OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 ยท ยง6. Transitions and local finiteness of cyclic centers

Lemma 6.3: Under local L1L^1 convergence to a set of positive measure, unit chord separation is uniform on compact angular sets

Angular states constrain density and unit chords.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Angular states at a center specify labels present in circle palettes along measurable sets of directions. Two such states concern both the colors near sums of unit directions and the geometry of chords in their essential supports.

Write ๐•Š=โ„/2ฯ€โ„ค\mathbb S=\mathbb R/2\pi\mathbb Z for the angular circle and ฯƒ\sigma for its normalized Haar measure. The unit direction of ฮธโˆˆ๐•Š\theta\in\mathbb S is e(ฮธ)=eiฮธe(\theta)=e^{i\theta}, and Rฮธ=ฮธ+ฯ€/3R\theta=\theta+\pi/3.โœฆ Let mm denote planar Lebesgue measure and ฮป\lambda Lebesgue measure on โ„\mathbb R. For a natural number kk, a weak measurable coloring c:โ„‚โ†’Fin⁡kc:\mathbb C\to\operatorname{Fin}k is an almost everywhere measurable map satisfying (1): c(z)โ‰ c(z+e(ฮธ))for (mร—ฯƒ)-almost every (z,ฮธ).c(z)\ne c\bigl(z+e(\theta)\bigr) \quad\text{for }(m\times\sigma)\text{-almost every }(z,\theta).(1)โœฆ Throughout, cc is a Borel measurable representative.

For FโІโ„‚F\subseteq\mathbb C, its density-one locus F(1)F^{(1)} is the set defined in (2). A typical color point zz is a point of {w:c(w)=c(z)}(1)\{w:c(w)=c(z)\}^{(1)}.โœฆ F(1)={zโˆˆโ„‚:limrโ†“0m(FโˆฉBยฏ(z,r))m(Bยฏ(z,r))=1}.F^{(1)}= \left\{z\in\mathbb C: \lim_{r\downarrow0} \frac{m\bigl(F\cap\overline B(z,r)\bigr)}{m\bigl(\overline B(z,r)\bigr)}=1 \right\}.(2)โœฆ Typical circle sampling at (y,r)(y,r) means that r>0r>0 and y+re(ฮธ)y+r e(\theta) is a typical color point for ฯƒ\sigma-almost every ฮธ\theta.โœฆ

Traces and Angular States

Let E=L2(๐•Š,ฯƒ;โ„)E=L^2(\mathbb S,\sigma;\mathbb R), with functions identified almost everywhere.โœฆ The weak unit ball W(E)W(E) of EE is the unit ball in the weak dual of EE.โœฆ The Riesz embedding sends vectors of norm at most one into W(E)W(E); write v(a)โˆˆEv(a)\in E for the inverse image of aโˆˆW(E)a\in W(E). A weak trace vector is an element bโˆˆW(E)Fin⁡kb\in W(E)^{\operatorname{Fin}k}, whose iith trace component is biโ™ฏ=v(bi)b_i^\sharp=v(b_i).

For a center yโˆˆโ„‚y\in\mathbb C, a real radius rr and a label iโˆˆFin⁡ki\in\operatorname{Fin}k, the circle color indicator fy,r,if_{y,r,i} is the function on ๐•Š\mathbb S defined by (3). The circle indicator in L2L^2 associated with fy,r,if_{y,r,i} is its equivalence class in EE, and the sampling vector s(y,r)s(y,r) is the weak trace vector obtained by applying the Riesz embedding to each color indicator. fy,r,i(ฮธ)=๐Ÿ{ฮทโˆˆ๐•Š:c(y+re(ฮท))=i}(ฮธ).f_{y,r,i}(\theta)= \mathbf1_{\{\eta\in\mathbb S:\ c(y+r e(\eta))=i\}}(\theta).(3)โœฆ The typical sample graph GG consists of the triples (y,r,s(y,r))(y,r,s(y,r)) with typical circle sampling at (y,r)(y,r).โœฆ A circle trace at xx is a weak trace vector bb such that (x,1,b)โˆˆGยฏ(x,1,b)\in\overline G, with closure in the product topology.โœฆ Denote the set of these traces by ๐’ฏx\mathcal T_x.โœฆ

For bโˆˆ๐’ฏxb\in\mathcal T_x and iโˆˆFin⁡ki\in\operatorname{Fin}k, the positive trace set Qb,iQ_{b,i} is the subset of ๐•Š\mathbb S defined by Qb,i={ฮธ:biโ™ฏ(ฮธ)>0}Q_{b,i}=\{\theta:b_i^\sharp(\theta)>0\}.โœฆ Choose a countable family ๐’ขx,iโІ๐’ฏx\mathcal G_{x,i}\subseteq\mathcal T_x whose positive trace sets realize the essential union of all Qb,iQ_{b,i} with respect to ฯƒ\sigma.โœฆ The palette color set Ux,iU_{x,i} is the subset of ๐•Š\mathbb S defined by Ux,i=โ‹ƒbโˆˆ๐’ขx,iQb,iU_{x,i}=\bigcup_{b\in\mathcal G_{x,i}}Q_{b,i}, and the circle palette Px(ฮธ)P_x(\theta) at ฮธโˆˆ๐•Š\theta\in\mathbb S is the label set defined by Px(ฮธ)={i:ฮธโˆˆUx,i}P_x(\theta)=\{i:\theta\in U_{x,i}\}.โœฆ

