OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. The image of the leading projection

Proposition 5.5 [The leading Ihara bracket]: The ambient Ihara bracket on homogeneous antisymmetric inputs with positive count over 𝔽2\mathbb F_2

Leading projections recover an ordinary bracket.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

In the free associative algebra on the letters x,yx,y in characteristic two, the quadratic alphabet A,C,BA,C,B separates the square x2x^2 and the commutator [x,y][x,y] from the letter yy. The count of BB letters gives another filtration besides ordinary weight, and the ambient Ihara bracket involves derivations acting on this presentation.

For a commutative ring kk and an alphabet Σ\Sigma, let 𝔣k(Σ)\mathfrak f_k(\Sigma) be the ordinary free Lie algebra on Σ\Sigma, and let 𝒜k(Σ)=k⟨Σ⟩\mathcal A_k(\Sigma)=k\langle\Sigma\rangle be the free associative algebra. An associative word is the monomial with coefficient one on a word in Σ\Sigma; a letter gives its associative generator. The universal associative embedding ι:𝔣k(Σ)→𝒜k(Σ)\iota:\mathfrak f_k(\Sigma)\to\mathcal A_k(\Sigma) sends each free generator to its associative generator.✦ The ordinary bracket in an associative algebra is [u,v]=uv−vu[u,v]=uv-vu. Associative evaluation extends an assignment of letters to an algebra homomorphism; Lie evaluation extends an assignment to a Lie homomorphism. In particular, ψ(a,b)\psi(a,b) denotes evaluation of a two-generator Lie polynomial at a,ba,b.

For a free Lie algebra, an assignment ff of elements of that algebra to its free generators determines the derivation ∂f\partial_f of that algebra satisfying ∂f(a)=f(a)\partial_f(a)=f(a).✦ A first-order Lie jet in a Lie algebra MM, written (u,v)∈M×M(u,v)\in M\times M, is a pair consisting of a base point and a velocity, with the bracket in (1); for an assignment f:Σ→𝔣k(Σ)f:\Sigma\to\mathfrak f_k(\Sigma), the Lie jet lift is the Lie homomorphism from 𝔣k(Σ)\mathfrak f_k(\Sigma) to its Lie algebra of first-order jets sending each free generator aa to (a,f(a))(a,f(a)), and its velocity is ∂f\partial_f. For an associative algebra, the dual-number substitution and its infinitesimal coefficient define the associative derivation extension ∂fass\partial_f^{\mathrm{ass}} in the same display: [(u,v),(u′,v′)]=([u,u′],[u,v′]+[v,u′]),a↦a+εf(a),ε2=0,u↦u+ε∂fass(u).\begin{aligned} [(u,v),(u',v')]&=([u,u'],[u,v']+[v,u']),\\ a&\longmapsto a+\varepsilon f(a),\qquad \varepsilon^2=0,\\ u&\longmapsto u+\varepsilon\partial_f^{\mathrm{ass}}(u). \end{aligned}(1)

Set k=𝔽2k=\mathbb F_2, the field of integers modulo two, and write 𝔣xy=𝔣k(x,y)\mathfrak f_{xy}=\mathfrak f_k(x,y) for the free Lie algebra on x,yx,y. The antisymmetry defect of ψ∈𝔣xy\psi\in\mathfrak f_{xy} is ψ(x,y)+ψ(y,x)\psi(x,y)+\psi(y,x); a polynomial ψ\psi in 𝔣xy\mathfrak f_{xy} is antisymmetric when its antisymmetry defect vanishes.✦ For ψ,ϕ∈𝔣xy\psi,\phi\in\mathfrak f_{xy}, the Ihara derivation DψD_\psi and the ambient Ihara bracket are defined by (2): Dψ(x)=0,Dψ(y)=[y,ψ],{ψ,ϕ}=Dψ(ϕ)−Dϕ(ψ)+[ψ,ϕ].\begin{aligned} D_\psi(x)&=0,&D_\psi(y)&=[y,\psi],\\ \{\psi,\phi\}&=D_\psi(\phi)-D_\phi(\psi)+[\psi,\phi]. \end{aligned}(2)

The Quadratic Presentation

Write 𝔣ACB=𝔣k(A,C,B)\mathfrak f_{ACB}=\mathfrak f_k(A,C,B) and 𝒮=𝒜k(A,C,B)\mathcal S=\mathcal A_k(A,C,B). The quadratic substitution Q:𝒮→𝒜k(x,y)Q:\mathcal S\to\mathcal A_k(x,y) is the algebra homomorphism prescribed in (3), and quadratic Lie evaluation ρ\rho is the Lie homomorphism from 𝔣ACB\mathfrak f_{ACB} to 𝒜k(x,y)\mathcal A_k(x,y) given by the composition in that display: Q(A)=x2,Q(C)=[x,y],Q(B)=y,ρ=Q∘ι.Q(A)=x^2,\qquad Q(C)=[x,y],\qquad Q(B)=y, \qquad \rho=Q\circ\iota.(3) The weights of A,C,BA,C,B are 2,2,12,2,1. Their BB-count weights are instead b(A)=b(C)=0b(A)=b(C)=0 and b(B)=1b(B)=1.✦ This count differs from ordinary yy-depth: CC has yy-depth one and BB-count zero.

