OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. The image of the leading projection

Corollary 5.4 [The all-weight upper bound]: Leading kernels descend to the next filtration step counting occurrences of B=yB=y, including reductions of rational solution subspaces

Odd generators bound the dimensions of solutions.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The number of homogeneous Drinfeld solutions in a given weight is compared with the corresponding component of a free Lie algebra on generators of weights 3,5,7,…3,5,7,\ldots. The leading maps use a filtration on characteristic-two solutions obtained by writing them in the quadratic letters A=x2A=x^2, C=[x,y]C=[x,y] and B=yB=y.

Let L=Lie⁡ℚ(x,y)L=\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbb Q}(x,y) be the free Lie algebra over the rational numbers on the letters x,yx,y, with the ordinary Lie bracket.✦ For a Lie polynomial pp, write p(a,b)p(a,b) for the unique Lie substitution sending xx to aa and yy to bb.✦ The rational infinitesimal braid algebra 𝔱4\mathfrak t_4 is the quotient of the free chord Lie algebra on cijc_{ij}, 0≤i<j≤30\le i<j\le3, by the ideal generated by (1); set cji=cijc_{ji}=c_{ij} and cii=0c_{ii}=0, and denote their quotient images by tijt_{ij}. [cij,ckl]=0(i,j,k,l distinct),[cij,cik+cjk]=0(i,j,k distinct).[c_{ij},c_{kl}]=0\quad(i,j,k,l\text{ distinct}),\qquad [c_{ij},c_{ik}+c_{jk}]=0\quad(i,j,k\text{ distinct}).(1)✦ For coefficients in a commutative ring SS, the braid algebra 𝔱4,S\mathfrak t_{4,S} is the quotient of the free Lie algebra on ordered pairs (i,j)(i,j) by the relations in (1) and the relations cii=0c_{ii}=0, cij=cjic_{ij}=c_{ji}; in the first bracket relation disjoint endpoint pairs suffice.✦

A Drinfeld solution is an element p∈Lp\in L satisfying (2).✦ The subspace of these solutions is WW, and Wn=W∩LnW_n=W\cap L_n, where LnL_n is the span of bracketed words containing nn letters. p(x,y)+p(y,x)=0,p(x,y)+p(y,−x−y)+p(−x−y,x)=0,p(t01,t12+t13)+p(t02+t12,t23)=p(t12,t23)+p(t01+t02,t13+t23)+p(t01,t12).\begin{aligned} p(x,y)+p(y,x)&=0,\\ p(x,y)+p(y,-x-y)+p(-x-y,x)&=0,\\ p(t_{01},t_{12}+t_{13})+p(t_{02}+t_{12},t_{23}) &=p(t_{12},t_{23})+p(t_{01}+t_{02},t_{13}+t_{23}) +p(t_{01},t_{12}). \end{aligned}(2)✦

Over 𝑭2\mathbf F_2, let W¯n\overline W_n be the homogeneous weight-nn subspace of Lie⁡𝑭2(x,y)\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbf F_2}(x,y) killed by the antisymmetry operator α\alpha, the special identity operator DD and the pentagon operator PP in (3).✦ Each free letter has weight one, and the chord generators in PP belong to 𝔱4,𝑭2\mathfrak t_{4,\mathbf F_2}. α(p)=p(x,y)+p(y,x),D(p)=[x,p(y,x)]+[−x−y,p(y,−x−y)],P(p)=p(t01,t12+t13)+p(t02+t12,t23)−p(t12,t23)−p(t01+t02,t13+t23)−p(t01,t12).\begin{aligned} \alpha(p)&=p(x,y)+p(y,x),\\ D(p)&=[x,p(y,x)]+[-x-y,p(y,-x-y)],\\ P(p)&=p(t_{01},t_{12}+t_{13})+p(t_{02}+t_{12},t_{23}) -p(t_{12},t_{23})\\ &\hspace{1em}-p(t_{01}+t_{02},t_{13}+t_{23})-p(t_{01},t_{12}). \end{aligned}(3)

