The Setting
Let be a unital inclusion of -algebras, given by a unital -homomorphism , with written , and let be a finite set of unitaries of . The question is whether contains a projection that almost commutes with each and takes half of it in every trace, uniformly over the tracial states of : the commutator small in the -norm of , and close to . A projection of this kind is a finite-set form of the tracial halving that uniform property asks for. Theorem 1.3 answers the question from real rank zero and small full projections in , and from nuclearity of or, in its second form, from the existence of positive diagonals of , defined below.
Tracial States and Uniform Norms
A tracial state on is a positive linear functional with and for all , and is the set of tracial states of .✦ The trace -norm of at and the uniform -norm of are (1)
The uniform halving error of an element at is the number .✦
Real Rank Zero, Fullness and Nuclearity
A -algebra has real rank zero when every self-adjoint element of is a norm limit of self-adjoint elements of with finite spectrum.✦ An element of is full when the closure of the two-sided ideal of generated by is all of .✦
A -norm on a complex -algebra is a submultiplicative algebra norm on with for every .✦ A -algebra is nuclear when, for every -algebra , the algebraic tensor product carries at most one -norm.✦
Positive Diagonals
Take real weights and elements of . The weighted conjugation average of the weights and the elements is the map given by .✦ The algebraic tensor product is spanned by the elementary tensors and is an -bimodule under and . For and in , the diagonal commutator of is the element of : (2)
Write for the unitary group of . A positive diagonal of for a finite set and consists of weights with and elements of of norm at most , with and the map and the element of built from them as above, such that (3)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be a -algebra of real rank zero with nonempty, and suppose that for every there is a full projection with . Let be a unital -homomorphism, a finite set of unitaries of and .
If is injective and is nuclear, there is a projection with (4)✦
If has a positive diagonal for every finite set of unitaries of and every , there is a projection with (5)✦
What Is Checked
Both claims are stated over the tracial states of , the -norms (1), the uniform halving error, full projections and real rank zero; (4) adds nuclearity, defined through -norms on , and (5) adds the positive diagonals (3).