OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Centrality and rational stability

Proposition 5.10: Stabilization for rank n≥12n \ge 12 under a matrix nil kernel, with block and frame-chain augmentation isomorphisms

Second rational homology stability for elementary matrix groups.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Given a ring RR and an integer n≥12n \ge 12, write E⁡n(R)\operatorname{E}_n(R) for the rank-nn elementary matrix group over RR. Does the standard rank inclusion E⁡n(R)→E⁡n+1(R)\operatorname{E}_n(R) \to \operatorname{E}_{n+1}(R) induce an isomorphism H2(E⁡n(R);ℚ)→H2(E⁡n+1(R);ℚ)H_2(\operatorname{E}_n(R); \mathbb{Q}) \to H_2(\operatorname{E}_{n+1}(R); \mathbb{Q}) on second rational group homology? These notes go through the three claims on second rational homology for 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebras equipped with an augmentation to 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2 and the definitions they are built on.

Elementary Groups and Matrix Stabilization

Let RR be a ring. An augmentation ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2 of a ring RR has the matrix nil kernel property if for every nonnegative integer mm and every m×mm \times m matrix AA over RR satisfying ε(Aij)=0\varepsilon(A_{ij}) = 0 for all indices ii and jj, the matrix AA is nilpotent.✦

Let ι\iota be an index set, and write GL⁡ι(R)\operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) for the group of invertible matrices over RR indexed by ι×ι\iota \times \iota. For distinct indices i,j∈ιi, j \in \iota and an element a∈Ra \in R, the elementary matrix eij(a)∈GL⁡ι(R)e_{ij}(a) \in \operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) is given by eij(a)=I+aEij,e_{ij}(a) = I + a E_{ij},(1)✦ where II is the identity matrix and aEija E_{ij} is the single-entry matrix with aa in row ii, column jj and 00 elsewhere. The elementary subgroup E⁡ι(R)\operatorname{E}_\iota(R) of GL⁡ι(R)\operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) is the subgroup generated by all elementary matrices (1) with i≠ji \neq j in ι\iota and a∈Ra \in R.✦ For a nonnegative integer nn, the elementary group E⁡n(R)\operatorname{E}_n(R) is the elementary subgroup E⁡{1,…,n}(R)\operatorname{E}_{\{1, \dots, n\}}(R).✦

Given index sets ι\iota and κ\kappa, the block inclusion bι,κ:GL⁡ι(R)→GL⁡ι⊔κ(R)b_{\iota,\kappa} : \operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) \to \operatorname{GL}_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(R) is the group homomorphism sending each invertible matrix UU to the block matrix diag⁡(U,Iκ)\operatorname{diag}(U, I_\kappa) with UU on the ι\iota-block, the identity matrix on the κ\kappa-block, and 00 on the off-diagonal blocks.✦ The permutation matrix homomorphism Pι:Sym⁡(ι)→GL⁡ι(R)P_\iota : \operatorname{Sym}(\iota) \to \operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) is the group homomorphism sending each permutation in the symmetric group Sym⁡(ι)\operatorname{Sym}(\iota) to its permutation matrix over RR.✦ Given a bijection e:ι→κe : \iota \to \kappa, the matrix relabeling homomorphism from GL⁡ι(R)\operatorname{GL}_\iota(R) to GL⁡κ(R)\operatorname{GL}_\kappa(R) is the group homomorphism reindexing rows and columns along ee, and the elementary group relabeling isomorphism ẽ:E⁡ι(R)→∼E⁡κ(R)\tilde{e} : \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) \xrightarrow{\sim} \operatorname{E}_\kappa(R) is its restriction to the elementary subgroups.