Homogeneous Components and Leading Maps

For an alphabet 𝒳\mathcal X over SS, write Lie⁡S(𝒳)\operatorname{Lie}_S(\mathcal X) for the ordinary free Lie algebra and 𝒯S(𝒳)=S⟨𝒳⟩\mathcal T_S(\mathcal X)=S\langle\mathcal X\rangle for the free associative algebra. The basis element indexed by a word ww in 𝒯S(𝒳)\mathcal T_S(\mathcal X) is the monomial with coefficient one at ww.✦ The universal associative embedding ι\iota sends each free Lie generator to its associative generator.✦ The associative evaluation of a letter assignment is the homomorphism between the corresponding free associative algebras that extends the assignment multiplicatively and linearly; alphabet renaming is the evaluation associated with a map of alphabets.

A bracketed word is a letter or the bracket of two bracketed words; its evaluation replaces each formal bracket by the ordinary Lie bracket. The underlying word of a bracketed word is the sequence of its leaves from left to right.✦ For letter weights ww, the weight of a word or bracketed word is the sum of its letter weights. Denote by HS,w,nH_{S,w,n} the span of bracketed words of weight nn, and by 𝒯S,w,n\mathcal T_{S,w,n} the span of associative words of that weight. The bihomogeneous component for two weight functions is the intersection of the corresponding homogeneous Lie components.✦

The support projection on a free associative algebra associated with a condition on words is the linear endomorphism that retains precisely the basis words satisfying that condition.✦ In particular, let Qw,nQ_{w,n} be the linear projection on the free associative algebra retaining words of weight nn, and let πw,n\pi_{w,n} be the Lie homogeneous projection characterized by (4). The associative weight filtration at rr is the span of words of weight at least rr.✦ πw,n(p)∈HS,w,n,ι(πw,n(p))=Qw,n(ιp).\pi_{w,n}(p)\in H_{S,w,n},\qquad \iota\bigl(\pi_{w,n}(p)\bigr)=Q_{w,n}(\iota p).(4)✦

Let 𝔣S=Lie⁡S(z3,z5,z7,…)\mathfrak f_S=\operatorname{Lie}_S(z_3,z_5,z_7,\ldots), where z2j+3z_{2j+3} has weight 2j+32j+3 for j≥0j\ge0. Write 𝔣S,n\mathfrak f_{S,n} for its weight-nn component and 𝔣S,n,r\mathfrak f_{S,n,r} for the intersection with bracket length rr; thus each generator has length one. Set Fn=𝔣ℚ,nF_n=\mathfrak f_{\mathbb Q,n}.✦

For n>1n>1, the quadratic representation map ρn:W¯n→Lie⁡𝑭2(A,C,B)\rho_n:\overline W_n\longrightarrow\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbf F_2}(A,C,B) is the linear map assigning a quadratic Lie representative.✦ Quadratic associative substitution qq and quadratic Lie evaluation u=q∘ιu=q\circ\iota are given by (5). q(A)=x2,q(C)=xy−yx,q(B)=y,u(ρn(p))=ιp.q(A)=x^2,\qquad q(C)=xy-yx,\qquad q(B)=y,\qquad u(\rho_n(p))=\iota p.(5) The quadratic letters have weights 2,2,12,2,1, respectively. Their BB-count assigns one to BB and zero to A,CA,C.✦ It differs from ordinary yy-depth: CC has depth one and BB-count zero. The solution filtration ℱrW¯n\mathcal F^r\overline W_n is the subspace defined in (6). ℱrW¯n={p∈W¯n:every word in ιρn(p) contains at least r letters B}.\mathcal F^r\overline W_n =\{p\in\overline W_n:\text{every word in }\iota\rho_n(p) \text{ contains at least }r\text{ letters }B\}.(6)✦

