OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Centrality and rational stability

Lemma 5.9: For finite ι,κ\iota, \kappa (|ι|≥5|\iota| \ge 5) and nil-kernel augmentation, frame actions are transitive, stabilizers split, and character homology vanishes for |κ|≥2|\kappa| \ge 2

Frame transitivity and stabilizer homology in elementary matrix groups.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Take an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra RR with an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra homomorphism ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2 and two finite index sets ι\iota and κ\kappa forming the disjoint union ι⊕κ\iota \oplus \kappa. The elementary matrix group over RR indexed by ι⊕κ\iota \oplus \kappa acts by left multiplication on column vectors having nonzero ε\varepsilon-residue, and hence on ordered and unordered frames whose ε\varepsilon-residues are 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-linearly independent. When |ι|≥5|\iota| \ge 5 and square matrices over ker⁡ε\ker \varepsilon are nilpotent, one asks whether this action is transitive on frames and how the stabilizer of the standard κ\kappa-frame splits with locally finite kernel. A companion question concerns the rational homology of that stabilizer, both with trivial coefficients and with coefficients in the orientation character from the top exterior frame chain module.

Elementary Groups and Column Frames

For a ring RR and a finite index set ι\iota, the general linear group GL⁡ι(R)\operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) is the group of invertible ι×ι\iota \times \iota matrices over RR. Given distinct i,j∈ιi, j \in \iota and a∈Ra \in R, the elementary matrix eij(a)∈GL⁡ι(R)e_{ij}(a) \in \operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) is the matrix I+aEijI + a E_{ij}, where II is the identity matrix and EijE_{ij} has entry 11 in row ii, column jj and 00 elsewhere. The elementary subgroup E⁡ι(R)\operatorname{E}_\iota(R) of GL⁡ι(R)\operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) is the subgroup generated by all elementary matrices eij(a)e_{ij}(a) for distinct i,j∈ιi, j \in \iota and a∈Ra \in R.✦ Over the disjoint union ι⊕κ\iota \oplus \kappa of finite index sets ι\iota and κ\kappa, the ambient elementary group GG is the subgroup E⁡ι⊕κ(R)\operatorname{E}_{\iota \oplus \kappa}(R) of GL⁡ι⊕κ(R)\operatorname{GL}_{\iota \oplus \kappa}(R).✦

A ring homomorphism ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2 has the matrix nil kernel property if for every integer n≥0n \ge 0, every n×nn \times n matrix over RR whose entries all map to 00 under ε\varepsilon is nilpotent.✦ Given an index set ι\iota and a homomorphism ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2, the vector residue map res⁡ε:Rι→𝔽2ι\operatorname{res}_\varepsilon : R^\iota \to \mathbb{F}_2^\iota is the map sending each vector v∈Rιv \in R^\iota to the vector i↦ε(vi)i \mapsto \varepsilon(v_i).✦ A column frame vertex over ι\iota with respect to ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2 is a vector v∈Rιv \in R^\iota satisfying res⁡ε(v)≠0\operatorname{res}_\varepsilon(v) \neq 0✦, and the vertex residue map ρ\rho is the map sending each column frame vertex vv to res⁡ε(v)∈𝔽2ι\operatorname{res}_\varepsilon(v) \in \mathbb{F}_2^\iota.✦ At each index i∈ιi \in \iota, the standard basis vertex eie_i over ι\iota is the column frame vertex having 11 at coordinate ii and 00 at all other coordinates.✦

For finite index sets ι\iota and κ\kappa, the set VV of ambient frame vertices consists of the column frame vertices over ι⊕κ\iota \oplus \kappa✦, and the sum vertex residue map ρ:V→𝔽2ι⊕κ\rho : V \to \mathbb{F}_2^{\iota \oplus \kappa} is the vertex residue map on VV.✦ Writing inr⁡:κ→ι⊕κ\operatorname{inr} : \kappa \to \iota \oplus \kappa for the inclusion of the right summand, the standard right vertex ej′∈Ve'_j \in V at j∈κj \in \kappa is the standard basis vertex einr⁡(j)e_{\operatorname{inr}(j)}✦; distinct indices in κ\kappa yield distinct standard right vertices.✦

