OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. A dual space with coded norming functionals

Lemma 5.3: Contractive rectangle projections, countable coordinate supports, and the pure norming families on each color

Norming arrays determine the coordinate completion.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The construction starts with finitely supported real vectors on an uncountable coordinate set. Rational coordinate functionals determine the norm; ordinal intervals and color intervals specify the coordinate restrictions under consideration.

Let Γ=ω1\Gamma=\omega_1, the set of ordinals below the initial ordinal of cardinality ℵ1\aleph_1.✦ Fix a bijection ϑ:Γ→ℕ×Γ\vartheta:\Gamma\to\mathbb N\times\Gamma, and let π1\pi_1 denote the projection onto the first coordinate.✦ The color c(a)c(a) of a∈Γa\in\Gamma and its color classes CkC_k are defined by (1); each CkC_k has cardinality ℵ1\aleph_1 and is unbounded in Γ\Gamma. c(a)=π1ϑ(a),Ck={a∈Γ:c(a)=k}.c(a)=\pi_1\vartheta(a),\qquad C_k=\{a\in\Gamma:c(a)=k\}.(1)

A finitely supported rational array ff on Γ\Gamma is a function f:Γ→ℚf:\Gamma\to\mathbb Q that vanishes outside a finite set.✦ Write 𝒜=c00(Γ,ℚ)\mathcal A=c_{00}(\Gamma,\mathbb Q) for the space of these arrays and δa\delta_a for the array equal to 11 at aa and 00 elsewhere. The notation c00(Γ,ℝ)c_{00}(\Gamma,\mathbb R) has the corresponding meaning for real vectors.

The operation families are the pure families, indexed by k∈ℕk\in\mathbb N, and a single mixed family.✦ For a base B⊆𝒜B\subseteq\mathcal A and an operation family ℱ\mathcal F, the construction stage S0ℱ(B)S_0^{\mathcal F}(B) is BB. The stage Sn+1ℱ(B)S_{n+1}^{\mathcal F}(B) retains Snℱ(B)S_n^{\mathcal F}(B) and adjoins the values of type I operations whose children lie in that stage, together with the values of type II operations for which all children of every piece of every path lie in that stage. Stage indices start at zero.

The pure base ℬk\mathcal B_k consists of zero and the signed coordinates of color kk.✦ For each color kk, the pure norming set KkK_k is the set of rational arrays on Γ\Gamma obtained from the pure base ℬk\mathcal B_k through the pure stages; the full norming set KK is the set of rational arrays on Γ\Gamma obtained from the union of the pure norming sets through the mixed stages, as in (2). ℬk={0}∪{δa,−δa:a∈Ck},Kk=⋃n≥0Snpure(k)(ℬk),K=⋃n≥0Snmixed(⋃k≥0Kk).\begin{aligned} \mathcal B_k&=\{0\}\cup\{\delta_a,-\delta_a:a\in C_k\},\\ K_k&=\bigcup_{n\geq0}S_n^{\mathrm{pure}(k)}(\mathcal B_k),\\ K&=\bigcup_{n\geq0}S_n^{\mathrm{mixed}} \left(\bigcup_{k\geq0}K_k\right). \end{aligned}(2)

Norming Sets and Completion

A norming set 𝒩\mathcal N on Γ\Gamma is a subset of 𝒜\mathcal A containing every positive coordinate array and having all coefficients bounded in absolute value by 11, as specified in (3). δa∈𝒩(a∈Γ),|f(a)|≤1(f∈𝒩,a∈Γ).\delta_a\in\mathcal N\quad(a\in\Gamma),\qquad |f(a)|\leq1\quad(f\in\mathcal N,\ a\in\Gamma).(3)✦

