OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · Section 1. Introduction

Theorem 1.1: Nonamenable groups admit counterexamples with bounds arbitrarily close to one, with separable Hilbert spaces for countable groups

Amenability characterizes unitarizable discrete groups.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let GG be a discrete group. The question for a uniformly bounded representation is whether a common operator norm bound can be replaced, after one similarity, by preservation of every vector norm.

For a complex Hilbert space HH, write ℬ(H)\mathcal B(H) for the bounded complex-linear operators on HH. A representation π\pi of GG on HH is a map into ℬ(H)\mathcal B(H) satisfying (1); its operator inverses are supplied by the group inverse. π(e)=IH,π(gh)=π(g)π(h),π(g)−1=π(g−1).\pi(e)=I_H,\qquad \pi(gh)=\pi(g)\pi(h),\qquad \pi(g)^{-1}=\pi(g^{-1}).(1) A representation π\pi on HH is uniformly bounded if there is a real number CC such that (2) holds. ∥π(g)∥≤C(g∈G).\|\pi(g)\|\leq C\qquad(g\in G).(2)

Invariant Means and Similarity

The space ℓ∞(G)\ell^\infty(G) consists of the bounded complex-valued functions on GG. For g∈Gg\in G, the left translation LgL_g on ℓ∞(G)\ell^\infty(G) is the operator defined by (3). Lgf(x)=f(g−1x)(x∈G).L_gf(x)=f(g^{-1}x)\qquad(x\in G).(3)✦ The group GG is amenable if there is a complex-linear functional m:ℓ∞(G)→ℂm:\ell^\infty(G)\to\mathbb C satisfying (4), where f≥0f\geq0 means that every value of ff is real and nonnegative. m(1)=1,m(f)≥0if f≥0,m(Lgf)=m(f)(g∈G,f∈ℓ∞(G)).m(1)=1,\qquad m(f)\geq0\ \text{if }f\geq0,\qquad m(L_gf)=m(f)\quad(g\in G,\ f\in\ell^\infty(G)).(4)✦

A representation π\pi of GG on a complex inner-product space HH is similar to a unitary representation if there is an invertible bounded complex-linear operator SS on HH with bounded inverse satisfying (5). ∥Sπ(g)S−1x∥=∥x∥(g∈G,x∈H).\|S\pi(g)S^{-1}x\|=\|x\|\qquad(g\in G,\ x\in H).(5)✦ The group GG is unitarizable if every uniformly bounded representation of GG on a complex Hilbert space is similar to a unitary representation.✦

For a real number aa, a counterexample with bound aa for GG is a pair (H,π)(H,\pi), where HH is a complex Hilbert space and π\pi is a representation of GG on HH, satisfying (6). ∥π(g)∥≤a(g∈G),π is not similar to a unitary representation.\|\pi(g)\|\leq a\quad(g\in G),\qquad \pi\text{ is not similar to a unitary representation}.(6) For a discrete group GG and a real number aa, write 𝒲a(G)\mathscr W_a(G) for the collection of counterexamples with bound aa for GG and 𝒲asep(G)\mathscr W_a^{\mathrm{sep}}(G) for the subcollection of pairs (H,π)(H,\pi) with HH separable. Let 𝒲ac(G)\mathscr W_a^{\mathrm c}(G) consist of the pairs in 𝒲a(G)\mathscr W_a(G) for which HH is separable whenever GG is countable. A separable 101101 counterexample (H,π)(H,\pi) for GG is a member of 𝒲101sep(G)\mathscr W_{101}^{\mathrm{sep}}(G).

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let GG be a discrete group. Then (7) holds. G is amenable⇔G is unitarizable.G\text{ is amenable}\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad G\text{ is unitarizable}.(7)✦ For a nonamenable discrete group GG and ε>0\varepsilon>0, the near-one counterexample assertion is (8). 𝒲1+εc(G)≠⌀.\mathscr W_{1+\varepsilon}^{\mathrm c}(G)\ne\varnothing.(8)✦ For a nonamenable discrete group GG and ε>0\varepsilon>0, the near-one counterexample assertion also holds in the form (9). 𝒲1+εc(G)≠⌀.\mathscr W_{1+\varepsilon}^{\mathrm c}(G)\ne\varnothing.(9)✦ G is unitarizable.G\text{ is unitarizable}.(10) For a countable nonamenable discrete group GG, the separable 101101 witness assertion is (11). 𝒲101sep(G)≠⌀.\mathscr W_{101}^{\mathrm{sep}}(G)\ne\varnothing.(11)✦ For a nonamenable discrete group GG, the 101101 counterexample assertion is (12). 𝒲101sep(G)≠⌀.\mathscr W_{101}^{\mathrm{sep}}(G)\ne\varnothing.(12)✦ For a nonamenable discrete group GG, the 101101 counterexample assertion also holds in the form (13). 𝒲101sep(G)≠⌀.\mathscr W_{101}^{\mathrm{sep}}(G)\ne\varnothing.(13)✦

In the paper, the result reads: a discrete group is amenable if and only if it is unitarizable, and for every discrete nonamenable group GG and every ε>0\varepsilon>0 there are a complex Hilbert space HH and a representation π:G→GL(H)\pi:G\to\mathrm{GL}(H) that is not similar to a unitary representation and satisfies ∥π(g)∥≤1+ε\|\pi(g)\|\leq1+\varepsilon for every g∈Gg\in G, where GL(H)\mathrm{GL}(H) is the group of invertible bounded complex-linear operators on HH, with HH separable when GG is countable.

What Is Checked

The assertions are stated over discrete groups, with amenability given by (4) and unitarizability defined using representations as in (1) on complete complex Hilbert spaces.