Given a set V0V_0, scalars FF, an FF-vector space WW, a map ρ0:V0→W\rho_0 : V_0 \to W, and an integer k≥0k \ge 0, the set ℱk(ρ0)\mathcal{F}_k(\rho_0) of frames of size kk consists of all finite subsets t⊆V0t \subseteq V_0 of cardinality kk on which ρ0\rho_0 is FF-linearly independent.✦ If a group HH acts on V0V_0 preserving FF-linear independence under ρ0\rho_0, the frame action of HH on ℱk(ρ0)\mathcal{F}_k(\rho_0) is the group action given by h⋅t={h⋅v:v∈t}h \cdot t = \{h \cdot v : v \in t\} for h∈Hh \in H and t∈ℱk(ρ0)t \in \mathcal{F}_k(\rho_0).✦ Over VV with F=𝔽2F = \mathbb{F}_2 and the sum vertex residue map ρ\rho, left matrix multiplication by GG preserves 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-linear independence under ρ\rho on every subset s⊆Vs \subseteq V✦, giving an action of GG on the set ℱ=ℱ|κ|(ρ)\mathcal{F} = \mathcal{F}_{|\kappa|}(\rho) of frames of size |κ||\kappa|. Inside ℱ\mathcal{F}, the standard base frame x0∈ℱx_0 \in \mathcal{F} is the frame {ej′:j∈κ}\{e'_j : j \in \kappa\}.✦

The Unordered Stabilizer

For any finite index set λ\lambda, write SλS_\lambda for the symmetric group on λ\lambda; the permutation matrix homomorphism Pλ:Sλ→GL⁡λ(R)P_\lambda : S_\lambda \to \operatorname{GL}_\lambda(R) is the group homomorphism sending each permutation in SλS_\lambda to its permutation matrix. The block inclusion β:GL⁡ι(R)→GL⁡ι⊕κ(R)\beta : \operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) \to \operatorname{GL}_{\iota \oplus \kappa}(R) is the group homomorphism sending u∈GL⁡ι(R)u \in \operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) to the block-diagonal matrix with uu on the ι\iota-block, the identity matrix IκI_\kappa on the κ\kappa-block, and zero on the off-diagonal blocks. On the right factor, the right block permutation homomorphism βκ:Sκ→GL⁡ι⊕κ(R)\beta_\kappa : S_\kappa \to \operatorname{GL}_{\iota \oplus \kappa}(R) is the group homomorphism sending each τ∈Sκ\tau \in S_\kappa to the block-diagonal permutation matrix acting trivially on ι\iota and by τ\tau on κ\kappa.✦

The unordered frame stabilizer KK is the stabilizer subgroup in GG of the set {ej′:j∈κ}⊆V\{e'_j : j \in \kappa\} \subseteq V under left multiplication.✦ Identifying κ\kappa with {ej′:j∈κ}\{e'_j : j \in \kappa\} via the bijection j↦ej′j \mapsto e'_j, the permutation homomorphism σ:K→Sκ\sigma : K \to S_\kappa is the group homomorphism characterized by U⋅ej′=eσ(U)(j)′U \cdot e'_j = e'_{\sigma(U)(j)} for all U∈KU \in K and j∈κj \in \kappa.✦ The right fixer subgroup FκF_\kappa of GL⁡ι⊕κ(R)\operatorname{GL}_{\iota \oplus \kappa}(R) is the subgroup consisting of all invertible matrices fixing the standard basis vector of Rι⊕κR^{\iota \oplus \kappa} at each coordinate in the right summand κ\kappa✦, and the right fixer projection pr⁡ι:Fκ→GL⁡ι(R)\operatorname{pr}_\iota : F_\kappa \to \operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) is the homomorphism taking each matrix in FκF_\kappa to its ι×ι\iota \times \iota upper-left block. For each U∈KU \in K, the right fixed part of UU is the element Ũ∈Fκ\tilde{U} \in F_\kappa given by Ũ=Uβκ(σ(U)−1).\tilde{U} = U \, \beta_\kappa(\sigma(U)^{-1}).(1)✦