Let bb denote BB-count, and let ee be the Lie homomorphism deleting AA and retaining C,BC,B, with target Lie⁡𝑭2(C,B)\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbf F_2}(C,B). The leading deletion λn,r\lambda_{n,r} and the odd component inclusion jn,rj_{n,r} are the maps in (7). Here h:𝒯𝑭2(z3,z5,…)→𝒯𝑭2(C,B)h:\mathcal T_{\mathbf F_2}(z_3,z_5,\ldots) \longrightarrow\mathcal T_{\mathbf F_2}(C,B) is the positive commutator substitution specified there. λn,r(p)=ιe(πb,r(ρn(p))),p∈ℱrW¯n,h(z2j+3)=(ad⁡C)j+1B,jn,r(v)=h(ιv),v∈𝔣𝑭2,n,r.\begin{aligned} \lambda_{n,r}(p)&=\iota e\bigl(\pi_{b,r}(\rho_n(p))\bigr), &&p\in\mathcal F^r\overline W_n,\\ h(z_{2j+3})&=(\operatorname{ad}C)^{j+1}B, &j_{n,r}(v)&=h(\iota v),\quad v\in\mathfrak f_{\mathbf F_2,n,r}. \end{aligned}(7) The commutator substitution factors through the tensor algebra on letters umu_m, m≥0m\ge0: positive index inclusion sends z2j+3z_{2j+3} to uj+1u_{j+1}, and binary commutator substitution sends umu_m to (ad⁡C)mB(\operatorname{ad}C)^mB. More generally, iterated commutator substitution sends (m,a)(m,a) to (ad⁡X)mYa(\operatorname{ad}X)^mY_a in the free algebra with distinguished letter XX and indexed letters YaY_a; the binary identification takes XX to CC and the single indexed letter to BB. In the free Lie algebra over SS on a distinguished generator XX and generators YaY_a indexed by an alphabet, the iterated commutator (ad⁡X)mYa(\operatorname{ad}X)^mY_a is obtained by applying the adjoint action of XX to YaY_a exactly mm times, for every nonnegative integer mm.

For n>2n>2, the associated graded projection γn,r\gamma_{n,r} from ℱrW¯n\mathcal F^r\overline W_n to 𝔣𝑭2,n,r\mathfrak f_{\mathbf F_2,n,r} is the linear map defined by (8), with the inverse taken on the image of jn,rj_{n,r}. γn,r=jn,r−1λn,r:ℱrW¯n→𝔣𝑭2,n,r.\gamma_{n,r}=j_{n,r}^{-1}\lambda_{n,r}: \mathcal F^r\overline W_n\longrightarrow\mathfrak f_{\mathbf F_2,n,r}.(8)✦

Integral Coordinate Lattices

Let InI_n be the set of words of length nn in x,yx,y.✦ For a prescribed collection of words in 𝒯S(𝒳)\mathcal T_S(\mathcal X), the word coefficient map is the SS-linear map from their span to the space of SS-valued families indexed by that collection, sending pp to its coefficients on those words. Composing the homogeneous associative embedding with this map gives Lie word coordinates.✦ Restriction along the homogeneous inclusions of WnW_n and W¯n\overline W_n gives cn:Wn→ℚInc_n:W_n\to\mathbb Q^{I_n} and c¯n:W¯n→𝑭2In\overline c_n:\overline W_n\to\mathbf F_2^{I_n}.

For a rational subspace V⊆ℚIV\subseteq\mathbb Q^I, its integral lattice Λ(V)\Lambda(V) consists of the integer coordinate families whose coordinatewise inclusion in ℚI\mathbb Q^I lies in VV.✦ For a rational subspace V⊆ℚIV\subseteq\mathbb Q^I and a coefficient field KK, the lattice reduction red⁡K(V)⊆KI\operatorname{red}_K(V)\subseteq K^I is the image in (9); the displayed scalar extension map sends a⊗va\otimes v to the coordinate family (avi)i∈I(a v_i)_{i\in I} over KK. Λ(V)=V∩ℤI,red⁡K(V)=im⁡(K⊗ℤΛ(V)→KI).\Lambda(V)=V\cap\mathbb Z^I,\qquad \operatorname{red}_K(V)=\operatorname{im}\left( K\otimes_{\mathbb Z}\Lambda(V)\longrightarrow K^I\right).(9)

