcal J(\Omega) is the product in (3), with Lebesgue measure restricted to Ω\Omega. 𝒥(Ω)=L2(Ω;V)×∏i=13L2(Ω;V).\mathcal J(\Omega) =L^2(\Omega;V)\times\prod_{i=1}^3 L^2(\Omega;V).(3) A smooth jet J∈𝒥(Ω)J\in\mathcal J(\Omega) is an element represented by a globally smooth field u:X→Vu:X\to V and its coordinate derivatives, all square integrable on Ω\Omega, with functions identified almost everywhere. A compactly supported smooth jet J∈𝒥(Ω)J\in\mathcal J(\Omega) is a smooth jet represented by a globally smooth field u:X→Vu:X\to V whose closed support is compact and contained in Ω\Omega.✦

The Sobolev space H1(Ω;V)H^1(\Omega;V) is the closure of the smooth jets in 𝒥(Ω)\mathcal J(\Omega).✦ A displacement u∈H1(Ω;V)u\in H^1(\Omega;V) has zero boundary trace if it belongs to the closure of the compactly supported smooth jets.✦ Two displacements u,v∈H1(Ω;V)u,v\in H^1(\Omega;V) have the same boundary trace if their difference belongs to the closure in 𝒥(Ω)\mathcal J(\Omega) of the compactly supported smooth jets.✦ The variational boundary data space ℬ(Ω)\mathcal B(\Omega) is the quotient of H1(Ω;V)H^1(\Omega;V) by equality of boundary traces; the boundary trace of a displacement u∈H1(Ω;V)u\in H^1(\Omega;V) is its quotient class γu=[u]\gamma u=[u].

The derivative components of a displacement jet define its divergence and linearized strain by (4). div⁡u=∑i=13∂iui,ε(u)ij=∂jui+∂iuj2.\operatorname{div}u=\sum_{i=1}^3\partial_i u_i, \qquad \varepsilon(u)_{ij}=\frac{\partial_j u_i+\partial_i u_j}{2}.(4) The elastic energy pairing ℰλ,μ\mathcal E_{\lambda,\mu} on H1(Ω;V)H^1(\Omega;V) is the real bilinear integral in (5). ℰλ,μ(u,v)=∫Ω(λdivudivv+2μ∑i,j=13ε(u)ijε(v)ij)dx.\mathcal E_{\lambda,\mu}(u,v) =\int_\Omega\left( \lambda\,\operatorname{div}u\,\operatorname{div}v +2\mu\sum_{i,j=1}^3\varepsilon(u)_{ij}\varepsilon(v)_{ij} \right)\,dx.(5)✦ A weak elastic equilibrium for (λ,μ)(\lambda,\mu) is a displacement u∈H1(Ω;V)u\in H^1(\Omega;V) such that ℰλ,μ(u,v)=0\mathcal E_{\lambda,\mu}(u,v)=0 for every displacement vv with zero boundary trace.✦

The Dirichlet displacement uf∈H1(Ω;V)u_f\in H^1(\Omega;V) associated with f∈ℬ(Ω)f\in\mathcal B(\Omega) is a selected displacement which, when the Dirichlet problem is solvable, is a weak elastic equilibrium with trace ff.✦ For boundary data f,g∈ℬ(Ω)f,g\in\mathcal B(\Omega), the displacement to traction pairing DN⁡λ,μ\operatorname{DN}_{\lambda,\mu} is the real bilinear pairing defined in (6), where vg∈H1(Ω;V)v_g\in H^1(\Omega;V) is a representative of gg. DN⁡λ,μ(f,g)=ℰλ,μ(uf,vg),γvg=g.\operatorname{DN}_{\lambda,\mu}(f,g) =\mathcal E_{\lambda,\mu}(u_f,v_g),\qquad \gamma v_g=g.(6)✦

Restricted Transports

The complex direction space ℂ3\mathbb C^3 consists of ordered triples of complex numbers, with bilinear product θ⋅p=∑i=13θipi\theta\cdot p=\sum_{i=1}^3\theta_i p_i without complex conjugation.✦ A vector v∈ℂ3v\in\mathbb C^3 is null if v⋅v=0v\cdot v=0; a null direction θ∈ℂ3\theta\in\mathbb C^3 is a nonzero null vector.✦ The transverse space HθH_\theta for a null direction θ\theta is the subspace of ℂ3\mathbb C^3 defined by Hθ={p∈ℂ3:θ⋅p=0}H_\theta=\{p\in\mathbb C^3:\theta\cdot p=0\}. For a direction θ∈ℂ3\theta\in\mathbb C^3, the complex directional derivative DθfD_\theta f of a real scalar function ff on XX is the complex-valued function defined by Dθf=θ⋅∇fD_\theta f=\theta\cdot\nabla f.✦