The lifted palette color set Lx,iL_{x,i} is the subset of โ„\mathbb R defined by Lx,i={tโˆˆโ„:[t]โˆˆUx,i}L_{x,i}=\{t\in\mathbb R:[t]\in U_{x,i}\}, where [t][t] denotes reduction modulo 2ฯ€2\pi.โœฆ A real angular state AA at xx representing a label set JโІFin⁡kJ\subseteq\operatorname{Fin}k is a measurable subset of โ„\mathbb R satisfying (4): ฮป(A\Lx,i)=0(iโˆˆJ).\lambda(A\setminus L_{x,i})=0\qquad(i\in J).(4)โœฆ

The closed essential support S(B)S(B) of a measurable set BโІโ„B\subseteq\mathbb R is the support of ฮป|B\lambda|_B: every open neighborhood of a point in S(B)S(B) meets BB in positive measure.

A set DโІโ„D\subseteq\mathbb R has linear density zero at tt when (5) holds. limrโ†“0ฮป(Dโˆฉ[tโˆ’r,t+r])r=0.\lim_{r\downarrow0}\frac{\lambda(D\cap[t-r,t+r])}{r}=0.(5)โœฆ

The angular coordinate chart on the real coordinate plane โ„2\mathbb R^2 sends (t,u)(t,u) to ([t],[u])([t],[u]).โœฆ The translated angular sum is ฮฆx,r(ฮฑ,ฮฒ)=x+re(ฮฑ)+e(ฮฒ)\Phi_{x,r}(\alpha,\beta)=x+r e(\alpha)+e(\beta) for (ฮฑ,ฮฒ)โˆˆ๐•Š2(\alpha,\beta)\in\mathbb S^2.โœฆ

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let c:โ„‚โ†’Fin⁡kc:\mathbb C\to\operatorname{Fin}k be a Borel measurable weak coloring. Fix a center xx, and let A,BA,B be real angular states there representing label sets J,KJ,K.

Suppose that AcA^c has linear density zero at tt, that BcB^c has linear density zero at uu, and that sin⁡(uโˆ’t)โ‰ 0\sin(u-t)\ne0. Then ฮฆx,1([t],[u])โˆˆ{zโˆˆโ„‚:c(z)โˆ‰JโˆชK}(1).\Phi_{x,1}([t],[u])\in\{z\in\mathbb C:c(z)\notin J\cup K\}^{(1)}.(6)โœฆ

Suppose instead that XX is the unique label outside JโˆชKJ\cup K and that ฮป(A)>0\lambda(A)>0. For any b,dโˆˆS(B)b,d\in S(B), |e([b])โˆ’e([d])|โ‰ 1.\bigl|e([b])-e([d])\bigr|\ne1.(7)โœฆ

For a sequence of centers xnx_n, let An,BnA_n,B_n be real angular states at xnx_n representing fixed label sets J,KJ,K, with XX the unique label outside their union. Let DโІโ„D\subseteq\mathbb R be measurable with ฮป(D)>0\lambda(D)>0. Assume the local L1L^1 convergence in (8): limnโ†’โˆžโˆซE|๐ŸAn(v)โˆ’๐ŸD(v)|dฮป(v)=0for every compact EโІโ„.\lim_{n\to\infty}\int_E \bigl|\mathbf1_{A_n}(v)-\mathbf1_D(v)\bigr|\,d\lambda(v)=0 \quad\text{for every compact }E\subseteq\mathbb R.(8) On every compact CโІโ„C\subseteq\mathbb R, the chordal distances between points of S(Bn)S(B_n) satisfy the eventual uniform separation bound (9) for some ฮต>0\varepsilon>0 and Nโˆˆโ„•N\in\mathbb N: ฮตโ‰ค||e([b])โˆ’e([d])|โˆ’1|(nโ‰ฅN,b,dโˆˆCโˆฉS(Bn)).\varepsilon\le \left|\,\bigl|e([b])-e([d])\bigr|-1\,\right| \quad\bigl(n\ge N,\ b,d\in C\cap S(B_n)\bigr).(9)โœฆ

In the paper, the result reads: for circle states ๐’œ,โ„ฌ\mathcal A,\mathcal B at xx representing disjoint label groups whose union omits exactly XX, nonparallel density-one directions aโˆˆ๐’œa\in\mathcal A and bโˆˆโ„ฌb\in\mathcal B give spatial density one of color XX at x+e(a)+e(b)x+e(a)+e(b); if ฯƒ(๐’œ)>0\sigma(\mathcal A)>0, the closed essential support of โ„ฌ\mathcal B has no unit chord and has a strict angular margin from its RR and Rโˆ’1R^{-1} translates, with this margin uniform for states ๐’œn,โ„ฌn\mathcal A_n,\mathcal B_n representing the same groups and satisfying ๐Ÿ๐’œnโ†’๐Ÿ๐’œ\mathbf1_{\mathcal A_n}\to\mathbf1_{\mathcal A} in L1(๐•Š,ฯƒ)L^1(\mathbb S,\sigma).

What Is Checked

The assertions (6), (7) and (9) are stated over Borel measurable representatives of weak colorings with finitely many labels and the measurable real angular states of (4). For every center yy, real radius rr and label ii, the circle color indicator has L2L^2 norm at most one.โœฆ