For a group homomorphism f:Γ1→Γ2f : \Gamma_1 \to \Gamma_2 and a nonnegative integer kk, the induced map on rational homology f*:Hk(Γ1;ℚ)→Hk(Γ2;ℚ)f_* : H_k(\Gamma_1; \mathbb{Q}) \to H_k(\Gamma_2; \mathbb{Q}) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-linear map induced by ff on group homology in degree kk with trivial ℚ\mathbb{Q}-coefficients.✦

Column Frames and the Frame Chain Complex

Let RR be a ring with augmentation ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2, and let ι\iota be an index set. The vector residue map Rι→𝔽2ιR^\iota \to \mathbb{F}_2^\iota is the map sending each vector v:ι→Rv : \iota \to R to the vector in 𝔽2ι\mathbb{F}_2^\iota whose ii-th coordinate is ε(vi)\varepsilon(v_i) for each i∈ιi \in \iota.✦ A column frame vertex over ι\iota with respect to ε\varepsilon is a vector v:ι→Rv : \iota \to R whose vector residue is nonzero; write Vι(ε)V_\iota(\varepsilon) for the set of column frame vertices over ι\iota.✦ The vertex residue map ρι:Vι(ε)→𝔽2ι\rho_\iota : V_\iota(\varepsilon) \to \mathbb{F}_2^\iota is the restriction of the vector residue map to Vι(ε)V_\iota(\varepsilon).✦ For each i∈ιi \in \iota, the standard basis vertex ei∈Vι(ε)e_i \in V_\iota(\varepsilon) is the column frame vertex having 11 at coordinate ii and 00 at all other coordinates.✦

Let VV be a set, let WW be a vector space over a field FF, let ρ:V→W\rho : V \to W be a map, and let kk be a nonnegative integer. A frame of size kk with respect to ρ\rho over FF is a finite subset t⊆Vt \subseteq V of cardinality kk on which ρ\rho is FF-linearly independent; write ℱk(V,ρ)\mathcal{F}_k(V, \rho) for the set of frames of size kk.✦ When a group Γ\Gamma acts on VV in a way that preserves FF-linear independence under ρ\rho, the action on frames of size kk is the group action of Γ\Gamma on ℱk(V,ρ)\mathcal{F}_k(V, \rho) defined by g⋅t={g⋅v:v∈t}g \cdot t = \{g \cdot v : v \in t\} for g∈Γg \in \Gamma and t∈ℱk(V,ρ)t \in \mathcal{F}_k(V, \rho).✦

For a vertex set VV, the vertex label space L(V)L(V) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-vector space of finitely supported functions V→ℚV \to \mathbb{Q}✦, and the ambient exterior algebra Λ(V)=Λℚ(L(V))\Lambda(V) = \Lambda_{\mathbb{Q}}(L(V)) is its exterior algebra over ℚ\mathbb{Q}.✦ The exterior algebra basis {bt}\{b_t\} of Λ(V)\Lambda(V), indexed by finite subsets t⊆Vt \subseteq V, is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-basis of Λ(V)\Lambda(V) induced by the standard unit basis of L(V)L(V).✦ For a map f:V→Vf : V \to V, the induced exterior algebra map Λ(f):Λ(V)→Λ(V)\Lambda(f) : \Lambda(V) \to \Lambda(V) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-algebra endomorphism induced by the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-linear extension of ff to L(V)L(V).✦ When a group Γ\Gamma acts on VV, the ambient representation of Γ\Gamma on Λ(V)\Lambda(V) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-linear representation in which each g∈Γg \in \Gamma acts by Λ(v↦g⋅v)\Lambda(v \mapsto g \cdot v).✦

Given ρ:V→W\rho : V \to W over FF, a subset s⊆Vs \subseteq V, and a nonnegative integer kk, the space of frame chains Ck(V;s)⊆Λ(V)C_k(V; s) \subseteq \Lambda(V) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-linear span of the basis elements btb_t over all finite subsets t⊆st \subseteq s of cardinality kk on which ρ\rho is FF-linearly independent.✦ When a group Γ\Gamma acts on VV preserving FF-linear independence under ρ\rho, the frame chain representation Ck(V)C_k(V) of Γ\Gamma over ℚ\mathbb{Q} in degree kk is the subrepresentation of the ambient representation on Ck(V;V)C_k(V; V).