The solution coordinate image cn(E)⊆ℚInc_n(E)\subseteq\mathbb Q^{I_n} of a rational subspace E⊆WnE\subseteq W_n is the image of EE under cnc_n.✦ The solution lattice reduction E¯⊆W¯n\overline E\subseteq\overline W_n of a rational subspace E⊆WnE\subseteq W_n, its filtration for n>1n>1 and its associated graded map for n>2n>2 are given by (10); ιn,rE\iota^E_{n,r} is the natural filtered inclusion. E¯=c¯n−1(red⁡𝑭2(cn(E))),ℱrE¯=E¯∩ℱrW¯n,ιn,rE:ℱrE¯↪ℱrW¯n,γn,rE=γn,r∘ιn,rE:ℱrE¯→𝔣𝑭2,n,r.\begin{aligned} \overline E&=\overline c_n^{-1} \bigl(\operatorname{red}_{\mathbf F_2}(c_n(E))\bigr),\\ \mathcal F^r\overline E&=\overline E\cap\mathcal F^r\overline W_n, &\iota^E_{n,r}&:\mathcal F^r\overline E\hookrightarrow \mathcal F^r\overline W_n,\\ \gamma^E_{n,r}&=\gamma_{n,r}\circ\iota^E_{n,r}: \mathcal F^r\overline E\longrightarrow\mathfrak f_{\mathbf F_2,n,r}. \end{aligned}(10)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let n,rn,r be nonnegative integers and let E⊆WnE\subseteq W_n be a rational subspace. For n>2n>2, the reduced and saturated leading maps satisfy (11) and (12), identifying their kernels with subspaces of W¯n\overline W_n and E¯\overline E, respectively: ker⁡γn,r⊆ℱr+1W¯n.\ker\gamma_{n,r}\subseteq\mathcal F^{r+1}\overline W_n.(11)✦ ker⁡γn,rE⊆ℱr+1E¯.\ker\gamma^E_{n,r}\subseteq\mathcal F^{r+1}\overline E.(12)✦ In these weights the dimension bounds are (13) and (14): dim⁡𝑭2W¯n≤dim⁡𝑭2𝔣𝑭2,n.\dim_{\mathbf F_2}\overline W_n \le\dim_{\mathbf F_2}\mathfrak f_{\mathbf F_2,n}.(13)✦ dim⁡ℚWn≤dim⁡ℚFn.\dim_{\mathbb Q}W_n\le\dim_{\mathbb Q}F_n.(14)✦ For n≤2n\le2, the rational solution space is given by (15): Wn=0.W_n=0.(15)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for every n,r≥0n,r\ge0, leading projection and the assignment g2j+3↦z2j+3g_{2j+3}\mapsto z_{2j+3} on its odd generators give an injection gr⁡ℱrL¯n↪𝔣𝑭2,n,r\operatorname{gr}_{\mathcal F}^r\overline L_n \hookrightarrow\mathfrak f_{\mathbf F_2,n,r} for its reduced space L¯n\overline L_n, and consequently dim⁡ℚWn=dim⁡𝑭2L¯n≤∑r≥0dn,r=dn\dim_{\mathbb Q}W_n=\dim_{\mathbf F_2}\overline L_n \le\sum_{r\ge0}d_{n,r}=d_n, where dn,r=dim⁡𝑭2𝔣𝑭2,n,rd_{n,r}=\dim_{\mathbf F_2}\mathfrak f_{\mathbf F_2,n,r}.

What Is Checked

The statements concern ordinary free Lie algebras over ℚ\mathbb Q and 𝑭2\mathbf F_2, their homogeneous solution subspaces, and the reductions of integral coordinate lattices of rational subspaces E⊆WnE\subseteq W_n. Homogeneous Lie components exist in every weight✦, and their projections preserve addition and scalar multiplication. The odd component inclusion jn,rj_{n,r} is injective for every n,rn,r✦; for n>2n>2, the leading deletion λn,r\lambda_{n,r} takes values in its image.✦