OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · 2. From a completed cone to its exceptional surface

Section 2.3 (setting): Double duals on the source model and the completed blowup, with rank comparisons over a formal power series ring AA

Finite depth-three modules admit exceptional models.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A module on a completed cone can be pulled back to a scheme containing its exceptional surface. The constructions here use both a model obtained from the surface over ℙℂ2\mathbb P^2_{\mathbb C} and the blowup of the completed section ideal.

Let K=ℂ(x0,x1)K=\mathbb C(x_0,x_1), the fraction field of ℂ[x0,x1]\mathbb C[x_0,x_1], and let (a0,…,a4)(a_0,\ldots,a_4) be the images in KK of the five line equations in (1): (x0,x1,x0−1,x1−1,x0−x1).(x_0,\ x_1,\ x_0-1,\ x_1-1,\ x_0-x_1).(1) For a prime pp, choose ppth roots of these elements in an algebraic closure of KK; the Kummer root field is the intermediate field generated by those chosen roots.✦ The concrete field LL and its augmented root family are given by (2): L=K(y0,…,y4),yi7=ai,(z0,z1,…,z5)=(1,y0,…,y4).L=K(y_0,\ldots,y_4),\qquad y_i^7=a_i,\qquad (z_0,z_1,\ldots,z_5)=(1,y_0,\ldots,y_4).(2) Set (α0,β0)=(1,4)(\alpha_0,\beta_0)=(1,4), (α1,β1)=(2,3)(\alpha_1,\beta_1)=(2,3) and (α2,β2)=(5,0)(\alpha_2,\beta_2)=(5,0).✦ Let tt be an indeterminate over LL; the section coefficients sab∈Ls_{ab}\in L and the section algebra B0⊂L[t]B_0\subset L[t] are those of (3), with 0≤a<60\leq a<6 and 0≤b<30\leq b<3: sab=zazαbzβb,B0=ℂ[sabt∣0≤a<6,0≤b<3].s_{ab}=z_a z_{\alpha_b}z_{\beta_b},\qquad B_0=\mathbb C[s_{ab}t\mid 0\leq a<6,\ 0\leq b<3].(3) The normalized coefficient space TnT_n is the complex vector subspace of LL consisting of coefficients whose degree-nn monomials are integral over B0B_0.✦ The graded section algebra CC, completed ring RR and normalized projective surface XX are defined in (4): Tn={c∈L∣ctn∈B0¯L[t]},C={∑ncntn∈L[t]∣cn∈Tn},R={∑n≥0cntn∈L[[t]]∣cn∈Tn},X=Proj⁡C.\begin{gathered} T_n=\{c\in L\mid ct^n\in\overline{B_0}^{\,L[t]}\},\qquad C=\left\{\sum_n c_nt^n\in L[t]\mid c_n\in T_n\right\},\\ R=\left\{\sum_{n\geq0}c_nt^n\in L[[t]]\mid c_n\in T_n\right\}, \qquad X=\operatorname{Proj}C. \end{gathered}(4) The grading on CC consists of its homogeneous monomials, and C→RC\to R sends a polynomial to the same series. The seventh-root family yi∈Ly_i\in L consists of the chosen seventh roots of the five line radicands. The chosen line pairs are (αb,βb)(\alpha_b,\beta_b), indexed by 0≤b<30\leq b<3, with the values specified above. The section monomials are the degree-one polynomials sabt∈L[t]s_{ab}t\in L[t]; they generate B0B_0 as a complex algebra.