Composing the right fixed part from (1) with pr⁡ι\operatorname{pr}_\iota defines the top block homomorphism pGL:K→GL⁡ι(R)p_{\operatorname{GL}} : K \to \operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) by pGL(U)=pr⁡ι(Ũ)p_{\operatorname{GL}}(U) = \operatorname{pr}_\iota(\tilde{U}). When RR is an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra, ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2 is an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra homomorphism with the matrix nil kernel property, and |ι|≥5|\iota| \ge 5, the image pGL(U)p_{\operatorname{GL}}(U) lies in E⁡ι(R)\operatorname{E}_\iota(R) for every U∈KU \in K, defining the projection p:K→E⁡ι(R)p : K \to \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) as the restriction of pGLp_{\operatorname{GL}} in codomain to E⁡ι(R)\operatorname{E}_\iota(R).✦ Pairing pp with σ\sigma yields the quotient map ψ:K→E⁡ι(R)×Sκ\psi : K \to \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) \times S_\kappa given by ψ(U)=(p(U),σ(U))\psi(U) = (p(U), \sigma(U)). For any B∈E⁡ι(R)B \in \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) and τ∈Sκ\tau \in S_\kappa, the section element s(B,τ)∈Ks(B, \tau) \in K is the product s(B,τ)=β(B)βκ(τ),s(B, \tau) = \beta(B) \, \beta_\kappa(\tau),(2)✦ and the complementary embedding c:E⁡ι(R)→Kc : \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) \to K is the homomorphism given by c(B)=s(B,1)c(B) = s(B, 1).

A group HH is locally finite if every finite subset of HH is contained in a finite subgroup of HH.✦

Rational Homology, Frame Chains, and Characters

For any group homomorphism f:H1→H2f : H_1 \to H_2 and integer n≥0n \ge 0, the induced map on rational homology f*:Hn(H1;ℚ)→Hn(H2;ℚ)f_* : H_n(H_1; \mathbb{Q}) \to H_n(H_2; \mathbb{Q}) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-linear map induced by ff on degree-nn group homology with trivial ℚ\mathbb{Q}-coefficients.✦

For a set V0V_0, the vertex label space ℚ(V0)\mathbb{Q}^{(V_0)} is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-vector space of finitely supported functions V0→ℚV_0 \to \mathbb{Q}✦, and the ambient exterior algebra Λℚ(ℚ(V0))\Lambda_{\mathbb{Q}}(\mathbb{Q}^{(V_0)}) is the exterior algebra of ℚ(V0)\mathbb{Q}^{(V_0)}, equipped with the exterior algebra basis (ωt)(\omega_t) indexed by finite subsets t⊆V0t \subseteq V_0 and induced by the standard unit basis of ℚ(V0)\mathbb{Q}^{(V_0)}.✦ Each map f:V0→V0f : V_0 \to V_0 induces a ℚ\mathbb{Q}-algebra endomorphism Λ(f)\Lambda(f) of Λℚ(ℚ(V0))\Lambda_{\mathbb{Q}}(\mathbb{Q}^{(V_0)}) extending the linear map on ℚ(V0)\mathbb{Q}^{(V_0)} that takes the unit basis vector at each vertex v∈V0v \in V_0 to that at f(v)f(v).✦ For any group HH acting on V0V_0, the ambient representation of HH on Λℚ(ℚ(V0))\Lambda_{\mathbb{Q}}(\mathbb{Q}^{(V_0)}) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-representation in which each h∈Hh \in H acts by Λ(v↦h⋅v)\Lambda(v \mapsto h \cdot v).✦ Given scalars FF, a map ρ0:V0→W\rho_0 : V_0 \to W into an FF-vector space WW, a subset T⊆V0T \subseteq V_0, and an integer k≥0k \ge 0, the space of frame chains Ck(T)C_k(T) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-subspace of Λℚ(ℚ(V0))\Lambda_{\mathbb{Q}}(\mathbb{Q}^{(V_0)}) given by Ck(T)=span⁡ℚ{ωt:t⊆T finite,|t|=k,ρ0 is F-linearly independent on t}.C_k(T) = \operatorname{span}_{\mathbb{Q}} \{\omega_t : t \subseteq T \text{ finite},\ |t| = k,\ \rho_0 \text{ is } F\text{-linearly independent on } t\}.(3)✦

