OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. From passages to absence of conjugate points

§6 (proof of Theorem 1.1): the final assembly: A uniform neck family and the obstruction to nonpositive sectional curvature

A compact three-manifold without conjugate points.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let Σ\Sigma be the quotient of the upper half-plane ℍ\mathbb H by the modular subgroup Γ\Gamma in (1), acting through its effective group of transformations.✦ The two hyperbolic generators are ϕ\phi and ψ\psi: ϕ=(1112),ψ=(1−1−12),Γ=⟨ϕ,ψ,−I⟩⊂SL(2,ℤ).\phi=\begin{pmatrix}1&1\\1&2\end{pmatrix},\qquad \psi=\begin{pmatrix}1&-1\\-1&2\end{pmatrix},\qquad \Gamma=\langle\phi,\psi,-I\rangle\subset\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb Z).(1) The surface height hh on Σ\Sigma is the real-valued function that assigns to each point the logarithm of the maximal imaginary part in its orbit.✦ For a threshold aa, the open truncated surface Σ<a\Sigma_{<a} of Σ\Sigma is the set of points with h<log⁡ah<\log a.✦ Write C6=ℝ/6ℤC_6=\mathbb R/6\mathbb Z✦, T2=C6×C6T^2=C_6\times C_6, and X=Σ<8×C6X=\Sigma_{<8}\times C_6 for the truncated product piece.✦ The circle deck group is 6ℤ6\mathbb Z, acting on ℝ\mathbb R by translations.✦

The cusp above a>1a>1 is the image of {z∈ℍ:Im⁡z>a}\{z\in\mathbb H:\operatorname{Im}z>a\} in Σ\Sigma; its cylinder coordinates are (r,x)∈(a,∞)×C6(r,x)\in(a,\infty)\times C_6. The torus collar O⊂XO\subset X is the product cusp with 2<r<82<r<8.✦ The glued three-manifold MM identifies two copies of XX along OO by the collar homeomorphism in (2).✦ Here ATA_T is the torus shear, and the radial inversion is r↦16/rr\mapsto16/r: AT(x,y)=(x+y,x),AT−1(x,y)=(y,x−y),(r,x,y)↦(16/r,y,x−y).A_T(x,y)=(x+y,x),\qquad A_T^{-1}(x,y)=(y,x-y),\qquad (r,x,y)\longmapsto(16/r,y,x-y).(2)

The Metric Family

A smooth Riemannian metric gg on a smooth manifold YY is a smooth family of positive definite symmetric inner products on its tangent spaces; write 𝒢∞(Y)\mathcal G^\infty(Y) for these metrics.✦ A local Riemannian metric gg on a smooth manifold YY is a smooth family of positive definite symmetric inner products on the tangent spaces over an open domain in YY.✦ The hyperbolic surface metric hΣh_\Sigma descends from the Euclidean half-plane metric scaled by (Im⁡z)−2(\operatorname{Im}z)^{-2}.✦ The flat metric on C6C_6 descends from the Euclidean metric on ℝ\mathbb R.✦ For a nonzero constant cc, the core product metric on Σ×C6\Sigma\times C_6, with circle coordinate θ\theta, is hΣ+c2dθ2h_\Sigma+c^2\,d\theta^2.✦

Let Θ\Theta denote the standard smooth transition from zero to one. The one-sided cutoff aa, its integral AA, and the shear and collar transitions χ\chi and λ\lambda are functions of neck height tt defined in (3): a(t)={exp⁡(−12/3−t),t<2/3,0,t≥2/3,A(t)=∫0ta(u)du,χ(t)=Θ(6(t−5/12)),λ(t)=Θ(2t+3/2).\begin{aligned} a(t)&=\begin{cases} \exp\!\left(-\dfrac{1}{2/3-t}\right),&t<2/3,\\ 0,&t\ge2/3, \end{cases} &A(t)&=\int_0^t a(u)\,du,\\ \chi(t)&=\Theta\bigl(6(t-5/12)\bigr), &\lambda(t)&=\Theta(2t+3/2). \end{aligned}(3) For neck parameter δ\delta, the collar denominator dδd_\delta, terminal decay rate νδ\nu_\delta, logarithmic decay kδk_\delta, and warping function ℓδ\ell_\delta are the functions in (4): dδ(t)=1+δA(t),νδ(t)=δa(t)2dδ(t),kδ(t)=1−λ(t)+λ(t)νδ(t),ℓδ(t)=exp⁡(−∫0tkδ(u)du).\begin{aligned} d_\delta(t)&=1+\delta A(t),& \nu_\delta(t)&=\frac{\delta a(t)}{2d_\delta(t)},\\ k_\delta(t)&=1-\lambda(t)+\lambda(t)\nu_\delta(t),& \ell_\delta(t)&=\exp\!\left(-\int_0^t k_\delta(u)\,du\right). \end{aligned}(4)

