OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. From passages to absence of conjugate points

Lemma 6.2 [The index-form criterion]: Global and interval criteria for abstract Jacobi equations and smooth three-manifolds

Nonnegative index excludes conjugate points.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Jacobi fields with two prescribed zeros are considered both for symmetric operator equations and along curves in a smooth three-manifold. Let VV be a real inner product space, and let MM be a smooth three-manifold with coordinate space ℝ3\mathbb R^3 and a smooth Riemannian metric gg. Geodesic time is denoted by ss.

The Abstract Index Form

For a family A(s):V→VA(s):V\to V of continuous linear endomorphisms and fields f,h:ℝ→Vf,h:\mathbb R\to V, the index density ιA\iota_A and the bilinear and quadratic index forms BA,IAB_A,I_A are defined by (1). Derivatives are ordinary derivatives with respect to ss. ιA(f,h;s)=⟨f′(s),h′(s)⟩−⟨A(s)f(s),h(s)⟩,BA(f,h)=∫ℝιA(f,h;s)ds,IA(f)=BA(f,f).\begin{aligned} \iota_A(f,h;s)&=\langle f'(s),h'(s)\rangle -\langle A(s)f(s),h(s)\rangle,\\ B_A(f,h)&=\int_{\mathbb R}\iota_A(f,h;s)\,ds, &I_A(f)&=B_A(f,f). \end{aligned}(1) A smooth solution f:ℝ→Vf:\mathbb R\to V of the abstract Jacobi equation satisfies (2) on its time domain. Write Cc∞(ℝ,V)C_c^\infty(\mathbb R,V) for the smooth compactly supported VV-valued functions. f″(s)+A(s)f(s)=0.f''(s)+A(s)f(s)=0.(2)

The Intrinsic Index Form

For a chart cc of MM, write eie_i for the standard coordinate vectors of ℝ3\mathbb R^3; for a differentiable function FF on an open subset of ℝ3\mathbb R^3 and a point xx in its domain, write ∂iF(x)=dFx(ei)\partial_i F(x)=dF_x(e_i) for coordinate differentiation. Indices range from 00 to 22. The metric matrix (gij)(g_{ij}) in (3) is the matrix of inner products of the coordinate tangent vectors; its inverse is denoted by (gij)(g^{ij}).✦ gij(x)=gc−1(x)(d(c−1)xei,d(c−1)xej).g_{ij}(x)=g_{c^{-1}(x)}\bigl(d(c^{-1})_x e_i,d(c^{-1})_x e_j\bigr).(3)✦ For vectors u,v∈ℝ3u,v\in\mathbb R^3, a coordinate curve xx, and an ℝ3\mathbb R^3-valued field ww along xx, the Christoffel symbols Γjki\Gamma^i_{jk}, their connection term Γx(u,v)\Gamma_x(u,v), and the coordinate covariant derivative 𝒟scw\mathcal D_s^c w are given by (4). Γjki(x)=12∑lgil(x)(∂jglk(x)+∂kglj(x)−∂lgjk(x)),(Γx(u,v))i=∑j,kΓjki(x)ujvk,𝒟scw=w′(s)+Γx(s)(x′(s),w(s)).\begin{aligned} \Gamma^i_{jk}(x)&=\frac12\sum_l g^{il}(x) \bigl(\partial_j g_{lk}(x)+\partial_k g_{lj}(x) -\partial_l g_{jk}(x)\bigr),\\ \bigl(\Gamma_x(u,v)\bigr)^i&=\sum_{j,k}\Gamma^i_{jk}(x)u^jv^k,\\ \mathcal D_s^c w&=w'(s)+\Gamma_{x(s)}\bigl(x'(s),w(s)\bigr). \end{aligned}(4) For vectors u,v,z∈ℝ3u,v,z\in\mathbb R^3, the curvature components RlkijR^l{}_{kij} and the coordinate curvature operator Rc(u,v)zR_c(u,v)z are defined by (5). Rlkij=∂iΓjkl−∂jΓikl+∑a(ΓialΓjka−ΓjalΓika),(Rc(u,v)z)l=∑k,i,jRlkijzkuivj.\begin{aligned} R^l{}_{kij} &=\partial_i\Gamma^l_{jk}-\partial_j\Gamma^l_{ik} +\sum_a\bigl(\Gamma^l_{ia}\Gamma^a_{jk} -\Gamma^l_{ja}\Gamma^a_{ik}\bigr),\\ \bigl(R_c(u,v)z\bigr)^l&=\sum_{k,i,j}R^l{}_{kij}z^ku^iv^j. \end{aligned}(5)

For a curve γ:ℝ→M\gamma:\mathbb R\to M, a field JJ along γ\gamma assigns a vector J(s)∈Tγ(s)MJ(s)\in T_{\gamma(s)}M to each time. The coordinates wcw_c of a field JJ along a curve γ:ℝ→M\gamma:\mathbb R\to M in a chart cc are the coordinate functions given by wc(s)=dcγ(s)J(s)w_c(s)=dc_{\gamma(s)}J(s).✦ A field JJ along a curve γ:ℝ→M\gamma:\mathbb R\to M is smooth on a time set UU when its coordinates wcw_c are smooth on U∩γ−1(dom⁡c)U\cap\gamma^{-1}(\operatorname{dom}c) for every chart cc.✦

