The Setting
Take a separable, simple, nuclear -algebra with a tracial state, its uniform tracial completion , and the ultrapower of along a free ultrafilter on . Two properties are read off : real rank zero, which supplies projections in in abundance, and uniform property , which asks for one projection there that commutes with and halves its traces. The question is whether the first forces the second.
The library states the theorem over the completion and the ultrapower built below, and in a second, self-contained form that also asserts five facts on which those constructions rest.
Traces, Ideals and Ultraproducts
A tracial state of a -algebra is a positive linear functional with and for all ; denotes the set of tracial states of .✦ For a nonempty family of tracial states of , the uniform 2-norm of is the supremum of its trace 2-norms: (1)✦
Fix such a family and a filter on a set . A family of elements of is null along if along .✦ A sequence in is uniformly Cauchy if as .✦ Write for the -algebra of norm-bounded families in with the supremum norm, and when .
A closed self-adjoint ideal of a -algebra is a norm-closed two-sided ideal of with ; the quotient map is .✦ If a tracial state of vanishes on , its descended trace is the tracial state of .✦ The null ideal is the closed self-adjoint ideal of formed by the bounded families null along .✦
For a unital -homomorphism and , the pullback is a tracial state of .✦ For tracial states of and an ultrafilter on , the ultraproduct trace is the tracial state of given by (2)✦
The Uniform Tracial Completion and Its Ultrapower
Keep and the family . The Cauchy algebra is the unital -subalgebra of formed by the uniformly Cauchy sequences✦, and its Cauchy null ideal is , where is the null ideal along the filter of cofinite subsets of .✦ The uniform tracial completion of with respect to is the quotient (3)✦
Fix a free ultrafilter on , one containing every cofinite set. For , the Cauchy trace of is the tracial state of , the pullback along the inclusion of the ultraproduct trace of the constant family .✦ The completion trace of is the tracial state of descended from the Cauchy trace of .✦
Let be an ultrafilter on . The ultrapower of along is the quotient by the null ideal along , (4)✦ The diagonal embedding of into is the unital -homomorphism that sends to the class of the constant family . For a map , the limit trace is the tracial state of descended from the ultraproduct trace of : (5)✦
In the theorem, is the uniform tracial completion of with respect to all of , and is the completion trace of . For a free ultrafilter on , is the ultrapower of along with respect to the family , an element stands for its image under the diagonal embedding, and is the set of limit traces of the sequences in .
The Hypotheses
A -algebra is simple if its only closed two-sided ideals are and .✦ A -norm on a -algebra is an algebra norm on with for all .✦ Nuclearity of a -algebra means that, for every -algebra , the algebraic tensor product carries at most one -norm.✦ A -algebra is stably finite if, for every , each with satisfies .✦ Finally, a -algebra has real rank zero if for every self-adjoint and every there is a self-adjoint with finite spectrum and .✦
The Self-contained Form
The five facts are labelled (N), (Z), (C), (L) and (T) in the order listed below. For every -algebra , every nonempty family of tracial states of and every set :
for every closed self-adjoint ideal of and all , the quotient norm satisfies , and ✦;
for every filter on , the families null along contain , are closed under sums, negatives and adjoints and under products with a bounded family on either side, and the bounded ones form a closed subset of ✦;
constant sequences are uniformly Cauchy, uniformly Cauchy sequences are closed under sums and adjoints, products of bounded uniformly Cauchy sequences are uniformly Cauchy, and the bounded ones form a closed subset of ✦;
for tracial states of , an ultrafilter on and , the limit exists✦;
for an ultrafilter on and a map , the ultraproduct trace of vanishes on every bounded family null along .✦
The Claim
Theorem 1 (Real rank zero and uniform property ). Let be a separable, simple, infinite-dimensional, nuclear and stably finite -algebra with a tracial state, its uniform tracial completion and a free ultrafilter on . If has real rank zero, then has uniform property at ✦: there is a projection such that (6)✦ Let be this statement, taken over every such and ✦, and the same statement with , and built from (N), (Z), (C), (L) and (T).✦ Then (7)✦ and, with the assertion (7), both and are equivalent to : (8)✦ (9)✦
What Is Checked
The theorem is stated over a separable, simple, infinite-dimensional, nuclear and stably finite -algebra with a tracial state, its uniform tracial completion with the completion traces , the ultrapower along a free ultrafilter with the diagonal embedding and the limit traces , and real rank zero; its self-contained form is stated over the facts (N), (Z), (C), (L) and (T) and the same constructions built from them.
The library proves that the five facts hold for the quotient norm, the null families, the uniformly Cauchy sequences and the ultraproduct traces defined above. It proves as well that a tracial state vanishing on a closed self-adjoint ideal takes the same value at two elements whose difference lies in the ideal, that the zero family is null✦ and the adjoint of a bounded null family is null✦, that is additive✦ and homogeneous in ✦, that the ultraproduct trace of vanishes on ✦, and that the Cauchy trace of vanishes on the Cauchy null ideal.✦