The torus cylinder ℝ×T2\mathbb R\times T^2 is covered by ℝ×ℝ2\mathbb R\times\mathbb R^2, with the horizontal coordinates reduced modulo 66. For 0<δ≤1/20<\delta\le1/2 and a positive period BB, the neck radii ρ1\rho_1 and ρ2\rho_2 and the interpolating neck metric nδ,Bn_{\delta,B} have the expressions in (5) on this covering space. For a tangent vector with components (u0,u1,u2)(u_0,u_1,u_2) in the covering coordinates, the corresponding triangular frame sends (u0,u1,u2)(u_0,u_1,u_2) to (u0,ρ1(u1−χu2),ρ2u2)(u_0,\rho_1(u_1-\chi u_2),\rho_2u_2): ρ1(δ,B,t)=δ2B6ℓδ(t),ρ2(δ,B,t)=B6ℓδ(1−t),nδ,B=dt2+ρ1(δ,B,t)2(dx−χ(t)dy)2+ρ2(δ,B,t)2dy2.\begin{aligned} \rho_1(\delta,B,t)&=\frac{\delta^2B}{6}\ell_\delta(t),& \rho_2(\delta,B,t)&=\frac{B}{6}\ell_\delta(1-t),\\ n_{\delta,B}&=dt^2+ \rho_1(\delta,B,t)^2\bigl(dx-\chi(t)\,dy\bigr)^2 +\rho_2(\delta,B,t)^2\,dy^2. \end{aligned}(5) The cylinder deck group is (6ℤ)2(6\mathbb Z)^2, acting by translations of the two horizontal coordinates and fixing the height.

For a real parameter Λ\Lambda, the radial cylinder reparametrization RΛR_\Lambda changes only the height, using the transition η\eta and radial profile fΛf_\Lambda in (6).✦ Its lift to ℝ×ℝ2\mathbb R\times\mathbb R^2 uses the same formula: η(t)=Θ(4t−1),fΛ(t)=(1−η(t))(t−Λ−1)+η(t)t−log⁡2log⁡4,RΛ(t,x,y)=(fΛ(t),x,y).\begin{aligned} \eta(t)&=\Theta(4t-1),\\ f_\Lambda(t)&=(1-\eta(t))(t-\Lambda-1) +\eta(t)\frac{t-\log2}{\log4},\\ R_\Lambda(t,x,y)&=(f_\Lambda(t),x,y). \end{aligned}(6)✦ Let 𝜍(t,x,y)=(1−t,AT(x,y))\varsigma(t,x,y)=(1-t,A_T(x,y)) be the reversing cylinder map.✦ The matching period BδB_\delta, left and right circle scales cℓ,crc_\ell,c_r, neck lengths Λℓ,Λr\Lambda_\ell,\Lambda_r, and cylindrical metrics gℓcyl,grcylg_\ell^{\mathrm{cyl}},g_r^{\mathrm{cyl}} are specified in (7): Bδ=6e4ℓδ(−1),cℓ=Bδ6ℓδ(1),cr=δ2Bδ6ℓδ(1),Λℓ=4−2log⁡δ,Λr=4,gℓcyl=RΛℓ*nδ,Bδ,grcyl=R4*𝜍*nδ,Bδ.\begin{aligned} B_\delta&=\frac{6}{e^4\ell_\delta(-1)},& c_\ell&=\frac{B_\delta}{6}\ell_\delta(1),& c_r&=\frac{\delta^2B_\delta}{6}\ell_\delta(1),\\ \Lambda_\ell&=4-2\log\delta,&\Lambda_r&=4,\\ g_\ell^{\mathrm{cyl}}&=R_{\Lambda_\ell}^{*}n_{\delta,B_\delta},& g_r^{\mathrm{cyl}}&=R_4^{*}\varsigma^{*}n_{\delta,B_\delta}. \end{aligned}(7)