Choose nonzero w0,w1,w2∈T1w_0,w_1,w_2\in T_1 for which the polynomial substitution in (5) is finite and injective.✦ Its graded form induces the projective normalization morphism ν:X→ℙℂ2\nu:X\to\mathbb P^2_{\mathbb C}.✦ The completed substitution and the scalar extension identification are also fixed as in (5): S=ℂ[u0,u1,u2]→C,ui↦wit,A=ℂ[[u0,u1,u2]]→R,ui↦wit,A⊗SC≃R,a⊗c↦a(w0t,w1t,w2t)c.\begin{gathered} S=\mathbb C[u_0,u_1,u_2]\longrightarrow C,\qquad u_i\longmapsto w_it, \qquad A=\mathbb C[[u_0,u_1,u_2]]\longrightarrow R,\\ u_i\longmapsto w_it,\qquad A\otimes_S C\simeq R,\qquad a\otimes c\longmapsto a(w_0t,w_1t,w_2t)c. \end{gathered}(5) The polynomial parameter ring SS is the polynomial ring over ℂ\mathbb C in the three variables u0,u1,u2u_0,u_1,u_2. The power-series parameter ring AA is the formal power-series ring over ℂ\mathbb C in u0,u1,u2u_0,u_1,u_2. The completion morphism Spec⁡A→Spec⁡S\operatorname{Spec}A\to\operatorname{Spec}S is induced by the inclusion of polynomials into formal power series. For c∈T1c\in T_1, the linear section associated with cc is the degree-one monomial ct∈Cct\in C; the normalization parameters give the linear sections witw_it.

The Source Model and Its Divisor

Let 𝔪=(u0,u1,u2)⊂S\mathfrak m=(u_0,u_1,u_2)\subset S.✦ For an indeterminate vv over SS, the Rees algebra of 𝔪\mathfrak m has degree-nn part 𝔪nvn\mathfrak m^n v^n and degree-zero algebra SS. The polynomial blowup V0V_0, its completion VV, and the source models W0,WW_0,W are the schemes of (6): V0=Proj⁡(⨁n≥0𝔪nvn),V=V0×Spec⁡SSpec⁡A,W0=X×ℙ2V0,W=X×ℙ2V.\begin{gathered} V_0=\operatorname{Proj}\!\left(\bigoplus_{n\geq0}\mathfrak m^n v^n\right), \qquad V=V_0\times_{\operatorname{Spec}S}\operatorname{Spec}A,\\ W_0=X\times_{\mathbb P^2}V_0,\qquad W=X\times_{\mathbb P^2}V. \end{gathered}(6) The direction map V0→ℙ2V_0\to\mathbb P^2 is induced by the graded substitution ui↦uivu_i\mapsto u_iv; the direction map of VV is its composite with V→V0V\to V_0. Write g0:W0→V0g_0:W_0\to V_0 and g:W→Vg:W\to V for the projections. The blowdown V0→Spec⁡SV_0\to\operatorname{Spec}S uses the degree-zero identification, and V→Spec⁡AV\to\operatorname{Spec}A is the other projection. For an ideal 𝔟\mathfrak b in a ring TT and an element s∈𝔟s\in\mathfrak b, the linear Rees section associated with ss is the degree-one element svsv of its Rees algebra. The sections uivu_iv are the coordinate Rees sections for the origin ideal.

The origin fiber of V0→Spec⁡SV_0\to\operatorname{Spec}S, formed using constant-term evaluation S→ℂS\to\mathbb C, is identified with ℙ2\mathbb P^2 by the direction map.✦ Its inclusion is i0:ℙ2→V0i_0:\mathbb P^2\to V_0; constant-term evaluation A→ℂA\to\mathbb C gives i:ℙ2→Vi:\mathbb P^2\to V. Pullback along ν\nu gives j:X→Wj:X\to W.✦ The plane divisor ideal II and source divisor ideal JJ are the kernels in (7); write HH for the conormal line j*Jj^*J on XX: I=ker⁡(𝒪V→i*𝒪ℙ2),J=ker⁡(𝒪W→j*𝒪X).I=\ker(\mathcal O_V\longrightarrow i_*\mathcal O_{\mathbb P^2}),\qquad J=\ker(\mathcal O_W\longrightarrow j_*\mathcal O_X).(7) The source zero section j:X→Wj:X\to W is the morphism with components the identity on XX and the composite X→νℙ2→iVX\xrightarrow{\nu}\mathbb P^2\xrightarrow{i}V.