When a group HH acts on V0V_0 preserving FF-linear independence under ρ0\rho_0, the ambient representation of HH preserves Ck(V0)C_k(V_0) from (3)✦, making Ck(V0)C_k(V_0) a subrepresentation called the frame chain representation of HH. The basis elements ωt\omega_t with t∈ℱk(ρ0)t \in \mathcal{F}_k(\rho_0) span Ck(V0)C_k(V_0)✦ and form the frame chain basis of Ck(V0)C_k(V_0) indexed by ℱk(ρ0)\mathcal{F}_k(\rho_0).✦ Specializing to H=GH = G, V0=VV_0 = V, F=𝔽2F = \mathbb{F}_2, ρ0=ρ\rho_0 = \rho, and k=|κ|k = |\kappa| yields the top frame representation A=C|κ|(V)A = C_{|\kappa|}(V) of GG and its top frame basis b=(bx)x∈ℱb = (b_x)_{x \in \mathcal{F}}.

Suppose a group HH acts on a set XX with base point y0∈Xy_0 \in X and acts linearly on a ℚ\mathbb{Q}-vector space MM with basis (ux)x∈X(u_x)_{x \in X} such that for every h∈Hh \in H and x∈Xx \in X there exists α∈ℚ×\alpha \in \mathbb{Q}^\times with h⋅ux=αuh⋅xh \cdot u_x = \alpha \, u_{h \cdot x}. Each element hh of the stabilizer Stab⁡H(y0)\operatorname{Stab}_H(y_0) of y0y_0 in HH determines a unique monomial scalar factor λ(h)∈ℚ×\lambda(h) \in \mathbb{Q}^\times satisfying h⋅uy0=λ(h)uy0h \cdot u_{y_0} = \lambda(h) \, u_{y_0}✦, and the map h↦λ(h)h \mapsto \lambda(h) is a group homomorphism Stab⁡H(y0)→ℚ×\operatorname{Stab}_H(y_0) \to \mathbb{Q}^\times, the monomial character. For every g∈Gg \in G and x∈ℱx \in \mathcal{F}, there exists α∈ℚ×\alpha \in \mathbb{Q}^\times such that g⋅bx=αbg⋅xg \cdot b_x = \alpha \, b_{g \cdot x}✦; for GG acting on ℱ\mathcal{F} with base frame x0x_0, representation AA, and basis bb, the resulting monomial character is the base stabilizer character χ0:Stab⁡G(x0)→ℚ×\chi_0 : \operatorname{Stab}_G(x_0) \to \mathbb{Q}^\times.✦ Under the identification Stab⁡G(x0)=K\operatorname{Stab}_G(x_0) = K, the character χ:K→ℚ×\chi : K \to \mathbb{Q}^\times is the base stabilizer character χ0\chi_0. For any group HH and homomorphism θ:H→ℚ×\theta : H \to \mathbb{Q}^\times, the scalar representation ℚθ\mathbb{Q}_\theta is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-vector space ℚ\mathbb{Q} on which each h∈Hh \in H acts as multiplication by θ(h)\theta(h).✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let RR be an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra, let ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2 be an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra homomorphism with the matrix nil kernel property, and let ι\iota and κ\kappa be finite index sets with |ι|≥5|\iota| \ge 5. For any family (vj)j∈κ(v_j)_{j \in \kappa} in VV whose residues (ρ(vj))j∈κ(\rho(v_j))_{j \in \kappa} are 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-linearly independent, there exists U∈GU \in G satisfying U⋅ej′=vjfor all j∈κ.U \cdot e'_j = v_j \quad \text{for all } j \in \kappa.(4)✦ For every frame x∈ℱx \in \mathcal{F}, there exists g∈Gg \in G satisfying g⋅x0=x.g \cdot x_0 = x.(5)✦ The projection p:K→E⁡ι(R)p : K \to \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) and complementary embedding c:E⁡ι(R)→Kc : \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) \to K satisfy p(K)=E⁡ι(R),p(K) = \operatorname{E}_\iota(R),(6)✦ together with p∘c=id⁡E⁡ι(R)p \circ c = \operatorname{id}_{\operatorname{E}_\iota(R)}(7)✦ and ker⁡p is locally finite,\ker p \text{ is locally finite,}(8)✦ and for every integer n≥0n \ge 0, the induced map on rational homology satisfies c*:Hn(E⁡ι(R);ℚ)→∼Hn(K;ℚ).c_* : H_n(\operatorname{E}_\iota(R); \mathbb{Q}) \xrightarrow{\;\sim\;} H_n(K; \mathbb{Q}).(9)✦ The quotient map ψ:K→E⁡ι(R)×Sκ\psi : K \to \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) \times S_\kappa satisfies ψ(K)=E⁡ι(R)×Sκ\psi(K) = \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) \times S_\kappa(10)✦ and ker⁡ψ is locally finite.\ker \psi \text{ is locally finite.}(11)✦ If in addition |κ|≥2|\kappa| \ge 2, then for every integer n≥0n \ge 0, Hn(K;ℚχ)=0H_n(K; \mathbb{Q}_\chi) = 0(12)✦ and Hn(G;A)=0.H_n(G; A) = 0.(13)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for m≥13m \ge 13, 1≤l≤41 \le l \le 4, and r=m−lr = m - l, the group E⁡m(R)\operatorname{E}_m(R) acts transitively on ordered ll-frames, the stabilizer KlK_l of the unordered frame {er+1,…,em}\{e_{r+1}, \dots, e_m\} has a split exact sequence 1→Nl→Kl→E⁡r(R)→11 \to N_l \to K_l \to \operatorname{E}_r(R) \to 1 with NlN_l locally finite, and for the orientation module ℚϵl\mathbb{Q}_{\epsilon_l}, the homology Hq(Kl;ℚϵl)H_q(K_l; \mathbb{Q}_{\epsilon_l}) is isomorphic to Hq(E⁡m−1(R);ℚ)H_q(\operatorname{E}_{m-1}(R); \mathbb{Q}) via complementary inclusion when l=1l = 1 and vanishes when 2≤l≤42 \le l \le 4. The theorem answers this setup by replacing {1,…,r}\{1, \dots, r\} and {r+1,…,m}\{r+1, \dots, m\} with finite index sets ι\iota and κ\kappa satisfying |ι|≥5|\iota| \ge 5, pairing the projection onto E⁡ι(R)\operatorname{E}_\iota(R) with the permutation map to SκS_\kappa, and realizing the orientation module via the character χ\chi derived from the frame chain representation AA.