The space ℓ∞(𝒩)\ell_\infty(\mathcal N) consists of bounded real functions on 𝒩\mathcal N, with its supremum norm.✦ The coordinate evaluation vector ηa∈ℓ∞(𝒩)\eta_a\in\ell_\infty(\mathcal N) and the real linear finite-support map I𝒩:c00(Γ,ℝ)→ℓ∞(𝒩)I_{\mathcal N}:c_{00}(\Gamma,\mathbb R)\to\ell_\infty(\mathcal N) are specified by (4). ηa(f)=f(a),I𝒩v=∑a∈Γv(a)ηa.\eta_a(f)=f(a),\qquad I_{\mathcal N}v=\sum_{a\in\Gamma}v(a)\eta_a.(4)

The norming completion E𝒩E_{\mathcal N} is the closed real evaluation span in (5), with its inherited norm.✦ The finite-support inclusion j𝒩:c00(Γ,ℝ)→E𝒩j_{\mathcal N}:c_{00}(\Gamma,\mathbb R)\to E_{\mathcal N} is the evaluation map I𝒩I_{\mathcal N} with codomain restricted to E𝒩E_{\mathcal N}. E𝒩=I𝒩(c00(Γ,ℝ))¯ℓ∞(𝒩),j𝒩v=I𝒩v∈E𝒩.E_{\mathcal N}= \overline{I_{\mathcal N}(c_{00}(\Gamma,\mathbb R))} ^{\,\ell_\infty(\mathcal N)},\qquad j_{\mathcal N}v=I_{\mathcal N}v\in E_{\mathcal N}.(5)

For a∈Γa\in\Gamma, the coordinate generator g𝒩,a∈E𝒩g_{\mathcal N,a}\in E_{\mathcal N} is the image of δa\delta_a under j𝒩j_{\mathcal N}.✦ For f∈𝒩f\in\mathcal N, the norming evaluation functional φf∈E𝒩*\varphi_f\in E_{\mathcal N}^* maps x∈E𝒩x\in E_{\mathcal N} to x(f)x(f); for a∈Γa\in\Gamma, the coordinate functional e𝒩,a*∈E𝒩*e_{\mathcal N,a}^*\in E_{\mathcal N}^* is φδa\varphi_{\delta_a}. g𝒩,a=j𝒩δa,φf(x)=x(f),e𝒩,a*=φδa.g_{\mathcal N,a}=j_{\mathcal N}\delta_a,\qquad \varphi_f(x)=x(f),\qquad e_{\mathcal N,a}^*=\varphi_{\delta_a}.(6)

The coordinate predual X0,𝒩X_{0,\mathcal N} is the norm-closed real linear span of the coordinate functionals in E𝒩*E_{\mathcal N}^*.✦ For f∈𝒜f\in\mathcal A, the rational coordinate combination fˆ∈X0,𝒩\widehat f\in X_{0,\mathcal N} is the finite sum of the coordinate functionals with coefficients f(a)f(a), as in (7). For x∈E𝒩x\in E_{\mathcal N} and f∈𝒜f\in\mathcal A, the array pairing ⟨x,f⟩𝒩\langle x,f\rangle_{\mathcal N} is the real number fˆ(x)\widehat f(x) in (7). X0,𝒩=span⁡ℝ{e𝒩,a*:a∈Γ}¯∥⋅∥,fˆ=∑a∈Γf(a)e𝒩,a*∈X0,𝒩(f∈𝒜),⟨x,f⟩𝒩=fˆ(x).\begin{aligned} X_{0,\mathcal N} &=\overline{\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb R} \{e_{\mathcal N,a}^*:a\in\Gamma\}}^{\,\|\cdot\|},\\ \widehat f&=\sum_{a\in\Gamma}f(a)e_{\mathcal N,a}^* \in X_{0,\mathcal N}\quad(f\in\mathcal A),\\ \langle x,f\rangle_{\mathcal N}&=\widehat f(x). \end{aligned}(7)

For the full norming set KK, write E=EKE=E_K✦, X0=X0,KX_0=X_{0,K}, ea=gK,ae_a=g_{K,a}✦ and ea*=eK,a*e_a^*=e_{K,a}^*.✦ The coordinate support of x∈Ex\in E is supp⁡x={a∈Γ:ea*(x)≠0}\operatorname{supp}x=\{a\in\Gamma:e_a^*(x)\ne0\}.