A bracketed word tt on an alphabet Σ\Sigma is a letter of Σ\Sigma or a bracket of two bracketed words on Σ\Sigma.✦ The evaluation of a bracketed word tt, denoted by tevt^{\mathrm{ev}}, replaces each letter by its free generator and each bracketing by the ordinary Lie bracket; its underlying word lists the letters from left to right. For letter weights ww, the weight dwd_w of a word or bracketed word is the sum of its letter weights. The homogeneous associative space 𝒜w,n\mathcal A_{w,n} and filtration 𝒜w≥n\mathcal A_w^{\ge n} are the word spans in (4); the homogeneous Lie space 𝔣w,n\mathfrak f_{w,n} is the span of bracket evaluations of weight nn: 𝒜w,n=span⁡k{u:dw(u)=n},𝒜w≥n=span⁡k{u:dw(u)≥n},𝔣w,n=span⁡k{tev:dw(t)=n}.\begin{aligned} \mathcal A_{w,n}&=\operatorname{span}_k\{u:d_w(u)=n\},& \mathcal A_w^{\ge n}&=\operatorname{span}_k\{u:d_w(u)\ge n\},\\ \mathfrak f_{w,n}&=\operatorname{span}_k\{t^{\mathrm{ev}}:d_w(t)=n\}. \end{aligned}(4) A word-support projection on a free associative algebra is the linear projection that retains precisely the words satisfying a prescribed condition. For a Lie polynomial pp, denote by πw,nass\pi_{w,n}^{\mathrm{ass}} the projection retaining words of weight nn, and by πw,nLiep\pi_{w,n}^{\mathrm{Lie}}p the homogeneous Lie component specified by (5): πw,nLiep∈𝔣w,n,ι(πw,nLiep)=πw,nass(ιp).\pi_{w,n}^{\mathrm{Lie}}p\in\mathfrak f_{w,n},\qquad \iota(\pi_{w,n}^{\mathrm{Lie}}p) =\pi_{w,n}^{\mathrm{ass}}(\iota p).(5) For BB-count, put Fr𝒮=𝒮b≥rF^r\mathcal S=\mathcal S_b^{\ge r} and abbreviate the count projections by πrass\pi_r^{\mathrm{ass}} and πrLie\pi_r^{\mathrm{Lie}}. Ordinary weight on x,yx,y assigns weight one to each letter.

Let 𝔣CB=𝔣k(C,B)\mathfrak f_{CB}=\mathfrak f_k(C,B) and 𝒯=k⟨C,B⟩\mathcal T=k\langle C,B\rangle. The AA-deletion map e:𝔣ACB→𝔣CBe:\mathfrak f_{ACB}\to\mathfrak f_{CB} is the Lie homomorphism sending AA to zero and preserving C,BC,B.✦ For h∈𝒯h\in\mathcal T, the erasing and shifting substitution Eh:𝒮→𝒯E_h:\mathcal S\to\mathcal T is the algebra homomorphism in (6); write E=E0E=E_0. The leading Lie projection λr:𝔣ACB→𝔣CB\lambda_r:\mathfrak f_{ACB}\to\mathfrak f_{CB} is defined there as well: Eh(A)=0,Eh(C)=C,Eh(B)=B+h,λr(p)=e(πrLiep).E_h(A)=0,\qquad E_h(C)=C,\qquad E_h(B)=B+h, \qquad \lambda_r(p)=e(\pi_r^{\mathrm{Lie}}p).(6)

