OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. Introduction · §1.1

Corollary 1.4: On every separable infinite-dimensional complex Hilbert space, an operator TT whose commutant {T}′\{T\}' is transitive, proper and closed in the strong operator topology

A nonzero quasinilpotent operator with no nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let ℋ\mathcal H be a separable infinite-dimensional complex Hilbert space and B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H) the algebra of bounded operators on it. A closed subspace ℳ\mathcal M of ℋ\mathcal H is hyperinvariant for T∈B(ℋ)T \in B(\mathcal H) when Aℳ⊆ℳA\mathcal M \subseteq \mathcal M for every A∈B(ℋ)A \in B(\mathcal H) that commutes with TT; the subspaces 00 and ℋ\mathcal H always are. The hyperinvariant subspace problem asks whether every operator on ℋ\mathcal H other than a multiple of the identity has a hyperinvariant subspace besides these two. Corollary 1.4 concerns quasinilpotent operators, those with ∥Tn∥1/n→0\|T^n\|^{1/n} \to 0: is there, on every such ℋ\mathcal H, a nonzero one whose only hyperinvariant subspaces are 00 and ℋ\mathcal H?

The library’s concrete operator is the forward operator SS on L2(ℤ2;ℓ2(ℤ))L^2(\mathbb Z_2;\ell^2(\mathbb Z)), where ℤ2\mathbb Z_2 is the ring of 2-adic integers: a field of weighted bilateral shifts on ℓ2(ℤ)\ell^2(\mathbb Z) over ℤ2\mathbb Z_2, with weights built from the residues of x∈ℤ2x \in \mathbb Z_2 modulo powers of 22.

Commutants and Transitivity

The commutant {T}′\{T\}' of an operator TT on a complex Hilbert space ℋ\mathcal H is the unital subalgebra of B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H) of the operators commuting with TT, the centralizer of TT: {T}′={A∈B(ℋ):AT=TA}.\{T\}' = \{A \in B(\mathcal H) : AT = TA\}.(1)✦ An operator T∈B(ℋ)T \in B(\mathcal H) has a transitive commutant when its only hyperinvariant subspaces are 00 and ℋ\mathcal H: ℳ⊆ℋ closed,Aℳ⊆ℳ for all A∈{T}′⇒ℳ=0 or ℳ=ℋ.\mathcal M \subseteq \mathcal H \text{ closed}, \quad A\mathcal M \subseteq \mathcal M \text{ for all } A \in \{T\}' \quad \Longrightarrow \quad \mathcal M = 0 \text{ or } \mathcal M = \mathcal H.(2)✦

The strong operator topology on B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H) is the topology induced by the maps A↦AxA \mapsto Ax from B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H) to ℋ\mathcal H, one for each x∈ℋx \in \mathcal H.✦

The Forward Operator

The 2-adic integers ℤ2\mathbb Z_2 carry the completion μ\mu of their Haar measure, normalized by μ(ℤ2)=1\mu(\mathbb Z_2) = 1.✦ The fiber is ℓ2(ℤ)\ell^2(\mathbb Z), with standard basis (ej)j∈ℤ(e_j)_{j \in \mathbb Z}✦, and L2(ℤ2;ℓ2(ℤ))L^2(\mathbb Z_2;\ell^2(\mathbb Z)) is the Hilbert space of square-integrable functions from (ℤ2,μ)(\mathbb Z_2,\mu) to ℓ2(ℤ)\ell^2(\mathbb Z)✦.

For x∈ℤ2x \in \mathbb Z_2 and m≥0m \ge 0, the residue rm(x)r_m(x) is the integer in {0,1,…,2m−1}\{0, 1, \dots, 2^m - 1\} congruent to xx modulo 2m2^m. The plus and minus residue sequences of xx are tx(m)=rm(x)t_x(m) = r_m(x)✦ and ux(m)=2m−1−rm(x)u_x(m) = 2^m - 1 - r_m(x)✦.

For an integer k≥1k \ge 1, the block of kk is b(k)=⌊log⁡8k⌋+1b(k) = \lfloor \log_8 k \rfloor + 1✦ and its scale is 2b(k)2^{b(k)}✦. For a sequence tt of natural numbers, the half exponent hth_t and its correction term ctc_t are the functions on k≥0k \ge 0 given by ht(k)=10(k+1)+ct(k),ct(0)=0,ct(k)=100(2b(k)−2+t(b(k)))(k≥1).h_t(k) = 10(k+1) + c_t(k), \qquad c_t(0) = 0, \qquad c_t(k) = 100\bigl(2^{b(k)} - 2 + t(b(k))\bigr) \quad (k \ge 1).(3) For two such sequences tt and uu, the bilateral exponent Et,uE_{t,u} on ℤ\mathbb Z equals ht(j)h_t(j) at j≥0j \ge 0 and hu(−j−1)h_u(-j-1) at j≤−1j \le -1, with hh as in (3)✦, and the bilateral weight is βt,u=e−Et,u\beta_{t,u} = e^{-E_{t,u}}✦. The weight sequence of x∈ℤ2x \in \mathbb Z_2 is the bilateral weight of its residue sequences: βx(j)=βtx,ux(j)={e−htx(j),j≥0,e−hux(−j−1),j≤−1.\beta_x(j) = \beta_{t_x,u_x}(j) = \begin{cases} e^{-h_{t_x}(j)}, & j \ge 0,\\ e^{-h_{u_x}(-j-1)}, & j \le -1. \end{cases}(4)✦

