The Setting
Let be a finite field of odd characteristic with elements, a symmetric bilinear form on a finite-dimensional vector space over , and a subspace of of dimension . The restriction of to is degenerate or nondegenerate, and a nondegenerate form has a sign . For each , a family of -dimensional subspaces then has a share of members on which restricts to a nondegenerate form of sign , and a share on which it restricts to one of sign . The question is how close each share is to when is drawn uniformly at random.
The result stated below is a step in the part of the counterexample to Sidorenko’s conjecture that treats transverse configurations and determinant signs.
Signs of Restricted Forms
The uniform mean of a real function on a finite set is its average over : (1)✦
The set of symmetric bilinear forms on a vector space over consists of the bilinear maps with for all .✦ For a natural number , the space of symmetric matrices of size is the subspace of the space of matrices over consisting of the matrices with . A matrix defines the symmetric bilinear form on given by (2)✦
For vector spaces and over , the pullback of a form along a linear map is the form . The restriction of to a subspace of is its pullback along the inclusion of in .
The radical of is the subspace , and is nondegenerate when . The radical quotient form of is the nondegenerate form on given by .✦ The sign of is the quadratic character of the determinant of the Gram matrix of in a basis of , (3)✦ with when has rank zero. For , the sign indicator of is when is nondegenerate and , and otherwise.✦
The share of a family of subspaces of , indexed by a nonempty finite set , for a form and a sign , is the fraction of indices for which is nondegenerate of sign :
For a vector space over and a natural number , is the set of subspaces of of dimension .✦ On , two further shares of a matrix run over subspaces of a fixed dimension . For and , the share over all -dimensional subspaces of is the average of the sign indicator of over : For a bilinear form on , let be the set of with for all , the totally isotropic ones. For and , the share over the totally isotropic -dimensional subspaces of is the average of the sign indicator of over :
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be a finite field of odd characteristic with elements, a natural number and . Let be a family of pairwise distinct -dimensional subspaces of a finite-dimensional vector space over , indexed by a nonempty finite set . Then the share of (4) satisfies (7)✦ and (8)✦ If moreover and the family has members, then (9)✦ For , the share over all -dimensional subspaces of satisfies (10)✦ For and a nondegenerate symmetric bilinear form on of sign , the share over the totally isotropic -dimensional subspaces of satisfies (11)✦
In the paper, the result reads: for any nonempty family of distinct -dimensional subspaces of with and a uniform symmetric form , the share of the on which is nondegenerate of sign satisfies uniformly, and the same holds conditionally on being nondegenerate, or on and being nondegenerate, uniformly in the form .
What Is Checked
The bounds (7) to (11) are stated over the uniform mean (1) on and on , the sign (3) taken through the radical quotient form, the sign indicator , restriction as pullback along an inclusion, the form of a symmetric matrix (2), and the shares (4), (5) and (6) over subspaces of dimension .
The library also proves that is a bijection from onto ✦, and that pullback along a linear map is a linear map from to ✦.