For 0≤i<30\leq i<3, let PiP_i be the coordinate ring of the standard open D+(ui)⊂ℙ2D_+(u_i)\subset\mathbb P^2, and let DiD_i be the homogeneous localization C[(wit)−1]0C[(w_it)^{-1}]_0. The corresponding blowup and source chart rings are given in (8); all chart maps are the induced localization maps or tensor factor inclusions: Bi=((⨁n𝔪nvn)[(uiv)−1])0,Ci=Di⊗PiBi,λi=1⊗ui∈Ci,Cˆi=Ci⊗SA,λˆi=λi⊗1.\begin{gathered} B_i=\left(\left(\bigoplus_n\mathfrak m^n v^n\right)[(u_iv)^{-1}]\right)_0, \qquad C_i=D_i\otimes_{P_i}B_i,\\ \lambda_i=1\otimes u_i\in C_i,\qquad \widehat C_i=C_i\otimes_S A,\qquad \widehat\lambda_i=\lambda_i\otimes1. \end{gathered}(8) The canonical maps Spec⁡Di→X\operatorname{Spec}D_i\to X and Spec⁡Bi→V0\operatorname{Spec}B_i\to V_0 give an affine cover Spec⁡Ci→W0\operatorname{Spec}C_i\to W_0; the completed inclusions Spec⁡Cˆi→W\operatorname{Spec}\widehat C_i\to W give an affine cover of WW. The zero evaluation ϵi:Ci→Di\epsilon_i:C_i\to D_i is evaluation at λi=0\lambda_i=0 under the polynomial presentation Ci≃Di[λi]C_i\simeq D_i[\lambda_i].✦ The completed zero ideal is the extension of ker⁡ϵi\ker\epsilon_i to Cˆi\widehat C_i; the completed evaluation ϵˆi:Cˆi→Di\widehat\epsilon_i:\widehat C_i\to D_i is the quotient map followed by the canonical zero quotient identification. The blowup chart direction homomorphism Pi→BiP_i\to B_i is obtained from the graded substitution uj↦ujvu_j\mapsto u_jv by homogeneous localization away from uiu_i. The surface chart direction homomorphism Pi→DiP_i\to D_i is the homogeneous localization of the graded normalization homomorphism, with the distinguished variable uiu_i mapping to the linear section witw_it. The blowdown chart homomorphism S→BiS\to B_i is the scalar map through degree zero of the Rees algebra. The source chart base homomorphism S→CiS\to C_i is its composite with the inclusion of the blowup tensor factor. The source fiber coordinate λi∈Ci\lambda_i\in C_i is the image of uiu_i under the source chart base homomorphism, and the completed fiber coordinate λˆi∈Cˆi\widehat\lambda_i\in\widehat C_i is its image under scalar extension. The Rees chart polynomial homomorphism Pi[ξ]→BiP_i[\xi]\to B_i sends coefficients through the direction homomorphism Pi→BiP_i\to B_i and sends ξ\xi to the image of uiu_i under the blowdown chart homomorphism. The Rees chart polynomial homomorphism is an isomorphism of PiP_i-algebras, identifying the blowup chart ring BiB_i with a polynomial ring in one variable over PiP_i.

Evaluation at t=1t=1 embeds DiD_i in LL and preserves complex scalars. For f(t)=∑ncntn∈Cf(t)=\sum_n c_nt^n\in C, the section chart evaluation is the polynomial f(t/wi)f(t/w_i) with coefficients in DiD_i.✦ Substituting λi\lambda_i for its variable defines the cone evaluation C→CiC\to C_i.✦ These evaluations give q0:W0→Spec⁡Cq_0:W_0\to\operatorname{Spec}C.✦ Let ρ:W→W0\rho:W\to W_0 be the completion projection.✦ Scalar extension of q0q_0, using (5), defines p:W→Spec⁡Rp:W\to\operatorname{Spec}R.✦ Evaluation at one on the section algebra is the ring homomorphism C→LC\to L obtained by evaluating a section polynomial at t=1t=1. Homogeneous polynomial rescaling at wiw_i is the complex algebra homomorphism C→L[t]C\to L[t] that sends f(t)f(t) to f(t/wi)f(t/w_i). The scalar extended cone evaluation is the morphism W→Spec⁡A×Spec⁡SSpec⁡CW\to\operatorname{Spec}A\times_{\operatorname{Spec}S}\operatorname{Spec}C whose components are the composite W→gV→Spec⁡AW\xrightarrow{g}V\to\operatorname{Spec}A and the composite W→ρW0→q0Spec⁡CW\xrightarrow{\rho}W_0\xrightarrow{q_0}\operatorname{Spec}C.