Coordinate Crops

An ordinal and color rectangle A=(I,J)A=(I,J) consists of an order-convex subset I⊆ΓI\subseteq\Gamma and an order-convex subset J⊆ℕJ\subseteq\mathbb N.✦ Its support set depends on the operation family according to (8). Apure(k)=I,Amixed=I∩c−1(J).A_{\mathrm{pure}(k)}=I,\qquad A_{\mathrm{mixed}}=I\cap c^{-1}(J).(8)✦

A norming set 𝒩\mathcal N is stable under a coordinate crop D⊆ΓD\subseteq\Gamma when the array obtained by setting ff equal to zero outside DD belongs to 𝒩\mathcal N for every f∈𝒩f\in\mathcal N.✦ For such a crop, the cropped normer πDf\pi_Df, the ambient crop operator TDT_D on ℓ∞(𝒩)\ell_\infty(\mathcal N), and its restriction PDP_D to E𝒩E_{\mathcal N} are given by (9). πDf=f𝟏D,(TDu)(f)=u(πDf),PD=TD|E𝒩:E𝒩→E𝒩.\pi_Df=f\mathbf1_D,\qquad (T_Du)(f)=u(\pi_Df),\qquad P_D=T_D|_{E_{\mathcal N}}:E_{\mathcal N}\to E_{\mathcal N}.(9) For the full family, the rectangle projection PA:E→EP_A:E\to E is PAmixedP_{A_{\mathrm{mixed}}}.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1 (Lemma 5.3). Let 𝒩\mathcal N be a norming set satisfying (3). Its completion satisfies (10): ∥x∥=supf∈𝒩|φf(x)|(x∈E𝒩).\|x\|=\sup_{f\in\mathcal N}|\varphi_f(x)| \qquad(x\in E_{\mathcal N}).(10)✦ For this norming set, the finite support inclusion has dense range: j𝒩(c00(Γ,ℝ))¯E𝒩=E𝒩.\overline{j_{\mathcal N}(c_{00}(\Gamma,\mathbb R))}^{\,E_{\mathcal N}} =E_{\mathcal N}.(11)✦ For the full family KK of (2), its completion EE satisfies (12), (13) and (14): ∥ea∥=1(a∈Γ).\|e_a\|=1\qquad(a\in\Gamma).(12)✦ ∥PAx∥≤∥x∥(x∈E,A an ordinal and color rectangle).\|P_Ax\|\leq\|x\|\qquad(x\in E,\ A\text{ an ordinal and color rectangle}).(13)✦ supp⁡x is countable(x∈E).\operatorname{supp}x\text{ is countable}\qquad(x\in E).(14)✦ For every color kk, the inclusion (15) holds: Kk⊆K.K_k\subseteq K.(15)✦ Let x∈Ex\in E have support contained in CkC_k, and let r≥0r\geq0. If |⟨x,f⟩K|≤r|\langle x,f\rangle_K|\leq r for every f∈Kkf\in K_k, then the bound (16) holds: ∥x∥≤r.\|x\|\leq r.(16)✦

What Is Checked

The statements concern the real closed evaluation spans E𝒩E_{\mathcal N} and their specialization to the full family KK on Γ=ω1\Gamma=\omega_1, with rectangle crops and vectors supported on one color.

For the full family, the library establishes the norming conditions in (3) and stability under every crop AmixedA_{\mathrm{mixed}} from (8).✦ For a general norming set stable under DD, the ambient operator TDT_D in (9) preserves E𝒩E_{\mathcal N}.✦ Each coordinate functional e𝒩,a*e_{\mathcal N,a}^* belongs to the coordinate predual X0,𝒩X_{0,\mathcal N} in (7).✦ For every norming set 𝒩\mathcal N, the finite support inclusion j𝒩j_{\mathcal N} has dense range in E𝒩E_{\mathcal N}.