The covariant derivative DsJD_sJ and curvature field KγJK_\gamma J are the tangent vectors defined in (6), using the chart at γ(s)\gamma(s) and x=c∘γx=c\circ\gamma. DsJ=d(c−1)x(s)(𝒟scwc),KγJ(s)=d(c−1)x(s)(Rc(wc(s),x′(s))x′(s)).\begin{aligned} D_sJ&=d(c^{-1})_{x(s)}\bigl(\mathcal D_s^c w_c\bigr),\\ K_\gamma J(s)&=d(c^{-1})_{x(s)} \bigl(R_c(w_c(s),x'(s))x'(s)\bigr). \end{aligned}(6) A geodesic on UU is a smooth curve γ\gamma satisfying the first equation in (7) in every chart wherever s∈Us\in U and the curve lies in that chart.✦ A Jacobi field JJ along a curve γ:ℝ→M\gamma:\mathbb R\to M on a time set UU is a field smooth on UU satisfying the second equation in (7) in every chart wherever s∈Us\in U and γ(s)\gamma(s) lies in that chart.✦ 𝒟scx′=0,𝒟sc(𝒟scwc)+Rc(wc,x′)x′=0.\mathcal D_s^c x'=0, \qquad \mathcal D_s^c(\mathcal D_s^c w_c) +R_c(w_c,x')x'=0.(7)

The intrinsic index density ιg,γ\iota_{g,\gamma} and index form Ig,γI_{g,\gamma} are defined by (8) for fields J,HJ,H along γ\gamma. ιg,γ(J,H;s)=gγ(s)(DsJ,DsH)−gγ(s)(KγJ(s),H(s)),Ig,γ(J,H)=∫ℝιg,γ(J,H;s)ds.\begin{aligned} \iota_{g,\gamma}(J,H;s) &=g_{\gamma(s)}(D_sJ,D_sH) -g_{\gamma(s)}(K_\gamma J(s),H(s)),\\ I_{g,\gamma}(J,H)&=\int_{\mathbb R}\iota_{g,\gamma}(J,H;s)\,ds. \end{aligned}(8) For a curve γ:ℝ→M\gamma:\mathbb R\to M and a time set UU, the set 𝒯γ(U)\mathcal T_\gamma(U) consists of the fields along γ\gamma that are smooth on UU and whose closed support is compact and contained in UU. Nonnegative index along γ\gamma on UU means the condition in (9). Ig,γ(H,H)≥0(H∈𝒯γ(U)).I_{g,\gamma}(H,H)\geq0\qquad\bigl(H\in\mathcal T_\gamma(U)\bigr).(9)✦ The metric gg has no conjugate points, denoted by 𝖭𝖢(g)\mathsf{NC}(g), when on every open interval UU, every Jacobi field along every geodesic on UU with two distinct zeros vanishes throughout UU.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let A:ℝ→ℒ(V,V)A:\mathbb R\to\mathcal L(V,V) be a continuous family of continuous linear endomorphisms of VV, self-adjoint at every time, and suppose IA(h)≥0I_A(h)\geq0 for every h∈Cc∞(ℝ,V)h\in C_c^\infty(\mathbb R,V). A smooth solution ff of (2) on ℝ\mathbb R with f(a)=f(b)=0f(a)=f(b)=0 at distinct times a,ba,b satisfies f(s)=0(s∈ℝ).f(s)=0\qquad(s\in\mathbb R).(10)✦ Under the same hypotheses on AA and IAI_A, let UU be an open interval and let ff be smooth on UU and satisfy (2) there. If f(a)=f(b)=0f(a)=f(b)=0 for distinct a,b∈Ua,b\in U, then f(s)=0(s∈U).f(s)=0\qquad(s\in U).(11)✦

Let γ\gamma be smooth on an open interval UU, and suppose its intrinsic index is nonnegative on UU. Every Jacobi field JJ along γ\gamma on UU with J(a)=J(b)=0J(a)=J(b)=0 at times a<ba<b in UU satisfies J(s)=0(s∈U).J(s)=0\qquad(s\in U).(12)✦ If gg has nonnegative intrinsic index along every geodesic on every open interval of times, then 𝖭𝖢(g).\mathsf{NC}(g).(13)✦

In the paper, the result reads: a complete smooth Riemannian manifold (M,g)(M,g) has no conjugate points if Ig,γ(H,H)≥0I_{g,\gamma}(H,H)\geq0 for every smooth compactly supported field HH along every complete unit-speed geodesic γ\gamma.

What Is Checked

The criteria (10) and (11) are stated over continuous self-adjoint operator fields on a real inner product space, and (12) and (13) over smooth Riemannian metrics on three-manifolds and fields in the tangent spaces along their curves.