The product cusp coordinates retain the circle factor of Σ×C6\Sigma\times C_6. Their logarithmic height change r↦log⁡rr\mapsto\log r, with inverse t↦ett\mapsto e^t, pulls each cylindrical metric back to the product cusp above e1/8e^{1/8}. The left and right whole piece metrics glue these cusp metrics to their core product metrics on h<1/4h<1/4, with circle scales cℓc_\ell and crc_r, respectively. The left and right piece metrics on XX are the restrictions of the left and right whole piece metrics to XX. Denote by gδg_\delta the metric on MM obtained by gluing the piece metrics and expressing the result in real three-dimensional coordinates.✦

For a real threshold aa, the height cylinder (a,∞)×T2(a,\infty)\times T^2 is the product of the open height ray with the two quotient circles.✦ The logarithmic cylinder domain for a threshold aa is the open subset of ℝ×T2\mathbb R\times T^2 whose height exceeds log⁡a\log a.✦

The Passage Hypotheses

The passage cometric P(δ,t)P(\delta,t) is the real 2×22\times2 matrix in (8); its inverse metric matrix is Q=P−1Q=P^{-1}.✦ The diagonal coefficients d1,d2d_1,d_2 and cometric shear σ\sigma are d1(δ,t)=1+δA(t),d2(δ,t)=1+δA(1−t),σ(δ,t)=δ2χ(t),P(δ,t)=(d1+d2σ2d2σd2σd2).\begin{aligned} d_1(\delta,t)&=1+\delta A(t),& d_2(\delta,t)&=1+\delta A(1-t),& \sigma(\delta,t)&=\delta^2\chi(t),\\ P(\delta,t)&= \begin{pmatrix} d_1+d_2\sigma^2&d_2\sigma\\ d_2\sigma&d_2 \end{pmatrix}. \end{aligned}(8) The endpoint frame matrix C2C_2 defines the left and right coordinate cometrics Pℓ,PrP_\ell,P_r in (9), where τ\tau is inward endpoint height: C2(δ)=(011−δ2),Pℓ(δ,τ)=P(δ,τ),Pr(δ,τ)=C2(δ)P(δ,1−τ)C2(δ)𝖳.C_2(\delta)=\begin{pmatrix}0&1\\1&-\delta^2\end{pmatrix},\qquad P_\ell(\delta,\tau)=P(\delta,\tau),\qquad P_r(\delta,\tau)=C_2(\delta)P(\delta,1-\tau)C_2(\delta)^{\mathsf T}.(9)

For a transverse vector q∈ℝ2q\in\mathbb R^2, write |q|2=q𝖳q|q|^2=q^{\mathsf T}q and q𝖳Dqq^{\mathsf T}Dq for the quadratic form of a real matrix DD. The passage bounds with constant CC and parameter δ\delta are the inequalities (10), required at both ends ε∈{ℓ,r}\varepsilon\in\{\ell,r\}, for every τ∈[0,1]\tau\in[0,1] and q∈ℝ2q\in\mathbb R^2.✦ Primes denote derivatives in inward endpoint height: 19|q|2≤q𝖳Pε(δ,τ)q≤18|q|2,|Pε′(δ,τ)q|2≤C2δ2|q|2,0≤q𝖳(−Pε″(δ,τ))q,|Pε′(δ,τ)q|2≤Cδq𝖳(−Pε″(δ,τ))q.\begin{aligned} \frac19|q|^2&\le q^{\mathsf T}P_\varepsilon(\delta,\tau)q \le18|q|^2,\\ |P_\varepsilon'(\delta,\tau)q|^2&\le C^2\delta^2|q|^2,\\ 0&\le q^{\mathsf T}\bigl(-P_\varepsilon''(\delta,\tau)\bigr)q,\\ |P_\varepsilon'(\delta,\tau)q|^2 &\le C\delta\,q^{\mathsf T}\bigl(-P_\varepsilon''(\delta,\tau)\bigr)q. \end{aligned}(10)