For a scheme YY, write Coh⁡(Y)\operatorname{Coh}(Y) for the category of 𝒪Y\mathcal O_Y-modules of finite presentation.✦ A line trivialization of an 𝒪Y\mathcal O_Y-module ℱ\mathcal F on a scheme YY is an open cover of YY with isomorphisms from the restrictions of ℱ\mathcal F to the structure sheaves on its members.✦ The source ideal JJ has the chart trivializations given by its local generators λˆi\widehat\lambda_i.✦ Tensoring by JJ, followed by its inclusion into 𝒪W\mathcal O_W, gives the ideal action on coherent sheaves.✦ For a coherent sheaf ℱ\mathcal F on WW, the Cartier restriction ℱ|X∈Coh⁡(X)\mathcal F|_X\in\operatorname{Coh}(X) is the sheaf characterized by (9): j*(ℱ|X)≃coker⁡(J⊗𝒪Wℱ→ℱ).j_*(\mathcal F|_X)\simeq \operatorname{coker}(J\otimes_{\mathcal O_W}\mathcal F\longrightarrow\mathcal F).(9)✦

Let U*=g−1(V\i(ℙ2))U^*=g^{-1}(V\setminus i(\mathbb P^2)), where the complement is the open complement of the closed immersion ii.✦ The framed source open U*⊂WU^*\subset W is the inverse image under gg of the open complement of the plane zero section.✦

Double Duals and the Exceptional Chart

For sheaves ℱ,𝒢\mathcal F,\mathcal G on a scheme YY, the internal Hom sheaf ℋom𝒪Y(ℱ,𝒢)\mathcal Hom_{\mathcal O_Y}(\mathcal F,\mathcal G) is the sheaf whose sections over an open UU are the 𝒪U\mathcal O_U-linear morphisms ℱ|U→𝒢|U\mathcal F|_U\to\mathcal G|_U, compatible with restriction.✦ The dual ℱ*\mathcal F^* of an 𝒪Y\mathcal O_Y-module ℱ\mathcal F on a scheme YY is the sheaf on YY defined by ℱ*=ℋom𝒪Y(ℱ,𝒪Y)\mathcal F^*=\mathcal Hom_{\mathcal O_Y}(\mathcal F,\mathcal O_Y). For an RR-module MM, let M̃\widetilde M denote its associated sheaf on Spec⁡R\operatorname{Spec}R; the source double-dual model ℰs(M)\mathcal E_s(M) is the sheaf on WW defined by ℰs(M)=(p*M̃)**\mathcal E_s(M)=(p^*\widetilde M)^{**}.✦ A framed extension of MM is a coherent sheaf ℱ\mathcal F on WW whose sections on every open are torsion-free over the corresponding ring of functions, whose Cartier restriction to XX has the same property, and which is equipped with an isomorphism ℱ|U*≃ℰs(M)|U*\mathcal F|_{U^*}\simeq\mathcal E_s(M)|_{U^*}.✦ For an RR-module MM, the collection 𝒮(M)\mathscr S(M) consists of the framed extensions of MM on WW.

The completed sections σab=sabt∈R\sigma_{ab}=s_{ab}t\in R generate the ideal 𝔞=(σab)\mathfrak a=(\sigma_{ab}). Its blowup YY and a distinguished exceptional chart are defined in (10): Y=Proj⁡(⨁n≥0𝔞nvn),q:Y→Spec⁡R,B=((⨁n𝔞nvn)[(σ00v)−1])0,b=image of σ00 in B,D=B/(b).\begin{gathered} Y=\operatorname{Proj}\!\left(\bigoplus_{n\geq0}\mathfrak a^n v^n\right), \qquad q:Y\longrightarrow\operatorname{Spec}R,\\ B=\left(\left(\bigoplus_n\mathfrak a^n v^n\right) [(\sigma_{00}v)^{-1}]\right)_0,\qquad b=\text{image of }\sigma_{00}\text{ in }B,\qquad D=B/(b). \end{gathered}(10) Here qq is the blowdown obtained from the degree-zero algebra RR.✦ The quotient B→DB\to D and the chart inclusion define k:Spec⁡D→Yk:\operatorname{Spec}D\to Y.✦ The completed blowup double dual and its exceptional section module are (11): ℰb(M)=(q*M̃)**,Q(M)=Γ(Spec⁡D,k*ℰb(M)).\mathcal E_b(M)=(q^*\widetilde M)^{**},\qquad Q(M)=\Gamma(\operatorname{Spec}D,k^*\mathcal E_b(M)).(11)

