OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. The chord contradiction

Lemma 5.1 [The secant estimate]: The estimate depends on the target length ratio and the contraction parameter

Bounds for supports on aligned chords.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The secant estimate concerns supporting functionals on the plane spanned by an aligned chord’s base point and its source direction.

Let XX and YY be real normed spaces. The unit sphere SXS_X is the set in (1), with the inherited distance; SYS_Y is defined in the same way. SX={x∈X:∥x∥=1}.S_X=\{x\in X:\|x\|=1\}.(1)✦ Let f:SX→SYf:S_X\to S_Y be a surjective isometry. The signed defect Dq(x,y)D_q(x,y) at q∈ℝq\in\mathbb{R} and x,y∈SXx,y\in S_X is the real number in (2). Dq(x,y)=∥f(x)−qf(y)∥−∥x−qy∥.D_q(x,y)=\|f(x)-qf(y)\|-\|x-qy\|.(2)✦ A real number MM is a uniform defect bound for ff if it satisfies (3). |Dq(x,y)|≤M(x,y∈SX,0≤q≤1).|D_q(x,y)|\le M \qquad(x,y\in S_X,\quad 0\le q\le1).(3)✦

Fix y∈SXy\in S_X and t,M∈ℝt,M\in\mathbb{R}. An aligned extremal chord configuration for f,y,t,Mf,y,t,M consists of points x,z,v∈SXx,z,v\in S_X and w∈SYw\in S_Y, together with positive real lengths p,r,s,up,r,s,u, satisfying (4). x=ty+pv,z=ty−rv,f(x)=tf(y)+sw,f(z)=tf(y)−uw,s−p=M,r−u=M,p+r=s+u,p+r≤2.\begin{gathered} x=ty+pv,\qquad z=ty-rv,\\ f(x)=tf(y)+sw,\qquad f(z)=tf(y)-uw,\\ s-p=M,\qquad r-u=M,\\ p+r=s+u,\qquad p+r\le2. \end{gathered}(4)✦ The chord length dd and the ratios A,BA,B of an aligned extremal chord configuration for f,y,t,Mf,y,t,M are the real numbers defined in (5). d=p+r,A=pd,B=ud.d=p+r,\qquad A=\frac{p}{d},\qquad B=\frac{u}{d}.(5)

The complementary parameter ϵ\epsilon of an aligned extremal chord configuration with parameter tt is the real number ϵ=1−t\epsilon=1-t. The secant step hh and the secant parameter θ\theta are the real numbers defined in (6). h=min⁡{ts,ϵu},θ=hsp.h=\min\left\{\frac{t}{s},\frac{\epsilon}{u}\right\}, \qquad \theta=\frac{hs}{p}.(6) The secant slope KK is the quotient in (7). K=∥ruv+hy∥−∥psv+hy∥ru−ps.K=\frac{ \left\|\frac{r}{u}v+hy\right\| -\left\|\frac{p}{s}v+hy\right\| }{\frac{r}{u}-\frac{p}{s}}.(7)✦

A support φ:X→ℝ\varphi:X\to\mathbb{R} at a∈Xa\in X is a continuous real-linear functional satisfying (8). ∥φ∥≤1,φ(a)=∥a∥.\|\varphi\|\le1,\qquad \varphi(a)=\|a\|.(8)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let an aligned extremal chord configuration be given for a surjective sphere isometry between real normed spaces. Suppose that M>0M>0, 0<t<10<t<1, and MM is a uniform defect bound. Every support φ\varphi at v+θyv+\theta y satisfies the secant bounds (9). ϵp≤φ(v)≤K≤{1−B,B≤ϵ,B,B>ϵ.\frac{\epsilon}{p}\le\varphi(v)\le K \le \begin{cases} 1-B,& B\le\epsilon,\\ B,& B>\epsilon. \end{cases}(9)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for the attained configuration of §4, with its surjective sphere isometry between nonzero real Banach spaces, global defect bound M>0M>0, 0<t<10<t<1, and the aligned chords of Proposition 4.2, every support φ\varphi at v+θyv+\theta y satisfies ϵ/p≤φ(v)≤K≤1−B\epsilon/p\le\varphi(v)\le K\le1-B when B≤ϵB\le\epsilon and ϵ/p≤φ(v)≤K≤B\epsilon/p\le\varphi(v)\le K\le B when B>ϵB>\epsilon, in the notation above.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over real normed spaces, a surjective isometry of their unit spheres, an aligned extremal chord configuration with a positive uniform defect bound and 0<t<10<t<1, and a continuous real-linear support at the prescribed vector.