What Is Checked

The statements (4) through (13) are formulated over an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra RR, an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra homomorphism ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2 with the matrix nil kernel property, and finite index sets ι\iota and κ\kappa satisfying |ι|≥5|\iota| \ge 5, with the additional hypothesis |κ|≥2|\kappa| \ge 2 in (12) and (13). Within this setting, (4) and (5) are stated over G=E⁡ι⊕κ(R)G = \operatorname{E}_{\iota \oplus \kappa}(R), the vertices VV, the standard right vertices ej′e'_j, and the frames ℱ\mathcal{F} with base frame x0x_0; (6), (7), and (8) are stated over the unordered stabilizer KK, the projection pp, and the complementary embedding cc; (9) is stated over the induced rational homology map c*c_*; (10) and (11) are stated over the quotient map ψ\psi; and (12) and (13) are stated over the scalar representation ℚχ\mathbb{Q}_\chi and the top frame representation AA. The library also checks that for every finite index set λ\lambda and τ∈Sλ\tau \in S_\lambda, the permutation matrix Pλ(τ)P_\lambda(\tau) belongs to E⁡λ(R)\operatorname{E}_\lambda(R)✦, and that the block inclusion β\beta maps E⁡ι(R)\operatorname{E}_\iota(R) into GG.✦