OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. Transitions and local finiteness of cyclic centers

Lemma 6.4: For measurable angular states representing two color groups of a Borel weak coloring

At most two omitted colors obstruct alternation.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Fix a center x∈ℂx\in\mathbb C. Groups of colors present in directions around xx can be recorded by measurable sets of angles, with rotation through sixty degrees comparing directions. Write 𝕋=ℝ/2πℤ\mathbb T=\mathbb R/2\pi\mathbb Z for the circle of angles, ρ:ℝ→𝕋\rho:\mathbb R\to\mathbb T for the quotient map, and μ\mu for normalized angular Haar measure. The unit direction at t∈𝕋t\in\mathbb T is eite^{it}, and Rt=t+π/3Rt=t+\pi/3.

For a natural number kk, a weak measurable coloring c:ℂ→Finkc:\mathbb C\to\mathrm{Fin}\,k is an almost everywhere measurable function for planar Lebesgue measure m2m_2 satisfying c(z)≠c(z+eit)for (m2×μ)-almost every (z,t).c(z)\ne c(z+e^{it}) \quad\text{for }(m_2\times\mu)\text{-almost every }(z,t).(1)✦ Throughout, take a Borel measurable representative cc satisfying (1).

Circle Traces and Angular States

A set A⊆ℂA\subseteq\mathbb C has density one at zz when the following limit, taken in the extended nonnegative reals, holds: limr↓0m2(A∩B¯(z,r))m2(B¯(z,r))=1.\lim_{r\downarrow0} \frac{m_2(A\cap\overline B(z,r))}{m_2(\overline B(z,r))}=1.(2)✦ A typical color point zz is a point where its color class {w:c(w)=c(z)}\{w:c(w)=c(z)\} has density one in the sense of (2).✦ A typical circle sampling is a pair (y,r)∈ℂ×ℝ(y,r)\in\mathbb C\times\mathbb R with r>0r>0 for which y+reity+re^{it} is typical for μ\mu-almost every tt.✦

The real Hilbert space E=L2(𝕋,μ;ℝ)E=L^2(\mathbb T,\mu;\mathbb R) consists of square-integrable real functions identified up to almost everywhere equality.✦ For a real Hilbert space FF, its weak unit ball Bw(F)B_w(F) consists of weak dual functionals whose strong dual norms are at most one.✦ The Riesz duality embedding sends v∈Fv\in F to the functional w↦⟨v,w⟩w\mapsto\langle v,w\rangle in the weak dual.✦ The weak unit ball embedding ιF\iota_F of a real Hilbert space FF is the restriction of its Riesz duality embedding to ∥v∥≤1\|v\|\leq1; the underlying Hilbert vector of an element of Bw(F)B_w(F) is its inverse Riesz image.✦ A weak trace vector is an element b∈Bw(E)Finkb\in B_w(E)^{\mathrm{Fin}\,k}, with the product of the weak topologies.✦

The circle color indicator for center yy, radius rr and label ii is the real function fy,r,i(t)=𝟏{c(y+reit)=i}.f_{y,r,i}(t)=\mathbf 1_{\{c(y+re^{it})=i\}}.(3)✦ The circle indicator uy,r,iu_{y,r,i} in L2L^2 is the almost everywhere class of fy,r,if_{y,r,i}. The circle sampling vector σy,r\sigma_{y,r} is the weak trace vector whose coordinate at ii is ιE(uy,r,i)\iota_E(u_{y,r,i}).✦ The typical circle sample graph 𝒮c\mathcal S_c and the set 𝒯x\mathcal T_x of circle traces at xx are 𝒮c={(y,r,σy,r):(y,r) is a typical circle sampling},𝒯x={b∈Bw(E)Fink:(x,1,b)∈𝒮c¯}.\begin{aligned} \mathcal S_c &=\{(y,r,\sigma_{y,r}):(y,r)\text{ is a typical circle sampling}\},\\ \mathcal T_x &=\{b\in B_w(E)^{\mathrm{Fin}\,k}:(x,1,b)\in\overline{\mathcal S_c}\}. \end{aligned}(4) For a weak trace vector b∈Bw(E)Finkb\in B_w(E)^{\mathrm{Fin}\,k}, the trace color component βb,i∈E\beta_{b,i}\in E at a label i∈Finki\in\mathrm{Fin}\,k is the underlying Hilbert vector of bib_i, in particular when b∈𝒯xb\in\mathcal T_x is a circle trace as in (4). The positive trace set Sx,i(b)S_{x,i}(b) of a circle trace b∈𝒯xb\in\mathcal T_x is the set Sx,i(b)={t∈𝕋:βb,i(t)>0}.S_{x,i}(b)=\{t\in\mathbb T:\beta_{b,i}(t)>0\}.(5)✦

For each label ii, the countable palette generators 𝒢x,i\mathcal G_{x,i} are a chosen countable subset of 𝒯x\mathcal T_x whose measurable positive trace sets (5) realize the essential union of all such sets for μ\mu.✦ The palette color set Cx,iC_{x,i}, its lift C̃x,i\widetilde C_{x,i} to real angles, and the circle palette PxP_x are defined by Cx,i=⋃b∈𝒢x,iSx,i(b),C̃x,i=ρ−1(Cx,i),Px(eit)={i:t∈Cx,i}.C_{x,i}=\bigcup_{b\in\mathcal G_{x,i}}S_{x,i}(b), \qquad \widetilde C_{x,i}=\rho^{-1}(C_{x,i}), \qquad P_x(e^{it})=\{i:t\in C_{x,i}\}.(6) A real angular state representing a finite color group J⊆FinkJ\subseteq\mathrm{Fin}\,k is a Borel set A⊆ℝA\subseteq\mathbb R lying almost everywhere in every lifted palette color set from (6) indexed by JJ.✦ With m1m_1 denoting Lebesgue measure on ℝ\mathbb R, write State⁡x(A,J)⇔A is Borel and m1(A\C̃x,i)=0 for every i∈J.\operatorname{State}_x(A,J) \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad A\text{ is Borel and } m_1(A\setminus\widetilde C_{x,i})=0\text{ for every }i\in J.(7)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let c:ℂ→Finkc:\mathbb C\to\mathrm{Fin}\,k be a Borel measurable weak coloring, and fix x∈ℂx\in\mathbb C. Let J,K⊆FinkJ,K\subseteq\mathrm{Fin}\,k be color groups whose union omits at most two labels. Suppose s:𝕋→{0,1}s:\mathbb T\to\{0,1\} is measurable, and its real level sets Aa={u∈ℝ:s(ρ(u))=a}A_a=\{u\in\mathbb R:s(\rho(u))=a\} satisfy State⁡x(A0,J)\operatorname{State}_x(A_0,J) and State⁡x(A1,K)\operatorname{State}_x(A_1,K) as in (7). Then μ({t∈𝕋:s(Rt)=s(t)})>0.\mu\bigl(\{t\in\mathbb T:s(Rt)=s(t)\}\bigr)>0.(8)✦

In the paper, the result reads: at a fixed center xx there is no measurable state function taking only the values X,DX,D, representing the singleton {X}\{X\} and a fixed pair DD disjoint from {X}\{X\}, and changing state under RR almost everywhere.

What Is Checked

The statement (8) is over a Borel measurable weak coloring, an arbitrary center, two finite color groups with at most two labels outside their union, and a measurable circle function whose lifted level sets are real angular states. For every Borel measurable coloring, center yy, real radius rr and label ii, the circle indicator (3) belongs to L2(μ)L^2(\mu)✦, and its class uy,r,iu_{y,r,i} has norm at most one.✦