The linear residual action sends BB to CC and annihilates A,CA,C; the quadratic residual action sends CC to [A,B][A,B] and annihilates A,BA,B. The associative residual derivation δass\delta^{\mathrm{ass}} on 𝒮\mathcal S is the associative derivation that annihilates AA, sends BB to CC and sends CC to [A,B][A,B]. The residual Lie derivation δLie\delta^{\mathrm{Lie}} on 𝔣ACB\mathfrak f_{ACB} is the Lie derivation that annihilates AA, sends BB to CC and sends CC to [A,B][A,B]. For p∈𝔣ACBp\in\mathfrak f_{ACB}, the leading Ihara Lie derivation 𝒟pLie\mathscr D_p^{\mathrm{Lie}} is the free derivation given in (7). For P∈𝒮P\in\mathcal S, its associative counterpart 𝒟Pass\mathscr D_P^{\mathrm{ass}} is the associative derivation with the same formulas, using PP and δass\delta^{\mathrm{ass}}: δLie(A)=0,δLie(B)=C,δLie(C)=[A,B],𝒟pLie(A)=0,𝒟pLie(B)=[B,p],𝒟pLie(C)=[C,p]+[B,δLiep].\begin{aligned} \delta^{\mathrm{Lie}}(A)&=0,& \delta^{\mathrm{Lie}}(B)&=C,& \delta^{\mathrm{Lie}}(C)&=[A,B],\\ \mathscr D_p^{\mathrm{Lie}}(A)&=0,& \mathscr D_p^{\mathrm{Lie}}(B)&=[B,p],& \mathscr D_p^{\mathrm{Lie}}(C)&=[C,p]+[B,\delta^{\mathrm{Lie}}p]. \end{aligned}(7) For Lie polynomials p,qp,q in 𝔣ACB\mathfrak f_{ACB} and associative polynomials P,Q′P,Q' in 𝒮\mathcal S, the leading Lie Ihara bracket ℐLie\mathcal I^{\mathrm{Lie}} and associative leading Ihara bracket ℐass\mathcal I^{\mathrm{ass}} are defined by (8): ℐLie(p,q)=𝒟pLieq−𝒟qLiep+[p,q],ℐass(P,Q′)=𝒟PassQ′−𝒟Q′assP+[P,Q′].\begin{aligned} \mathcal I^{\mathrm{Lie}}(p,q) &=\mathscr D_p^{\mathrm{Lie}}q-\mathscr D_q^{\mathrm{Lie}}p+[p,q],\\ \mathcal I^{\mathrm{ass}}(P,Q') &=\mathscr D_P^{\mathrm{ass}}Q'-\mathscr D_{Q'}^{\mathrm{ass}}P+[P,Q']. \end{aligned}(8)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let ψ,ϕ∈𝔣xy\psi,\phi\in\mathfrak f_{xy} and p,q∈𝔣ACBp,q\in\mathfrak f_{ACB} satisfy ρ(p)=ιψ\rho(p)=\iota\psi and ρ(q)=ιϕ\rho(q)=\iota\phi. The quadratic evaluations satisfy (9): ρ(ℐLie(p,q))=ι{ψ,ϕ}.\rho\bigl(\mathcal I^{\mathrm{Lie}}(p,q)\bigr) =\iota\{\psi,\phi\}.(9)✦ Suppose in addition that ψ,ϕ\psi,\phi are antisymmetric, that their associative images are homogeneous of ordinary weights n,m>1n,m>1, and that r,sr,s are positive integers with ιp∈Fr𝒮\iota p\in F^r\mathcal S and ιq∈Fs𝒮\iota q\in F^s\mathcal S. The leading Ihara bracket satisfies (10): ℐass(ιp,ιq)∈Fr+s𝒮,E(πr+sassℐass(ιp,ιq))=[ιλr(p),ιλs(q)].\begin{aligned} \mathcal I^{\mathrm{ass}}(\iota p,\iota q)&\in F^{r+s}\mathcal S,\\ E\bigl(\pi_{r+s}^{\mathrm{ass}} \mathcal I^{\mathrm{ass}}(\iota p,\iota q)\bigr) &=[\iota\lambda_r(p),\iota\lambda_s(q)]. \end{aligned}(10)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for ψ∈FrL¯n\psi\in F^r\overline L_n and ϕ∈FsL¯n′\phi\in F^s\overline L_{n'} in the count filtration of its homogeneous solution spaces, with n,n′>2n,n'>2 and r,s≥1r,s\ge1, and projected leading parts f,gf,g, the ambient Ihara bracket has count at least r+sr+s in its A,C,BA,C,B presentation and its count-(r+s)(r+s) component projects to [f,g][f,g], without prior bracket closure of the solution space.

What Is Checked

The claims are stated over ordinary free Lie algebras and free associative algebras over 𝔽2\mathbb F_2, with quadratic representatives; the leading formula imposes antisymmetry, ordinary weights greater than one and positive count bounds. For every choice of letter weights and every Lie polynomial, a homogeneous Lie component satisfying (5) exists.✦