The augmentation map η:L(V)→ℚ\eta : L(V) \to \mathbb{Q} on L(V)L(V) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-linear functional sending every element of VV to 11.✦ The boundary operator ∂:Λ(V)→Λ(V)\partial : \Lambda(V) \to \Lambda(V) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-linear endomorphism given by left contraction with η\eta.✦ The frame chain differential dk:Ck+1(V)→Ck(V)d_k : C_{k+1}(V) \to C_k(V) is the morphism of ℚ[Γ]\mathbb{Q}[\Gamma]-representations obtained by restricting ∂\partial to Ck+1(V;V)C_{k+1}(V; V). In degree 00, the degree-zero isomorphism δ0:C0(V)→∼ℚ\delta_0 : C_0(V) \xrightarrow{\sim} \mathbb{Q} is the isomorphism of ℚ[Γ]\mathbb{Q}[\Gamma]-representations with the trivial representation ℚ\mathbb{Q} given by taking the b∅b_\emptyset-coordinate, with inverse c↦cb∅c \mapsto c \, b_\emptyset.✦

Take an index set Ω\Omega, a ring RR with augmentation ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2, and the action of E⁡Ω(R)\operatorname{E}_\Omega(R) on the column frame vertices VΩ(ε)V_\Omega(\varepsilon). The frame chain representation Ck(Ω)C_k(\Omega) of E⁡Ω(R)\operatorname{E}_\Omega(R) in degree kk is the frame chain representation Ck(VΩ(ε))C_k(V_\Omega(\varepsilon)).✦ Composing the degree-00 frame chain differential d0:C1(Ω)→C0(Ω)d_0 : C_1(\Omega) \to C_0(\Omega) with the degree-00 isomorphism δ0:C0(Ω)→∼ℚ\delta_0 : C_0(\Omega) \xrightarrow{\sim} \mathbb{Q} yields the ℚ[E⁡Ω(R)]\mathbb{Q}[\operatorname{E}_\Omega(R)]-module augmentation map αΩ=δ0∘d0:C1(Ω)→ℚ.\alpha_\Omega = \delta_0 \circ d_0 : C_1(\Omega) \longrightarrow \mathbb{Q}.(2)✦ For a group Γ\Gamma, a morphism ψ:M→N\psi : M \to N of ℚ[Γ]\mathbb{Q}[\Gamma]-representations, and a nonnegative integer kk, the induced map on rational homology ψ*:Hk(Γ;M)→Hk(Γ;N)\psi_* : H_k(\Gamma; M) \to H_k(\Gamma; N) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-linear map induced by ψ\psi on group homology in degree kk.

Frame Stabilizers and the Block Homomorphism

Let ι\iota and κ\kappa be index sets, and let RR be a ring with augmentation ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2. For each j∈κj \in \kappa, the standard vertex of the right summand ejR∈Vι⊔κ(ε)e_j^{\mathrm{R}} \in V_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(\varepsilon) is the standard basis vertex at the image of jj in ι⊔κ\iota \sqcup \kappa. The unordered frame stabilizer KK is the stabilizer subgroup in E⁡ι⊔κ(R)\operatorname{E}_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(R) of the subset {ejR:j∈κ}⊆Vι⊔κ(ε)\{e_j^{\mathrm{R}} : j \in \kappa\} \subseteq V_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(\varepsilon).✦ The right block permutation homomorphism PR:Sym⁡(κ)→GL⁡ι⊔κ(R)P^{\mathrm{R}} : \operatorname{Sym}(\kappa) \to \operatorname{GL}_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(R) is the group homomorphism sending each p∈Sym⁡(κ)p \in \operatorname{Sym}(\kappa) to the permutation matrix acting trivially on ι\iota and by pp on κ\kappa. For A∈E⁡ι(R)A \in \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) and p∈Sym⁡(κ)p \in \operatorname{Sym}(\kappa), the section element s(A,p)s(A, p) is the product bι,κ(A)PR(p)b_{\iota,\kappa}(A) P^{\mathrm{R}}(p), and the complementary embedding c:E⁡ι(R)→Kc : \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) \to K is the group homomorphism defined by c(A)=s(A,1)c(A) = s(A, 1).

