OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 ยท ยง6. A rational Lie algebra of categorical values

Section 6: compatible derivations and finite gauge data: Symmetry and pentagon conditions for the free Lie algebra LL on two generators and the four-strand infinitesimal braid algebra ๐”ฑ4\mathfrak t_4

Finite gauge data define categorical values.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Categorical evaluation has an algebraic part involving free Lie substitutions and changes of gauge at the vertices of a pentagon. Let LL be the rational free Lie algebra on the generators xx and yy.โœฆ

The strand set is I={0,1,2,3}I=\{0,1,2,3\}. The set EE of chords on II and the free Lie algebra ๐”ฃ4\mathfrak f_4 on EE are defined in (1): E={(i,j)โˆˆI2:i<j},๐”ฃ4=Lie⁡โ„š(E).E=\{(i,j)\in I^2:i<j\},\qquad \mathfrak f_4=\operatorname{Lie}_{\mathbb Q}(E).(1) For distinct i,jโˆˆIi,j\in I, the free chord generator cij=cjic_{ij}=c_{ji} is the generator of ๐”ฃ4\mathfrak f_4 corresponding to their unordered pair; put cii=0c_{ii}=0.โœฆ The infinitesimal braid relation ideal JJ of ๐”ฃ4\mathfrak f_4 is the Lie ideal generated by the relations in (2); the infinitesimal braid algebra ๐”ฑ4\mathfrak t_4 is the quotient of ๐”ฃ4\mathfrak f_4 by JJ, and its chord generators tijt_{ij} are the images of the free chord generators cijc_{ij} in that quotient: โ„›4={[cij,ckl]:i,j,k,l pairwise distinct}โˆช{[cij,cik+cjk]:i,j,k pairwise distinct},J=โŸจโ„›4โŸฉLieideal,๐”ฑ4=๐”ฃ4/J,tij=cij+J.\begin{gathered} \begin{aligned} \mathcal R_4={}&\{[c_{ij},c_{kl}]:i,j,k,l\text{ pairwise distinct}\}\\ &\mathbin{\cup}\{[c_{ij},c_{ik}+c_{jk}]:i,j,k\text{ pairwise distinct}\}, \end{aligned}\\ J=\langle\mathcal R_4\rangle_{\mathrm{Lie\ ideal}},\qquad \mathfrak t_4=\mathfrak f_4/J,\qquad t_{ij}=c_{ij}+J. \end{gathered}(2)

For a rational Lie algebra MM and a,bโˆˆMa,b\in M, the substitution ev⁡a,b:Lโ†’M\operatorname{ev}_{a,b}:L\to M is the unique Lie homomorphism with the values in (3): ev⁡a,b(x)=a,ev⁡a,b(y)=b.\operatorname{ev}_{a,b}(x)=a,\qquad \operatorname{ev}_{a,b}(y)=b.(3)โœฆ The generator transposition ฯƒ\sigma and cyclic substitution ฯ\rho of LL are the Lie endomorphisms defined in (4). On the gauge index set O3={0,1,2}O_3=\{0,1,2\}, their respective object permutations are s=(01)s=(01) and r=(012)r=(012): ฯƒ=ev⁡y,x,ฯ=ev⁡y,โˆ’xโˆ’y.\sigma=\operatorname{ev}_{y,x},\qquad \rho=\operatorname{ev}_{y,-x-y}.(4)

Label the five further gauge indices by O4={A,B,C,D,E}O_4=\{A,B,C,D,E\}, with A=0A=0, B=1B=1, C=2C=2, D=3D=3, and E=4E=4. The five pentagon substitutions ฯ•ab:Lโ†’๐”ฑ4\phi_{ab}:L\to\mathfrak t_4 are those of (5): ฯ•AD=ev⁡t02+t12,t23,ฯ•DE=ev⁡t01,t12+t13,ฯ•AB=ev⁡t01,t12,ฯ•BC=ev⁡t01+t02,t13+t23,ฯ•CE=ev⁡t12,t23.\begin{aligned} \phi_{AD}&=\operatorname{ev}_{t_{02}+t_{12},\,t_{23}},& \phi_{DE}&=\operatorname{ev}_{t_{01},\,t_{12}+t_{13}},\\ \phi_{AB}&=\operatorname{ev}_{t_{01},\,t_{12}},& \phi_{BC}&=\operatorname{ev}_{t_{01}+t_{02},\,t_{13}+t_{23}},\\ \phi_{CE}&=\operatorname{ev}_{t_{12},\,t_{23}}. \end{aligned}(5)

The Definition

Definition 1. Let SS be a commutative ring, MM a Lie algebra over SS, and OO a set. Categorical gauge data on MM, indexed by OO, are pairs g=(d,h)g=(d,h) in the set ๐’ขS(M,O)\mathcal G_S(M,O) of (6), where dd is an SS-linear Lie derivation and h:Oโ†’Mh:O\to M: ๐’ขS(M,O)=Der⁡S(M)ร—MO.\mathcal G_S(M,O)=\operatorname{Der}_S(M)\times M^O.(6)โœฆ For p,qโˆˆOp,q\in O, the gauge difference upqgโˆˆMu^g_{pq}\in M and loop derivation โ„“pgโˆˆDer⁡S(M)\ell^g_p\in\operatorname{Der}_S(M) are defined by (7): upqg=h(q)โˆ’h(p),โ„“pg=dโˆ’ad⁡h(p).u^g_{pq}=h(q)-h(p),\qquad \ell^g_p=d-\operatorname{ad}_{h(p)}.(7)

