OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. The chord contradiction

Lemma 5.2 [Neither chord ratio is large]: For a contraction factor tt with 0<t<10<t<1, both proportions are controlled by 1−t1-t when positive defect is attained

Uniform defect bounds constrain aligned chord ratios.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

An aligned chord compares the positions of two sphere points on opposite sides of a contracted sphere point with the corresponding positions of their images. Let XX and YY be real normed spaces. For E=X,YE=X,Y, the unit sphere SES_E, with the inherited distance, is the set in (1). SE={a∈E:∥a∥=1}.S_E=\{a\in E:\|a\|=1\}.(1)✦ Fix a surjective sphere isometry f:SX→SYf:S_X\to S_Y.

The signed defect Dq(x,y)D_q(x,y) at q∈ℝq\in\mathbb R and x,y∈SXx,y\in S_X is the real number in (2). Dq(x,y)=∥f(x)−qf(y)∥−∥x−qy∥.D_q(x,y)=\|f(x)-qf(y)\|-\|x-qy\|.(2)✦ A uniform defect bound for ff is a real number MM satisfying (3). |Dq(x,y)|≤M(x,y∈SX,0≤q≤1).|D_q(x,y)|\le M \qquad(x,y\in S_X,\ 0\le q\le1).(3)✦

For y∈SXy\in S_X and real parameters t,Mt,M, an aligned extremal chord configuration CC consists of points x,z,v∈SXx,z,v\in S_X, a point w∈SYw\in S_Y, and positive real lengths p,r,s,up,r,s,u satisfying (4) and (5). x=ty+pv,z=ty−rv,f(x)=tf(y)+sw,f(z)=tf(y)−uw.\begin{aligned} x&=ty+pv, & z&=ty-rv,\\ f(x)&=tf(y)+sw, & f(z)&=tf(y)-uw. \end{aligned}(4) s−p=M,r−u=M,p+r=s+u,p+r≤2.s-p=M,\qquad r-u=M,\qquad p+r=s+u,\qquad p+r\le2.(5)✦ The chord length dd of CC and its ratios AA and BB are defined by (6); the contraction gap is denoted by ε\varepsilon. d=p+r,A=pd,B=ud,ε=1−t.d=p+r,\qquad A=\frac{p}{d},\qquad B=\frac{u}{d},\qquad \varepsilon=1-t.(6)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let CC be an aligned extremal chord configuration for f,y,t,Mf,y,t,M. Suppose that M>0M>0, that 0<t<10<t<1, and that MM is a uniform defect bound for ff. The large-ratio exclusion (7) and the simultaneous bounds (8) hold. There is no such configuration with B>1−t.\text{There is no such configuration with }B>1-t.(7)✦ A≤1−tandB≤1−t.A\le1-t\qquad\text{and}\qquad B\le1-t.(8)✦

In the paper, the result reads: under the attained positive defect and aligned chord hypotheses of Lemma 5.1, neither A>εA>\varepsilon nor B>εB>\varepsilon is possible, equivalently A≤1−tA\le1-t and B≤1−tB\le1-t.

What Is Checked

The claims are stated over surjective isometries between the unit spheres of real normed spaces, aligned extremal chord configurations with 0<t<10<t<1, and positive uniform bounds for the signed defect.