OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. Transverse configurations and determinant signs · §4

Lemma 4.2 [Split forms and their maximal isotropic subspaces]: For qq odd, nondegenerate symmetric forms on 𝔽q2r\mathbb F_q^{2r} of sign χ((−1)r)\chi((-1)^r) are hyperbolic, with ∼2q(r2)\sim 2q^{\binom r2} Lagrangians as q→∞q \to \infty

Hyperbolic symmetric forms and the number of their Lagrangian subspaces.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The construction behind the counterexample to Sidorenko’s conjecture works with symmetric matrices of even size D=2rD = 2r over a finite field 𝔽q\mathbb F_q of odd characteristic, and with the symmetric bilinear forms they define. This lemma is about two invariants of a nondegenerate symmetric form on a space of dimension 2r2r: its sign, the quadratic character of its determinant, and the number of subspaces of dimension rr on which the form vanishes identically.

The model form is the hyperbolic form of 𝔽qr\mathbb F_q^r, an orthogonal sum of rr hyperbolic planes, a hyperbolic plane being the hyperbolic form of a line. The library states that every nondegenerate symmetric form with the sign of the hyperbolic form is equivalent to it, and counts the Lagrangian subspaces of the hyperbolic form, the subspaces of dimension rr on which it vanishes, exactly and as q→∞q \to \infty.

Forms and Their Signs

Throughout, 𝔽q\mathbb F_q is a finite field with qq elements and χ\chi is its quadratic character.

For a finite-dimensional vector space VV over 𝔽q\mathbb F_q with dual space V*V^*, the hyperbolic form HVH_V of VV is the bilinear form on V⊕V*V \oplus V^* given by HV((v,f),(w,g))=g(v)+f(w).H_V\bigl((v,f),(w,g)\bigr) = g(v) + f(w).(1)✦

Two bilinear forms, BB on a space EE and CC on a space FF, are equivalent, written B≃CB \simeq C, when there is a linear isomorphism φ:E→F\varphi \colon E \to F with C(φx,φy)=B(x,y)for all x,y∈E.C(\varphi x, \varphi y) = B(x,y) \quad \text{for all } x, y \in E.(2)✦

The radical of a symmetric bilinear form BB on a finite-dimensional space EE over 𝔽q\mathbb F_q is the subspace R={x∈E:B(x,y)=0 for all y∈E}R = \{x \in E : B(x,y) = 0 \text{ for all } y \in E\}, and the radical quotient form of BB is the nondegenerate bilinear form B‾\bar B on E/RE/R given by B‾(x+R,y+R)=B(x,y).\bar B(x + R, y + R) = B(x,y).(3)✦

The sign sgn⁡B\operatorname{sgn} B of a symmetric bilinear form BB on EE is the quadratic character of the determinant of the Gram matrix G‾\bar G of B‾\bar B in a basis of E/RE/R, sgn⁡B=χ(det⁡G‾),\operatorname{sgn} B = \chi(\det \bar G),(4)✦ and it is 11 when BB has rank zero, the empty determinant being 11.

Lagrangian Subspaces and Their Counts

A Lagrangian subspace of a bilinear form BB on EE is a subspace LL of EE equal to its orthogonal: L=L⟂={y∈E:B(x,y)=0 for all x∈L}.L = L^{\perp} = \{y \in E : B(x,y) = 0 \text{ for all } x \in L\}.(5)✦ Write Λ(B)\Lambda(B) for the set of Lagrangian subspaces of BB, and Nr=|Λ(H𝔽qr)|N_r = |\Lambda(H_{\mathbb F_q^r})| for the number of Lagrangian subspaces of the hyperbolic form of 𝔽qr\mathbb F_q^r.

For 0≤k≤n0 \le k \le n, the Gaussian binomial coefficient (nk)q\binom{n}{k}_q is the number of subspaces of dimension kk of a space of dimension nn over 𝔽q\mathbb F_q.

For natural numbers DD and kk, the Grassmann correction factor gD,kg_{D,k} is the function of a real variable xx given by gD,k(x)=∏i=0k−11−x−(D−i)1−x−(k−i),g_{D,k}(x) = \prod_{i=0}^{k-1} \frac{1 - x^{-(D-i)}}{1 - x^{-(k-i)}},(6) and for a natural number rr the orthogonal factor is the function Φr\Phi_r of a real variable xx given by Φr(x)=∑k=0rgr,k(x)x(r−k2).\Phi_r(x) = \sum_{k=0}^{r} \frac{g_{r,k}(x)}{x^{\binom{r-k}{2}}}.(7)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let 𝔽q\mathbb F_q be a finite field.

  1. For a space VV of finite dimension nn over 𝔽q\mathbb F_q, the hyperbolic form of VV, which is symmetric, has sign sgn⁡HV=χ((−1)n).\operatorname{sgn} H_V = \chi\bigl((-1)^n\bigr).(8)✦

  2. Suppose qq is odd, let rr be a natural number, and let BB be a nondegenerate symmetric bilinear form on a space EE of dimension 2r2r over 𝔽q\mathbb F_q whose sign is c0=χ((−1)r)c_0 = \chi((-1)^r). Then BB is equivalent to the hyperbolic form of 𝔽qr\mathbb F_q^r, B≃H𝔽qr,B \simeq H_{\mathbb F_q^r},(9)✦ it has as many Lagrangian subspaces as that form, |Λ(B)|=Nr,|\Lambda(B)| = N_r,(10)✦ and their number divided by q(r2)q^{\binom r2} is the orthogonal factor at qq: |Λ(B)|q(r2)=Φr(q).\frac{|\Lambda(B)|}{q^{\binom r2}} = \Phi_r(q).(11)✦

  3. Suppose qq is odd, and let VV be a space of dimension nn over 𝔽q\mathbb F_q. The number of Lagrangian subspaces of the hyperbolic form of VV is a sum over the subspaces UU of VV, |Λ(HV)|=∑U≤Vq(dim⁡U2),|\Lambda(H_V)| = \sum_{U \le V} q^{\binom{\dim U}{2}},(12)✦ and a sum over dimensions, |Λ(HV)|=∑k=0n(nk)qq(k2).|\Lambda(H_V)| = \sum_{k=0}^{n} \binom{n}{k}_q \, q^{\binom k2}.(13)✦

  4. For every r≥1r \ge 1, the orthogonal factor tends to 22 as the real variable tends to infinity: limx→∞Φr(x)=2.\lim_{x \to \infty} \Phi_r(x) = 2.(14)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for r≥1r \ge 1, a nondegenerate symmetric form on a space of dimension 2r2r over 𝔽q\mathbb F_q has a totally isotropic subspace of dimension rr if and only if its sign is c0=χ((−1)r)c_0 = \chi((-1)^r); such a form is an orthogonal sum of rr hyperbolic planes, and the number of its totally isotropic subspaces of dimension rr is Nr=∏a=0r−1(1+qa)=2q(r2)(1+O(1/q))N_r = \prod_{a=0}^{r-1}(1 + q^a) = 2q^{\binom r2}(1 + O(1/q)).

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over the hyperbolic form (1), equivalence of forms (2), the sign (4) of a symmetric form taken on its radical quotient form (3), the Lagrangian subspaces (5) of a form, the subspaces of a given dimension, and the factors gD,kg_{D,k} and Φr\Phi_r of (6) and (7). Beyond the claim, the library proves that the hyperbolic form HVH_V is symmetric.✦