OctoInformBeta

Invariant projections, hyperinvariant subspaces, and transitive algebras

Let ℋ\mathcal H be a complex Hilbert space and let TT be a bounded operator on ℋ\mathcal H. The commutant of TT is the algebra {T}′={A∈B(ℋ):AT=TA}\{T\}'=\{A\in B(\mathcal H):AT=TA\}. A closed subspace of ℋ\mathcal H is hyperinvariant for TT when every operator in {T}′\{T\}' leaves it invariant. An algebra of operators on ℋ\mathcal H is transitive when its only common closed invariant subspaces are 00 and ℋ\mathcal H. The commutant {T}′\{T\}' is transitive exactly when 00 and ℋ\mathcal H are the only hyperinvariant subspaces of TT. For an irrational θ∈(0,1)\theta\in(0,1), let RθR_\theta be the von Neumann algebra generated, in its tracial representation, by unitaries UU and VV with VU=e2πiθUVVU=e^{2\pi i\theta}UV, its trace τ\tau being determined by τ(1)=1\tau(1)=1 and τ(UkVn)=0\tau(U^kV^n)=0 for (k,n)≠(0,0)(k,n)\neq(0,0). The algebra RθR_\theta is the hyperfinite factor of type II1\mathrm{II}_1. Let mm be normalized Haar measure on the unit circle 𝕋\mathbb T. For a continuous function ff on 𝕋\mathbb T, the weighted rotation with weight ff is the operator Tf=Uf(V)T_f=Uf(V) in RθR_\theta. An invariant projection of TfT_f is a projection p∈Rθp\in R_\theta with (1−p)Tfp=0(1-p)T_fp=0. It is nontrivial when p≠0,1p\neq0,1. The determinant of Fuglede and Kadison of the weight is Δ(f(V))=exp⁡(∫𝕋log⁡|f|dm)\Delta(f(V))=\exp\bigl(\int_{\mathbb T}\log|f|\,dm\bigr), with log⁡0=−∞\log0=-\infty and exp⁡(−∞)=0\exp(-\infty)=0. Zhu, Fang and Shi asked whether TfT_f must have a nontrivial invariant projection when ff is nonzero almost everywhere, |f||f| is not constant and Δ(f(V))=0\Delta(f(V))=0.

The projection onto a hyperinvariant subspace of an operator in a von Neumann algebra ℳ\mathcal M belongs to ℳ\mathcal M, an observation recorded by Dykema. The Brown measure of an operator AA in a factor of type II1\mathrm{II}_1 is the probability measure μA\mu_A on the plane with ∫log⁡|z−λ|dμA(z)=log⁡Δ(A−λ)\int\log|z-\lambda|\,d\mu_A(z)=\log\Delta(A-\lambda) for every λ∈ℂ\lambda\in\mathbb C, Δ\Delta being the determinant of Fuglede and Kadison in the factor. For an operator in a factor of type II1\mathrm{II}_1, Haagerup and Schultz attach to each Borel subset of the plane a hyperinvariant subspace whose projection lies in the factor and has trace equal to the mass the Brown measure of the operator gives that set. For the weighted rotations, Dykema and Schultz identify the Brown measure of TfT_f as the uniform measure on the circle of radius Δ(f(V))\Delta(f(V)). When Δ(f(V))=0\Delta(f(V))=0 this measure is the point mass at 00. Then the projections of Haagerup and Schultz for TfT_f are trivial. The quasinilpotent operator of Dykema and Haagerup is an operator in a factor of type II1\mathrm{II}_1 whose Brown measure is the point mass at 00. Dykema and Haagerup construct a one-parameter family of nontrivial hyperinvariant subspaces, with projections in the factor, for this operator. Tucci constructed quasinilpotent generators of the hyperfinite factor with nontrivial invariant projections. Zhu, Fang and Shi exhibited continuous weights ff with exactly one zero and Δ(f(V))=0\Delta(f(V))=0. For such weights the operator TfT_f is quasinilpotent.

The preprint answers the question of Zhu, Fang and Shi negatively, with the angle prescribed in advance: by its Theorem 1.1, for every irrational θ∈(0,1)\theta\in(0,1) there is a continuous f:𝕋→[0,1]f:\mathbb T\to[0,1] with f−1({0})={1}f^{-1}(\{0\})=\{1\} and ∫𝕋log⁡fdm=−∞\int_{\mathbb T}\log f\,dm=-\infty whose weighted rotation TfT_f has no nontrivial invariant projection. The preprint derives from it its Corollary 1.4: every separable infinite-dimensional complex Hilbert space carries a nonzero operator TT with ∥Tn∥1/n→0\|T^n\|^{1/n}\to0 whose commutant is transitive.

The Lean library BackwardIntertwiners contains the preprint’s Lemma 1.2, on the commutant as a strongly closed unital algebra, and its Corollary 1.4, but not its Theorem 1.1. The Lean library has two theorems of its own, which are not results of the preprint. They concern the direct model of a companion work, Backward intertwiners and a transitive commutant, which the preprint cites. Let ℤ2\mathbb Z_2 be the 22-adic integers with Haar measure. Let (ej)j∈ℤ(e_j)_{j\in\mathbb Z} be the standard basis of ℓ2(ℤ)\ell^2(\mathbb Z). The forward operator SS of the direct model is the operator on L2(ℤ2;ℓ2(ℤ))L^2(\mathbb Z_2;\ell^2(\mathbb Z)) that acts on the fiber at each x∈ℤ2x\in\mathbb Z_2 as the weighted bilateral shift ej↦βx(j)ej+1e_j\mapsto\beta_x(j)e_{j+1}, whose weights βx(j)\beta_x(j) are read from the 22-adic digits of xx. The backward operator of the direct model is the operator that carries the fiber at xx to the fiber at x+1x+1 by ej↦bx(j)ej−1e_j\mapsto b_x(j)e_{j-1}, with coefficients bx(j)∈[0,1]b_x(j)\in[0,1] fixed by the direct model. The backward operator commutes with SS. The powers of SS satisfy ∥Sn∥≤exp⁡(−10⌊(n+1)2/4⌋)\|S^n\|\le\exp(-10\lfloor(n+1)^2/4\rfloor) for n≥1n\ge1. The first theorem of the Lean library is that the algebra generated by SS, the backward operator and the multiplications by functions in L∞(ℤ2)L^\infty(\mathbb Z_2) is transitive. In the Lean library, the operator of Corollary 1.4 is built from this SS. The second theorem of the Lean library gives closed invariant subspaces of SS that the backward operator does not preserve. Let WW be the unweighted shift that acts on each fiber as ej↦ej+1e_j\mapsto e_{j+1}. The second theorem also gives the atomic and diffuse algebras generated by the conjugates of |S||S| under the powers of WW. Lean has checked every result of the Lean library, so the Lean library is the reference. Each result on these pages is stated as the Lean library states it and linked to the Lean declaration behind it, with the preprint’s statement beside it where the two differ. The preprint is a guide only: it gives the results their order and their names.