For real coefficient functions m,km,k on XX, the scalar recovery transport coefficient T[m,k]T[m,k] and the real transport coefficient matrix 𝒬[m,k](x)∈ℝ3×3\mathcal Q[m,k](x)\in\mathbb R^{3\times3} are defined by (7); all coefficients and derivatives on the right are evaluated at xx. T[m,k](x,θ)=Dθlog⁡kk+m(x),𝒬[m,k]ij(x)=12[(mk+m∂jlogk−12∂jlogm)∂ilogm−mk+m(∇2logm)ij].\begin{aligned} T[m,k](x,\theta) &=D_\theta\log\frac{k}{k+m}(x),\\ \mathcal Q[m,k]_{ij}(x) &=\frac12\left[ \left(\frac{m}{k+m}\,\partial_j\log k -\frac12\,\partial_j\log m\right)\partial_i\log m -\frac{m}{k+m}\,(\nabla^2\log m)_{ij} \right]. \end{aligned}(7) The recovery transport vector Q[m,k](x,θ)∈ℂ3Q[m,k](x,\theta)\in\mathbb C^3 is the matrix product 𝒬[m,k](x)θ\mathcal Q[m,k](x)\theta, viewing the real matrix as a complex matrix.✦

For two coefficient pairs (mj,kj)(m_j,k_j), write Tj=T[mj,kj]T_j=T[m_j,k_j] and Qj=Q[mj,kj]Q_j=Q[m_j,k_j]. Equality of their restricted transports is the pointwise condition (8), at every x∈Xx\in X and every null direction θ\theta. T1(x,θ)=T2(x,θ),(Q1(x,θ)−Q2(x,θ))⋅p=0for every p∈Hθ.T_1(x,\theta)=T_2(x,\theta),\qquad \bigl(Q_1(x,\theta)-Q_2(x,\theta)\bigr)\cdot p=0 \quad\text{for every }p\in H_\theta.(8)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let I3I_3 denote the identity matrix on ℂ3\mathbb C^3, and let K∈ℂ3×3K\in\mathbb C^{3\times3} be a complex matrix such that (Kθ)⋅p=0(K\theta)\cdot p=0 for every null direction θ\theta and every p∈Hθp\in H_\theta. Then K=κI3for some κ∈ℂ.K=\kappa I_3\qquad\text{for some }\kappa\in\mathbb C.(9)✦

Let m1,k1,m2,k2m_1,k_1,m_2,k_2 be strictly positive smooth real functions on XX. Suppose their restricted transports are equal and the two coefficient pairs agree on a nonempty open set W⊂XW\subset X. Then m1=m2,k1=k2on X.m_1=m_2,\qquad k_1=k_2\qquad\text{on }X.(10)✦

Let Ω⊂X\Omega\subset X be bounded and open. Let (λj,μj)(\lambda_j,\mu_j), j=1,2j=1,2, be smooth real Lamé pairs satisfying μj>0\mu_j>0 and 3λj+2μj>03\lambda_j+2\mu_j>0 throughout XX, with each coefficient constant outside a compact set. Suppose the pairs agree on X\ΩX\setminus\Omega and their displacement to traction pairings agree on ℬ(Ω)×ℬ(Ω)\mathcal B(\Omega)\times\mathcal B(\Omega). Then λ1=λ2,μ1=μ2on X.\lambda_1=\lambda_2,\qquad \mu_1=\mu_2\qquad\text{on }X.(11)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for common extended admissible pairs, equality of the restricted TT and QQ determines k1/ℓ1=k2/ℓ2k_1/\ell_1=k_2/\ell_2 and reduces η=log⁡m1−log⁡m2\eta=\log m_1-\log m_2 to ∇2η=B(x)∇η+qI3\nabla^2\eta=B(x)\nabla\eta+qI_3 with smooth coefficients BB and qq, while its exterior zero value and Lemma 6.4 give m1=m2m_1=m_2 and k1=k2k_1=k_2, hence equality of both original Lamé moduli on Ω\Omega.

What Is Checked

The objects in (9) are arbitrary complex matrices and the bilinear null cone, while (10) is stated for the concrete TT and QQ of smooth positive real coefficient functions. The boundary comparison (11) uses the variational trace quotient of H1(Ω;V)H^1(\Omega;V) for bounded open Ω\Omega and smooth Lamé pairs with common exterior values and coefficients constant outside compact sets. The smooth coefficient space is a complex algebra under pointwise operations: it contains the constants and is closed under sums and products.✦