For a sequence aa on ℤ\mathbb Z with |a(j)|≤C|a(j)| \le C for all jj, the diagonal operator DaD_a on ℓ2(ℤ)\ell^2(\mathbb Z) is (Dav)(j)=a(j)v(j)(D_a v)(j) = a(j)\,v(j), and ∥Dav∥≤C∥v∥\|D_a v\| \le C\|v\|✦. For a bijection σ\sigma of ℤ\mathbb Z, the permutation unitary PσP_\sigma on ℓ2(ℤ)\ell^2(\mathbb Z) is (Pσv)(j)=v(σ(j))(P_\sigma v)(j) = v(\sigma(j)), and the weighted permutation operator of σ\sigma and aa is PσDaP_\sigma D_a✦. The forward fiber SxS_x at x∈ℤ2x \in \mathbb Z_2 is the weighted permutation operator of σ(j)=j−1\sigma(j) = j - 1 and the weights βx\beta_x of (4), the weighted bilateral shift Sxej=βx(j)ej+1,j∈ℤ.S_x e_j = \beta_x(j)\, e_{j+1}, \qquad j \in \mathbb Z.(5)✦

For a measure space XX and C≥0C \ge 0, let x↦Axx \mapsto A_x be a field of operators on ℓ2(ℤ)\ell^2(\mathbb Z) with ∥Ax∥≤C\|A_x\| \le C for every x∈Xx \in X, such that x↦Axf(x)x \mapsto A_x f(x) is measurable whenever f:X→ℓ2(ℤ)f \colon X \to \ell^2(\mathbb Z) is. The decomposable operator of the field is the operator AA on L2(X;ℓ2(ℤ))L^2(X;\ell^2(\mathbb Z)) given by (Af)(x)=Axf(x)(Af)(x) = A_x f(x), and it satisfies ∥Af∥≤C∥f∥\|Af\| \le C\|f\|✦. The fibers (5) satisfy ∥Sx∥≤e−10\|S_x\| \le e^{-10}✦, and x↦Sxf(x)x \mapsto S_x f(x) is measurable whenever f:ℤ2→ℓ2(ℤ)f \colon \mathbb Z_2 \to \ell^2(\mathbb Z) is✦. The forward operator SS on L2(ℤ2;ℓ2(ℤ))L^2(\mathbb Z_2;\ell^2(\mathbb Z)) is the decomposable operator of this field, with C=e−10C = e^{-10}: (Sf)(x)=Sxf(x),f∈L2(ℤ2;ℓ2(ℤ)),x∈ℤ2.(Sf)(x) = S_x f(x), \qquad f \in L^2(\mathbb Z_2;\ell^2(\mathbb Z)), \ x \in \mathbb Z_2.(6)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let ℋ\mathcal H be a separable infinite-dimensional complex Hilbert space. Then there is an operator T∈B(ℋ)T \in B(\mathcal H) with T≠0,limn→∞∥Tn∥1/n=0,{T}′ transitive,{T}′≠B(ℋ),{T}′ closed in the strong operator topology.\begin{gathered} T \neq 0, \qquad \lim_{n \to \infty} \|T^n\|^{1/n} = 0, \qquad \{T\}' \text{ transitive},\\ \{T\}' \neq B(\mathcal H), \qquad \{T\}' \text{ closed in the strong operator topology}. \end{gathered}(7)✦

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over an arbitrary separable infinite-dimensional complex Hilbert space ℋ\mathcal H, the commutant (1), transitivity (2) and the strong operator topology on B(ℋ)B(\mathcal H).

For a complex Hilbert space ℋ\mathcal H, the full statement F(ℋ)F(\mathcal H) is that some T∈B(ℋ)T \in B(\mathcal H) satisfies the five conditions of (7)✦, and the main statement M(ℋ)M(\mathcal H) is that some T∈B(ℋ)T \in B(\mathcal H) satisfies the first three✦.

The library proves that the forward operator (6) satisfies S≠0,S \neq 0,(8)✦ limn→∞∥Sn∥1/n=0,\lim_{n \to \infty} \|S^n\|^{1/n} = 0,(9)✦ {S}′ is transitive,\{S\}' \text{ is transitive},(10)✦ on a space with dim⁡L2(ℤ2;ℓ2(ℤ))=∞,\dim L^2(\mathbb Z_2;\ell^2(\mathbb Z)) = \infty,(11)✦ and that the main statement holds on that space: M(L2(ℤ2;ℓ2(ℤ))).M\bigl(L^2(\mathbb Z_2;\ell^2(\mathbb Z))\bigr).(12)✦

Let U:ℋ→𝒦U \colon \mathcal H \to \mathcal K be a unitary between complex Hilbert spaces. For every T∈B(ℋ)T \in B(\mathcal H), {T}′ transitive⇒{UTU*}′ transitive,\{T\}' \text{ transitive} \quad \Longrightarrow \quad \{UTU^*\}' \text{ transitive},(13)✦ and M(ℋ)⇒M(𝒦).M(\mathcal H) \quad \Longrightarrow \quad M(\mathcal K).(14)✦ Between two separable infinite-dimensional complex Hilbert spaces ℋ\mathcal H and 𝒦\mathcal K there is a unitary U:ℋ→𝒦.U \colon \mathcal H \to \mathcal K.(15)✦

On a nonzero complex Hilbert space ℋ\mathcal H, M(ℋ)⇒F(ℋ).M(\mathcal H) \quad \Longrightarrow \quad F(\mathcal H).(16)✦