The Setting
Let be a complex Hilbert space, the algebra of bounded operators on and the identity operator. Whether an operator has a nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace, a closed subspace other than and invariant under every operator commuting with , is a question about the algebra of the operators that commute with . A scalar operator commutes with every operator in , so every closed subspace is hyperinvariant for it, and the question is about nonscalar operators.
Definitions
The commutant of an operator is the centralizer of in , the unital complex subalgebra of the operators that commute with : (1)✦
The strong operator topology (SOT) on is the topology induced by the maps from to , one for each .✦
An operator is quasinilpotent when (2)
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be a complex Hilbert space and .
The commutant of is closed in the strong operator topology: (3)✦
If every bounded operator on commutes with , then is a scalar multiple of the identity: (4)✦
If and is nonzero and quasinilpotent, then some bounded operator on does not commute with : (5)✦
In the paper, the result reads: if is nonscalar, then is a proper, strong-operator closed, unital complex algebra, and it is transitive exactly when has no nontrivial hyperinvariant subspace.
What Is Checked
The claim is stated over the commutant (1), a unital complex subalgebra of , and over the strong operator topology on induced by the maps ; its part (iii) takes quasinilpotence in the norm form (2).