Write rT(N)r_T(N) for the rank of a module NN over a ring TT, and put d=rA(R)d=r_A(R). For a module NN over a local ring TT with maximal ideal 𝔪T\mathfrak m_T, the depth depth⁡TN\operatorname{depth}_T N is the supremum of lengths of finite NN-regular sequences in the maximal ideal, as in (12): depth⁡TN=sup⁡{ℓ∣r1,…,rℓ∈𝔪T form an N-regular sequence}.\operatorname{depth}_T N= \sup\{\ell\mid r_1,\ldots,r_\ell\in\mathfrak m_T \text{ form an }N\text{-regular sequence}\}.(12)✦ Let 𝔪R\mathfrak m_R denote the maximal ideal of RR. The completed blowup parameter b∈Bb\in B is the image of σ00\sigma_{00} under the natural homomorphism R→BR\to B.✦ The completed blowup homogeneous section is the degree-one Rees section σ00v\sigma_{00}v✦, and the chart inclusion Spec⁡B→Y\operatorname{Spec}B\to Y is the standard open immersion away from this section.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let TT be a Noetherian local ring finite as an AA-module, and let NN be a nonzero finite TT-module of depth three. The restricted AA-module satisfies (13): N is free over A.N\text{ is free over }A.(13)✦ Let T′T' be a commutative local ring and let N′N' be a finite T′T'-module with dim⁡T′≤depth⁡T′N′\dim T'\leq\operatorname{depth}_{T'}N'. For a prime 𝔭\mathfrak p such that N𝔭′≠0N'_{\mathfrak p}\neq0, the localized depth satisfies (14): dim⁡T𝔭′≤depth⁡T𝔭′N𝔭′.\dim T'_{\mathfrak p}\leq \operatorname{depth}_{T'_{\mathfrak p}}N'_{\mathfrak p}.(14)✦ For a finite RR-module MM, the source model satisfies (15): ℰs(M)∈Coh⁡(W).\mathcal E_s(M)\in\operatorname{Coh}(W).(15)✦ For any RR-module MM and any open U⊂WU\subset W, the section module satisfies (16): ℰs(M)(U) is torsion-free over Γ(U,𝒪W).\mathcal E_s(M)(U)\text{ is torsion-free over }\Gamma(U,\mathcal O_W).(16)✦ If MM is a nonzero finite RR-module with depth⁡RM=3\operatorname{depth}_R M=3, its completed blowup model satisfies (17): ℰb(M)∈Coh⁡(Y),ℰb(M)(U) is torsion-free over Γ(U,𝒪Y)for every open U⊂Y,Q(M) is torsion-free over D,0<rD(Q(M)).\begin{gathered} \mathcal E_b(M)\in\operatorname{Coh}(Y),\\ \mathcal E_b(M)(U)\text{ is torsion-free over }\Gamma(U,\mathcal O_Y) \quad\text{for every open }U\subset Y,\\ Q(M)\text{ is torsion-free over }D,\qquad 0<r_D(Q(M)). \end{gathered}(17)✦ For every finite RR-module MM, the exceptional rank and the parameter-ring rank obey (18) and (19), respectively: rD(Q(M))=rR(M).r_D(Q(M))=r_R(M).(18)✦ rA(M)=drD(Q(M)).r_A(M)=d\,r_D(Q(M)).(19)✦ For every finite RR-module MM, the initial framed extension is (20): s0(M)=(ℰs(M),id⁡ℰs(M)|U*)∈𝒮(M).s_0(M)=\bigl(\mathcal E_s(M),\operatorname{id}_{\mathcal E_s(M)|_{U^*}}\bigr) \in\mathscr S(M).(20)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if MM is a nonzero finite module of depth three over R=R(X,H)R=R(X,H), then MM is free of positive rank over AA and locally free on Spec⁡R\{𝔪R}\operatorname{Spec}R\setminus\{\mathfrak m_R\}, while ℰ=(p*M̃)**\mathcal E=(p^*\widetilde M)^{**} is coherent and torsion-free, agrees with MM off XX, and has torsion-free restriction P=ℰ|XP=\mathcal E|_X of the same positive generic rank.

