OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. From passages to absence of conjugate points

Proposition 6.1 [Assembly of passage estimates]: An integral decomposition and its application to the intrinsic index on open time domains

Assembling nonnegative passage integrals.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Along a curve in a three-manifold, the times spent in an open region divide into passages. The assembly question concerns the index integral over all time when its integral on each passage is controlled separately.

A passage JJ of a time set A⊆ℝA\subseteq\mathbb R is a connected component of AA containing a point of AA. Write 𝒫(A)\mathcal P(A) for the family in (1), where CA(s)C_A(s) denotes the connected component of AA containing ss. 𝒫(A)={CA(s):s∈A}.\mathcal P(A)=\{C_A(s):s\in A\}.(1)✦

Let MM be a smooth three-manifold modeled on ℝ3\mathbb R^3. A Riemannian metric gg on MM is a smooth assignment of inner products gqg_q to the tangent spaces TqMT_qM.✦ For real normed vector spaces V,WV,W, a continuous bilinear form bb on WW, and a continuous linear map B:V→WB:V\to W, the pullback B*bB^*b is the bilinear form on VV in (2).✦ For a map F:N→MF:N\to M of smooth manifolds, the pullback tangent inner product F*gF^*g is the bilinear form on the tangent spaces of NN given in the second part of (2).✦ (B*b)(u,v)=b(Bu,Bv),(F*g)q(u,v)=gF(q)(dFqu,dFqv).\begin{aligned} (B^*b)(u,v)&=b(Bu,Bv),\\ (F^*g)_q(u,v)&=g_{F(q)}(dF_q u,dF_q v). \end{aligned}(2)

All coordinate indices range over {0,1,2}\{0,1,2\}, and eie_i is the standard basis vector with component 11 at ii and 00 elsewhere.✦ For an atlas chart cc, the metric in chart coordinates is Gc=(c−1)*gG_c=(c^{-1})^*g.✦ The metric matrix (gij)(g_{ij}) of GcG_c and the coordinate derivative ∂ih\partial_i h of a function h:ℝ3→ℝh:\mathbb R^3\to\mathbb R are defined by (3). gij(x)=Gc(x)(ei,ej),∂ih(x)=dhx(ei).g_{ij}(x)=G_c(x)(e_i,e_j), \qquad \partial_i h(x)=dh_x(e_i).(3)

Write (gij)=(gij)−1(g^{ij})=(g_{ij})^{-1}. The Christoffel symbols Γjki\Gamma^i_{jk} of gg in cc, and the connection term Γc(x)(u,v)∈ℝ3\Gamma_c(x)(u,v)\in\mathbb R^3, are the quantities in (4). Γjki=12∑lgil(∂jglk+∂kglj−∂lgjk),(Γc(x)(u,v))i=∑j,kΓjki(x)ujvk.\begin{aligned} \Gamma^i_{jk} &=\frac12\sum_l g^{il} (\partial_jg_{lk}+\partial_kg_{lj}-\partial_lg_{jk}),\\ \bigl(\Gamma_c(x)(u,v)\bigr)^i &=\sum_{j,k}\Gamma^i_{jk}(x)u^jv^k. \end{aligned}(4)

The curvature components RlkijR^l{}_{kij} of gg in a chart cc are the scalar functions in the first line of (5). The coordinate curvature operator Rc(x)(u,v)wR_c(x)(u,v)w of gg in cc is the trilinear function of the coordinate vectors u,v,wu,v,w in the second line of (5). Rlkij=∂iΓjkl−∂jΓikl+∑a(ΓialΓjka−ΓjalΓika),(Rc(x)(u,v)w)l=∑k,i,jRlkij(x)wkuivj.\begin{aligned} R^l{}_{kij} &=\partial_i\Gamma^l_{jk}-\partial_j\Gamma^l_{ik} +\sum_a\bigl(\Gamma^l_{ia}\Gamma^a_{jk} -\Gamma^l_{ja}\Gamma^a_{ik}\bigr),\\ \bigl(R_c(x)(u,v)w\bigr)^l &=\sum_{k,i,j}R^l{}_{kij}(x)w^ku^iv^j. \end{aligned}(5)

The metric gg has nonpositive sectional curvature at q∈Mq\in M when (6) holds for every atlas chart cc containing qq and every u,v∈ℝ3u,v\in\mathbb R^3. Gc(c(q))(Rc(c(q))(u,v)v,u)≤0.G_c(c(q))\bigl(R_c(c(q))(u,v)v,u\bigr)\leq0.(6)✦

The Index Density

Let γ:ℝ→M\gamma:\mathbb R\to M be a curve and U⊆ℝU\subseteq\mathbb R a set of times. A tangent field JJ along γ\gamma assigns J(s)∈Tγ(s)MJ(s)\in T_{\gamma(s)}M to each ss. Its vector field coordinates in a chart cc are wc(s)=dcγ(s)J(s)w_c(s)=dc_{\gamma(s)}J(s).✦ A tangent field JJ along γ\gamma is smooth on UU when its coordinate expression wcw_c is smooth on U∩γ−1(dom⁡c)U\cap\gamma^{-1}(\operatorname{dom}c) for every atlas chart cc.✦ The family 𝒱U(γ)\mathcal V_U(\gamma) consists of tangent fields along γ\gamma that are smooth on UU and whose closed support is compact and contained in UU.