Suppose κ\kappa is finite. Write G=E⁡ι⊔κ(R)G = \operatorname{E}_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(R) for the ambient elementary group, Vι⊔κ(ε)V_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(\varepsilon) for the ambient frame vertices, ρι⊔κ:Vι⊔κ(ε)→𝔽2ι⊔κ\rho_{\iota \sqcup \kappa} : V_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(\varepsilon) \to \mathbb{F}_2^{\iota \sqcup \kappa} for the sum vertex residue map, and j↦ejRj \mapsto e_j^{\mathrm{R}} for the right frame vertex map κ→Vι⊔κ(ε)\kappa \to V_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(\varepsilon). Let ℱ|κ|\mathcal{F}_{|\kappa|} be the set of frames of size |κ||\kappa| in Vι⊔κ(ε)V_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(\varepsilon) over 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2 with respect to ρι⊔κ\rho_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}; the action of GG on Vι⊔κ(ε)V_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(\varepsilon) induces an action of GG on ℱ|κ|\mathcal{F}_{|\kappa|}.✦ The standard base frame b0∈ℱ|κ|b_0 \in \mathcal{F}_{|\kappa|} is the frame {ejR:j∈κ}\{e_j^{\mathrm{R}} : j \in \kappa\} formed as the image of κ\kappa under the right frame vertex map.✦ Write Sκ=Stab⁡G(b0)S_\kappa = \operatorname{Stab}_G(b_0) for the stabilizer of b0b_0 in GG.

Take κ=𝟏\kappa = \mathbf{1} to be a one-element index set, giving the action on singleton frames of G=E⁡ι⊔𝟏(R)G = \operatorname{E}_{\iota \sqcup \mathbf{1}}(R) on ℱ1\mathcal{F}_1, and write S=Stab⁡G(b0)S = \operatorname{Stab}_G(b_0) for the vertex stabilizer of the singleton standard base frame. The lift to the vertex stabilizer ℓι:E⁡ι(R)→S\ell_\iota : \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) \to S is the group homomorphism sending each A∈E⁡ι(R)A \in \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) to bι,𝟏(A)∈Sb_{\iota,\mathbf{1}}(A) \in S. The elementary block homomorphism βι:E⁡ι(R)→E⁡ι⊔𝟏(R)\beta_\iota : \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) \to \operatorname{E}_{\iota \sqcup \mathbf{1}}(R) is the composite of ℓι\ell_\iota with the subgroup inclusion S↪GS \hookrightarrow G.✦ For a nonnegative integer nn, let ẽn:E⁡{1,…,n}⊔𝟏(R)→∼E⁡n+1(R)\tilde{e}_n : \operatorname{E}_{\{1, \dots, n\} \sqcup \mathbf{1}}(R) \xrightarrow{\sim} \operatorname{E}_{n+1}(R) be the elementary group relabeling isomorphism along the canonical bijection {1,…,n}⊔𝟏→{1,…,n+1}\{1, \dots, n\} \sqcup \mathbf{1} \to \{1, \dots, n+1\}; the elementary stabilization map νn:E⁡n(R)→E⁡n+1(R)\nu_n : \operatorname{E}_n(R) \to \operatorname{E}_{n+1}(R) is the composite νn=ẽn∘β{1,…,n}.\nu_n = \tilde{e}_n \circ \beta_{\{1, \dots, n\}}.(3)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let RR be an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra with an augmentation ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2. When ε\varepsilon has the matrix nil kernel property and n≥12n \ge 12 is an integer, the elementary stabilization map (3) induces an isomorphism on second rational homology: (νn)*:H2(E⁡n(R);ℚ)→∼H2(E⁡n+1(R);ℚ).(\nu_n)_* : H_2(\operatorname{E}_n(R); \mathbb{Q}) \xrightarrow{\;\sim\;} H_2(\operatorname{E}_{n+1}(R); \mathbb{Q}).(4)✦ When ε\varepsilon has the matrix nil kernel property and ι\iota is a finite index set with |ι|≥12|\iota| \ge 12, the map on H2(−;ℚ)H_2(-; \mathbb{Q}) induced by the elementary block homomorphism βι:E⁡ι(R)→E⁡ι⊔𝟏(R)\beta_\iota : \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) \to \operatorname{E}_{\iota \sqcup \mathbf{1}}(R) is an isomorphism, (βι)*:H2(E⁡ι(R);ℚ)→∼H2(E⁡ι⊔𝟏(R);ℚ).(\beta_\iota)_* : H_2(\operatorname{E}_\iota(R); \mathbb{Q}) \xrightarrow{\;\sim\;} H_2(\operatorname{E}_{\iota \sqcup \mathbf{1}}(R); \mathbb{Q}).(5)✦ When ε\varepsilon has the matrix nil kernel property and Ω\Omega is a finite index set with |Ω|≥13|\Omega| \ge 13, the frame-chain augmentation map (2) induces an isomorphism on second rational homology with representation coefficients: (αΩ)*:H2(E⁡Ω(R);C1(Ω))→∼H2(E⁡Ω(R);ℚ).(\alpha_\Omega)_* : H_2(\operatorname{E}_\Omega(R); C_1(\Omega)) \xrightarrow{\;\sim\;} H_2(\operatorname{E}_\Omega(R); \mathbb{Q}).(6)✦

