OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. The chord contradiction

Proposition 5.3 [No attained positive maximum]: The aligned extremal chord configuration is impossible for a surjective sphere isometry of real Banach spaces

Positive defect bounds are unattained for 0<t<10<t<1..

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let XX and YY be real Banach spaces. The unit spheres SXS_X of XX and SYS_Y of YY are the sets in (1), equipped with the inherited distances: SX={x∈X:∥x∥=1},SY={y∈Y:∥y∥=1}.S_X=\{x\in X:\|x\|=1\},\qquad S_Y=\{y\in Y:\|y\|=1\}.(1) For a surjective isometry f:SX→SYf:S_X\to S_Y, the signed defect Dq(x,y)D_q(x,y) at a real parameter qq and points x,y∈SXx,y\in S_X is the change in distance to a scalar multiple specified by (2): Dq(x,y)=∥f(x)−qf(y)∥−∥x−qy∥.D_q(x,y)=\|f(x)-qf(y)\|-\|x-qy\|.(2)✦ A uniform defect bound MM for ff is a real number satisfying (3): |Dq(x,y)|≤M(x,y∈SX,0≤q≤1).|D_q(x,y)|\le M \qquad(x,y\in S_X,\ 0\le q\le1).(3)✦

Aligned Extremal Chords

For y∈SXy\in S_X and t,M∈ℝt,M\in\mathbb R, an aligned extremal chord configuration for f,y,t,Mf,y,t,M is a tuple (x,z,v,w,p,r,s,u)(x,z,v,w,p,r,s,u) with x,z,v∈SXx,z,v\in S_X, w∈SYw\in S_Y, and positive real lengths p,r,s,up,r,s,u, satisfying (4) and (5): x=ty+pv,z=ty−rv,f(x)=tf(y)+sw,f(z)=tf(y)−uw,\begin{aligned} x&=ty+pv, & z&=ty-rv,\\ f(x)&=tf(y)+sw, & f(z)&=tf(y)-uw, \end{aligned}(4) s−p=M,r−u=M,d=p+r=s+u≤2.s-p=M,\qquad r-u=M,\qquad d=p+r=s+u\le2.(5)✦ Write 𝒞(f,y,t,M)\mathcal C(f,y,t,M) for the set of these configurations, with dd denoting their common chord length as in (5).

The Claim

Theorem 1. Suppose M>0M>0, 0<t<10<t<1, and MM is a uniform defect bound for ff in the sense of (3). For every y∈SXy\in S_X, 𝒞(f,y,t,M)=⌀.\mathcal C(f,y,t,M)=\varnothing.(6)✦ For every x,y∈SXx,y\in S_X, Dt(x,y)≠M.D_t(x,y)\ne M.(7)✦

In the paper, the result reads: there do not exist nonzero real Banach spaces X,YX,Y, a surjective sphere isometry f:SX→SYf:S_X\to S_Y, numbers M>0M>0 and 0<t<10<t<1, and points x0,y∈SXx_0,y\in S_X such that |Dq(a,c)|≤M|D_q(a,c)|\le M for all a,c∈SXa,c\in S_X and 0≤q≤10\le q\le1, and Dt(x0,y)=MD_t(x_0,y)=M.

What Is Checked

The claims (6) and (7) are stated over real Banach spaces and a surjective sphere isometry with a positive uniform defect bound at an interior parameter; the first also concerns the aligned extremal chord configurations of (4) and (5).