OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Separable evaluation images

Lemma 2.1: Uniformly nonzero terms give convergent prefixes, with evaluation onto its closed coordinate span under range inclusion and completeness

Finite prefix normers give uniform prefix bounds.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Finite sets in the unit ball of a normed space can control initial segments of a sequence in its dual while annihilating every later term. Let 𝕂\mathbb K be ℝ\mathbb R or ℂ\mathbb C, let XX be a normed space over 𝕂\mathbb K, and let (fn)n∈ℕ0(f_n)_{n\in\mathbb N_0} be a sequence in X*X^*. Indices start at zero, so a prefix of length mm contains the terms with indices less than mm. For a scalar sequence cc, its finite prefix sum is Sm(c)=∑i<mcifi.S_m(c)=\sum_{i<m}c_i f_i .(1)

A family (Dm)m∈ℕ0(D_m)_{m\in\mathbb N_0} of finite prefix normers for (fn)(f_n) is a family of finite subsets of the closed unit ball BXB_X satisfying (2), with the prefix sums defined by (1): Dm⊆BX(m≥0),for every scalar sequence c there is d∈Dm with ∥Sm(c)∥≤2|Sm(c)(d)|(m≥1),fn(d)=0(n≥m,d∈Dm).\begin{aligned} &D_m\subseteq B_X &&(m\geq0),\\ &\text{for every scalar sequence }c\text{ there is }d\in D_m \text{ with }\|S_m(c)\|\leq2|S_m(c)(d)| &&(m\geq1),\\ &f_n(d)=0 &&(n\geq m,\ d\in D_m). \end{aligned}(2)✦ Fix such a family of finite prefix normers.

Coordinates and Evaluation

The algebraic span VV and the closed linear span GG of the sequence are the subspaces of X*X^* defined in (3), with closure taken in norm: V=span⁡{fn:n≥0},G=V¯⊆X*.V=\operatorname{span}\{f_n:n\geq0\},\qquad G=\overline V\subseteq X^*.(3)✦

Suppose that a>0a>0 and ∥fn∥≥a\|f_n\|\geq a for every nn. The algebraic coordinate functional αn∈V*\alpha_n\in V^* assigns to a finite linear combination its coefficient at fnf_n.✦ An ambient coordinate extension en∈X**e_n\in X^{**} is a continuous linear functional extending αn\alpha_n with norm at most 4/a4/a.✦ Choose such extensions; the coordinate functional fn#∈G*f_n^\#\in G^* is the restriction of ene_n to GG, as in (4): αn(∑icifi)=cn(c finitely supported),en|V=αn,∥en∥≤4/a,fn#=en|G.\begin{aligned} \alpha_n\left(\sum_i c_i f_i\right)&=c_n &&(c\text{ finitely supported}),\\ e_n|_V&=\alpha_n,\qquad \|e_n\|\leq4/a, &\qquad f_n^\#&=e_n|_G. \end{aligned}(4)

The closed coordinate span ZZ is the norm-closed subspace of G*G^* defined by (5): Z=span⁡{fn#:n≥0}¯⊆G*.Z=\overline{\operatorname{span}\{f_n^\#:n\geq0\}}\subseteq G^*.(5)✦

The prefix operator Pm:G→GP_m:G\to G is the continuous linear map in (6): Pmg=∑i<mfi#(g)fi.P_m g=\sum_{i<m}f_i^\#(g)f_i .(6)✦

The evaluation operator RG:X→G*R_G:X\to G^* is the continuous linear map given by (7): (RGx)(g)=g(x)(x∈X,g∈G).(R_Gx)(g)=g(x)\qquad(x\in X,\ g\in G).(7)✦ When RG(X)⊆ZR_G(X)\subseteq Z, write R:X→ZR:X\to Z for evaluation with codomain ZZ.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let XX be a real or complex normed space, and let (fn)⊆X*(f_n)\subseteq X^* admit a family of finite prefix normers. For every scalar sequence cc and integers 0≤m≤N0\leq m\leq N, the prefix estimate is (8): ∥Sm(c)∥≤2∥SN(c)∥.\|S_m(c)\|\leq2\|S_N(c)\|.(8)✦ Assume in addition that a>0a>0 and ∥fn∥≥a\|f_n\|\geq a for every nn. For every scalar sequence cc and n<Nn<N, the coefficient estimate is (9): |cn|≤4a∥SN(c)∥.|c_n|\leq\frac4a\|S_N(c)\|.(9)✦ For each g∈Gg\in G, the prefix operators satisfy the norm convergence in (10): limm→∞∥Pmg−g∥=0.\lim_{m\to\infty}\|P_mg-g\|=0.(10)✦ Suppose also that RG(X)⊆ZR_G(X)\subseteq Z. For every h∈Z*h\in Z^*, the adjoint estimate is (11), where R*h=h∘RR^*h=h\circ R: ∥R*h∥≥12∥h∥.\|R^*h\|\geq\tfrac12\|h\|.(11)✦ If XX is complete, evaluation satisfies (12): R(X)=Z.R(X)=Z.(12)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a real or complex Banach space XX and a sequence (fn)⊆X*(f_n)\subseteq X^* with 0<a≤∥fn∥≤b<∞0<a\leq\|f_n\|\leq b<\infty, if for every m≥1m\geq1 there is a finite Dm⊆BXD_m\subseteq B_X such that max⁡d∈Dm|v(d)|≥∥v∥/2\max_{d\in D_m}|v(d)|\geq\|v\|/2 for every v∈span⁡{f0,…,fm−1}v\in\operatorname{span}\{f_0,\ldots,f_{m-1}\} and fnf_n vanishes on DmD_m for n≥mn\geq m, using zero-based indices here, then (fn)(f_n) is basic with prefix projection norms at most 22 and |cn|≤(4/a)∥∑icifi∥|c_n|\leq(4/a)\|\sum_i c_i f_i\| for finite sums, and, for G=[fn]G=[f_n] and Z=[fn#]⊆G*Z=[f_n^\#]\subseteq G^*, the inclusion RG(X)⊆ZR_G(X)\subseteq Z implies that RG:X→ZR_G:X\to Z is onto and ∥RG*h∥≥∥h∥/2\|R_G^*h\|\geq\|h\|/2 for every h∈Z*h\in Z^*.

What Is Checked

The assertions concern finite prefix normers on real or complex normed spaces, with a positive uniform lower bound on ∥fn∥\|f_n\| for the coordinate constructions and completeness of XX for surjectivity. The sequence (fn)(f_n) is linearly independent under that lower bound.✦