The turning constants a0,βa_0,\beta and mixed coefficient bound Cm(C)C_m(C) are the numbers in (11): a0=e−3/2,β=1+e−9/262,Cm(C)=a(0)+2Ca(0)+22Ca(0)3.a_0=e^{-3/2},\qquad \beta=\frac{1+e^{-9/26}}2,\qquad C_m(C)=a(0)+\sqrt{2Ca(0)}+2\sqrt{\frac{2Ca(0)}3}.(11) For real coefficients Ce,CmC_e,C_m, the neck smallness condition is (12): 0<δ≤1,δ≤12Cm,δ≤1−β2Cm+Cea0.0<\delta\le1,\qquad \delta\le\frac1{2C_m},\qquad \delta\le\frac{1-\beta}{2C_m+C_ea_0}.(12)✦

Index and Conjugacy

Let gg be a smooth metric and γ\gamma a curve. A field JJ along γ\gamma is smooth on a time set UU when, in every chart cc, its coordinate field w(s)=dcγ(s)J(s)w(s)=dc_{\gamma(s)}J(s) is smooth on U∩γ−1(dom⁡c)U\cap\gamma^{-1}(\operatorname{dom}c).✦ For x=c∘γx=c\circ\gamma, the coordinate covariant derivative is Dsw=w′+Γ(x)(x′,w)D_sw=w'+\Gamma(x)(x',w), where Γ\Gamma is the connection term formed from the Christoffel symbols of the coordinate metric matrix (gij)(g_{ij}).✦ The intrinsic derivative DsJD_sJ of a field JJ along a curve γ\gamma is the field obtained by transporting its coordinate covariant derivative DswD_sw by dc−1dc^{-1}✦; the curvature term R(J,γ̇)γ̇R(J,\dot\gamma)\dot\gamma is obtained by transporting the corresponding coordinate curvature operator by dc−1dc^{-1}.✦ The curvature components RlkijR^l{}_{kij} are the coordinate coefficients of the curvature operator, so that the llth component of R(u,v)wR(u,v)w is ∑k,i,jRlkijwkuivj\sum_{k,i,j}R^l{}_{kij}w^ku^iv^j.✦

A geodesic γ\gamma for a smooth metric gg on a time set UU is a smooth curve with vanishing covariant acceleration in every chart.✦ A Jacobi field JJ along a curve γ\gamma on a time set UU is a smooth field satisfying the Jacobi equation in (13) on every chart domain: Ds2J+R(J,γ̇)γ̇=0.D_s^2J+R(J,\dot\gamma)\dot\gamma=0.(13)✦

For fields JJ and HH along a curve γ\gamma in a smooth metric gg, the intrinsic index form Ig,γI_{g,\gamma} is the integral of the density ιg,γ\iota_{g,\gamma} in (14) over geodesic time ss: ιg,γ(J,H;s)=g(DsJ,DsH)−g(R(J,γ̇)γ̇,H),Ig,γ(J,H)=∫ℝιg,γ(J,H;s)ds.\begin{aligned} \iota_{g,\gamma}(J,H;s) &=g(D_sJ,D_sH)-g\bigl(R(J,\dot\gamma)\dot\gamma,H\bigr),\\ I_{g,\gamma}(J,H)&=\int_{\mathbb R}\iota_{g,\gamma}(J,H;s)\,ds. \end{aligned}(14)✦ The intrinsic index form Ig,γI_{g,\gamma} along a curve γ\gamma is nonnegative on a time set UU if Ig,γ(J,J)≥0I_{g,\gamma}(J,J)\ge0 for every field JJ smooth on UU whose closed support is compact and contained in UU.✦