What Is Checked

The stabilization claim (4) is stated over an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra RR with an augmentation ε:R→𝔽2\varepsilon : R \to \mathbb{F}_2 satisfying the matrix nil kernel property, an integer n≥12n \ge 12, the elementary groups E⁡n(R)\operatorname{E}_n(R) and E⁡n+1(R)\operatorname{E}_{n+1}(R), and the stabilization map (3) on second rational group homology with trivial ℚ\mathbb{Q}-coefficients. The block claim (5) is stated over RR, ε\varepsilon satisfying the matrix nil kernel property, a finite index set ι\iota with |ι|≥12|\iota| \ge 12, and the elementary block homomorphism βι\beta_\iota on second rational homology. The augmentation claim (6) is stated over RR, ε\varepsilon satisfying the matrix nil kernel property, a finite index set Ω\Omega with |Ω|≥13|\Omega| \ge 13, the group E⁡Ω(R)\operatorname{E}_\Omega(R), and the frame-chain augmentation map (2) on second rational group homology with ℚ[E⁡Ω(R)]\mathbb{Q}[\operatorname{E}_\Omega(R)]-representation coefficients.

The block inclusion maps E⁡ι(R)\operatorname{E}_\iota(R) into E⁡ι⊔κ(R)\operatorname{E}_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(R), and every permutation matrix over RR indexed by ι\iota belongs to E⁡ι(R)\operatorname{E}_\iota(R).✦ For every A∈E⁡ι(R)A \in \operatorname{E}_\iota(R) and p∈Sym⁡(κ)p \in \operatorname{Sym}(\kappa), the section element s(A,p)s(A, p) belongs to E⁡ι⊔κ(R)\operatorname{E}_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(R) and to KK.✦ When κ\kappa is finite, the stabilizer SκS_\kappa of the standard base frame b0b_0 in G=E⁡ι⊔κ(R)G = \operatorname{E}_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(R) equals KK as subgroups of GG✦, giving the base stabilizer isomorphism Sκ→∼KS_\kappa \xrightarrow{\sim} K.✦ On column frame vertices Vι(ε)V_\iota(\varepsilon), the action of E⁡ι(R)\operatorname{E}_\iota(R) preserves 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-linear independence under ρι\rho_\iota✦, as does the action of GG on Vι⊔κ(ε)V_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}(\varepsilon) under ρι⊔κ\rho_{\iota \sqcup \kappa}.✦ For any field FF and any group action on a vertex set VV preserving FF-linear independence under ρ:V→W\rho : V \to W, the induced exterior algebra action of each group element maps the space Ck(V;V)C_k(V; V) into itself.✦