Let NN be a Lie algebra over SS, PP a set, kโˆˆ๐’ขS(N,P)k\in\mathcal G_S(N,P), F:Mโ†’NF:M\to N an SS-linear Lie homomorphism, and f:Oโ†’Pf:O\to P a map. The gauge compatibility condition Comp⁡(F,f;g,k)\operatorname{Comp}(F,f;g,k) for gg and kk along (F,f)(F,f) is defined in (8): Comp⁡(F,f;g,k)โ‡”uf(p)f(q)k=F(upqg)(p,qโˆˆO),โ„“f(p)kโˆ˜F=Fโˆ˜โ„“pg(pโˆˆO).\begin{gathered} \operatorname{Comp}(F,f;g,k)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\\ \begin{aligned} u^k_{f(p)f(q)}&=F(u^g_{pq}) &&(p,q\in O),\\ \ell^k_{f(p)}\circ F&=F\circ\ell^g_p &&(p\in O). \end{aligned} \end{gathered}(8) For p,qโˆˆOp,q\in O and a,bโˆˆPa,b\in P, the edge gauge compatibility condition EdgeComp⁡p,q;a,b(F;g,k)\operatorname{EdgeComp}_{p,q;a,b}(F;g,k) for gg and kk along FF is defined in (9): EdgeComp⁡p,q;a,b(F;g,k)โ‡”uabk=F(upqg)andโ„“akโˆ˜F=Fโˆ˜โ„“pg.\begin{gathered} \operatorname{EdgeComp}_{p,q;a,b}(F;g,k) \quad\Longleftrightarrow\\ u^k_{ab}=F(u^g_{pq})\quad\text{and}\quad \ell^k_a\circ F=F\circ\ell^g_p. \end{gathered}(9)

A finite categorical gauge witness w=(g3,g4)w=(g_3,g_4) is a pair belonging to the set ๐’ฒ\mathcal W defined in (10): ๐’ฒ={(g3,g4)โˆˆ๐’ขโ„š(L,O3)ร—๐’ขโ„š(๐”ฑ4,O4):Comp⁡(ฯƒ,s;g3,g3),Comp⁡(ฯ,r;g3,g3),โ„“0g3(x)=0,โ„“1g3(y)=0,EdgeComp⁡0,1;a,b(ฯ•ab;g3,g4)(abโˆˆ{AD,DE,AB,BC,CE})}.\begin{aligned} \mathcal W=\bigl\{(g_3,g_4)\in &\mathcal G_{\mathbb Q}(L,O_3)\times \mathcal G_{\mathbb Q}(\mathfrak t_4,O_4):\\ &\operatorname{Comp}(\sigma,s;g_3,g_3),\quad \operatorname{Comp}(\rho,r;g_3,g_3),\\ &\ell^{g_3}_0(x)=0,\quad\ell^{g_3}_1(y)=0,\\ &\operatorname{EdgeComp}_{0,1;a,b}(\phi_{ab};g_3,g_4) \quad(ab\in\{AD,DE,AB,BC,CE\})\bigr\}. \end{aligned}(10)โœฆ The categorical value v(w)โˆˆLv(w)\in L of a witness w=(g3,g4)w=(g_3,g_4) is the element defined in (11): v(w)=u01g3.v(w)=u^{g_3}_{01}.(11)โœฆ

In the paper, the result reads: with coefficients KK, for label sets II with |I|โ‰ค4|I|\leq4 and their infinitesimal braid Lie algebras ๐”ฑI\mathfrak t_I, the category ๐’ž(I;K)\mathcal C(I;K) has planar labeled binary trees as objects and the completed universal enveloping algebra Uห†(๐”ฑIโŠ—K)\widehat U(\mathfrak t_I\otimes K), the product of its discrete homogeneous pieces, as every arrow space, with composition by multiplication and coproduct with primitive chords; its specified operations are relabeling, outer block substitution for blocks BiB_i given by tijโ†ฆโˆ‘aโˆˆBi,bโˆˆBjtabt_{ij}\mapsto\sum_{a\in B_i,\,b\in B_j}t_{ab}, and inner insertion; Dn(K)D_n(K) consists of weight-nn derivations and coderivations compatible with these operations and zero in arity two, and evaluation is on the unit reassociation arrow ฮฑ:((12)3)โ†’(1(23))\alpha:((12)3)\to(1(23)).

What Is Checked

The gauge data and their compatibilities are stated over Lie algebras over commutative rings, while the witnesses and their values are stated over the rational Lie algebras LL and ๐”ฑ4\mathfrak t_4 with the finite index sets O3O_3 and O4O_4.