For a coordinate curve x:ℝ→ℝ3x:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R^3 and a coordinate field w:ℝ→ℝ3w:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R^3, the coordinate covariant derivative DscwD_s^c w is the vector in the first line of (7).✦ Let RR denote the curvature tensor of gg; with xc=c∘γx_c=c\circ\gamma and cc the chart at γ(s)\gamma(s), the covariant derivative DsJD_sJ and the curvature term ℛγJ(s)=R(J,γ̇)γ̇\mathcal R_\gamma J(s)=R(J,\dot\gamma)\dot\gamma are the transported vectors in the remaining lines of (7). Dscw=w′(s)+Γc(x(s))(x′(s),w(s)),DsJ=d(c−1)xc(s)(Dscwc),ℛγJ(s)=d(c−1)xc(s)(Rc(xc(s))(wc(s),xc′(s))xc′(s)).\begin{aligned} D_s^c w&=w'(s)+\Gamma_c(x(s))(x'(s),w(s)),\\ D_sJ&=d(c^{-1})_{x_c(s)}\bigl(D_s^c w_c\bigr),\\ \mathcal R_\gamma J(s) &=d(c^{-1})_{x_c(s)} \bigl(R_c(x_c(s))(w_c(s),x_c'(s))x_c'(s)\bigr). \end{aligned}(7)

For tangent fields J,HJ,H along γ\gamma, the index density i(J,H;s)i(J,H;s) and the intrinsic index form I(J,H)I(J,H) are defined in (8). For a time set BB, IBI_B denotes the restricted integral there. i(J,H;s)=gγ(s)(DsJ,DsH)−gγ(s)(ℛγJ(s),H(s)),IB(J,H)=∫Bi(J,H;s)ds,I(J,H)=Iℝ(J,H).\begin{aligned} i(J,H;s) &=g_{\gamma(s)}(D_sJ,D_sH) -g_{\gamma(s)}(\mathcal R_\gamma J(s),H(s)),\\ I_B(J,H)&=\int_B i(J,H;s)\,ds, \qquad I(J,H)=I_{\mathbb R}(J,H). \end{aligned}(8)

The intrinsic index form II along γ\gamma is nonnegative on UU when I(J,J)≥0I(J,J)\geq0 for every J∈𝒱U(γ)J\in\mathcal V_U(\gamma).✦ For a unit-speed geodesic γ\gamma, a tangent field JJ along γ\gamma, and a time set BB, the normal index IB⟂(J)I_B^\perp(J) is the scalar in (9). IB⟂(J)=IB(J,J)−∫B(ddsgγ(s)(J(s),γ̇(s)))2ds.I_B^\perp(J)=I_B(J,J) -\int_B\left(\frac{d}{ds}g_{\gamma(s)}(J(s),\dot\gamma(s))\right)^2\,ds.(9)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let A⊆ℝA\subseteq\mathbb R be open. For an integrable function f:ℝ→ℝf:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R, the convergent passage sum and the complementary integral satisfy (10). ∑J∈𝒫(A)∫Jf(s)ds=∫Af(s)ds,∫Af(s)ds+∫ℝ\Af(s)ds=∫ℝf(s)ds.\sum_{J\in\mathcal P(A)}\int_J f(s)\,ds=\int_A f(s)\,ds, \qquad \int_A f(s)\,ds+\int_{\mathbb R\setminus A}f(s)\,ds =\int_{\mathbb R}f(s)\,ds.(10)✦

If this integrable ff has ∫Jf(s)ds≥0\int_J f(s)\,ds\geq0 for every J∈𝒫(A)J\in\mathcal P(A) and f(s)≥0f(s)\geq0 for s∉As\notin A, its total integral satisfies (11). ∫ℝf(s)ds≥0.\int_{\mathbb R}f(s)\,ds\geq0.(11)✦

For a continuous compactly supported ff, the same passage and complementary inequalities give (12). ∫ℝf(s)ds≥0.\int_{\mathbb R}f(s)\,ds\geq0.(12)✦

Let gg be a smooth Riemannian metric on a three-manifold MM, and let O⊆MO\subseteq M be open, with nonpositive sectional curvature at every point outside OO. Let U⊆ℝU\subseteq\mathbb R be open and γ:ℝ→M\gamma:\mathbb R\to M smooth on UU. Suppose IJ(V,V)≥0I_J(V,V)\geq0 for every V∈𝒱U(γ)V\in\mathcal V_U(\gamma) and every passage JJ of U∩γ−1(O)U\cap\gamma^{-1}(O). Then the index form satisfies (13). I(V,V)≥0for every V∈𝒱U(γ).I(V,V)\geq0 \qquad\text{for every }V\in\mathcal V_U(\gamma).(13)✦

In the paper, the result reads: on a complete smooth Riemannian manifold (M,g)(M,g), if O⊆MO\subseteq M is open, sectional curvature is nonpositive on M\OM\setminus O, and IJ(V,V)≥0I_J(V,V)\geq0 for every complete unit-speed geodesic γ:ℝ→M\gamma:\mathbb R\to M, every passage JJ of γ−1(O)\gamma^{-1}(O), and every smooth compactly supported field VV along γ\gamma, then Iℝ(V,V)≥0I_{\mathbb R}(V,V)\geq0 for all such γ,V\gamma,V, with the same conclusion under the stronger passage hypothesis IJ⟂(V)≥0I_J^\perp(V)\geq0.

What Is Checked

The scalar statements are over integrable real densities, including continuous densities of compact support, on the real line and passages of open time sets; the intrinsic statement is over smooth Riemannian metrics on three-manifolds and curves smooth on arbitrary open time domains, with smooth tangent fields whose compact closed support lies in the time domain.