A smooth metric gg has no conjugate points, denoted 𝒩(g)\mathcal N(g), if every Jacobi field along every geodesic on an open interval UU that vanishes at two distinct times of UU vanishes throughout UU.✦

A smooth metric gg has nonpositive sectional curvature, written Kg≤0K_g\le0, when g(R(u,v)v,u)≤0g(R(u,v)v,u)\le0 for all coordinate vectors u,vu,v at every point of every chart image.✦

An atlas on a smooth manifold is positively oriented when the derivative of every coordinate transition has positive determinant.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Suppose 0<δ≤1/20<\delta\le1/2 and C≥18C\ge18 satisfy the passage bounds (10) and the smallness condition (12) with coefficients 3C3C and Cm(C)C_m(C). Let UU be an open interval, γ\gamma a gδg_\delta-geodesic on UU, and JJ a field smooth on UU whose closed support is compact and contained in UU; then the intrinsic index form satisfies (15): Igδ,γ(J,J)≥0.I_{g_\delta,\gamma}(J,J)\ge0.(15)✦ The metric gδg_\delta has no conjugate points: 𝒩(gδ).\mathcal N(g_\delta).(16)✦

For the full family, there exists a parameter δ0\delta_0 satisfying (17): 0<δ0≤1/2,𝒩(gδ)for every 0<δ≤δ0.0<\delta_0\le1/2,\qquad \mathcal N(g_\delta)\quad\text{for every }0<\delta\le\delta_0.(17)✦

There exists a Hausdorff, second countable, compact connected smooth three-manifold NN with a positively oriented atlas and with the metric properties (18): {g∈𝒢∞(N):𝒩(g)}≠⌀,{g∈𝒢∞(N):Kg≤0}=⌀.\bigl\{g\in\mathcal G^\infty(N):\mathcal N(g)\bigr\}\ne\varnothing, \qquad \bigl\{g\in\mathcal G^\infty(N):K_g\le0\bigr\}=\varnothing.(18)✦

What Is Checked

The local assertions are stated over the explicit glued metrics gδg_\delta on MM, their endpoint cometrics, and geodesics on arbitrary open intervals; the uniform assertion concerns the full neck family.

The surface and circle quotient projections, and the torus cylinder projection, are smooth covering maps. Their deck actions are smooth isometries of the respective lifted metrics. The chosen quotient sections are right inverses to projection, and the cylinder local inverses are smooth.✦ The horoball quotient and cylinder projections have equal fibers.✦

The shear cutoff χ\chi is smooth on ℝ\mathbb R.✦ For every real length parameter Λ\Lambda, both the radial cylinder reparametrization and its lift to ℝ×ℝ2\mathbb R\times\mathbb R^2 are smooth. The reversing cylinder map 𝜍\varsigma and its inverse are smooth.

The triangular frame depends smoothly on the point✦ and is invertible when its radii are nonzero. Its pullback of the Euclidean bilinear form is smooth and positive definite, with bounded unit balls. For Λ≥4\Lambda\ge4, the radial profile has positive slope✦, and the differential of its lift is the linear dilation of the height component by that slope✦; the lift commutes with the cylinder projection.✦ The matching period is positive✦, and Λℓ≥4\Lambda_\ell\ge4 for the allowed parameters.✦

The descended and glued tangent inner products are smooth, symmetric and positive definite, and their unit balls are bounded.

The product cusp charts are smooth with invertible differential. The logarithmic height changes and their inverses are smooth✦. Below height 1/41/4, the cylindrical metrics have the cusp formula dt2+e−2tdx2+c2dy2dt^2+e^{-2t}dx^2+c^2dy^2, with c=cℓc=c_\ell and c=crc=c_r on the left and right, respectively. The core and cusp domains cover the whole product piece✦ and their local metrics agree on overlaps.✦ The piece inclusions are smooth with invertible differential; the open piece charts cover MM✦, their inverses are smooth, and the two piece metrics agree on their overlap.✦