What Is Checked

The statements are over the coefficientwise completed ring (4), the source pullback (6), and the distinguished Rees chart (10); their depth is the regular-sequence depth (12). The source completion square is Cartesian: (21) identifies the completion projection and the maps to the polynomial base.✦ W≃W0×Spec⁡SSpec⁡A,(ρ,W→gV→Spec⁡A).W\simeq W_0\times_{\operatorname{Spec}S}\operatorname{Spec}A, \qquad (\rho,\,W\xrightarrow{g}V\longrightarrow\operatorname{Spec}A).(21)✦

The chart substitutions preserve homogeneous degree.✦ For an integral graded map φ:𝒜→ℬ\varphi:\mathcal A\to\mathcal B over a field, with degree-zero part of 𝒜\mathcal A consisting of scalars, the irrelevant ideals satisfy (22); the induced projective morphism contracts homogeneous primes and acts on sections through the corresponding local ring maps. ℬ+⊆φ(𝒜+)ℬ.\mathcal B_+\subseteq\sqrt{\varphi(\mathcal A_+)\mathcal B}.(22)✦

Each ϵi\epsilon_i is surjective.✦

For the graded direction homomorphism ui↦uivu_i\mapsto u_iv, the irrelevant ideal of the origin Rees algebra is contained in the radical of the ideal generated by the images of the projective coordinate variables.✦

For coefficients vi∈Tdiv_i\in T_{d_i} of positive degrees did_i, the generating monomial series vitdiv_it^{d_i} admit formal power-series substitution.✦ Substitution of these series defines a homomorphism from the multivariable power-series ring over the coefficient field to the graded series algebra of the coefficient spaces.✦

For a surjective algebra homomorphism B′→D′B'\to D' over S′S' and an S′S'-algebra A′A', quotient commutes with scalar extension as in (23), where the denominator is the extended kernel: (B′⊗S′A′)/(ker⁡(B′→D′))(B′⊗S′A′)≃D′⊗S′A′.(B'\otimes_{S'}A')/(\ker(B'\to D'))(B'\otimes_{S'}A') \simeq D'\otimes_{S'}A'.(23)✦ Let kk denote the coefficient field. If S′=k[ui]S'=k[u_i], A′=k[[ui]]A'=k[[u_i]], and the action of S′S' on D′D' factors through constant-term evaluation, the origin base change is D′⊗S′A′≃D′D'\otimes_{S'}A'\simeq D', with d′⊗a′↦d′a′(0)d'\otimes a'\mapsto d'a'(0).✦ On the completed source charts, (24) gives the regular principal equation of the zero section: ker⁡ϵˆi=(λˆi),Cˆi/(λˆi)≃Di,λˆi is a nonzerodivisor on Cˆi.\ker\widehat\epsilon_i=(\widehat\lambda_i),\qquad \widehat C_i/(\widehat\lambda_i)\simeq D_i,\qquad \widehat\lambda_i\text{ is a nonzerodivisor on }\widehat C_i.(24) The zero chart maps commute with jj and the surface chart inclusions.✦ When the action of S′S' on D′D' factors through constant-term evaluation, the origin series evaluation is the S′S'-algebra homomorphism A′→D′A'\to D' obtained by taking the constant coefficient and then its scalar image in D′D'.

For a commutative ring FF and a commutative FF-algebra GG, polynomial base change is the GG-algebra isomorphism G⊗FF[ξ]≃G[ξ]G\otimes_F F[\xi]\simeq G[\xi] preserving coefficients from GG and sending the variable in the second tensor factor to ξ\xi.✦

For a closed immersion into a locally Noetherian scheme, its ideal sheaf is coherent.✦ On an affine chart, the ideal’s section inclusion identifies its sections with the kernel of the comorphism✦; if that kernel is generated by a regular element tt, multiplication by tt identifies the ideal with the structure sheaf. Tensoring a coherent sheaf by a line bundle preserves coherence, and finite pushforward to a locally Noetherian scheme preserves coherence. The cokernel of the ideal action is in the image of pushforward from the closed subscheme, as used in (9).✦ For a finitely presented module sheaf on an affine scheme, a linear isomorphism of its global sections with the global functions determines an isomorphism of the sheaf with the structure sheaf.