OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. Introduction · §1.1

Lemma 1.2: For bounded operators on a complex Hilbert space ℋ\mathcal H; a nonzero quasinilpotent operator fails to commute with some operator in B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H)

Commutants are strongly closed; only scalars commute with everything.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let ℋ\mathcal H be a complex Hilbert space, B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H) the algebra of bounded operators on ℋ\mathcal H and II the identity operator. Whether an operator T∈B(ℋ)T \in B(\mathcal H) has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace, a closed subspace other than 00 and ℋ\mathcal H invariant under every operator commuting with TT, is a question about the algebra of the operators that commute with TT. A scalar operator cIcI commutes with every operator in B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H), so every closed subspace is hyperinvariant for it, and the question is about nonscalar operators.

Definitions

The commutant {T}′\{T\}' of an operator T∈B(ℋ)T \in B(\mathcal H) is the centralizer of TT in B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H), the unital complex subalgebra of the operators that commute with TT: {T}′={A∈B(ℋ):AT=TA}.\{T\}' = \{A \in B(\mathcal H) : AT = TA\}.(1)✦

The strong operator topology (SOT) on B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H) is the topology induced by the maps A↦AxA \mapsto Ax from B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H) to ℋ\mathcal H, one for each x∈ℋx \in \mathcal H.✦

An operator T∈B(ℋ)T \in B(\mathcal H) is quasinilpotent when limn→∞∥Tn∥1/n=0.\lim_{n \to \infty} \|T^n\|^{1/n} = 0.(2)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let ℋ\mathcal H be a complex Hilbert space and T∈B(ℋ)T \in B(\mathcal H).

  1. The commutant of TT is closed in the strong operator topology: {T}′¯SOT={T}′.\overline{\{T\}'}^{\,\mathrm{SOT}} = \{T\}'.(3)✦

  2. If every bounded operator on ℋ\mathcal H commutes with TT, then TT is a scalar multiple of the identity: T=cIfor some c∈ℂ.T = cI \quad \text{for some } c \in \mathbb C.(4)✦

  3. If ℋ≠0\mathcal H \neq 0 and TT is nonzero and quasinilpotent, then some bounded operator on ℋ\mathcal H does not commute with TT: AT≠TAfor some A∈B(ℋ).AT \neq TA \quad \text{for some } A \in B(\mathcal H).(5)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if T∈B(ℋ)T \in B(\mathcal H) is nonscalar, then {T}′\{T\}' is a proper, strong-operator closed, unital complex algebra, and it is transitive exactly when TT has no nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over the commutant (1), a unital complex subalgebra of B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H), and over the strong operator topology on B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H) induced by the maps A↦AxA \mapsto Ax; its part (iii) takes quasinilpotence in the norm form (2).