OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. A dual space with coded norming functionals

Lemma 5.4: Finite real vectors in the norming completion and bounds by their coefficient norms

A coordinate bound within each color.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The coordinate set Γ=ω1\Gamma=\omega_1 is the set of countable ordinals. Its color classes carry separate pure norming operations, followed by a mixed family of operations. Fix a bijection π:Γ→ℕ×Γ\pi\colon\Gamma\to\mathbb N\times\Gamma.✦ The color c(a)c(a) of an ordinal a∈Γa\in\Gamma is the first component of π(a)\pi(a), and the color class CkC_k is the fiber specified in (1).✦ c(a)=pr⁡1π(a),Ck={a∈Γ:c(a)=k}.c(a)=\operatorname{pr}_1\pi(a),\qquad C_k=\{a\in\Gamma:c(a)=k\}.(1) Each CkC_k has cardinality ℵ1\aleph_1 and is unbounded in ω1\omega_1.

A finitely supported rational array on Γ\Gamma is a function from Γ\Gamma to ℚ\mathbb Q that vanishes outside a finite set; their space is c00(Γ;ℚ)c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb Q).✦ For a∈Γa\in\Gamma, the coordinate array δa∈c00(Γ;ℚ)\delta_a\in c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb Q) is the function with value 11 at aa and 00 elsewhere. Write c00(Γ;ℝ)c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb R) for the corresponding space of finitely supported real families.

The operation families are the pure families pk\mathrm p_k, indexed by k∈ℕk\in\mathbb N, and one mixed family m\mathrm m.✦ Their primal exponents are specified by (2); the natural-number indices begin at zero. s(pk)=sk=k+2,s(m)=2.s(\mathrm p_k)=s_k=k+2,\qquad s(\mathrm m)=2.(2)✦

For a set A⊆c00(Γ;ℚ)A\subseteq c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb Q) and an operation family ff, the construction stages AnfA_n^f are subsets of c00(Γ;ℚ)c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb Q) defined recursively, starting with A0f=AA_0^f=A. Stage n+1n+1 retains AnfA_n^f and adjoins the values of type I operations whose children lie in AnfA_n^f, together with the values of type II operations whose children in every piece of every path lie in AnfA_n^f.✦ These closure indices also begin at zero.

The pure base Ak⊆c00(Γ;ℚ)A_k\subseteq c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb Q) is the set consisting of zero and the signed coordinate arrays of color kk.✦ For k∈ℕk\in\mathbb N, the pure norming set Kk⊆c00(Γ;ℚ)K_k\subseteq c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb Q) is the union of the stages generated from AkA_k by the pure family pk\mathrm p_k✦; the full norming set K⊆c00(Γ;ℚ)K\subseteq c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb Q) is the union of the mixed stages generated from all the pure norming sets, as in (3).✦ Ak={0}∪{δa,−δa:a∈Ck},Kk=⋃n∈ℕ(Ak)npk,K=⋃n∈ℕ(⋃k∈ℕKk)nm.A_k=\{0\}\cup\{\delta_a,-\delta_a:a\in C_k\},\qquad K_k=\bigcup_{n\in\mathbb N}(A_k)_n^{\mathrm p_k},\qquad K=\bigcup_{n\in\mathbb N} \left(\bigcup_{k\in\mathbb N}K_k\right)_n^{\mathrm m}.(3)

The Norming Completion

A norming set LL on Γ\Gamma is a subset of c00(Γ;ℚ)c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb Q) containing every coordinate array and satisfying the coefficient bound in (4).✦ δa∈L(a∈Γ),|f(a)|≤1(f∈L,a∈Γ).\delta_a\in L\quad(a\in\Gamma),\qquad |f(a)|\leq 1\quad(f\in L,\ a\in\Gamma).(4)

For a norming set LL on Γ\Gamma, the space ℓ∞(L)\ell_\infty(L) is the space of bounded real functions on LL, equipped with its supremum norm.✦ For a norming set LL on Γ\Gamma and a∈Γa\in\Gamma, the coordinate evaluation vector uaL∈ℓ∞(L)u_a^L\in\ell_\infty(L) is the function evaluating an array at aa✦, and the finite-support map TL:c00(Γ;ℝ)→ℓ∞(L)T_L\colon c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb R)\to\ell_\infty(L) sends each family to the linear combination in (5).✦ uaL(f)=f(a),TLx=∑a∈supp⁡xxauaL(x∈c00(Γ;ℝ)).u_a^L(f)=f(a),\qquad T_Lx=\sum_{a\in\operatorname{supp}x}x_a u_a^L \quad\bigl(x\in c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb R)\bigr).(5)

For a norming set LL on Γ\Gamma, the norming completion ELE_L is the closed span of the coordinate evaluation vectors uaLu_a^L, for a∈Γa\in\Gamma, in ℓ∞(L)\ell_\infty(L).✦ For a norming set LL on Γ\Gamma, the finite-support inclusion IL:c00(Γ;ℝ)→ELI_L\colon c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb R)\to E_L is the linear map with the same values as TLT_L, regarded as vectors of ELE_L.✦ EL=TL(c00(Γ;ℝ))¯ℓ∞(L),ILx=TLx∈EL.E_L=\overline{T_L\bigl(c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb R)\bigr)}^{\,\ell_\infty(L)}, \qquad I_Lx=T_Lx\in E_L.(6) For the full norming set, write E=EKE=E_K and ea=IKδae_a=I_K\delta_a.

For p∈[0,∞]p\in[0,\infty] and x∈c00(Γ;ℝ)x\in c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb R), the associated finite real ℓp\ell_p vector is the element of ℓp(Γ)\ell_p(\Gamma) whose coordinate at aa is xax_a; finite support ensures membership also when p=0p=0.✦ At the primal exponent sks_k, its coefficient norm is (7). ∥x∥ℓsk(Γ)=(∑a∈supp⁡x|xa|sk)1/sk.\|x\|_{\ell_{s_k}(\Gamma)} =\left(\sum_{a\in\operatorname{supp}x}|x_a|^{s_k}\right)^{1/s_k}.(7)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let k∈ℕk\in\mathbb N and let x∈c00(Γ;ℝ)x\in c_{00}(\Gamma;\mathbb R) have support contained in CkC_k. Then ∥IKx∥E≤∥x∥ℓsk(Γ).\|I_Kx\|_E\leq\|x\|_{\ell_{s_k}(\Gamma)}.(8)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for every kk and every finitely supported real family (ba)a∈Ck(b_a)_{a\in C_k}, ∥∑a∈Ckbaea∥E≤∥(ba)∥ℓsk(Ck)\|\sum_{a\in C_k}b_a e_a\|_E\leq\|(b_a)\|_{\ell_{s_k}(C_k)}, and consequently the same coordinate series converges in EE whenever (ba)∈ℓsk(Ck)(b_a)\in\ell_{s_k}(C_k).

What Is Checked

The claim (8) is stated over finitely supported real families on Γ\Gamma, supported in one color class, and their finite-support inclusion into the completion associated with the full norming set.

For the full norming set KK, every coordinate array δa\delta_a belongs to KK✦, and every f∈Kf\in K satisfies |f(a)|≤1|f(a)|\leq 1 for all a∈Γa\in\Gamma.✦